Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
What Patricia Arquette Should Have Said About the Wage Gap and Women’s Rights
What Patricia Arquette Should Have Said About the Wage Gap and Women’s Rights
Nov 5, 2024 2:10 PM

During last night’s Oscar ceremony, Best Supporting Actresswinner Patricia Arquette used her acceptance speech to rail against unfair pay for women:

To every women who gave birth to every taxpayer and citizen of this nation, we have fought for everybody else’s equal rights. It’s our time … to have wage equality once and for all and equal rights for women in the United States of America.

The wage equality that Arquette is referring to is the gender wage gap—the difference between male and female earnings expressed as a percentage of male earnings. Because she frames the issue as a matter of equal rights, Arquette presumably believes that the problem is caused by intentional discrimination.

The gender wage gap certainly exists, but there is considerable debate about the size of the gap and whether it is caused primary by discrimination or by other factors, such as education and work hours. Much of the confusion is caused by the use of misleading statistics by politically motivated groups. For example, last night the Department of Labor (DOL)posted on their Twitter account:

FACT: Women make 78% of what their male counterparts make. Learn more: #Oscars

To say that the Labor Department was being intentionally dishonest would require knowing their motives. It’s much easier to assume basic petence. For instance, the tweet claims the gap is 78 percent. But on the “Equal Pay” page they link to the gap is claimed to be 81 percent (“women earn about 81 cents on the pared to men”). Dig deeper onto the site and you’ll find other claims, such as that the gap is77 percent. The differences may seem small, but it reveals a significant problem when a government agency can’t even agree with itself about what the real number should be.

One number you won’t find on their “Equal Pay” page is 94 percent. That was the true wage gap found in a 2009 study by the economics consulting firm CONSAD ResearchCorporation, prepared for the Department of Labor. In the introduction to the report the Labor Department says, “the raw wage gap continues to be used in misleading ways to advance public policy agendas without fully explaining the reasons behind the gap. The purpose of this report is to identify the reasons that explain the wage gap in order to more fully inform policymakers and the public.” That statement is rather prophetic since the DOL is now the one using “misleading ways to advance public policy agendas” related to the wage gap.

As this video by the Independent Women’s Forum explains, the causes of the gender wage gap are mostly based on individual preferences:

The gender wage gap isn’t the most pressing public policy issue even in the area of equal rights for women. But for those who are concerned about gender wage discrimination, there’s a simple solution: increased free petition. As AEI’s Andrew Biggs and Mark Perry explain,

Some gender discrimination in the labor market certainly does exist. But the best solution isn’t more lawsuits. In fact, the Obama administration’s proposal to shift the burden of proof in gender discrimination cases against employers would make hiring a female employee a potential legal liability for employers, and thus employers would hire fewer women.

What female workers need is a vibrant petitive workplace, since it petition that weeds out discrimination. When one employer discriminates against women, a new employer could earn a windfall profit by hiring an all-female workforce and paying them slightly more. … Several studies have shown that as industries faced petition, through either deregulation or international trade, the gender pay gap shrank. And the pay gap is larger in monopoly markets petition and smaller in start-ups and small businesses that must be productive in order to survive. Women need more markets, more enterprise, and more opportunity, not more regulation and litigation.

Maybe that’s what Arquette really meant, that women “need more markets, more enterprise, and more opportunity.” (It seems to have worked well for her.) If she had made that claim in her speech last night it would have been a positive proposal for advancing equal rights for women. And if she had spoken that truth to the Hollywood audience it would have been a performance worthy of another Oscar.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Absolute Comfort Corrupts Absolutely
Lord Acton famously said that, “Power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely.” Joseph Pearce finds fort can play a similar role in our lives and that fort corrupts absolutely.” That is why we tend to numb ourselves with distractions, from mood-altering drugs to social media: Shortly after Odysseus and his men leave Troy, heading home after the interminable siege and ultimate destruction of that City, they land on the island of the Lotus-Eaters. After the horrors of war,...
10 Things Political Scientists Know That We Don’t
“If economics is the dismal science,” says Hans Noel, an associate professor at Georgetown University, “then political science is the dismissed science.” Most Americans—from pundits to voters—don’t think that political science has much to say about political life. But there are some things, notes Noel, that “political scientists know that it seems many practitioners, pundits, journalists, and otherwise informed citizens do not.” Here are excerpts from Noel’s list of ten things political scientists know that you don’t: #1. It’s The...
Is Christian Worldview Worth a Premium?
In an interview on Christian distance education, Dylan Pahman, the assistant editor for Acton’s Journal of Markets & Morality, talks about the education bubble, rising costs of higher education, and whether Christian worldview integration in a distance education program is worth a premium: Luke Morgan: As a blogger for the Acton Institute, you have written about the education bubble, the textbook bubble, and other items regarding what education costs, and how those things should work in a free market. Could...
Radio Free Acton: Remembering Holodomor with Luba Markewycz
In this edition of Radio Free Acton, Paul Edwards speaks with Luba Markewycz of the Ukrainian Institute of Modern Art in Chicago, Illinois about the Holodomor – the Great Famine of the 1930s inflicted on Ukraine by Josef Stalin’s Soviet Government that killed millions of Ukrainians through starvation. They discuss the Holodomor itself, and the process undertaken by Markewycz to create an exhibition of art by young Ukrainians memorate the event. You can listen to the podcast using the audio...
Is Putin an Orthodox Jihadist?
What should Westerners make of Vladimir Putin? Some view the Russian president as a type of Western democratic politician while others think he is shaped by Chekism, the idea that the secret political police control (or should control) everything in society. But John R. Schindler, an Orthodox Christian, thinks the West may be underestimating the influence of militant Russian Orthodoxy on Putin’s worldview: In his fire-breathing speech to the Duma in March when he announced Russia’s annexation of Crimea, Putin...
Pope Francis, World Day Of Peace And Human Trafficking
January 1, for Catholics, is celebrated as the World Day of Peace. For January 1, 2015, Pope Francis’ message is a reflection on the horror of human trafficking. Entitled No Longer Slaves But Brothers And Sisters, the pope’s message calls trafficking an “abominable phenomenon” which cheapens human life and denies basic human rights to those enslaved. Taking his theme from St. Paul’s letter to Philemon, Pope Francis reflects on human dignity and true fraternity among all peoples. Pope Francis prayerfully...
Is Christianity Driving China’s Economic Growth?
For the past three decades China has been the world’s fastest-growing major economy, with growth rates averaging 10 percent a year for 30 years. As Brian J. Grim, founder and president of the Religious Freedom & Business Foundation, notes, there are many reasons for the growth, such as market mechanisms, modern technology and Western management practices. But one factor that is often overlooked is the role of Christianity: A study by Purdue University’s Fenggang Yang (cited recently in the Economist)...
Undercover Boss Celebrates Female Dehumanization
To end the 2014 on an incredibly dehumanizing note, CBS aired an episode of Undercover Boss that stirred up protests from all walks of life. Undercover Boss is usually a wonderful program that allows CEOs to see what is happening on the ground in panies and reward hard workers accordingly. However, this particular episode profiled Doug Guller, the CEO of Bikinis Sports Bar & Grill, who fired a bartender after she decided not to dehumanize herself by wearing a T-shirt...
Why Do Black Lives Matter?
“Black lives matter.’ ‘All lives matter. These slogans may forever summarize the deep tensions in American life in 2014,’ says Anthony Bradley in this week’s Acton Commentary. “We can loudly protest that “Black lives matter” but it will mean nothing in the long run if we cannot explain why black lives matter.” Black lives matter because black people are persons. One of the greatest tragedies in American history was the myth that America could flourish without blacks flourishing as persons....
The Year in Acton Commentary 2014
Every Wednesday we publish the Acton Commentary, a weekly article that covers topics related to Acton’s mission. As es to a close I thought it would be worth highlighting the mentaries that have been produced by Acton Institute staffers over the past year. Rev. Robert A. Sirico A Dangerous Moment with Promise The Holy War on Corporate Politicking Pope Francis, without the politics The Holy War on Corporate Politicking Pope Francis, without the politics Samuel Gregg Poverty, the Rule of...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved