Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Value investing: Restoring ownership and ethics to investment
Value investing: Restoring ownership and ethics to investment
Feb 1, 2026 11:46 PM

In today’s global economy, it can be easy to feel like robotic worker bees or petty consumer fleas in a big, blurry economic order. The feeling is understandable. Value creation, even at its largest margins, is increasingly difficult to spot.

That’s not necessarily a bad thing, of course. Size, scale, and efficiency all have significant perks. But while we should be wary of the modern to temptation to blindly castigate “big business” only because of its bigness, we should also be mindful that consolidation and centralization do, e with their own assortment of risks and blind spots.

Which brings us to the more basic question: As our economy continues to grow in size plexity and efficiency, what might we lose if we’re not paying attention? I’ve outlined some of those risks as it relates to the effects of economic modernity on trade and consumerism, family andchild-rearing, and physical labor, but the areas of impact are endless.

In a new video from the Denver Institute for Faith and Work, we see how the same pitfalls and tendencies can occur when es to investment and ownership. And one of the ways we might respond:

Mutual funds are one the most popular ways that people choose to invest, yet they offer little visibility into what, exactly, the funds are supporting. What do our investments actually purchase? What kind of ownership are buyers stepping into?

For many, those questions warrant a shrug, at best. For Eventide, a Boston-based asset management firm, those are questions worth answering, requiring inputs and information that go well beyond balance sheets and surface-level measurements of financial health.

“As an investor in mutual funds, not only do you not have any idea how panies you own are being operated, you don’t even know what you own,” says Eventide’s Jason Myhre. “Investing’s original and most basic purpose is about supplying capital to create businesses. But today investing has really e divorced from that ownership idea, and people are really seeking to profit from the market itself as an abstract entity.”

This isn’t to say that mutual funds are “bad.” They have a productive and fruitful place in financial stewardship. But again, in a world where this represents the status quo of everyday investment, what might we lose if we’re not attentive to the underlying distinctions? Eventide seeks to restore that care and concern among investors, offering an opportunity to regain an ownership mentality of investment and, more importantly, know es with it.

“The thesis is that investing is ownership,” says Finny Kuruvilla, pany’s CIO. “You’re connected to panies via your fund manager. So you’ll be a .001% owner of pany, and ownership should invite us to consider more carefully, ‘Well, what are the things do we own?’ You then have some ethical degree of involvement with the activities of pany.”

To assess pany, Eventide uses what they call a “Business 360” approach, grading how the business engages with a wide range of stakeholders, including customers, employees, supply chain participants, munities, the overall environment, and broader society. Some might be tempted to call this a varied approach to “social entrepreneurship,” but for the folks at Eventide, they’d prefer that we avoid mon dichotomization between “social good” and “profitability.”

“When we talk about investing, in our minds, we tend to dichotomize what’s smart and what’s right,” says Myhre. “But for Biblical thinkers…and I think the call of any believer today, is to not see those as separable concepts. So when we talk about investing and this idea of value creation, it’s not ‘profit takes this path’ and then ‘social good takes this other path’ and we’re trying to hold them together with some kind of a linkage or make some kind of a trade-off decision. We believe that what is right is also what is smart.”

In an economic order that is increasingly big and blurry and difficult to navigate, and amid a culture that prefers investment via routine deposits/withdrawals, Eventide reminds us that we can still prioritize intentional ownership in the information age, using human wisdom, human conscience, and spiritual discernment as stewards in service of the Supreme Investor.

“Conscience is there,” write Gerard Berghoef and Lester DeKoster in their book, Faithful in All God’s House. “We need not, and could not, create it. But how exciting a challenge to enlist its voice in our efforts to serve the Christ through obedience to the divine Law in the form of good stewardship.”

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Pope Benedict: Justice is not enough
Last Saturday Pope Benedict XVI addressed a group called Italian National Civil Protection, made up largely of volunteers. This is the organization that provided much of the crowd control at two of Rome’s largest public events, the World Youth Day in 2000, and the funeral of Pope John Paul II in 2005. (I was in Rome for both events and can personally attest to the surprising order these volunteers brought. If only the same order could be seen in everyday...
Two Cheers for the Bishops of England and Wales
Choosing the Common Good from Catholic Westminster on Vimeo. In today’s Acton Commentary, I review a new statement titled Choosing the Common Good (download it here) from the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of England and Wales. In the introductory video linked above, The Most Rev. Vincent Nichols, Archbishop of Westminster, introduces Choosing the Common Good and discusses the key themes in Catholic Social Teaching “as a contribution to the wide-ranging debate about the values and vision that underpin our society.” Here...
Tiger Woods, Morality, and the Market
Via Victor Claar (follow him on Twitter here), an op-ed in The Oracle (Henderson State University’s student paper) by Caleb Taylor, “Tiger Woods and Capitalism.” A taste: “Contrary to what Michael Moore thinks, capitalism promotes moral and ethical behavior. In Woods’ case, it punishes poor behavior. Sponsors such as Nielsen, AT&T, Gillete and Gatorade have all either suspended or removed their endorsement deals with Tiger due to his moral mistakes.” ...
‘Man is man’s greatest resource’
recently asked me ment on statements made by Ettore Gotti Tedeschi, president of the Vatican bank, about the economic effects of demographic decline in Western industrialized countries. Tedeschi told the Zenit news service that the “true cause” of the financial crisis is the low birth rate in these countries. “Instead of stimulating families and society to again believe in the future and have children […] we have stopped having children and have created a situation, a negative economic context...
Review: In the Land of Believers
In what is another book that points to America’s cultural divide, Gina Welch decides to go undercover at the late Jerry Falwell’s Thomas Road Baptist Church in Lynchburg, Virginia. An atheist, Yale and University of Virginia liberal graduate from Berkeley, California, Welch declares her undercover ruse was needed to better understand evangelicals. In the Land of Believers, Welch decides to fake conversion, e baptized in the church, immerse herself in classes, and even goes to Alaska on a mission trip...
Beyond Sovereignty: Money and its Future
Over at Public Discourse, Acton’s Samuel Gregg has just published a piece about the future of money. The issuance of money, he writes, is often associated with issues of national sovereignty, despite the fact that governments have long abused their monopoly of the money supply. Gregg argues, however, that the role played by mismanaged monetary policy in the 2008 financial crisis may well open up the opportunity to consider some truly radical options for how we supply money to the...
QOTD: Why economics matters
The control of wealth is the control over human life. So if a centrally planned economy decides how wealth is to be created and how it is to be distributed, then they really have a control over human life. That’s from Arnold Beichman, the journalist and scholar, who died Feb. 17 at the age of 96. The Heritage Foundation InsiderOnline Blog retrieved the quote from a 2004 article in a Columbia College alumni magazine. There was also this: Centrally planned...
Faith through failing works?
The Civil Society Trust reviews Jay Richards’ book “Money, Greed and God” (buy it here) and reflects on passion. We can read in Genesis that man was created by God, in His own image. Richards expands on that in a way that struck me as particularly novel. If God is the Creator with a capital ‘C’, then being created in His image, mankind has been endowed with the ability to create as well — we are creators with a little...
Conferencia: Instituciones, Ética y Finanzas
El alivio de la pobreza y el desarrollo económico dependen en gran medida de la creación de riqueza que proviene de la iniciativa empresarial y de negocios. Pero ni ercio ni la libertad empresarial podrán florecer en un ambiente donde la estabilidad monetaria está ausente, el sistema bancario es débil, los derechos de propiedad carecen de protección, y el marco legal es arbitrariamente quebrantado. ¿Cuáles son los fundamentos morales y económicos de estas instituciones? ¿Cómo se pueden crear y proteger...
An analogy for good government
Riffing off of Lord Acton’s quote on liberty and good government, I came up with an analogy that was well-received at last month’s inaugural Acton on Tap. In his essay, “The History of Freedom in Antiquity,” Acton said the following: Now Liberty and good government do not exclude each other; and there are excellent reasons why they should go together; but they do not necessarily go together. Liberty is not a means to a higher political end. It is itself...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved