Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
What if we redistributed all profits to workers?
What if we redistributed all profits to workers?
Sep 15, 2025 6:37 AM

A plaint by the political left is that the CEOs of panies earn too much money. The implication is not, however, that the “excess” money should be distributed to the shareholders (who actually own pany). Instead, the ideais that “fairness” requires that much of theprofitthat normally goes toward the CEO’s pay should be redistributed to the rest of pany’s employees.

But what if we took it a step further: What if we redistributed all corporate profits to workers? What if the profits of every pany were not given to the shareholders but divided equally among every worker in America?How much do you think it would raise the average worker’s pay?

Take a moment to do a rough guestimation of how much the hourly wage would be raised if all profits were redistributed. Have a number in mind?

The answer to the question is that the average worker’s hourly wage would increase by . . .

. . . $7 an hour.

Kevin A. Hassett crunched the numbers e up with that figure:

To answer this question, we gathered data on after-tax corporate profits from the Bureau of Economic Analysis. We then gathered data on average hours worked per week per nonfarm employee from the Bureau of Labor Statistics and transformed these weekly data into data on the aggregate number of yearly hours worked by all nonfarm employees. Finally, we divided quarterly corporate profits by the aggregate number of hours worked by nonfarm employees over the same period, labeling this value the “expropriation subsidy” on the chart. To get an idea of how much of a per hour wage increase this policy could create, simply add the values of the two lines at a point in time.

As the chart shows, if every dollar of U.S. corporate profits were allocated to America’s employees, the effect would be to add a bit more than $7 to the average wage.

For most of us, $7 an hour would be a e raise. But it also wouldn’t be life-changing. The average hourly wage for non-government workers is currently $25. Bumping it to $32 would have a small effect on our lifestyles, and almost no affect at all on the overall economy.

Most people with a basic understanding of economics realize that making a profit is a necessary incentive to encourage people to take the risks and endure the hassles e with starting and running a business. If you work at a pany, think what would happen if the business you work for stopped earning a profit. You probably realize that it’d be better to forego a $7 bump in pay if it meant getting to have and keep a job your job.

Yet most economically literate people who wouldn’t risk their own jobs over a $7 increase in pay are more than willing to risk the elimination of someone else’s job for that same amount. That is essentially what is happening in thedebate about raising the minimum wage to $15 an hour.

The current federal minimum wage is $7.25 an hour. If we added $7 more we’d get a wage of $14.25. The “Fight for $15” campaign would increase it an additional .75 cents.

So where do employers get the additional $7.75 increase to pay their workers? From their profits. The problem, of course, is that many firms that hire minimum wage workers don’t have sufficient profits to pay an increase of $7 an hour.

Keep in mind the $7 we mentioned earlier was from all private industries. Many of the most profitable firms are the ones that do not hire many minimum wage workers. Of the 20 most panies in the world, nine are based in the United States. These include two banks, Wells Fargo and JPMorgan Chase; two panies, Exxon Mobil and Chevron; two technology firms, Apple and Microsoft; and the conglomerate Berkshire Hathaway.

You don’t see many minimum wage bank tellers or gas station attendants in America. The reason is because those industries found ways to automate (e.g., ATMs and pay-at-pump machines) to eliminate their low-skilled labor costs. So the industries that often make less profit than the average are the ones that are expected to bear the brunt of the cost ofsubsidizing the increase in minimum wages.

While it may feel that raising the minimum wage is the right thing to do, it doesn’t help those who are put out of a job because they are priced out of the labor market. If you wouldn’t want to lose your own job so that someone else could make an additional $7 an hour, then you shouldn’t be eager to do the same to America’s least-skilled workers.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
The state of flux
The new Paramount movie Aeon Flux starring Charlize Theron paints a picture of a post-apocalyptic future for humankind. But the “perfect society” will remain a myth this side of the eschaton, says Jordan Ballor. The fulfillment of merely human potential cannot approach the “fullness of hope es with the recognition of God and an afterlife,” he writes. Read the mentary here. ...
Cartoon Incorporated
Says Harvard economist Kenneth Rogoff: Hollywood’s cartoon-like caricatures of evil multinational corporations may some day seize mainstream consciousness, leading to political upheavals that shatter today’s social contract. That won’t be good for profits, or for the poor. For more on Tinseltown’s demonization of multinational corporations, see “The Manchurian Mistake.” ...
Self-interest run amok
Anyone familiar with the Acton Institute knows we appreciate the work of economists. But we also object when economists overreach and try to apply useful tools and concepts in inappropriate ways. This happens, for example, when they claim that the charity of Mother Teresa can be exhaustively explained by reference to self-interest. (She gets warm feelings and satisfaction from what she does, you see.) Well, here’s a blunt example of such thinking. Richard Tomkins in the Financial plains this holiday...
Keeping the Kalamazoo Promise
I haven’t had a chance to talk about this yet, but early last month, school district officials in Kalamazoo, Michigan announced “The Kalamazoo Promise.” The Promise consists of a group of anonymous donors that e together mit to fund the post-secondary education of every student of the Kalamazoo Public School system. To receive full-funding for four years, you must have to attend KPS schools from grades K-12 (funding is gradually decreased depending on the number of years in the system)....
Results matter
A Boston-based program operated by clergy and police officers, the Boston Re-Entry, was denied further funding for their ex-convict re-integration program, seemingly and at least in part because they were not ing about their program’s results. The Black Ministerial Alliance is one of the major groups involved in the program. The Boston Globe reports that “applicants for funds from President Bush’s Prisoner Reentry Initiative were required to demonstrate a record of success in rehabilitating ex-convicts. The proposal from the ministers...
Christian solidarity
“No man is an island unto himself. Every man is a piece of the continent, a part of the main.” —John Donne “For none of us lives to himself alone and none of us dies to himself alone.” —Romans 14:7 ...
Life, liberty, and the pursuit of a crisp image
An interesting piece today by George Will, outlining what he calls a new government entitlement program that is being batted around the House and Senate: $990 million (according to the House) or $3 billion (according to the Senate) to subsidize digital converters for television sets. The idea is that by 2009, analog transmission will be a thing of the past, and even though most households by that time will already have digital televisions, our beneficent leaders consider it their responsibility...
R&L Autumn issue features Winter
For those of you looking for some holiday reading, check out the new issue of Religion & Liberty. The issue features an interview with Ralph Winter, producer of such films as X-Men, X-Men 2, X-Men 3, The Fantastic Four, a Star Trek here and there, and a host of other films. Besides being an A-list producer in Hollywood, Winter is known for his Christian faith and insights into ‘the industry of influence’. The issue also features an article by critic...
‘The War on Christmas’
“Happy Holidays” has e the accepted greeting in December. Even the White House has embraced “Happy Holidays” over the more traditional and Christian “Merry Christmas.” Understandably, many people are upset about the use of the word “holiday” rather than “Christmas.” I wanted to take a quick look at some traditions surrounding the December holidays, sorting out which situations should be using “Christmas” and which should be using “Holiday.” First off, saying “Happy Holidays” is a very easy, quick, inoffensive and...
Pascal wagers, Kant bets
You probably have heard of Pascal’s Wager, but have you heard of Kant’s Bet? Immanuel Kant, the 18th century moral philosopher, famous for his discussion of the categorical imperative, has an interesting section bearing on economics in his Canon of Pure Reason es at the conclusion of his Critique of Pure Reason). In the section discussion epistemology, entitled, “Opining, Knowing, and Believing,” Kant explores the difference between subjective conviction that something is true and objective certainty. The personal basis for...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved