Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Why Family-Friendly Employment Requirements Aren’t Always Family-Friendly
Why Family-Friendly Employment Requirements Aren’t Always Family-Friendly
Apr 3, 2025 3:25 PM

Three of the most basic principles of economics are that people are price-sensitive, risk-averse, and that they respond to incentives.

If you raise the price of a good or service people will, in general, tend to buy less (price-sensitive). If you give a person a choice between a certain e (“I’ll pay you $50 for nothing”) or a higher payoff on an uncertain e (“I’ll pay you $100 or nothing based on a coin-flip”), they’ll generally take the less risky option (risk-averse). And if you give people a way to get a lower price without any risk, they’ll generally prefer that option (response to incentives).

Each of these principles seems intuitive, even obvious. Yet for some reason when bine them to create a public policy people are shocked to find itcan have “unintended consequences.

Take, for example, so-called “family-friendly policies” such as employer-mandated childcare, paid maternity leave, or requirements to allow full-time employees to work part-time work when they have a baby. Here is the opening of a recent New York Times article titled, “When Family-Friendly Policies Backfire.”

In Chile, a law requires employers to provide working mothers with child care. One result? Women are paid less.

In Spain, a policy to give parents of young children the right to work part-time has led to a decline in full-time, stable jobs available to all women — even those who are not mothers.

Elsewhere in Europe, generous maternity leaves have meant that women are much less likely than men to e managers or achieve other high-powered positions at work.

When you consider that employers areprice-sensitive, risk-averse, and incentive-responding, none of this should be surprising. Women are the sex that bears children, so if you create policies that make it more risky and expensive to hire women, businesses will hire fewer women.

We may wish it were otherwise, of course. We may wish we lived in a world where it was possible to have family-friendly policies in which there would be no unintended consequences or adverse affects on mothers. But because we live in a world where resources (especially time and money) are scarce, we shouldn’t be surprised when businesses respond rationally to the incentives they are given.

The Times article attempts to find a solution, though.

Perhaps the most successful way to devise policies that help working families but avoid unintended consequences, people who study the issue say, is to make them gender neutral. In places like Sweden and Quebec, for instance, parental leave policies encourage both men and women to take time off for a new baby.

“It has to e something that humans do,” Ms. Glynn, from the Center for American Progress, said, “as opposed to something that women do.”

Can anyone spot the flaw in this reasoning? That’s right: Even in a “gender neutral” world only women can get pregnant.

If you made such policies gender neutral, women would still take advantage of them at a higher rate because they are the ones that must bear the children. Even if a culture divided the child-rearing duties more or less equally, an employer would still have an incentive to hire fewer women since they would, all other things being equal, be more likely to be affected by each additional child.

This is not to say that we shouldn’t encourage employers to adopt more family-friendly policies. Because the family is one the most important institutions in society, every other sphere (including business) should do what it can to aid and preserve the family. But it is foolish to try to mandate that which must be done voluntarily. Mandating such policies only causeswomen to suffer the consequences. As the Times article notes, “There is no simple way to prevent family-friendly policies from backfiring, researchers say.”

However, we should also not expect business to bear the burden alone. Other institutions—including churches and the extended family—should also voluntarily do more to help families that are in need of assistance (especially when es to childcare).

We all benefit from strong families and we all suffer when the family is weak. That is why we need more than “family-friendly” employment policies. We need to createa more family-friendly society.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
5 Facts about international human rights
Today is the 70th anniversary of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, a milestone document in the history of human rights. In honor of the observance, here are five facts you should know about international human rights: 1. Prior to the 1940s there were a number of documents, such as the the British Magna Carta and the U.S. Bill of Rights, that advanced the recognition of human rights. But few documents were recognized internationally as applying to all people at...
An Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn centenary
On this day in 1918, Russian writer and historian Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn was born inKislovodsk, Russia, to Taisia and Isaaki Solzhenitsyn, parents of peasant stock who had received a university education. When he died in 2008 near Moscow, Solzhenitsyn had published his monumental Gulag Archipelago and other literary and historical works — which continue to appear in English for the first time. Over the next few weeks, we’ll be posting Acton archival material and new writings and media on the blog...
Samuel Gregg: Paris is burning
“Since 1789, we’ve all had good reason to worry whenever riots break out in Paris,” says Acton research director Samuel Gregg. “Whether it’s 1848 or 1968, social upheaval in France rarely ends well.” The sheer fury vented throughout France by thegilets jaunesmovement over the past three weeks has highlighted specific grievances animating many French citizens. The truth, however, is that the burning cars, blocked highways, vandalism, lawlessness, and running battles between rioters and police in the streets are symptomatic of...
5 Facts about Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn
Yesterday marked the 100th anniversary of the birth of Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn. The celebrated novelist and dissident is considered by many to be a key figure in the demise munism and the collapse of the Soviet Union. As Daniel J. Mahoney says, “Solzhenitsyn embodied, in thought as well as deed, the two great moral wellsprings of European civilization: humility and magnanimity, humble deference to an ‘order of things’ and the spirited defense of human liberty and dignity.” In honor of his...
‘The Great Awokening’: The threat of America’s new political religions
The decline of religion in America is real—that is, depending on how you define “religion.” Weekly church attendance is in decline, as is self-identification with a formal religion, denomination, or belief system. Meanwhile, the rise of the “nones” seems increasingly steady in speed, replacing religious-cultural standards and norms of old with a modern menu of “personal spiritualties” based on any number of humanistic priorities—from humanitarianism to political activism to self-helpism to the garden-variety exultations of hedonism, materialism, fortability. But not...
How taxing work affects employment
Note: This is post #104 in a weekly video series on basic economics. An important factor influencing an individual’s decision whether to keep working as they get older is their government’s tax and retirement policies. Taxes on earnings plus penalties, like losing retirement benefits, gives us an implicit tax rate, explains economist Alex Tabarrok. Countries with higher implicit tax rates for older workers see a much lower labor force participation rate for people considered retirement age. (If you find the...
FAQ: What happens in a confidence vote?
Prime Minister Theresa May will face a confidence vote today between 6 and 8 p.m. local time (1 to 3 p.m. Eastern time). The result is expected no later than 9 p.m. London time. What is a confidence vote, how does it work, and what happens afterwards? What is a confidence vote? Under the UK’s parliamentary system, the ruling party’s leader es prime minister. If the leader loses his or her support, Conservative members of Parliament vote to express their...
From inmates to entrepreneurs: How work transforms the soul and spirit
James, Gene and Dexter at Refoundry With the promising (but now passing) prospect of a new wave of criminal justice reform circulating around Capitol Hill, discussions have reemerged as to how we might improve the justice system to better help and support our prison population (current and former) in rehabilitating their lives and avoiding the status quo of systematic detours. Meanwhile, at a cultural and institutional level, we continue to new ways of helping individuals better recognize their gifts and...
FAQ: Who is Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer, Angela Merkel’s successor in Germany?
On Friday, December 7, Angela Merkel’s ruling Christian Democrats elected Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer as party leader. “AKK,” as she is known, is liberal on economic issues, conservative on social issues, and once called for the Roman Catholic Church to ordain a “quota” of female clerics. Here are the facts you need to know. What happened at Friday’s CDU party leadership vote? Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer narrowly won the delegates’ vote to e party leader of the Christian Democratic Union (CDU) in a narrow,...
A Hanukkah meditation on Maimonides … and venture capitalism
If the average person had to describe a capitalist, he might name “Dickens’ unredeemed Scrooge, or Gordon (‘Greed is good!’) Gecko from the movieWallStreet.” However, the real patron saint of venture capitalism may well be the great Jewish theologian and philosopher Moses Maimonides,writes Laurie Morrow, Ph.D., in a Hanukkah meditationfor Acton’sReligion & Liberty Transatlanticwebsite. “Rambam” believed that the highest form of charity is enabling someone to start a business or take other means so that he will no longer have...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved