Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
What if we redistributed all profits to workers?
What if we redistributed all profits to workers?
Dec 28, 2025 1:33 PM

A plaint by the political left is that the CEOs of panies earn too much money. The implication is not, however, that the “excess” money should be distributed to the shareholders (who actually own pany). Instead, the ideais that “fairness” requires that much of theprofitthat normally goes toward the CEO’s pay should be redistributed to the rest of pany’s employees.

But what if we took it a step further: What if we redistributed all corporate profits to workers? What if the profits of every pany were not given to the shareholders but divided equally among every worker in America?How much do you think it would raise the average worker’s pay?

Take a moment to do a rough guestimation of how much the hourly wage would be raised if all profits were redistributed. Have a number in mind?

The answer to the question is that the average worker’s hourly wage would increase by . . .

. . . $7 an hour.

Kevin A. Hassett crunched the numbers e up with that figure:

To answer this question, we gathered data on after-tax corporate profits from the Bureau of Economic Analysis. We then gathered data on average hours worked per week per nonfarm employee from the Bureau of Labor Statistics and transformed these weekly data into data on the aggregate number of yearly hours worked by all nonfarm employees. Finally, we divided quarterly corporate profits by the aggregate number of hours worked by nonfarm employees over the same period, labeling this value the “expropriation subsidy” on the chart. To get an idea of how much of a per hour wage increase this policy could create, simply add the values of the two lines at a point in time.

As the chart shows, if every dollar of U.S. corporate profits were allocated to America’s employees, the effect would be to add a bit more than $7 to the average wage.

For most of us, $7 an hour would be a e raise. But it also wouldn’t be life-changing. The average hourly wage for non-government workers is currently $25. Bumping it to $32 would have a small effect on our lifestyles, and almost no affect at all on the overall economy.

Most people with a basic understanding of economics realize that making a profit is a necessary incentive to encourage people to take the risks and endure the hassles e with starting and running a business. If you work at a pany, think what would happen if the business you work for stopped earning a profit. You probably realize that it’d be better to forego a $7 bump in pay if it meant getting to have and keep a job your job.

Yet most economically literate people who wouldn’t risk their own jobs over a $7 increase in pay are more than willing to risk the elimination of someone else’s job for that same amount. That is essentially what is happening in thedebate about raising the minimum wage to $15 an hour.

The current federal minimum wage is $7.25 an hour. If we added $7 more we’d get a wage of $14.25. The “Fight for $15” campaign would increase it an additional .75 cents.

So where do employers get the additional $7.75 increase to pay their workers? From their profits. The problem, of course, is that many firms that hire minimum wage workers don’t have sufficient profits to pay an increase of $7 an hour.

Keep in mind the $7 we mentioned earlier was from all private industries. Many of the most profitable firms are the ones that do not hire many minimum wage workers. Of the 20 most panies in the world, nine are based in the United States. These include two banks, Wells Fargo and JPMorgan Chase; two panies, Exxon Mobil and Chevron; two technology firms, Apple and Microsoft; and the conglomerate Berkshire Hathaway.

You don’t see many minimum wage bank tellers or gas station attendants in America. The reason is because those industries found ways to automate (e.g., ATMs and pay-at-pump machines) to eliminate their low-skilled labor costs. So the industries that often make less profit than the average are the ones that are expected to bear the brunt of the cost ofsubsidizing the increase in minimum wages.

While it may feel that raising the minimum wage is the right thing to do, it doesn’t help those who are put out of a job because they are priced out of the labor market. If you wouldn’t want to lose your own job so that someone else could make an additional $7 an hour, then you shouldn’t be eager to do the same to America’s least-skilled workers.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Health Care Reform Begins at Home
This is the Acton Commentary for January 12. “Americans of all ages, all conditions, and all dispositions constantly form associations,” wrote French observer Alexis de Tocqueville in the 1830s. “If it is proposed to inculcate some truth or to foster some feeling by the encouragement of a great example, they form a society.” Could this organizing spirit hold the potential to transform the nation’s health care? With the House in Republican hands, it appears that the 2010 Patient Protection and...
What Indians and Chinese make of their tycoons
An interesting report in The Economist on the rise of flashy and free spending entrepreneur “gazillionaires” in India and China and how they are perceived: In much of India, life is getting perceptibly better each year. Wealth per person has vaulted by 150% in the past decade, from $2,000 to $5,000. Many Indians think the nation’s entrepreneurs deserve some of the credit. In Dharavi, a slum outside Mumbai, an illiterate mother called Aruna sits in her tiny one-room flat, which...
The Sheep and the Goats: Work and Service to Others
In this week’s Acton Commentary, “The Sheep and the Goats: Work and Service to Others,” I visit Lester DeKoster’s interpretation of the parable of the sheep and the goats from Matthew 25. Although not many have discussed this as an “economic” parable, DeKoster’s point is that anyone who truly serves another through legitimate work, whether paid or unpaid, can be understood to be a “sheep.” Work, for DeKoster, is “the form in which we make ourselves useful to others, and...
The Golden Mean and the Problem of Executive Compensation
There was a good deal of discussion in the media over “unfair” pensation, especially in light of the bonuses, golden parachutes, and other forms of remuneration received by CEOs during the bailout. I have yet to hear plaint about CEOs being underpaid, though. But this might change as it es apparent that pensation of executives might well be a way to wriggle out of higher payroll tax liability. Consider the case of CPA David Watson, who “incurred the wrath of...
Preview: R&L Interviews Thomas C. Oden
Tom Oden In the ing Winter 2011 issue of Religion & Liberty, we are featuring an interview with Thomas C. Oden. The interview mainly focuses on the importance and wisdom of the Church Fathers and their deep relevancy for today’s Church and culture. The content below however delves into Marxist liberation theology and the direction of Oden’s own denomination, The United Methodist Church. Some of the below portion will be available only for readers of the PowerBlog. I’d like to...
Martin Luther King, Jr. and Natural Law
A popular citation of Martin Luther King, Jr.’s justly-famous “Letter from Birmingham Jail” is his reference to natural law and Thomas Aquinas: How does one determine whether a law is just or unjust? A just law is a man-made code that squares with the moral law or the law of God. An unjust law is a code that is out of harmony with the moral law. To put it in the terms of St. Thomas Aquinas: An unjust law is...
Free eBook: A Prescription for Health Care Reform
With health care moving back to center stage in Washington, we’re publishing Dr. Donald Condit’s Acton monograph A Prescription for Health Care Reform as a free eBook readable in a variety of formats. This excellent work continues to be available for $6 (paperback) in the Acton Bookshoppe. For your free eBook, visit Acton’s Smashwords page. The Condit book will soon be available in the Kindle store (no charge for that, either) and in other eBook retail sites. We’ll keep you...
Radio Free Acton: Concealing Christian Identity
Radio Free Acton hits the web once again today, this time featuring an exchange between Hunter Baker, author of The End of Secularism, and Jonathan Malesic, author of Secret Faith in the Public Square: An Argument for the Concealment of Christian Identity. Their conversation continues an exchange begun in the Controversy section of the latest issue of Acton’s Journal of Markets & Morality. Should Christians be overt about their faith when operating in the public square, or should Christian identity...
Journal of Markets & Morality 13, no. 2 (Fall 2010)
The latest issue of the Journal of Markets & Morality (13.2) is now available online to subscribers. This issue features a fine set of articles from Manfred Spieker, Gregorio Guitián, Joseph Burke, and Jim Skillen. It also has the usual range of book reviews, so ably overseen by the journal’s book review editor Kevin Schmiesing. This issue also has two special features. The first is a controversy between Jonathan Malesic, assistant professor of theology at King’s College in Wilkes-Barre, Pennsylvania,...
CFP: Modern Christian Social Thought (JMM 14.2)
I’ve issued a call for publication for a special issue of the Journal of Markets & Morality to appear in the Fall of 2011 (14.2). The details are below, and you can download and circulate a PDF as well. Call for Publication: Modern Christian Social Thought In recognition of a number of significant anniversaries occurring this year, the Journal of Markets & Morality invites submissions for a special theme issue, “Modern Christian Social Thought” (vol. 14, no. 2). The year...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved