Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY
/
With Texas’ Deportation Law on Pause, Migrants Turn to the Church
With Texas’ Deportation Law on Pause, Migrants Turn to the Church
Jul 12, 2025 4:55 AM

  Palm Sunday looked different this year for a small majority-immigrant church in Fort Worth. For part of the service, the pastors invited an immigration lawyer to speak about what to expect if Texas enacts a new law that authorizes the state to arrest and deport migrants.

  There is a lot of fear in our church in regard to this law and a lot of uncertainty. What does it mean? How does it affect their cases? asked Anyra Cano, one of the pastors.

  The congregation, mostly first-generation immigrants from Latin America, knows they can come to us when they have those kinds of questions, she added.

  Texas Senate Bill 4 (SB 4) comes as the latest salvo amid long-standing tensions between Republican Gov. Greg Abbott and the Biden administration over the nations immigration enforcement.

  Last year, over 2.4 million people sought to cross the US-Mexico border. Texas (like other Republican-governed states) has tried to respond by taking matters into its own hands. Abbott signed SB 4 into law in December, making illegal border-crossing not just a federal offense but a state crime.

  Currently, the bill is tied up in courta federal appeals court ruled Wednesday that SB 4 will remain on hold.

  The law would allow Texas police to question and detain anyone they suspect of illegally crossing the US-Mexico border. Though SB 4 doesnt allow arrests in schools, places of worship, or health care facilities, even the possibility of brushes with police officers with deportation power has raised concerns for immigrant communities in Texasand for the Christian leaders who serve them.

  Many of the attendees at Canos church do have some kind of status, albeit perhaps not a more permanent one like citizenship. Some are on humanitarian parole, while others have temporary protected status or are recipients of Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA).

  But they all know someone who isnt documented. If they see a police car at the church they will be worried, Cano said. Theres that distrust of [wondering], Will I lose my papers? (She asked that her church not be named due to concerns that its immigrant congregants could be targeted.)

  Leaders in immigrant churches and communities worry that SB 4 will exacerbate that distrust. Cano recalled a family who used to attend their church and declined to press charges in a domestic violence case because they didnt want either parent to be deported.

  Thats the worry sometimes with laws like thesewhat will happen is that instead of seeking the help they do need, theyre afraid about these other issues, Cano said. Thats what happens with these kinds of laws, is that injustice continues.

  Texas ministries play an important role in serving newly arrived asylum seekers, particularly since a caravan surge a few years ago. What started as a short-term response by the ecumenical nonprofit Fellowship Southwest has developed into a long-term project.

  The group, launched by the Cooperative Baptist Fellowship, works to support churches and ministries involved in mercy ministries. They help buy food, pay rent for shelters, and support churches that do ministry on both sides of the US-Mexico border.

  Were sort of a conduit, where we have these long, trusted relationships with people serving migrants directly on the border, executive director Stephen Reeves told CT. They do this really intense work with a population that suffered so much trauma and, in some cases, pretty dangerous situations, given the cartel activity in Mexican border towns.

  Reeves, who has a background as an attorney in religious liberty law, has also fielded questions from churches and ministry leaders in Texas wondering what SB 4 means for their work.

  I would think someone at church following the dictates of their conscience and their faith, exercising their religion by serving those they feel Jesus called them to serve, has a pretty good case to make that this is within their religious liberty to serve them, Reeves said. But most people dont want to be in a court case.

  The law is geared toward recent crossers, not longtime residents, as Texas statute of limitations prevents misdemeanors being adjudicated two years after an offense has taken place.

  In many border-town churches, Reeves said, Border Patrol and police officers occupy the same pews as migrants and asylum seekers.

  At a church in Brownsville a few weeks ago, Reeves met lots of migrants, including recently released asylum seekers. He remembers the pastor at one point in the service asking a Border Patrol agent to stand up so the congregation could thank him for his work.

  He hopes SB 4 doesnt undo the tenuous trust that church leaders are working to build. Though the law bars arrests on church property, people have to leave the church at some point, he said, so its just another thing [pastors] have to worry about. Who might show up outside their church? Will the police come as theyre ministering to folks?

  In response to an influx at Texas border with Mexico in recent years, Abbott has bused new arrivals to cities under Democratic controllike New York and Washington, DCand in 2021 deployed Operation Lone Star, sending state troopers to arrest migrants on charges of trespassing.

  Some of these efforts have landed the state government in court: An appeals court recently ordered Texas to remove a 1,000-foot buoy barrier in the Rio Grande river near Eagle Pass, Texas, but the court is rehearing the case in May.

  For SB 4, the law faces both local and federal challenges. The county of El Paso and two immigrant rights organizations sued to stop the law, and the US Justice Department challenged the constitutionality of the law on the grounds that immigration enforcement belongs to federal, not state, authorities.

  The Biden administration argued that the law violates the supremacy clause of the Constitution, which holds that federal law is the supreme Law of the Land Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding. The administration also argued SB 4 violates previous Supreme Court precedent. (In Arizona v. United States in 2012, the court held that the removal process of immigrants in the country illegally is entrusted to the discretion of the Federal Government.)

  Currently, SB 4 is on hold while the US Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals considers arguments in the lawsuit filed by El Paso County and immigration rights groups. One dissenting federal judge wrote that Texas is helpless if it cant pass laws regulating immigration and that federal non-enforcement is only exacerbating the situation.

  The appeals court holds another hearing next month. Texas may appeal it to the Supreme Court as well. Abbott has made it clear the state isnt backing down; Texas has already arrested over 40,000 people who have crossed the border on grounds of trespassing.

  In the meantime, migrants, and the ministries that help them, remain in limbo.

  These politicians fighting amongst each otherits not a solution. And nobodys offering a solution. What we need is comprehensive legal immigration reform. The asylum process is backlogged and we dont have the resources, Reeves said. Im going to keep working for comprehensive reform, but in the meantime, weve got people in our backyard literally down here that need a lot of help.

  Recent surveys have shown that evangelicals are becoming more concerned about high numbers of immigration to the US but still believe Christians should care for those who are in the country, even if they are in the country illegally.

  Meanwhile, 80 percent of evangelicals support bipartisan immigration reform that would do more to secure the border while also creating a pathway to citizenship for certain groups of undocumented immigrants.

  Though systemic reform remains elusive, Christians are finding ways to practically serve the people in their church and community, including those who are hidden in the shadows due to their undocumented status.

  Canos church has offered help, such as connecting congregants with immigration lawyers, trying to mend distrust between immigrants and the police, and providing financial assistance to church members eligible for DACA. Their church is also discussing whether to hold a Know Your Rights workshop at some point, but theyre waiting to see if SB 4 comes into effect.

  Cano remembers that when the church first opened its doors 16 years ago, Catholic women in the neighborhood would cross the street to avoid running into believers near the evangelical church. When members went on prayer walks and went door to door, most didnt open up to them.

  But over time, theyve started to find common ground. Those same neighbors come to the church for Zumba classes and health and job fairs.

  Cano says the churchs efforts to meet the tangible needs of the community have introduced the community to a different kind of Christian faith, one that not only cares for their spiritual life but also for their life in a holistic manner, in a loving manner. Weve had people tell us, I cant believe a church does this, Cano said.

  Were not being political. Were just trying to get you what you need, in a place that you trust. Our hope is people will know Jesus through what the church does, because we do it because of Jesus.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY
Spiritual enterprise: Doing virtuous business
With the onset of the financial crisis and economic downturn, there has been a lot of discussion about the future of the free economy in this country. Scandal and corruption among executives and financial institutions has of course played a significant part in fueling the discussion. While paying tribute to the free economy and the wealth it has created, Theodore Roosevelt Malloch also looks to reinforce and renew the foundations of virtuous business in Spiritual Enterprise. Malloch agrees that...
The scandal of evangelical politics
In The Scandal of Evangelical Politics, Ronald J. Sider attempts to construct a methodology for evangelical Christians to participate faithfully in the political process. His construct is a backlash—to a degree—of the political monopolization of the religious right and its influence in politics. The book is a response to past evangelical involvement, which Sider sees as largely being a failure and highly contradictory. And while his methodology does not necessarily contradict any political goals of Christian conservatives, and is...
"Brand loyalty" in the American religious marketplace
Earlier this year, the Pew Forum for Religion and Public Life released the first installment of a truly impressive study based upon a massive survey of more than 35,000 Americans. Its portrait of the American religious landscape attracted a great deal of media attention, typically focusing on three or four principal themes. If you were to read only the press accounts, here's what you would know: While Americans are still overwhelmingly -- at least nominally -- Christian (78.4 percent...
Busting a pop culture illusion
For the past several decades, American popular culture has frequently promulgated an idea central to modern liberalism: the idea of a life without limits, that we can have everything we want with out having to make hard choices. That assumption is especially evident in Walt Disney movies, and not only in recent ones. Fortunately, the makers of some pop culture products see the absurdity and danger of that notion. The life-without-limits mindset, derived most directly from the ideas of...
The envy trap
It is one of the great puzzles, true throughout all human history, that during an economic downturn, people turn on the rich. They call for them to be taxed, harassed, beaten, and jailed. Because they have money when others are losing money, envy is unleashed and encouraged by the political establishment. It amounts to a kind of lashing out at the most conspicuous target, even though doing so won’t actually plish anything. On the face of it, this should...
Cardinal Bertone's "The Ethics of the Common Good in the Social Doctrine of the Church"
Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone, the Vatican's Secretary of State and effectively the second most important official in the Catholic Church, takes a close look at economic globalization and the social nature of markets in a book published in September, in Italian and Russian, by the Libreria Editrice Vaticana. Bertone’s book, “The Ethics of the Common Good in the Social Doctrine of the Church” (L'etica del Bene Comune nella Dottrina Sociale della Chiesa) is also notable for its ecumenical character; it...
Taking a stand: An interview with Governor Mark Sanford
You’ve taken a very principled approach in working for smaller government, lower taxes, individual liberty, and, for fostering a culture of personal responsibility. Those principles are taking a battering in Washington today. Can anything turn the tide? George Washington and his fairly battered band of patriots were facing far greater odds. The situation looked much more bleak. And yet they were resolved to creating the perfect union that they believed in. And they ultimately prevailed against incredibly long odds....
Turkey: Islam's bridge to religious and economic liberty?
You say there's a growing sector in Turkish society that is engaged with the market economy and that's a healthy trend. Do you see that trend continuing in Turkey? There is in this economy a capitalist development, and this is important. In the past, generally speaking, the religious people were more of the peasant class and they were mostly in agriculture--not in modern industrial production. Generally speaking, the bourgeois, the people who were the capitalists, who were owners of...
Power and corruption in Catholic Boston
Lord Acton’s quotation concerning the corrupting effect of power is widely known. Less so is the fact that the target of his criticism on that particular occasion was the power possessed not by government but by church officials. Acton’s understanding of ecclesiastical authority (as distinct from power) is debatable, but his insight into human nature is not. A case study—not that we need another to file away in the vast archives of the history of human frailty—is the collapse...
Editor's note
Currently there are serious concerns about economic prosperity in a nation that has for so long benefited from tremendous economic growth and stability. Likewise, some are deeply troubled about government proposed solutions and cures for our economic ailments. South Carolina's governor Mark Sanford brings substantial thought and credibility to free-market ideas while articulating the danger of greater centralized power. Those paying attention to current events will be well aware that Governor San ford has risen to be perhaps the...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved