Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Tweeting the abyss: Explaining Nietzsche in 140 characters (or less)
Tweeting the abyss: Explaining Nietzsche in 140 characters (or less)
Feb 4, 2025 11:56 PM

While trying to teach the most consequential thoughts of West civilization to undergraduates, C. Ivan Spencer hit upon a unique idea: What if they were written in tweets instead of tomes?

That’s the kernel of his book Tweetable Nietzsche: His Essential Ideas Revealed and Explained. Somehow, the idea that the callously exploitative philosophy of Friedrich Nietzsche could be mass-marketed so easily makes it all the more unsettling.

Spencer’s book is reviewed this weekend by Josh Herring, a humanities instructor atThales Academy, at the Acton Institute’s Religion & Liberty Transatlantic website.

“Spencer begins with Nietzsche’s most famous thought:‘God is dead. God remains dead. And we have killed him,’” Herring writes. “From this foundation flow all of Nietzsche’s considerations.”

The first of Nietzsche’s insights is that, without God, all truth is relative. Herring recounts elements of Nietzsche’s Victorian-era philosophy, which sound startlingly contemporary:

He argued for perspectivism, meaning that a truth-claim is nothing more than the perspective of the speaker. Without God’s existence, without anything existing transcendentally, truth is nothing more than a perspective to pared with other perspectives. One must exercise his “will to power” and select the perspective that best suits him as an egoistic individual.

Moral relativism is the core of postmodernism, which has held the West in thrall for a generation. However, the West longs to preserve the emotional qualities of the values associated with Christianity – passion, gentleness – without its moral (particularly its sexual) constraints. Thus, EU politicians speak endlessly of “European values” or “Western values” which, if they have a basis in the West’s history, omit vital elements of its historic creed to unduly magnify (or invert) others. The EU has reduced these values to political undertakings best exemplified by welfare state programs, environmentalism, and various forms of identity politics.

Nietzsche was too consistent, too honest, to advocate any form of warmed-over Christianity. His philosophy would strip away all the intellectual furnishings of Western piety and reinvent the concept of values de novo, from the ground up.

Neitzsche submitted his own idea of the verities that should replace the Judeo-Christian consensus – an ethic of superiority, contempt, and brutality that seeks to impose its will upon those deemed inferior:

The “overman” is the one who has rejected the outdated morality shaped by the Judeo-Christian heritage; such a one will ascend to a position where he lives “beyond good and evil.” Nietzsche sees the overman as the eventual evolutionary leap mankind will make, and he leaves open the possibility that individual overmen will arise along the way.

Humans are not to act in accordance with “good” or “evil,” because such concepts only exist parison with the non-existent God. Instead, people have will and must “will to power.” Nietzsche does not clearly explain this doctrine but implies that is the exercise of will by each individual to seek his own benefit. This egoistic principle forms the core of Nietzschean ethics.

Nationalism, imperialism, and militarism flow naturally from this outlook. At least one version of Nietzsche’s ethics influenced the Third Reich, and now inspires the Alt-Right. Applied to business, Nietzsche would exalt plunder merce, and deceit over fulfilling contracts. Confrontation would replace cooperation in every facet of society. His philosophy shows how far the West’s historic values can be reversed if rejecting God is carried out to its logical conclusion.

Spencer’s book shows with frightening clarity that the core concepts of this ethical devolution can be conveyed in easily digestible bits, 140 characters at a time.

Read Josh Herring’s full review here.

domain.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
The Dangers of Democratic Tyranny
In the context mentary on protests like those in Quebec and the Occupy movement more broadly, it’s worth reflecting on the dangers of democratic tyranny. The “people” can be tyrannical just as an individual sovereign or an oligarchy might. That’s why Aristotle considered democracy a defective form of government, because it too easily enshrines the will of the majority into an insuperable law. As Lord Acton put it, “It is bad to be oppressed by a minority, but it is...
Review: Can One Kill ‘For Greater Glory’?
Immediately after watching For Greater Glory, I found myself struggling to appreciate the myriad good intentions, talents and the $40 million that went into making it. Unlike the Cristeros who fought against the Mexican government, however, my efforts ultimately were unsuccessful. The film opened on a relatively limited 757 screens this past weekend, grossing $1.8 million and earning the No. 10 position of all films currently in theatrical release. Additionally, the film reportedly has been doing boffo at the Mexican...
Only a Sunday Believer?
“I do my religion on Sundays.” That was House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi’s answer to a press conference question on the Catholic Church’s stance on contraception, according to The Washington Examiner. Pelosi has consistently backed the Obama administration’s call to force employers to offer abortion, sterilization and birth control as part of employee health care, despite many organizations’ ethical, moral and religious objections (Acton’s PowerBlog offers more here on this topic.) Pelosi’s answer is telling: Her faith should not affect...
Samuel Gregg: Why Austerity Isn’t Enough
Writing on The American Spectator website, Acton Research Director Samuel Gregg looks at the strange notion of European fiscal “austerity” even as more old continent economies veer toward the abyss. Is America far behind? Needless to say, Greece is Europe’s poster child for reform-failure. Throughout 2011, the Greek parliament passed reforms that diminished regulations that applied to many professions in the economy’s service sector. But as two Wall Street Journal journalists demonstrated one year later, “despite the change in the...
How Junk Bonds Killed the Three Martini Lunch
A recent editorial in the New York Times claims that during the 1980s leveraged buyouts “contributed significantly to the growth of the e gap, moving wealth from the middle class to the top end.” First Things editor R.R. Reno explains why the real story is plicated, more interesting, and explains much more than e inequality: The upper middle class world responded to the leveraged buyout revolution by upping mitments to education and economically oriented self-discipline. The old white-collar social contract...
DCI John Luther: Secular Authority
John Luther is pierced for Jenny's transgressions.An essay of mine on the wonderful and difficult BBC series “Luther” is up over at the Comment magazine website, “Get Your Hands Dirty: The Vocational Theology of Luther.” In this piece I reflect on DCI John Luther’s “overriding need to protect other people from injustice and harm, and even sometimes the consequences of their own sin and guilt,” and how that fits in with the Christian (and particularly Lutheran) doctrine of vocation. Indeed,...
Being a Christian CEO Means Never Having to Fire Someone
Does being a Christian in business mean you’ll never have to fire someone? Of course not. But that’s one of the many subtexts that is detectable in the recent attention being given to this story: “CEO of Christian Publishing Firm Fires 25 Employees after Anonymous Email.” Now I don’t know any more details than what is contained in the Romenesko report, and it may well be that CEO Ryan Tate acted in an imprudent and incorrect fashion following his receipt...
Politics and Pulpits Don’t Mix
Over at Commentary Magazine, Jonathan S. Tobin remarks on the double standards liberals have about allowing politicians to promote political positions from the pulpits of churches and synagogues: [A]llowing a religious event to e the venue for partisan politics is always asking for trouble. No one is saying, or ought to say, that synagogue buildings can’t be used for debates or forums in which politics is discussed. But there is a big difference between a Sunday morning bagel breakfast to...
30 Years Ago Today: Reagan’s Westminster Address
The Washington Post’s editorial page reminds us that today is the 30th anniversary of Ronald Reagan’s address at Westminster Hall, London. The speech, famous for its “ash heap of history line,” was Reagan’s challenge to the Soviet Union’s very legitimacy and pointed to its hollow core. Reagan’s great strength was not just America’s military posture against the Soviets, but that he truly made the Cold War a battle of moral ideas. It was a decisive pivot away from America’s policy...
Buying a House Makes People Less Entrepreneurial
Suzy Khimm points out an interesting study from the UK’s Spatial Economics Research Centre: Our fixed-effects estimates show that purchasing a house reduces the likelihood of starting a business by 20-25%. … This result is driven by homeowners with mortgages and persists for several years after entering homeownership. … We argue that this finding can be rationalized by the fact that homeowners typically have to overinvest in housing (Brueckner, 1997; Flavin and Yamashita, 2002) and therefore cannot adequately diversify their...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved