Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Why truly free trade is also truly fair
Why truly free trade is also truly fair
Nov 19, 2024 4:24 AM

Throughout our political discourse, we continue to hear critiques of free trade from left and right, each of them ultimately aiming to prod us closer toan abstract notion of so-called “fair” or “fairer” trade. Evenwhen the value of free trade is recognized, such admissions tend to be quickly panied by fuzzy, convoluted qualifiers, such as “free trade must also be fair.”

It’s a refrain that sounds agreeable enough on the surface, yet it bears an underlying ambivalence toward freedom and expresses little confidence in the fairness of such freedom, hinting ata moral dissonance between “free” and “fair” that doesn’t actually exist.

Indeed, trade that is truly free is also truly fair.

“Free trade simply means unimpeded exchanges between individuals over political borders,” writes Pierre Lemieux, an economist at the University of Québec in Outaouais. “It is the international (or interregional) equivalent of domestic free markets. In free trade, any individual or private entity can make deals, as opposed to the government’s making one deal for everybody (which will be good for some and bad for others).”

In a new primer, Lemieux seeks to address 7 key objections to free trade, most of which deal with the basic economics, showing how, contrary to the popular arguments, free trade is a positive force for job creation and growth in the national economy as a whole.

He concludes, however, by addressing those more basic objections about “fairness,” which Lemieux believes are, more often than not, “moral excuses” or narrow “material interests masquerading as ethics.” As Lemieux goes on to argue, we must first stop “defining freedom in terms of fairness,” and instead “define fairness in terms of liberty.”

“Trade is fair if it is entered into voluntarily by two private parties,” he writes. “As philosopher Robert Nozick argued, socialism needs to ‘forbid capitalist acts between consenting adults.’ Free trade is made of capitalist acts between consenting adults,” and “except for extreme cases, one can argue for the presumption that fairness is liberty and that free trade is fair by definition.”

Once we understand the fairness of trade itself, we move to the individual parties involved, recognizing that “every human being should be treated equally in a formal sense.” As Lemieux explains:

Protectionism can be in the interest of most people in a large country if—and only if—their government is able to change the terms of trade in their favor. As mentioned previously, this is the only serious argument against free trade—that a large country can manipulate the terms of trade in its favor with optimal tariffs. Even in that case, protectionism remains morally unacceptable in light of the usual methodology of economics and the foundations of a free society. It should be taken for granted, as proposed by the individualist methodology of economics, that all human beings have the same moral weight—whether they are nationals or foreigners, wherever they happen to have been born.

Whatever the temporary or targeted merits of a particular protectionist policy for a particular industry in a particular country, we must continue to ask ourselves: What about the particular people who happen to live outside those particular borders? Are they being treated “fairly” by protectionist and restrictionist policies?

Given how muddled our vocabulary and trade policy has e, it’s understandable that the ethics and economics would continue to get lost in the debate. So-called “fair trade” products are far too often haphazardmanipulations of the market, even as our so-called “free trade agreements” are far too often not so free.

But though we may indeed live in plex world that will continue to be filled with promises and hazardous variationsof managed trade, we’d still do well to nudge our needles in the right direction as to what is truly free, and in turn, what is truly fair.

“Free trade is fair trade,” Lemieux concludes. “The fair trade argument is usually an excuse for special interests or for state power. What is fair is to let each individual or private entity reach his or its own bargains. Even if domestic protectionism can favor some people in their own countries at the cost of harming foreigners, and especially poorer foreigners, it does not seem morally acceptable to do so.”

Image:Novgorod Marketplace” by Appolinary Vasnetsov

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
What Matters Most for Social Mobility?
Earlier this year I wrote a series of posts explaining 12 principles that generally drive the thinking of conservative evangelicals when es to economics. Number 9 on my list was: 9. Social mobility — specifically getting people out of poverty — is infinitely more important than e inequality. Social mobility is the ability of an individual or family to improve (or lower) their economic status. The two main types of social mobility are intergenerational (i.e., a person is better off...
Faith and the Artisan Economy
I recently detailed the relationship between stewardship and the use of one’s God given gifts through vocational jobs as a path toward human flourishing. Much like vocational work’s hands on occupations, are artisanal jobs, which are on the rise in America. These positions are developed by the individual as a creative outlet to provide a good or a service not in the market. They do not require formal training, but education is important as a foundation for inspired enrichment. The...
How to Understand Snowpiercer
Snowpiercer is the most political film of the year. And likely to be one of the most misunderstood. Snowpiercer is also very weird, which you’d probably expect from a South Korean sci-fi post-apocalyptic action film based on a French graphic novel that stars Chris Evans (Captain America) and Tilda Swinton (The Chronicles of Narnia). The basic plot of the movie is that in 2014, an experiment to counteract global warming (which is based on a real plan) causes an ice...
New Intelligence Report: Illegal Immigrants Not Fleeing Violence
that a new intelligence study suggests that the latest surge of illegal immigrants are not fleeing violence in their homelands, but rather are under the misconception that if they make it to the United States border, they will be granted permission to stay. The 10-page July 7 report was issued by the El Paso Intelligence Center (EPIC), which according to the Justice Department website is led by the DEA and incorporates Homeland Security. Its focus is on the collection and...
Is a Nicaraguan and World Bank Partnership Going to Help the Country?
Recently, the World Bank agreed to partner with Nicaragua to give the country 69 million U.S. dollars in aid. This poses the immediate question of whether or not this aid will be effective in producing its stated goal of decreasing poverty and increasing economic productivity. Should the World Bank continue to give money to the government of Nicaragua, which – especially of late – has been showing a decrease in political stability and democratic processes? History shows that international loans...
Audio: Elise Hilton on the Border Crisis
Earlier today, Elise Hilton was featured on the Neal Larson Show discussing several facets of the current “Border Crisis” and suggesting how to address this situation. Listen below: Read mentary this paring our current situation with one 50 years ago in Cuba. ...
What Works in Helping the Poor?
How do we help struggling Americans rise out of poverty? Robert Doar, AEI’s fellow in poverty studies and former New York City missioner, offers four key principles everyone concerned with fighting poverty should know. ...
A Better Way to Fair Trade?
A few months ago, the Fairtrade movement came under fire after a British study stated that fairtrade certified farmers were actually making less and were working in worse conditions than non-certified farmers. Of course, this was not the first time the fairtrade movement was accused of failing to fulfill its goals. However, Vega, a pany based inLeón, Nicaragua has decided to employ a new method of business that focuses much more on the coffee farmers. They see the problem with...
Fewer Babies, Longer Lives
The Transom links today to a piece about how Proctor & Gamble is ramping up product lines aimed at older adults. “The flip side of the low birthrate is we’re all living longer,” said corporate exec Tom Falk. In fact, the global trend over the last two hundred years has been toward longer lives and fewer babies. This trend really gathered momentum in just the last half-century or so. Consider this short video I put together for a talk at...
Partnering With Poor Women For Health, Fertility
Once, in a Bible study I was involved with, we women got chatting, and one lady (as we were discussing poverty in Haiti) said, “If we could just get those women to stop having so many kids…” [drawn-out sigh.] My reply was that we didn’t need to stop women from having babies; we needed to help educate women. For years, organizations like the World Health Organization have tried to distribute artificial birth control in the developing world. The thinking here...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved