Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Trigger Warning: This Article Contains References to ‘Citizens United’ and ‘Dark Money’
Trigger Warning: This Article Contains References to ‘Citizens United’ and ‘Dark Money’
Jan 21, 2026 4:34 AM

Your writer has identified a surefire, two-word mantra guaranteed to elicit shrieks of terror and the rending of garments from the left: “Citizens United,” shorthand for the Supreme Court decision that overturned the Bipartisan Campaign Finance Reform Act of 2002. The runner-up spot is reserved for the phrase “dark money,” which are trigger words for private donations from individuals and corporations.

Despite all the phony-baloney rationalizations the left hurls at private donations and limits, there’s nothing really to be concerned about. Our Republic will not crumble because of Citizens United or even dark money.

First, however, let’s give the left a turn at the podium. The Forum for Sustainable and Responsible Investment (formerly the Social Investment Forum) is only one group of activist investors getting their knickers in a twist over Citizens United and Dark Money – and they’re joined by “religious” investment activist groups Interfaith Center for Corporate Responsibility and As You Sow, which, as we know by now, subscribe more to the church of liberal ideology than they do anything remotely cosmological. This from the SIR publication: “Confronting Corporate Money in Politics:”

Since the Citizens United decision, there has been an increase in shareholder proposals on political spending, asking for greater board oversight of campaign spending as well as increased disclosure to investors. A parallel shareholder campaign to encourage more disclosure of direct and indirect lobbying started in 2012. Both efforts contend that investors need information on corporate spending on elections and lobbying so they can make informed decisions and assess related risks. Shareholder resolutions are crucial tools for encouraging panies to address key environmental, social and corporate governance (ESG) issues. By filing resolutions, which may then proceed to a vote by all shareholders in pany, active shareholders bring important issues to the attention pany management, often winning media attention and educating the public as well. Proponents believe that without strong disclosure rules, shareholders are unable to hold directors and executives accountable when they spend corporate funds on politics.

A key emphasis of both campaign spending and lobbying disclosure initiatives from investors focuses on corporate funding of intermediary non-profit groups, such as trade associations, that may keep their donors secret. According to the Center for Political Accountability (CPA), more mutual funds are voting in support of Confronting Corporate Money in Politics: A Guide for Individual & Institutional Investors resolutions asking panies to reveal political donations to nonprofits and trade associations. The CPA reports that in 2013, 39 percent of the mutual funds voted in favor of shareholder resolutions calling panies to reveal their donations, up from 34 percent in 2012….

At a minimum, if you directly own shares in pany, you should pay close attention to the shareholder resolutions that ing to votes at their annual meetings and be sure to vote your shares. Helpful information on ing shareholder resolutions is offered by the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility, as well as a corporate lobbying chart on Green America’s website. If you are an institutional investor or rely on investment managers to vote your shares, make sure they are voting in accordance with your views. Proxy advisory firms are available to assist with drafting proxy voting guidelines for your institution; they can also vote your institution’s shares in accordance with these guidelines. Additionally, for background on political spending and lobbying expenditures being raised through shareholder resolutions, as well as lists of shareholder resolutions that have been filed for votes at panies’ ing annual meetings, please see the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility (ICCR), As You Sow Foundation and the Sustainable Investments Institute.

All of this is so much piffle when confronted with real-world facts, as noted by The Center for Competitive Politics (CCP), “America’s largest nonprofit dedicated solely to defending First Amendment rights to political speech and assembly.” In a broadcast email, CCP President David Keating turns to actual events rather than crystal-ball prognostications to allay fears of a corporate takeover of the American political system:

‘Scott Walker and Rick Perry have demonstrated once again that while money is an important part of a successful campaign, a candidate’s message, ability to connect with voters, media coverage, and experience matter as well. Ultimately, voters are the ones who get the final say,’ said CCP President David Keating. ‘Walker raised millions of dollars and the Super PAC supporting his candidacy raised millions more, but support for Walker still fell to an asterisk in a recent poll. Restricting money to candidates or independent groups will only lead to fewer choices, not more, and that’s bad for voters and bad for America.’

Republican Presidential candidates Scott Walker and Rick Perry suspended their campaigns, Keating reminds readers, after Walker’s Super Political Action mitted $16 million in televised advertisements in three states. For his part, Perry has to refund millions of dollars in contributions.

Despite the millions of dollars in each candidate’s war chest, the well-funded Perry and Walker campaigns failed to gain enough traction to propel either into the primaries. As for the Republican frontrunner who is funding his campaign from a vast personal fortune, Keating notes his opponents should be championing less fundraising restrictions rather than more:

‘Debate sponsors are literally running out of room on stage to fit all of the viable candidates for President, and that’s a good problem to have,’ said David Keating, CCP President. ‘Recent court rulings have made it easier to fund campaigns, and that’s creating petition. Voters are getting more choices, which in turn means a more robust debate on issues ranging from taxes to foreign policy and everything in between. Bigger fundraising by presidential candidates and Super PACs will lead to better informed voters, which is good for democracy and good for America.’

Just so. It’s time for shareholder activists such as ICCR and AYS to drop the religious charade, and simply admit they’re shilling for leftist causes.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Book Review: Carl Anderson’s ‘A Civilization of Love’
On March 29, Carl Anderson’s A Civilization of Love (HarperOne, 2008) first appeared on the New York Times Best Seller list as one of hottest-selling books in America among the “Hard Cover Advice” category. Since then the author has been on an energetic European and American tour to promote his book. In just 200 pages, Anderson writes convincingly to elaborate a treatise to dispel dominant secular ideologies whose ethical frameworks falsely aim at human fulfillment and forming good and just...
European foreign aid caught between dishonesty and incompetence
International aid groups have criticized the EU and many of its member states for falling behind their promises to step up foreign aid to 0.5 per cent of GDP by 2010 and 0.7 per cent by 2015. On the one hand, these groups are right to expose the accounting tricks governments use in order to promote themselves as saviors of Africa. On the other hand, the aid groups should consider very carefully whether their focus on state aid is really...
Farm bill takes aim at taxpayers
The new farm bill may be one of the most shameless displays of government largesse ever, even more so when you consider who will most benefit from the pork. Citizens Against Government Waste called it “The most farcical farm bill in history.” The Economist dubbed it “Harvest of Disgrace.” The Wall Street Journal opines, “If farm prices stay high, consumers face higher grocery bills and farmers get rich. If farm prices fall, taxpayers kick in the difference and farmers still...
Assumptions about the ‘Libertarian’ Jesus
Here’s the key assumption in Michael Gerson’s piece from last week, “The Libertarian Jesus”: passion cannot replace Medicaid or provide AIDS drugs to millions of people in Africa for the rest of their lives. In these cases, a role for government is necessary passionate — the expression of mitments to the general welfare and the value of every human life. passion certainly could do this, and much more. Private giving generally dwarfs government programs in both real dollars and effectiveness....
Intellectual foundations of evangelicalism
In an interview promoting his recent book Faith in the Halls of Power: How Evangelicals Joined the American Elite, D. Michael Lindsay, describes what he sees to be the intellectual sources of evangelicalism: And the interesting thing is that the Presbyterian tradition, the Reformed tradition, has provided some of the intellectual gravitas for evangelical ascendancy. And it’s being promulgated in lots of creative ways so that you have the idea of Kuyper or a mission of cultural engagement is being...
Memorial Day: John Gillespie Magee Jr. & ‘High Flight’
John Gillespie Magee, Jr. is remembered fondly by American aviators who defended and sacrificed for this nation in World War II to the present day. He is remembered for his touching poem High Flight, which he penned in 1941. Magee was born to an American father and British mother in Shanghai, China in 1922. His parents were Christian missionaries in the country. Well educated in China, England, and the United States, Magee received a scholarship to Yale University, where his...
Dealing with rising gas prices
As the Drudge Report today hails ing of the fuel-efficient Smart car, it might be worth pointing out other ways in which people are adapting to deal with higher fuel prices. I don’t mean to minimize any of the pain associated with skyrocketing energy costs, whether personal (I feel it, too) or economy-wide, but it is interesting to observe the myriad and often unexpected effects of price changes. It’s the market working. Or, to put it another way, it’s the...
Looking for happiness, finding faith
Dr. Arthur C. Brooks spoke about “happiness” at an Acton Lecture Series event last week. Dr. Brooks, a professor of Business and Government Policy at Syracuse University and a visiting scholar with the American Enterprise Institute, presented evidence which suggests that religion is the greatest factor in general human happiness in the United States. Religion, argues Dr. Brooks, is essential to human flourishing in the United States and public secularism should be strongly guarded against by everyone – religious or...
Warming wailing waning
Sometime Acton publications contributor and adjunct scholar Thomas Sieger Derr posts on the First Things blog under the title, “The End of the Global Warming Scare?” Derr identifies a trend that has not been ignored on this blog: increasingly vocal and widespread skepticism toward at least the most dire predictions emanating from the climate change disaster crowd. I would add to Derr’s observations that consternation over oil prices is likely to encourage reluctance to implement any costly programs that have...
Did Maxine Waters just suggest that she might try to nationalize the US oil industry?
Why yes, yes she did: Link: Via Hot Air. ...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved