Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Yes, the gender wage gap is still a myth—and a potentially dangerous one
Yes, the gender wage gap is still a myth—and a potentially dangerous one
Mar 1, 2026 12:54 AM

Today is Equal Pay Day, a day set aside to perpetuate the myth of the “gender pay gap,” which claims that, because of gender discrimination, women receive about 22 percent lower pay on average for doing the same work as men.

The observance was started in 1996 by the National Committee on Pay Equity, and yet after 21 years and hundreds of articles debunking the claim, the idea that gender pay gap is a real problem is a myth that just won’t die.

At this point it’s difficult not to assume that some organizations are either too dishonest or too ideologically motivated to recognize the truth. For example, the Economic Policy Institute (EPI) claims that, “On average in 2016, women were paid 22 percent less than men, after controlling for race and ethnicity, education, experience, and location.” That claim is so unsupportable that the EPI has to resort to some creative obfuscation.

For instance, critics of the pay gap myth frequently point out that a significant reason men, on average, earn higher wages than women is because they are willing to take more dangerous jobs. As Andrew Biggs and Mark Perry explain, “Economists have long found that, all else equal, more dangerous jobs pay higher average wages than safer jobs. And the 20 jobs with the highest occupational fatality rates tracked by the Bureau of Labor Statistics are on average 93% male.”

EPI implies that the reason little girls don’t grow up and take dangerous jobs like fishing and logging is because of gender based discrimination:

Gender discrimination doesn’t happen only in the pay-setting practices of employers making wage offers to nearly identical workers of different genders. It can happen at every stage of a woman’s life, from steering her away from science and technology education to shouldering her with home responsibilities that impede her capacity to work the long hours of demanding professions.

Get that? It’s not that women prefer to take jobs that allow them more time at home with their kids. No, it’s because at every stage of woman’s life, she is being pushed away from having trees fall on them in a logging camp toward the safety of home. (Yes, I realize that EPI only mentions “science and technology” and not high-paying deadly jobs. They intentional downplay and ignore industries where the wage gap is most significant.)

This sort of diversion from “employers are discriminating against women” to “society caused the wage gap” is necessary for wage-gap mythmakers. If there was truly a 22 percent wage gap caused by discrimination against women by businesses, we’d be able to point out businesses that actually engage in this practice. We would be seeing corporations shamed in the news because of their blatant discriminatory pay practices. But we don’t, because such examples are so rare as to be statistically insignificant.

To be able to maintain the illusion the wage-gap is real, advocates have to claim women must be being discriminated against somewhere else other than the workplace. For instance, the average male in the U.S. spends 4,500 more muting to work each year. Why don’t women make the same choice? Obviously, it must be discrimination. If such discrimination didn’t exist would be free to get stuck in traffic at the same high rates as men.

But why does this myth matter? Why can’t we just ignore this issue until April 4 rolls around next year? One reason is because if the wage gap is caused in part by women’s choices then “closing the gap” will require taking away such choices. Recently the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) released a report on Australia claiming stay-at-home mothers were the “greatest untapped potential” for Australia’s workforce and that they were creating “potentially large losses to the economy.”

Sarrah Le Marquand, the editor-in-chief of Stellar magazine, used the report to make the argument that “It should be illegal to be a stay-at-home mum”:

Rather than wail about the supposed liberation in a woman’s right to choose to shun paid employment, we should make it a legal requirement that all parents of children of school-age or older are gainfully employed.

[…]

[I]t’s time for a serious rethink of this kid-glove approach to women of child-bearing and child-rearing age. Holding us less accountable when es to our employment responsibilities is not doing anyone any favours. Not children, not fathers, not bosses — and certainly not women.

Only when the female half of the population is expected to hold down a job and earn money to pay the bills in the same way that men are routinely expected to do will we see things change for the better for either gender.

While you may find Le Marquand’s op-ed ridiculous, she’s presenting a view shared by far too many people: If an individual’s life choices are “bad” for the economy, then those choices must be restricted. This is also the hidden logic that sustains the gender wage gap myth. Initially, the advocates claim that women don’t choose certain jobs because of the inherent biases of society. Then the logical next step is to encourage women to take such job—even if they don’t want to—for the good of “society.”

And if there aren’t enough women willing ply? Well, what’s the purpose of having a government if you can’t use it’s power to force people to do what it best for the nation’s economy?

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
The FAQs: Right to Work Laws and Economic Freedom
What is a Right to Work law? Right to Work laws are state laws that guarantee a person cannot pelled to join or pay dues to a labor union as a condition of employment. Why are Right to Work laws considered a matter of economic freedom? Economic freedom exists when people have the liberty to produce, trade, and consume legitimate goods and services that are acquired without the use of force, fraud, or theft. Mandatory unionism violates a person’s economic...
A Thought on Wealth and Wisdom
My friend John Teevan of Grace College sends out a newsletter every month called “Economic Prospect.” This month’s edition included this valuable insight: Here is a short passage from Ezekiel 28:4-5 that speaks to us about overconfidence in producing wealth: By your wisdom and understanding you have gained wealth for yourself and amassed gold and silver in your treasuries. By your great skill in trading you have increased your wealth, and because of your wealth your heart has grown proud....
The Poverty Trap in France
In France, more than half ofthe population benefits directly or indirectly from welfare payments. Not surprisingly, the result has been that that the poverty rate for the past twenty years has remained unchanged. “Despite its good intentions,” saysSylvain Charat, “welfareship has created a ‘poverty trap.’” Let’s take an unemployed mother living alone with two children between six and 10 years old. In 2010, there were 284,445 French families in this situation that were on welfare. This mother will be given...
Asceticism and the Free Society
This past Friday, I had the opportunity to present a paper at the Sophia Institute annual conference at Union Theological Seminary. This year’s topic was “Marriage, Family, and Love in the Eastern Orthodox Tradition.” My paper was titled, “What Makes a Society?” and focused, in the context of marriage and the family, on developing an Orthodox Christian answer to that question. The Roman Catholic and neo-Calvinist answers, subsidiarity and sphere sovereignty, respectively (though not mutually exclusive), receive frequent attention on...
‘Markets Don’t Make Capitalism’
Earlier this week Dylan Pahman reflected on the question, “Which capitalism?” He helpfully explores the nature of capitalism and the importance of definitions. This conversation reminded me of a point made by Michael Novak during his conversation with Rev. Sirico earlier this year at Acton University. In the Q&A session, he argues that it is essential to understand the nature of what distinguishes capitalism from other economic systems: Novak says that “markets don’t make capitalism,” but rather that “enterprise, invention,...
‘Goodbye, Taiwan’: No Babies Means No Economic Base
It’s no secret that certain parts of the world have been losing population for some time. The tightly-controlled Chinese birthrate is the first thing es to most minds regarding this topic. However, large parts of Asia, Europe and now even the United States are beginning to see clear danger signs when es to economies and low birth rates. Taiwan’s birthrate is “dropping like a stone…” says an editorial in the Taipei Times. The majority of people realize there is a...
Commentary: Christmas and Secularism’s Futility
In today’s culture, there is always an abundance of news stories about the “War on Christmas.” In mentary this week, I address that concern and the lack of understanding of the deeper meaning of Christmas. Here’s a highlight: Every December cultural warriors mourn the incessant attacks on Christmas and secularism’s rise in society. News headlines carry stories of modern day Herods banning nativity scenes, religious performances, and even the word “Christmas.” Just as a majority of young people profess they...
Right to Work and the Free Rider Myth
One of the strongest arguments against Right to Work legislation is that such laws exasperates the “free rider” problem. In the context of unions, a free rider is an employee who pays no union dues or agency shop fees, but nonetheless receives the same benefits of union representation as dues-payers. While this concern should not override an employee’s right of free association, it was a concern that, I had always thought was worth taking seriously. But yesterday I discovered that...
Right to Work: The UAW and Planned Parenthood Make Common Cause
Video: UAW President Bob King thanks Planned Parenthood, environmentalists, clergy, et al., at anti Right-To-Work Protest looks at the — at first blush as least — strange alliance between the United Auto Workers union and Planned Parenthood on the Michigan Right to Work issue. Elise Hilton of the Acton Institute, interviewed by LifeSiteNews reporter Kirsten Andersen, says that the UAW, Planned Parenthood and other like minded groups are afraid that right-to-work laws will help defund the progressive agenda. “I don’t...
Today’s AU Online Lecture with Victor Claar Postponed
If you haven’t joined us for this lecture series yet, there’s still time! The final live session for the Globalization, Poverty, and Development AU Online series, Fair Trade vs. Free Trade, has been postponed. This means that you now have a few extra days to catch up on the lectures that we’ve already held before joining us next week for Victor Claar’s lecture on Tuesday, December 18, 2012. Also, if you’re interested in learning more about topics related to development,...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved