Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
What Exactly Does “Middle Class” Mean?
What Exactly Does “Middle Class” Mean?
Nov 13, 2024 10:19 AM

Whether they wear boxers or briefs is none of my concern. Nor do I care whether they choose to use a PC or a Mac. When es to presidential candidates one of the least-asked question I want answered is, “What do you mean when you say ‘middle class?’”

This undefined group of citizens seems to be a favorite of politicians on both ends of the political spectrum. Reagan and Bush cut their taxes. Bill Clinton and Obama did too (or so they claim).

Hillary Clinton has proposed cutting their taxes as has every Republican candidate. Even the socialist Bernie Sanders has said he’d lower taxes on the middle class (by raising taxes on the “rich”, naturally).

What they rarely ever explain, though, is who exactly they consider to be “middle class.” Most people use the term as a means of emotion-based self-categorization (“I don’t feel rich or poor so I must be middle class”). Ask the janitor sweeping pany’s floors and he’ll likely tell you he’s middle class. Query the vice-president of marketing and he will give you the same answer. The single girls down in accounts payable and the married attorneys in the legal department will give the same response.

In the land of equal opportunity, it appears, we’re all middle class.

But for the term is to be of any use it has to be clearly defined. When the presidential candidates offer to give money back to the “working poor” while promising to “soak the rich” how do we know they aren’t talking about us?

The reason the question is so difficult to answer is there is no consensus standard on what constitutes middle class.

Using the strict definition of “middle” we could use the median household e; in 2014, that was $53,657.If your family brings in $53,657 a year then let me be the first to congratulate you— you, my friend, are indisputably the middle of the middle class (at least as measured by e).

But how far above and below do we stretch the boundaries?

The Pew Research Center define e households as those whose annual household e is two-thirds to double the U.S. median household e after es have been adjusted for household size. According to Pew, “This amounts to about $42,000 to $126,000 annually, in 2014 dollars and for a household of three. e households have es less than two-thirds of the median, while e households have es that are more than double the median.”

Oddly, this metric seems both too broad and too narrow. If your family earns $42,000 a year and you triple your e you’d still be middle class. Yet if you earn $126,000 a year and earn an additional $1,000 you are suddenly in the bracket with the wealthy. That’s a problem with any numbers based bracket, of course, since therehasto be a cutoff somewhere.

Yet doesn’t that show the terms like “working poor,” “middle class,” and “rich” are too broad to be useful in our fluid and varied economy?

In East Texas, where I was raised, earning $126,000 a year will put you in the upper stratus of society. With the same e in San Francisco, however, you would be lucky to meet the mortgage requirements to buy a home. If the determination of whether you are rich or poor depends on your zip code then e shouldn’t be the only standard used.

(Perhaps rather than e levels we should consider levels of consumption.One measure of consumption used by Notre Dame Professor James X. Sullivan that includes spending on food, transportation, entertainment, housing and other items and excludes health care expenses and education (which Sullivan says might be considered investments) defines the middle class as those in the middle fifth of spending: between $38,200 and $49,900.)

Since we live in a country where the value of an e is a relative matter, why do politicians speak about it in such absolute terms? Because it let’s them make claims in which voters assume they aren’t talking about them personally (“They won’t be raising my taxes, I’m middle class.).

Don’t let them get away with that obfuscation. Never let a politician use the term “middle class” without finding out what they mean e, consumption, etc.) and what number they have in mind. Otherwise, you may be surprised at tax time to find that you aren’t middle class after all.

Note: Pew has a calculator that let’s you determine whether you are upper, middle, or lower class based on your household e and number of people in your household.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Book Review: ‘Sex and the Unreal City’ by Anthony Esolen
Sex and the Unreal City. Anthony Esolen Ignatius Press. 2020. 209 pages. What is the primary problem in society? An embrace of unreality, answers Anthony Esolen in his latest book, Sex and the Unreal City. In Esolen’s view, our culture has moved beyond promoting immorality to fully adopting unrealities as foundational “truths.” Esolen uses cutting wit to highlight how society is built upon false premises and promotes departure from reality. He says that someone ignoring the nature of reality is...
Joe Biden’s $15 minimum wage hike: when bad ideas cross the Atlantic
Joe Biden’s choices to serve in his potential Cabinet show the deep and unmistakable influence of labor unions. So does his promise to raise the minimum wage to $15 an hour, a pivotal part of organized labor’s agenda that disproportionately shuts young, poor, and minority workers out of the workforce. The good news is the minimum wage has e practically irrelevant to U.S. workers. The Wall Street Journal noted last August that “a tiny share of Americans, just 0.28% of...
Jimmy Lai faces life in prison under new ‘national security law’ charges
Chinese Communist authorities have levied new charges against Jimmy Lai, which could result the outspoken Catholic dissident spending the rest of his life in prison. On Friday, authorities formally charged the Hong Kong media tycoon with violating its restrictive“national security law.” “After in-depth investigation by National Security Department of Hong Kong Police, a 73-year-old man was charged with an additional offense of ‘collusion with a foreign country or with external elements to endanger national security,’” Hong Kong police announced via...
Checks and balances were built for today
First, a truism: Checks and balances are at the foundation of our national government. Second, a cliché: The U.S. is increasingly polarized. Combining these two, mentators have been eager to forecast the end of checks and balances in a time of political jockeying. But they misunderstand the very aim of checks and balances. For instance, according to one op-ed in the New York Times, “Democratic institutions function only when power is exercised with restraint. When parties abandon the spirit of...
FAQ: What is Hanukkah?
Hanukkah, the Jewish Festival of Lights, runs from the evening of Thursday, December 10 until Friday, December 18, 2020. Here is what you need to know. What is the history of Hanukkah? Hanukkah is the Hebrew word for “dedication,” and the holiday celebrates the rededication of the Jerusalem Temple after pagan desecration. The Syrian ruler Antiochus IV Epiphanes captured the Second Temple in Jerusalem in 168 B.C. and dedicated it to the worship of Zeus. To add insult to injury,...
Chinese Communist ‘Gospel’ teaches that Jesus killed a woman
China’s Communist government has given the world another example of how socialism is patible with Christianity, literally chapter and verse. A Chinese textbook teaches students that Jesus Christ stoned a woman to death while admitting that He is a sinner. China’s besieged Christian population says the government has twisted the Gospel in an effort to convince young people to obey edicts handed down by the Chinese Communist Party. The offending passage appears in a textbook intended to teach law and...
Jimmy Lai, 2020 Acton award recipient, arrested and denied bail
Jimmy Lai, the outspoken Catholic dissident who has dedicated his Hong Kong-based media empire to exposing Chinese repression, has been arrested on new charges and ordered to spend the next four months in jail. If convicted, Lai – who received the Acton Institute’s 2020 Faith and Freedom Award two weeks ago – as well as two of his associates face up to 14 years in prison. Authorities rounded up the men and pressed new charges during a hearing at the...
The heart of demographic decline: Why ‘pro-family’ policies won’t save us
In his 2013 book, What to Expect When No One’s Expecting, Jonathan V. Last warned of the ing demographic disaster,” pointing to America’s recent dip below replacement-level fertility. Today, the rate of decline still shows little sign of slowing, driven by plex “constellation of factors” that range from genuine blessings, to “problems of plenty,” to idols of choice and convenience. No matter how we parse the patchwork of potential causes, Last concludes that “there is something about modernity itself that...
Moderna’s market-oriented COVID-19 vaccine miracle
When the world faced a incurable pandemic, Big Pharma delivered. Moderna has joined Pfizer in successfully creating a COVID-19 vaccine with breathtaking speed, only to encounter the glacial pace of the government’s “expedited” approval process. Moderna actually developed a cure that is 95% effective, mRNA-1273, in just two days this January as part of the Trump administration’s Operation Warp Speed. At a time when few people – reportedly even members of the research team – had heard of the novel...
Who is Xavier Becerra, Joe Biden’s HHS nominee?
Joe Biden frequently says that he “seeks not to divide, but unify” Americans. But his announcement that he would like California Attorney General Xavier Becerra to lead the Department of Health and Human Services undercuts that sentiment. Xavier Becerra has repeatedly demonstrated how unsuitable he is for the job of overseeing Americans’ healthcare. He has said the disastrous Affordable Care Act is a good start, but not a sufficient government intervention into healthcare. He has shown himself hostile to religious...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved