Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Turning African game poachers into conservationists
Turning African game poachers into conservationists
Mar 19, 2025 1:39 PM

In a new video from theProperty and Environment Research Center in Bozeman, Montana, African hunting guide Mark Haldane explains how “habitat conservation depends on making wildlife petitive with other land uses.” This story is set in the Coutada 11 region in Mozambique along the Zambezi River delta. As PERC explains it, “bymaking the conservation of wildlife habitat economically viable, generating revenue used to fund anti-poaching efforts, and establishing critical e for munities, trophy hunting has proven to be an essential tool for wildlife conservation. These benefits help turn imperiled African wildlife from liabilities impeding economic growth, into assets to be cared for.”

Can trophy hunting be good for conservation? Why not use trophy hunting to turn wildlife into assets for munities? Haldane says that once local villagers were brought in to manage wildlife, they found a legal and much more promising path to earning a living. Among the first to be recruited were poachers who were slaughtering animals simply to survive.

“Every poacher that I can give a job to is a poacher that is taken out of the field,” Haldane says. “My entire anti-poaching unit are all poachers that have been turned into the unit.”

In PERC’s 2015 edition of “Free Market Environmentalism for the Next Generation,” Terry L. Anderson and Donald R. Leal describe how control over wildlife and natural resources are reverting to local villagers munities to own, contract, and profit from wildlife. They have essentially privatized the use of wildlife — encouraging hunting, tourism, and the sale of meat, hides and horns.” Anderson and Leal describe one of these initiatives — the CAMPFIRE program.

The incentive to participate in CAMPFIRE is simple: financial rewards. Profits are primarily generated by leasing trophy hunting concessions to foreign hunters. The process provides jobs munity pensation for crop and property damage, food for villagers, and revenue to build schools, clinics and wells. The World Wildlife Fund estimated that households participating in CAMPFIRE increased their es by at about 20 percent since the program was started in the late 1980s and at the same time wildlife populations shot up.

Elephant populations in CAMPFIRE areas soared from 37,000 to 85,000 between 1989 and 2006 … During the same period, this program generated more than $20 million in direct e, benefitting an estimated 90,000 households …

What about calls to ban import of big game trophies to the United States in the wake of the furor over the killing of Cecil the lion in 2015? That would soon create perverse es not helpful to wildlife conservation. And how could a ban on this type of hunting be reconciled with religious concern for animal welfare and wildlife conservation?

Make sure to listen to Russ Roberts’ February conversation with Catherine Semcer on Econ Talk. Now at PERC, Semcer was formerly Chief Operating Officer of Humanitarian Operations Protecting Elephants and also discusses recent efforts to relocate lions in Mozambique. Here she is responding to criticism that hunting is immoral (from the transcript):

I have heard those arguments. And, in response, you know, the first thing I would say is I am not a big game hunter. This is not something I engage in. But, you know I always ask those people, ‘Well, what is the alternative?’ Because if there was an alternative, my guess is we would implementing it by now. Also, you know: Who are we in the United States or in the United Kingdom or elsewhere to tell Africans how they should be managing their wildlife? Programs like CAMPFIRE and munity-based programs have their genesis within these munities. They have buy-in from the people in the continent. And I certainly understanding the fort that people might feel. But I would encourage them to be very careful about how they tread on this issue, lest we get back into some type of eco-colonialism in dealing with our African partners.

Some people will say that, you know, photo-tourism, is a viable alternative to trophy hunting. And in some places, that may or may not be true. But, what we know from the available research–primarily from Namibia–is that if hunting was eliminated in munity conservancies, 84% of those conservancies would no longer be economically viable. Now, what does that mean on the ground? That means more than 12 million acres of wildlife habitat immediately es more vulnerable to development. That’s roughly an area of 5 times the size of Yosemite National Park. So, I understand the fort. But, what are our alternatives? People like myself are very willing to listen. And, you know, would love to hear what they are. But they just have not been offered, and they are certainly not being employed on the ground right now.

Photo: Cecil the lion at Hwange National Park in 2010. mons.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Christianity and the Politics of Prison and Redemption
In a fine post over at the History News Network (HT: Religion in America), Jennifer Graber, assistant professor of religious studies at The College of Wooster and author of the ing book, The Furnace of Affliction: Prisons and Religion in Antebellum America, reflects on what the Michael Vick saga (to date) shows us about American attitudes towards crime, punishment, and redemption. Graber briefly traces the development of public policy and social attitudes towards punishment for violent and heinous crimes. She...
Rev. Sirico: Civility, not just after tragedy
The Detroit News today published a new column by Rev. Robert A. Sirico, president and co-founder of the Acton Institute: Civility, not just after tragedy The Rev. Robert Sirico The tragic shootings in Tucson that left U.S. Rep. Gabrielle Giffords gravely wounded and a score of others dead or wounded have sparked a national discussion about how we conduct our public discourse. This is something we should all e, in an age of instantaneous media and its often vitriolic political...
Acton Lecture Series 2010: Joseph Morris on Saul Alinsky
There’s still time to register for tomorrow’s opening lecture of the 2011 Acton Lecture Series (click here to reserve your seat for Rev. Robert A. Sirico’s “Christian Poverty in the Age of Prosperity”), and while we’re anticipating the start of the 2011 series we’ll continue our blog recap of the 2010 series. Today, we highlight one of my favorite lectures from last year: Joseph Morris’ “Alinsky for Dummies: His Persistent Influence and Its Meaning for American Society and Politics.” Saul...
Acton Lecture Series 2010 Recap: Miller & Carrasco
Continuing our recap of last year’s Acton Lecture Series in anticipation of Thursday’s opening lecture of the 2011 ALS (which you can register for right here), we’re pleased to present the video from February and March of 2010. On February 18, 2010, Acton’s Director of Media Michael Miller Delivered a lecture entitled “Does Capitalism Destroy Culture?” His lecture discussed the positive and negative impact of capitalism in society today. Miller pointed out that it’s not just Christians that are worried...
News: Acton Institute Among Top Global Think Tanks
GRAND RAPIDS, Mich. (Feb. 1, 2011) — A new survey of 5,500 organizations by the Think Tanks and Civil Societies Program at the University of Pennsylvania ranked the Acton Institute among the best global social policy organizations and in the top 50 think tanks overall in the United States. The 2010 Global Go-To Think Tank Rankings, directed by James G. McGann of the International Relations department at Penn, put Acton at No. 12 on the Top 25 Social Policy Think...
The Amnesiac Civility of Jim Wallis
Peter Wehner on Commentary Magazine’s Contentions blog looks at the recent joint statement on civility from Jim Wallis and Chuck Colson: … what is worth noting, I think, is that Wallis (as opposed to Colson) has repeatedly violated mitment to civility. For example, in 2007, Wallis said: “I believe that Dick Cheney is a liar; that Donald Rumsfeld is also a liar; and that George W. Bush was, and is, clueless about how to be the president of the United...
After Cape Town: Still Learning to Talk About Business and Ministry
Stephen Grabill and I follow up on the Lausanne Congress in this week’s Acton Commentary: After Cape Town: Still Learning to Talk About Business and Ministry By Brett Elder and Stephen Grabill The Cape Town Commitment — a document that flows out of the Third Lausanne Congress on Global Evangelization held in Cape Town, South Africa, this past October — has generated a great deal of discussion since its release last week.Prior documents and declarations proceeding from the previous two...
Humor and Prison Rape Culture
Yesterday I noted some items related to the question of punishment and restorative justice in the American criminal justice system. And in the past we’ve looked here at the PowerBlog of the issues surrounding political and social activism on prison rape. Now today Joe Carter, web editor at First Things, considers the Prison Rape Elimination Act and the broader cultural attitudes toward prison rape: While such laws are a useful beginning, what is needed more than any legislation is a...
Acton on Tap: Faith and Public Life in Reagan’s America
Ronald Reagan is in the news quite a bit these days. President Barack Obama is even trying to model himself after the popular president, as this piece in Time points out. Reagan’s centennial birthday is February 6. The Reagan Presidential Foundation & Library Centennial homepage is the essential site for information on the celebration. On February 17, those in the Grand Rapids area should plan on attending Acton on Tap at Derby Station in East Grand Rapids for a discussion...
Stewardship and the Human Vocation to Work
The following is my latest article for Acton Commentary: Stewardship and the Human Vocation to Work By Rev. Gregory Jensen Paying the bills and contributing to the collection basket are laudable. But Christian stewardship is significantly more than these; like prayer, fasting, and the sacraments, it is an essential part of our Christian life. More than what we say, the way we use our time, talent and treasure, reveals what we value, how we understand ourselves as men and women...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved