Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
What the Kyle Rittenhouse trial taught America about assumptions, keeping peace
What the Kyle Rittenhouse trial taught America about assumptions, keeping peace
Apr 6, 2025 3:23 AM

While questions of police brutality, persistent racism and criminal justice reform should concern all citizens, we must realize that violence and disorder provide no path to a more just future.

Read More…

On Nov. 19, Kyle Rittenhouse was found not guilty on all charges related to the fatal shooting of two men and the wounding of another on the third day of widespread rioting and civil unrest in Kenosha, Wisconsin, in August last year.

The trial had for many Americans e a symbol for debates about the Black Lives Matter movement, the right of self-defense, vigilantism, gun rights, white supremacyand the American justice system itself. In short, it had e a sort of Rorschach test for many of the most controversial issues of the day and everything that is either right or wrong with America itself.

President Joe Biden himself made a statement in the wake of the verdict, in which he noted that many Americans were “feeling angry and concerned, myself included,” but that all must acknowledge “that the jury has spoken.”

Lord Acton once wrote that the chief difficulty of the study of history is that mon report and outward seeming are bad copies of the reality, as the initiated know it.”

mon report and outward seeming of the events in Kenosha related to us by some journalists, pundits and public servants oftenproved bad copies of reality. Theywere weaponized in our polarized polity to disastrous effect, ignoring both a true understanding of events and our own responsibility in accounting for them.

All this began with a phone call placed to police on Aug. 23, 2020, by a woman reporting a domestic incident. The caller related that her boyfriend had taken her rental car’s keys and refused to return them. The boyfriend referred to in the call, Jacob Blake, had an outstanding warrant on charges connected with domestic abuse. Police officers responded to the call and attempted to subdue Blake, firing tasers at him twice but failing to overpower him.

After the initial confrontation with police, Blake was shot multiple times as he entered a vehicle. The officer who shot Blake believed him to have a knife in hand as he twisted toward the officer. Blake later admitted that he had picked up a knife at some point during the first confrontation, that he “wasn’t thinking clearly,” and that he did not intend to use it.

Blake was partially paralyzed as a result of the shooting and pleaded guilty to misdemeanor disorderly conduct. The police officers involved were investigated by the Kenosha County district attorney and the U.S. Justice Department, both of whom declined to bring charges. The arrest gone wrong was tragic but not unlawful.

These details were largely unknown when rioting and civil unrest began in Kenosha later that night. mon report and outward seeming of events —a Black man shot in the back by a White police officer — angered many during a summer in which several of the nation’s cities descended into chaos. Protesters concerned with police brutality, racism and the criminal justice system in general filled the streets, not to mention opportunistic rioters.

This vacuum of law and order also drew in Kyle Rittenhouse, who claimed he went to Kenosha to protect a car dealership from vandalism and to provide medical aid. On Sheridan Road that night there were two confrontations resulting in the shooting deaths of two men and the injury of another, video of which circulated widely on social media. In the chaos of the evening, Rittenhouse was not arrested but turned himself in to police in his hometown of Antioch, Illinois, after the shootings.

The questions of whether Kyle Rittenhouse lawfully possessed the firearm with which he fatally shot two and injured another and if he acted in self-defense has been settled by a jury of his peers in a court of law, which found him not guilty on all counts. The questions posed by the Black Lives Matter movement and its demands, the right of self-defense, vigilantism, gun rights, white supremacy and the American justice system remain.

Each has e a cypher through which various parties and cliques view the troubling events.

What remains unexplored is just how both state and citizenry failed so utterly in providing the basic security of persons and property on which all civilization rests, how media narratives — both traditional and social — can fuel social breakdown and how we as citizens can act responsibly to avoid such tragedies in the future.

While questions of police brutality, persistent racismand criminal justice reform should concern all citizens, we must realize that violence and disorder provide no path to a more just future.

Wherever we find ourselves, we must follow the admonition of the prophet Jeremiah, who councils us to “seek the peace of the city where I have caused you to be carried away captive, and pray to the Lord for it; for in its peace you will have peace.”

This involves a rejection of violence by citizens and mitment to maintain law and order by those in political authority.

We must also reject “just-so stories” that neatly fit our prejudices, and draw on wisdom and patience to find the truth, often hard to discern, of the nature of events and things.

Lastly, we must have solidarity with our fellow citizens, working side by side with themas evidence of mitment to justice and truthif madness is not to overtake us all.

This article originally appeared in The Detroit News on Dec. 8, 2021.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Rev. Robert Sirico on ‘Social Mortgage’
Rev. Robert Sirico was recently featured in El Salvador’s newspaper El Diaro de Hoy. Consuelo Interiano interviewed him about the free market, and social mortgage. Sirico begins by saying that private property isn’t just important for businesses to thrive, it’s absolutely necessary for their existence. He goes on to say that businesses and panies are the best way to help individuals escape poverty. Companies, large or small, create opportunities for work and offer individuals a means to elevate themselves out...
Terry Mattingly and Joe Carter on Surviving Easter
Leading mentator, Terry Mattingly looks back on Easter in an article about Catholics attending services despite the overcrowding from “Poinsettia and Lily Catholics,” those who only attend a Mass on Christmas and Easter. He describes how the influx of those attending mass affects Catholics who faithfully attend church every Sunday. He says: “I really am glad that they’re there,” wrote Fisher. “It’s got to be better than never going to Mass, and I do believe that the Holy Spirit could...
Conference on Poverty Co-Hosted by Acton Institute and Saint Vladimir’s Orthodox Theological Seminary
Saint Vladimir’s Orthodox Theological Seminary and the Acton Institute are co-hosting a “Conference on Poverty,” May 31–June 1, on the seminary campus. Conference speakers include Jay W. Richards, author of Money, Greed, and God, and Senior Fellow at the Discovery Institute; Susan R. Holman, senior writer at Harvard Global Health Institute, and author of The Hungry are Dying: Beggars in Roman Cappadocia and God Knows There’s Need: Christian Responses to Poverty; and Michael Matheson Miller, Acton Institute Research Fellow and...
Before and Beyond the Common Good
I recently argued that although vocation is important, there is a certain something that goes before and beyond it. As Lester DeKoster puts it, “The meaning we seek has to be in work itself.” Over at Think Christian, John Van Sloten puts forth something similar, focusing on our efforts to work for mon good— something not altogether separate from vocation: There’s a lot of talk in faith/work circles about the idea of working for mon good – for the good...
School Vouchers Increase College Attendance for Black Students
New research suggests that school vouchers have a greater impact on whether black students attend college than small class sizes or effective teachers: Matthew M. Chingos of the Brookings Institution and Paul E. Peterson, director of Harvard’s program on education policy and governance, tracked college enrollment information for students who participated in the School Choice Scholarship program, which began in 1997. They were able to get college enrollment information on 2,637 of the 2,666 students in the original cohort. The...
Does the Media Need to Be Schooled in Religion?
Nobody can know everything about everything, but in the age of the internet, fact-checking isn’t too tough. It’s one thing for a high-school student to attempt to slide by on “facts” in a research paper for sophomore social studies, but another when professional journalists make errors about easily investigated pieces of knowledge. Lately, the media has been getting blasted for getting the facts wrong about religion. Carl M. Cannon: The upshot during Holy Week this year was a spate of...
6 Things You Need to Know About Acton University
1. It’s truly international. Last year, we hosted 800+ people from over 70 countries. 2. You can create your own curriculum. Whether you’re interested in business, poverty alleviation and development, economics, history, social thought, urban ministry… just read the list of courses for yourself. You’ll find great stuff there. 2-1/2. We eat really well. 3. There is plenty of time to network, socialize and enjoy meeting all those people from all over the world. 4. The student fee is ridiculously...
Hipsters and Elitists versus Chain Stores
New York City’s hipster and elitist class seem to believe that they should have some role in determining what business owners do with their property. Like hipsters and elitists around the country, New York’s cohort are banding together to panies that do not present the utopian vision for the neighbors where these elites dwell (most of whom are renters, by the way). There is much buzz in New York City right now because more and more national chains are setting...
Think (and Read) before You Blog: A Response to Michael Sean Winters
Over at the National Catholic Reporter, Michael Sean Winters makes ments about my book ing Europe based on a review he had read by Fr. C.J. McCloskey. Here are the most pertinent of his observations: I know that American exceptionalism lives on both the left and the right, but when did the right e so Europhobic? And why? National Catholic Register has a review of a new book by the Acton Institute’s Samuel Gregg entitled ing Europe: Economic Decline, Culture,...
Journalists Bearing False Witness in Boston
There are arguably two forces that may be destroying the ethics of journalism today. The first is petition for rankings and advertising that drives the obsession to report something “first” in a 24-hour news cycle. The second is that social media exacerbates the first. These two forces make journalists vulnerable to poor, unethical reporting. We are seeing this play out in what could easily be considered unethical coverage of the tragedy in Boston by CNN and other news platforms. On...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved