Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY
/
When our success threatens our success
When our success threatens our success
Apr 2, 2025 1:42 AM

Book Review of The Complacent Class: The Self-Defeating Quest for the American Dream (St. Martin's Press 2017).

Tyler Cowen addresses the economic and social harms that arise from, as he says in The Complacent Class: The Self-Defeating Quest for the American Dream, “decisions that are at first glance” in our “best interests.” As our decisions play out, they can prove to have consequences “at the societal level” that, while “unintended,” are “not always good.”

Technological advances have created a “new culture of matching” that has improved the quality of life for many of us. At the same time, our ability to get exactly, or almost exactly, what we want also allows us to avoid the disappointments and dissatisfactions that inspired people to pursue the innovations that make matching possible. Paradoxically, getting what we want when we want it has “made us more risk averse and more set in our ways.” Our success threatens our success.

Socially, the matching culture is “more segregated” by education, economic status and especially race. This isn’t, as he stresses throughout the book, necessarily intentional. Butwhile racial intolerance has diminished, racial segregation is ing the norm in those areas of the country that are booming economically. Cowen says this happens because “the rich and well educated are keener to live together, in tight bunches and groups, than are the less well educated.” The irony in this is that “it’s these groups—the wealthy, the well-educated, and the creative class—who plain about inequality and American segregation with the greatest fervor.”

Moreover, when we look past words to deeds, we see that as the “self-selection process” runs its course, “no matter how ostensibly progressive their politics,” the “affluent and well educated in America” who live in large urban areas or centers of technological innovation “may be especially out of touch” with most Americans. Living in fortable bubble, the most successful among us don’t understand how, for all their good intentions, they have helped create a divided society where racial segregation and e inequality are ing mon.

Nevertheless, Cowen sees technology and the matching culture as fundamentally good things. Like many of us, he uses Spotify and Pandora to find music he likes. Software to match “college roommates” or “executives and employees” are socially and economically beneficial. “The bright side” of all this is that matching technologies can make possible “encounters with people who truly have different outlooks than we do and who municate that to us online or later maybe even in a personal meeting.”

But wealth production, technological innovation and a free society share mon foundation in human and Christian virtue. Forgetting this, as Cowen’s book illustrates, makes us vulnerable to the dark side in matching culture.

We are experiencing “a fundamental shift of societal energy away from building a new and freer world and toward rearranging the pieces in the world we already have.” For Cowen, “There was something to be said for patible, more challenge-laden accidental pairings with all their conflicts and messy resolutions.” fort, dissatisfaction and disappointment—whether acute, chronic, moral, social or economic—can spur the kind of innovations that have made the free market so successful in creating and distributing wealth.

In Cowen’s view, fort is also what fosters promise and other “error correction mechanisms” that are at the heart of a free society. On this he approvingly quotes Churchill: “You can always count on Americans to do the right thing—after they’ve tried everything else.” fortable way of life has robbed us of the irritation that motivates us to try new things. Complacency has “sapped us of the pioneer spirit that made America the world’s most productive and innovative economy. Furthermore, all this has happened at a time when we may need American dynamism more than ever before.”

Reading The Complacent Class reminded me of the parable of the rich fool (Luke 12:16-21). In mentary, St. Cyril of Alexandria asks, “What does the rich man do, surrounded by a great supply of many blessings beyond number?” Wealthy though the man is, “He speaks words of poverty.” The man is gripped by “distress and anxiety” because he has not “raise[d] his eyes to God” and does not “cherish love for the poor or desire the esteem it gains.”

Instead of charitable self-sacrifice, the rich fool pursues a life of self-satisfaction in which he, not God, will determine “the length of his life, as if he would also reap this from the ground” as he does wheat (Commentary of Luke, Homily 89). “And I will say to my soul, ‘Soul, you have many goods laid up for many years; take your ease; eat, drink, and be merry.’ (Luke 12:19 NKJV)."

In a word, the rich fool placent.

placency doesn’t mean forgoing productivity or planning for the future. In Proverbs, for example, we are told, “Go to the ant, you sluggard! Consider her ways and be wise” (6:6 NKJV). To be wisemeans, among other things, being productive and governing our lives without need of “captain, overseer or ruler” pel us to plant crops “in the summer” and to gather “food in the harvest” (6:7-8 e autumn.

Like the rich fool, Cowen’s America is in the grip of that gentle and pleasurable idleness about which Solomon warns us:

A little sleep, a little slumber,

A little folding of the hands to sleep—

So shall your e on you like a prowler,

And your need like an armed man.

(Proverbs 6:10-11 NKJV)

Whatever its short-term attractions, a placency means in the longterm that more and more Americans will slide back into the material poverty and tribalism that characterized humanity before the rise of the market economy.

In the last chapter, Cowen implicitly acknowledges the close connection placency and a culture of moral and social decay. He lays out for the readerseveral possible scenarios for America’s eventual “return of chaos” as placent class losses its hold on the culture. Though only time will tell, I suspect he is right when he says the “current system is in some ways broken and that placent class, for all its good intentions, has in some ways failed America.”

Whether this breakdown results in future innovation and economic growth or simply more chaos remains to be seen since. Though it may appear otherwise, the free market is fragile. Economic growth, technological innovation and a free society all depend on our willingness to endure and even pursue a relative degree of fort.

In other words, we must remember that the benefits of a free economy are not guaranteed; they depend on our personal and cultural willingness to cultivate virtue. As Cowen’s work suggests, the crisis we face now is that our success has made us indifferent, and at times even hostile, to the moral foundation that makes success possible.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY
Productivity and Potential
R&L: You have led an incredibly productive and active life, from the early civil rights movement to now working to strengthen the black family. What motivates you? Perkins: I don’t like to see human potential wasted, and that’s what happens when people are left behind, either because the system excludes them or because they have failed to adopt solid values. I spent 22 years, from 1962 to 1980, in rural Mississippi, and prior to that I lived in California....
Religion's Role in Public Life
R&L: Alexis de Tocqueville observed that religion is the first political institution in America, an observation you have said is even more true today than it was in the nineteenth century. Would you explain? Neuhaus: One can make the case that America is in many ways more religious today than it was in the 1830s when Tocqueville wrote. Tocqueville’s understanding of religion as the first political institution had nothing to do with what is viewed today as the influence...
Written on the Heart
Many Americans likely never heard of the concept of natural law until it was made an issue in the Clarence Thomas confirmation hearings. As then, we would do well to consider a good, clear definition. In the broadest sense of the term, natural law embraces the whole field of morality. Murder, adultery, incest, prostitution, theft are universally felt to be wrong; they run contrary to the natural law. Defense of one’s own life and that of others, the recognition...
Challenges Facing the Culture
R&L: What did you mean when you subtitled your 1989 book Against the Night, “Living in the New Dark Ages.” Have the last four years changed your views? Colson: When I wrote Against the Night, I was fearful that we were entering the new dark ages, that the barbarians were not only at the gates of our culture ing over the walls. Looking over these past four years, I see no signs that we are awakening to the threat;...
Chronicle of a Modern Christian Radical
George Weigel’s remarkable biography of a remarkable pope closes with G. K. Chesterton’s description of Saint Thomas More: “He was above all things, historic: He represented at once a type, a turning-point, and an ultimate destiny. If there had not been that particular man at that particular moment, the whole of history would have been different.” This is an apt description of the life and times of Karol Wojtyla, the poet, actor, and philosopher who would e Pope John...
Public Morality: The Jewish Contribution
R&L: There is a recognition by Jewish religious writers that wealth can undermine one’s spiritual well-being. In what way does this occur? Tamari: Since the need for the possession of wealth is an unlimited one, people will do things to earn that wealth; sometimes those actions are morally permissible and other times this great need for wealth, which can almost never be satisfied, will lead them to do things which are neither legal nor moral. In this way the...
Economic Imperialism
R&L: You are sometimes called an “economic imperialist.” What is meant by this? Becker: That refers to my belief that economic analysis can be applied to many problems in social life, not just those conventionally called “economic.” The theme of my Nobel lecture, based on my life’s work, is that the horizons of economics need to be expanded. Economists can talk not only about the demand for cars, but also about matters such as the family, discrimination, and religion,...
Christianity, Classical Liberalism are Liberty's Foundations
R&L: Explain the difference between classical liberalism and modern liberalism. Liggio: Modern liberals have tried to steal the cloak of classical liberalism. Classical liberalism was the dominant philosophy in the United States and England, really, until about the First World War. The war, unfortunately, was a disaster for liberalism, because it disrupted constitutional order. All the countries at war used extreme measures of repression. Even England and America created police states on the model of Germany or their Czarist...
Lessons from Liechtenstein
R&L: In the United States, monarchs are usually seen as either mere figureheads or as malevolent dictators. What is the role of a monarch in a free society? Liechtenstein: In our time, monarchies are an important factor in the stability of a country. The monarchy stands for continuity and moral responsibility for the next generation. The monarchs don’t hold their positions for a few years, and then, after an election, find themselves out of office. Rather, they automatically have...
Markets and Virtue
R&L: Please explore with us the way in which certain human virtues promised by the years of Communist rule in your country. Klaus: Basic human virtues such as thrift, honesty, and fidelity can grow and flourish only in an environment of individual freedom and self-responsibility. Communist totalitarianism deprived people of both of them, made them more passive, more cowardly, and more resigned than in countries with political pluralism, property rights, and market structures. R&L: In the long term, do...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved