Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Turning African game poachers into conservationists
Turning African game poachers into conservationists
Jan 4, 2026 10:54 PM

In a new video from theProperty and Environment Research Center in Bozeman, Montana, African hunting guide Mark Haldane explains how “habitat conservation depends on making wildlife petitive with other land uses.” This story is set in the Coutada 11 region in Mozambique along the Zambezi River delta. As PERC explains it, “bymaking the conservation of wildlife habitat economically viable, generating revenue used to fund anti-poaching efforts, and establishing critical e for munities, trophy hunting has proven to be an essential tool for wildlife conservation. These benefits help turn imperiled African wildlife from liabilities impeding economic growth, into assets to be cared for.”

Can trophy hunting be good for conservation? Why not use trophy hunting to turn wildlife into assets for munities? Haldane says that once local villagers were brought in to manage wildlife, they found a legal and much more promising path to earning a living. Among the first to be recruited were poachers who were slaughtering animals simply to survive.

“Every poacher that I can give a job to is a poacher that is taken out of the field,” Haldane says. “My entire anti-poaching unit are all poachers that have been turned into the unit.”

In PERC’s 2015 edition of “Free Market Environmentalism for the Next Generation,” Terry L. Anderson and Donald R. Leal describe how control over wildlife and natural resources are reverting to local villagers munities to own, contract, and profit from wildlife. They have essentially privatized the use of wildlife — encouraging hunting, tourism, and the sale of meat, hides and horns.” Anderson and Leal describe one of these initiatives — the CAMPFIRE program.

The incentive to participate in CAMPFIRE is simple: financial rewards. Profits are primarily generated by leasing trophy hunting concessions to foreign hunters. The process provides jobs munity pensation for crop and property damage, food for villagers, and revenue to build schools, clinics and wells. The World Wildlife Fund estimated that households participating in CAMPFIRE increased their es by at about 20 percent since the program was started in the late 1980s and at the same time wildlife populations shot up.

Elephant populations in CAMPFIRE areas soared from 37,000 to 85,000 between 1989 and 2006 … During the same period, this program generated more than $20 million in direct e, benefitting an estimated 90,000 households …

What about calls to ban import of big game trophies to the United States in the wake of the furor over the killing of Cecil the lion in 2015? That would soon create perverse es not helpful to wildlife conservation. And how could a ban on this type of hunting be reconciled with religious concern for animal welfare and wildlife conservation?

Make sure to listen to Russ Roberts’ February conversation with Catherine Semcer on Econ Talk. Now at PERC, Semcer was formerly Chief Operating Officer of Humanitarian Operations Protecting Elephants and also discusses recent efforts to relocate lions in Mozambique. Here she is responding to criticism that hunting is immoral (from the transcript):

I have heard those arguments. And, in response, you know, the first thing I would say is I am not a big game hunter. This is not something I engage in. But, you know I always ask those people, ‘Well, what is the alternative?’ Because if there was an alternative, my guess is we would implementing it by now. Also, you know: Who are we in the United States or in the United Kingdom or elsewhere to tell Africans how they should be managing their wildlife? Programs like CAMPFIRE and munity-based programs have their genesis within these munities. They have buy-in from the people in the continent. And I certainly understanding the fort that people might feel. But I would encourage them to be very careful about how they tread on this issue, lest we get back into some type of eco-colonialism in dealing with our African partners.

Some people will say that, you know, photo-tourism, is a viable alternative to trophy hunting. And in some places, that may or may not be true. But, what we know from the available research–primarily from Namibia–is that if hunting was eliminated in munity conservancies, 84% of those conservancies would no longer be economically viable. Now, what does that mean on the ground? That means more than 12 million acres of wildlife habitat immediately es more vulnerable to development. That’s roughly an area of 5 times the size of Yosemite National Park. So, I understand the fort. But, what are our alternatives? People like myself are very willing to listen. And, you know, would love to hear what they are. But they just have not been offered, and they are certainly not being employed on the ground right now.

Photo: Cecil the lion at Hwange National Park in 2010. mons.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
‘A Broadened Perspective on the Ethics of Early Modern Exchange’
Camarin M. Porter of the Department of History at University of Wisconsin-Madison reviews a text edited by Stephen J. Grabill, Sourcebook in Late-Scholastic Monetary Theory: The Contributions of Martin de Azpilcueta, Luis de Molina, and Juan de Mariana (Lexington, 2007). The review appears courtesy of H-Net, a unique and indispensable set of list-servs hosted by Michigan State University. The Sourcebook includes translations into English of selected texts from the significant figures listed in the book’s subtitle, as well as a...
Recommended: Belloc’s Puzzling Manifesto
Hilaire BellocOver the past five years, many conservatives and religiously-inclined people have been turning to the works of Hilaire Belloc and G.K. Chesterton as part of an effort to rethink the nature of economic life. Both these figures wrote about many other things than economics – and some would say that, for all their insights as Christian apologists, economics was never their strong point. Indeed many of their economic writings were heavily criticized when they were initially published in Britain...
Promises and perils of globalization
Thomas P.M. Barnett has written a good, concise, piece on the consolidation and deepening of globalization, specifically Wal-Mart’s tapping into local producers in developing countries. (HT: Real Clear World) As far as I can tell, there are no Wal-Mart’s in Italy, but having spent the last three weeks at my parents’ home in Flint, Michigan and shopping at places like Wal-Mart and Target, I can clearly see how far behind the curve Italy is. While family-run boutiques and the slow-food...
Not so separate after all
The New York Times is not known to be the most reliable or mentator on matters religious, but a recent Times article (marred, unfortunately, by a couple of inaccuracies) highlighted that France’s claim to have separated religion from the state is only true in parts. French cities and the countryside are dotted with beautiful churches, but few realize that the state is responsible for the physical upkeep of many of them. This is a legacy of the famous (or, infamous,...
Acton University: Register Today!
A friendly reminder that registration is currently open for the 2010 Acton University (AU), which will take place on June 15-18 in Grand Rapids, Mich. This year’s distinguished international faculty will once again guide participants through an expanded curriculum, offering even greater depth of exploration into the intellectual foundations of a free society. For four days each June in Grand Rapids, the Acton Institute convenes an ecumenical conference of 400 pastors, seminarians, educators, non-profit managers, business people and philanthropists from...
Wikipedia: Freedom in Community
In this week’s Acton Commentary, I reflect on a decade of Wikipedia, a remarkable experiment in human interaction: Ten years ago this month, Internet entrepreneur Jimmy Wales hired Larry Sanger to develop an online encyclopedia. You may have never heard of that project, titled “Nupedia,” but you’ve probably heard of the site that emerged from its ashes. Wikipedia is not only one of the most successful initiatives in the history of the Web but also a shining example of the...
Rev. Robert A. Sirico on Accountability in Leadership
In the wake of the Christmas Day bombing attempt on a Northwest Airlines flight from Amsterdam to Detroit and the ensuing controversy over the Obama Administration’s handling both of the pre-attack intelligence and the post-attack response, Neil Cavuto invited Acton President Rev. Robert A. Sirico on his show to discuss how President Obama might go about exercising proper leadership and accountability in his address to the nation last night. The clip from Your World with Neil Cavuto follows: ...
Secularism and Brit Hume
The Big Hollywood blogger and actor Adam Baldwin, recently of the television series Chuck and Firefly, has taken up his virtual pen to defend Brit Hume from those who have criticized him for suggesting that Tiger Woods should consider Christianity in his time of crisis. Hume made the statement on Fox News Sunday, thus prompting outrage from secularists who find such an offering offensive and irrelevant. Baldwin scores several times in his blog piece. Here is the foundation: As an...
Getting the Lead Out
In this week’s Acton Commentary, “From the Lead Frying Pan into the Toxic Fire,” I examine some of the fallout from the lead paint fiasco of 2007. Last month RC2 Corp. settled the civil penalty for violating a federal lead paint ban. But in the wake of subsequent federal action, I examine two unintended consequences. First, new federal regulations are posing an unsustainable burden on some small businesses, forcing them to make very hard choices about whether to keep their...
How to Help Haiti
I have to admit that my first few reactions to the news of an earthquake in the Caribbean weren’t especially charitable. I thought first that the scale of the reports had to be exaggerated, that things couldn’t be as bad as the media was breathlessly reporting. Then I wondered how long it would take for the environmental movement to make use of the disaster to advance their agenda. Neither of these reactions are particularly noble on my part, obviously. Blame...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved