Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Trump and Clinton are wrong: free trade helps the poor
Trump and Clinton are wrong: free trade helps the poor
Jan 31, 2026 4:42 AM

Imagine if Donald Trump made a campaign promise that he would lower the pay of every American, but would ensure that the poorest 10 percent have their pay lowered the most. Would you vote for him then? Or imagine if Hillary Clinton said she would increase inflation substantially to make the economy more “fair” for everyone. Would she win your support?

Neither candidate has made such a claim—at least not directly. TheAmerican people would immediate reject such harmful economic policies,and politiciansknow they’d be rejectedfor makingsuch inane promises.

In reality, though, both Clinton and Trump (as well as the candidates for the Green Party, Constitution Party, and the American Solidarity Part) have promised to implement policies that would have the same effect as increasing inflation or reducing pay, for all have proposed a means of lowering purchasing power.

Purchasing power is the number of goods or services that can be purchased with a unit of currency. There are several methods politicians can use to reduce purchasing power, but one of the most subtle mon is to increase barriers to foreign trade. As Nita Ghei says,

The benefits of freer international trade accrue to consumers in theform of increased choice and lower prices. More imports mean more bang for the buck, and that effectively functions like an increase in pay. Consumers either buy imported goods directly, like the finished shirt from Bangladesh, or they can buy an American-made good that includes ponents. When American producers have access to cheaper imports, they can increase production, create jobs and offer goods at a lower price.

There is significant evidence that e Americans benefit substantially from imports, and higher trade barriers will impose a proportionately greater cost on the poor.

The poorest Americans tend to assume (mostly because they’ve been lied to by people that know better) that international trade hurts them. In fact, it is just the opposite, not only for those living in the U.S., but for the poor in almost every part of the world. As The Economist recently noted,

A study by Pablo Fajgelbaum of the University of California, Los Angeles, and Amit Khandelwal, of Columbia University, suggests that in an average country, people on high es would lose 28% of their purchasing power if borders were closed to trade. But the poorest 10% of consumers would lose 63% of their spending power, because they buy relatively more imported goods. The authors find a bias of trade in favour of poorer people in all 40 countries in their study, which included 13 developing countries.

If the lives of the poor are disproportionately improved by freer trade, then why do they so often oppose it? The main reason is because it’s much easier for them to see the negative effects of trade. If the factory you work at making widgets closes and the jobs move overseas, it’s easy to assume that the total economic effect is negative. What is more difficult to see is how many poor people are now able to buy widgets because they are being produced at a lower cost.

That is why protectionism has an innate appeal—it’s easy to see the effects—while free trade seems, well, foreign. Yet what many people don’t realize is that protectionism not only hurts the majority of consumers, it rarely helps the minority of workers it was intended to protect. As Ghei notes,

[P]rotectionist measures, like duties on steel, do little to halt the decline of that industry, which employs 140,000 people now, yet those duties inflict higher costs on steel-consuming industries, which employ over 12 million people.

Free trade is one of the few policies that almost all economists, whether on the left or right, agree is beneficial to the majority of the population. But economically ignorant politicians (see: Clinton and Trump) know that by championing protectionist policies (all while claiming that they are really for “free trade”) they can win the votes of people that don’t know better. That is why those of us who do know better have a duty to the poor to set the record straight. We can’t stop politicians from lying to them. But we can do our best to see that they discover the truth.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
The Deutsche Bank tragedies
The story of the Deutsche Bank building following the NYC 9/11 attacks is a study in bureaucratic petence…but more importantly it’s an ongoing experience in human tragedy and loss. There’s a great deal to sort out. This piece, “The tombstone at Ground Zero,” does a good job introducing the issues. The article begins with an introduction into the fire at the building site in August of last year: …Thick black smoke was pouring out of the shell of what used...
Utopia!
Continuing with my posts highlighting just how wonderful things will be here in the United States when the government finally does its job and takes over the healthcare sector of the economy, I’d like to bring your attention once again to the fabulous success story that is the Canadian health care system: Last year, the Canadian government issued a series of reports to address the outcry over long wait times for critical tests, procedures and surgeries. Over a two year...
Persecution as a mark of the church
Last Friday the U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom released its 2008 report, noting eleven nations as “countries of particular concern,” being “those that are are most restrictive of religious freedom”: Burma, North Korea, Eritrea, Iran, Pakistan, China, Saudi Arabia, Sudan, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, and Vietnam. (HT: The God & Culture Blog) Howard Friedman relates, “The Commission is postponing its mendations as to Iraq pending a Commission visit to the country later this month. promise was approved after a sharp party-line...
The ethics of immigration
Sure to be a significant issue in the presidential campaign going forward, the question of immigration reform continues to divide otherwise like-minded religious folks. Mirror of Justice sage Michael Scaperlanda penned an article on the subject for First Things in February. A raft of letters upset with what the writers deemed Scaperlanda’s unreasonably lenient view toward illegal immigrants followed in the May issue (not accessible to non-subscribers), along with an article-length exchange between Scaperlanda and attorney William Chip. Scaperlanda’s initial...
The slippery slope of Catholic ecology
: What I have found odd is that so many Catholics, especially female religious, should gravitate toward what appears to be essentially pantheism or what some eco-spirituality thinkers prefer to call “panentheism” (the universe as the “body of God”) when the Church has addressed the entire ecology question in a way that would, practically speaking, lead to the same results in terms of respect for the created order and sustainability. Indeed. Given the present direction ofCatholic movement on climate change,...
Fundraising and the fungibility phenomenon
A fight broke out this week between non-profit groups over fundraising. While not in petition for donor dollars, the U.S. Sportsmen’s Alliance expressed its displeasure with Meijer, Inc. for participating in a fundraising event with the Humane Society of the United States. The program was set up to contribute money to a support Foreclosure Pets Fund, designed to give support to pet owners facing foreclosure. Meijer suspended the program after plaints from the Alliance that the chain was cooperating with...
Dr. Jennifer Roback Morse on The Glenn Beck Show
Acton Senior Fellow in Economics Jennifer Roback Morse made an appearance last night on The Glenn Beck Show on Headline News Network. The topic of conversation was “hookup culture” and the degraded sexual ethics of our culture. Dr. Morse is the author of Smart Sex: Finding Life-Long Love in a Hook-Up World. If you missed the show, the clip is below: ...
Catholic NGOs miss the boat on the food crisis
The recent dramatic rise of food prices reflects the worst agricultural crisis of the last 30 years, especially for developing countries whose citizens inevitably spend a larger portion of their es for basic needs. The list of countries facing social unrest as a result is long and growing: Cameroon, Egypt, Niger, Somalia, Ethiopia, Mauritania, Bangladesh, Burkina Faso, Haiti, Indonesia, Mexico, Argentina, and the Philippines. Consequences of these price increases are also affecting the United States, where rice is beginning to...
The Final Countdown: 2 weeks left for schools to apply for the Catholic High School Honor Roll
How is the 80’s song “The Final Countdown” by the band Europe tied to sound Catholic secondary education? Surprisingly, it’s through Acton’s Catholic High school Honor Roll. After a short prayer, the below video shows the pep band for Xavier High School in Appleton, Wisconsin pumping up the crowd for its Honor Roll announcement this past Fall. After applying for the Honor Roll last year, the school earned a place among the Top 50 Catholic high schools in the United...
Shedding the load
Daily Times of Pakistan: LAHORE: Electricity shortage has exceeded 3,500 megawatts and load shedding is likely to increase across the country, Geo TV reported on Sunday. The water in both Tarbela and Mangla dams has dropped to dead levels, causing the shortfall, the channel quoted PEPCO officials as saying. The electricity demand had shot up after an increase in the use of air conditioners… Ah, load shedding. We lived in Guam for a couple of years in the early 90’s....
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved