Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Why We Need To Get ‘Community’ Right
Why We Need To Get ‘Community’ Right
Jan 14, 2026 12:48 PM

What is a munity?” What are the boundaries of munity or organization? And – most important – why munity important?

Andy Crouch, writer, musician and Acton University plenary speaker, says we need to ask and answer these questions. He begins his discussion with the recent Supreme Court decision regarding Hobby Lobby and Conestoga Woods. While the decision was sound, Crouch says it speaks to something beyond the law:

It reminds us that fewer and fewer of our neighbors understand how religious organizations—and munities smaller than the state—contribute to human flourishing and mon good.

One essential question in Burwell v. Hobby Lobby was the extent to which a for-profit corporation can hold to a religious (in this case, Christian) identity. In her dissent, Ruth Bader Ginsburg cited approvingly the idea that for-profit groups “use labor to make a profit, rather than to perpetuate a religious-values-based mission.”

The words rather than are key. In Justice Ginsburg’s view, it seems, corporations cannot serve—or at least the law cannot recognize that they serve—any god other than Mammon. She articulated an equally small view of nonprofits when she wrote that “religious organizations exist to foster the interests of persons subscribing to the same religious faith.”

It seems, says Crouch, that we are meant to put boundaries on each and every organization. A business can make a profit, but not serve munity or its employees. A church can minister to the people that attend services on Sunday, but not the ones who don’t and never will. Crouch says we’re losing an important part of what it means to be human and to live munity.

What is happening is the erosion of corporate identity. We get our word corporate from the Latin word for “body.” It echoes the biblical (and parison of munity to a human body, with many parts working together for some greater good. The widespread alarm that “the Court thinks corporations are people!” is misplaced. As the journalist Megan McArdle observed, we want our society to treat corporations—whether for-profit or not-for-profit—like persons in many respects. Otherwise, “the government would have the right to shut down the presses at The New York Times; search Google’s servers without a warrant whenever they liked; tell churches (usually organized as corporations) what they could believe . . . and otherwise abridge fundamental human rights.”

Many of those fundamental human rights can be exercised only munity, in a form that embodies our mitments to one another.

We are a highly individualized society. We want everything to be personalized: our cell phone cases, our music play list, even our sermons. We pick and choose, based on our personal preferences, without taking munity into consideration. Relationships e transactions: you give me this and I’ll give you that. Businesses are there to stock the goods we want, churches are there to tell us what we want to hear.

What is the most deeply Christian response to such a world?

It can only be mit ourselves even pletely to that countercultural, corporate reality known as the church, in all its imperfect and local expressions, and in its wider global reality.

The church makes a stronger claim on us than the state. According to Jesus, it makes a deeper claim even than the family. And by being stronger and deeper than the family and the state, the church provides a family for those without families, and a people for those discarded and marginalized by society.

Living in a world “post-Hobby Lobby,” Crouch says, means that we must guard munities, our relationships and our churches from those who want to limit what they do and what they mean. We need to munity right, or everything else will go wrong.

Read “Life Together, Again” at Christianity Today.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Distributist Fantasies
If modern distributists would like to identify themselves as agrarians, they may, and line up behind John Crowe Ransom, Robert Penn Warren, and the rest of the contributors to I’ll Take My Stand. Then they would be making a super-catechetical argument and we should not take issue with them on this blog. Their claim, however, is to offer the only modern economic theory which is fully in line with Church teaching, and that we cannot allow to go unchallenged. The...
Rep. Justin Amash on Government Dysfunction
Last week I wrote mentary titled the “The Folly of More Centralized Power,” making the case against ceding anymore power to Washington and returning back to the fundamental principles of federalism. Rep. Amash (R-Mich.), a member of the freshmen class in Congress, made that case as well. Amash was asked about his Washington experience so far in an interview and declared, When I was in the state government, I thought things were dysfunctional there in my opinion. Now I’ve discovered...
Doug Bandow: Troubling News for Religious Liberty
The state of religious liberty around the world is poor, according a new study by the Pew Forum on Religion. Doug Bandow breaks down the report over at The American Spectator—his piece is titled “A World Spinning Backward.” Two years ago, Pew reported that 70 percent of humanity suffered from either government persecution of or social hostility to religion. That trend is growing. According to Pew’s new study, “more than 2.2 billion people—about a third of the world’s population—live in...
Distributists Ignore the Lessons of History
Distributism is not a new idea—it wasn’t conceived by G.K. Chesterton and Hilaire Belloc. As Belloc explains in The Servile State, their idea was a return to certain economic principles of medieval Europe—a guild system, wider ownership of the means of production, etc.—in order to right the injustices of capitalism. But distributism goes back further than that, to Tiberius and Gaius Gracchus in the second century B.C., and the theory’s proponents would do well to learn from the tragic failures...
Acton Commentary: School Choice Gains Traction
Political discourse and news media have been consumed of late by talk of debt, spending, and recession, but meanwhile the educational freedom movement has been making real progress. State legislatures across the country are giving a green light to vouchers and tax incentives that will in the future pay impressive dividends in the form of better educated students and more efficient schools. Read the rest of mentary here. ...
Get the Acton Android App
The Acton Institute has released a mobile app for smart phones and tablets based on the Android operating system. The free app keeps users up to date with the latest PowerBlog mentaries, events and other goings on at the institute. Point your puter or smart phone to the Android Market. In the pipeline — the Acton iPhone app for Apple mobile devices. Stay tuned! ...
Video: AEI’s Brooks on the Free Enterprise Debate
Visit for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy AEI President Arthur Brooks answers the question from MSNBC’s Matt Miller, “What do we do when huge forces beyond our control shape our destiny?” ...
Media Accidentally Admits Hurricanes Don’t Create Jobs
Though Hurricane/Tropical Storm Irene was not as devastating as expected, it took several dozen lives and has cause billions of dollars of damage. Some economists have tried to argue that the storm is a net gain for the economy—think of all the jobs that will be created by the clean-up and rebuilding! But treatment of the storm by the mainstream media has been surprisingly honest and nonpartisan, and their unguarded coverage is instructive. ABC News reports that economic losses due...
CFP: Orthodox Christian Economic Thought
Since its inception, the Journal of Markets & Morality has encouraged critical engagement between the disciplines of moral theology and economics. In the past, the vast majority of our contributors have focused on Protestant and Roman Catholic social thought applied to economics, with a few significant exceptions. Among the traditions often underrepresented, Orthodox Christianity has received meager attention despite its ever-growing presence and ever-increasing interest in the West. This call for publication is an effort to address this lacuna by...
How to Deliver a Recession: Cut Brake Lines, Accelerate Toward Cliff
Economic historian Brian Domitrovic has an interesting post up at his Forbes blog, Past & Present, on the proximate causes of the 2008 meltdown. According to Domitrovic, uncoordinated, even “weird” fiscal and budgetary policy in the early 2000s kept investors on the sidelines, and then flooded the system with easy money. The chickens came home to roost in 2008 (and they’re still perched in the coop). In 2000, as the stock market was treading water in the context of the...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved