Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The ‘Tragedy’ of the (Boston) Common
The ‘Tragedy’ of the (Boston) Common
Mar 26, 2026 2:54 PM

Boston Common Asset Management bills itself as “a leader in global sustainability initiatives.” Why would an investment portfolio pany label itself with the appellation “Common” when it carries such negative baggage? As it turns out, BCAM embraces mon” as something positive.

From the BCAM website:

Beginning in 1634, the Boston Common served as mon pasture for cattle grazing. As a public good, the Common was a space owned by no one but essential to all. We chose the name Boston Common because, like the Common of old, our work stands at the intersection of the economic and social lives of munity.

Never mind all that John Locke hootie-hoot about private property being the cornerstone of a free society. Please ignore all the papal encyclicals from Pope Leo XIII’s Rerum Novarum onward that champion private property. Oh, yes, pletely disregard the U.S. Constitution, which codifies private-property rights, and pay no attention to the “tragedy of mons” which inexplicably is ignored here.

One has to give BCAM credit, however, for consistency. They really, really despise privacy whether it’s property, political donations or corporate lobbying (although it’s also assumed they have no issue with the “penumbra of privacy” suddenly discovered in the U.S. Constitution by members of the Supreme Court after somehow every other legal mind overlooked it for nearly two centuries). Privacy for everything else apparently is subject to eradication in BCAM’s book.

BCAM – one of the many members of religious shareholder activist group the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility – weighed-in on its efforts to “shine a light on corporate lobbying practices” the other day on The Huffington Post. BCAM Director of Shareowner Engagement Lauren Compere (who also is a member of the ICCR Governing Board) remarked:

The 2016 U.S. presidential election campaign is set to be the most expensive yet, with some sources suggesting a whopping $10 billion in total costs. The huge price tag of the campaigns have put issues of corporate political spending and lobbying to the forefront as we enter proxy season – the period when panies hold their annual shareholder meetings, making lobbying one of the hottest topics on the agenda of investors.

Is that so? Try telling that to Jeb Bush, whose campaign burned through $130 million only to achieve also-ran status – and your writer has yet to hear any negative reputational fallout for the corporate contributors to his failed campaign. As for money buying votes, Ms. Compere has it upside down. This week’s presidential primary resulted in a victory for Donald Trump, who spent a whopping 13 cents per vote, while loser Bernie Sanders spent $9 per vote, accordingto a report from the Center for Public Integrity. Both campaigns, it should be noted, receive little to no corporate funding, anonymous or otherwise. CPI also reported Democrat Hillary Clinton spent $3.62 per vote.

Compere changes tack, and continues saying that private donations from corporations are bad because … well, you know … those funds might be used to challenge the nonexistent scientific consensus on climate change:

panies do their political lobbying behind closed doors it threatens both our democracy and ultimately the credibility and trust in pany’s own brand.

A key part of an investor’s job is to know and understand risk. However in the U.S., as well as many other countries, there are no regulations panies to publicly detail whether they have made direct payments to political parties, candidates, trade associations, special interest groups or lobbyists. This creates a lack of transparency, and increases the risk of corruption.

A lack of transparency also means panies often don’t know what trade associations are doing on behalf of their members. Ford Motor Company is just the latest to join over panies (including iconic brands Microsoft, PepsiCo, Mars, Wal-Mart, and Unilever), which have left the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) which is involved in drafting model state legislation on gun control, Voter ID laws, Stand Your Ground laws, anti-immigration bills, blocking EPA regulations, and reversing state regulations on renewable energy. Similarly, a number of panies have left the Chamber of Commerce which has spent over $1bn on lobbying since 1998. While new research from InfluenceMap indicates that major panies and their trade associations spent over $100m in 2015 on efforts to obstruct and delay climate policy.

Simply put, we believe it is in the best interests of shareholders panies to be transparent and accountable about whether they use corporate funds to influence regulation – both directly and indirectly.

Wow. There’s so much to unpack above, but it quickly can be summed up as activist investors of a certain political stripe should use their influence to force corporations to stop any funding of groups or candidates they disagree with regardless whether those actions actually benefit the corporation in question or its other investors. As for InfluenceMap and its impeccable, unbiased “research,” it’s merely more of the same, as noted by the group’s “Mission” on its website:

InfluenceMap is driven by a desire to remove the political gridlock that has hindered the climate change issue since the Earth Summit in 1992, and has since prevented a meaningful global agreement. Whilst the current mood of sustainability-driven CEOs appears to be confident that business is rallying behind the path to appropriate action, policymakers are sceptical, suggesting corporate influence has, and continues to be, a major factor in holding back the policy process. We provide our stakeholders with an online tool to access information on this topic, supporting key engagers in their interactions panies and corporate representatives. We point to and support the mendations of a key report on corporate engagement with climate policy from three UN agencies entitled Caring for Climate. It states that corporations be transparent, align their political influences (internally and externally), support climate legislation, and to stop obstructing it.

That’s unbiased stuff, you betcha. Ms. Compere concludes:

A petition has been brought to the SEC asking for the development of rules that require panies to disclose political contributions to shareholders. Yet, despite over 1.2 million letters submitted in support including institutional investors, leading academics, state treasurers, and even two former SEC Chairs Arthur Levitt and William Donaldson, Congress last year acted to prevent the SEC from implementing such a rule for the next year. A worrying decision, because when corporate lobbying and political contributions take place in the dark it is not only shareholder value that is put at risk, democracy itself is also weakened. And when that happens we all lose.

Worrying? To whom – other than activist shareholders attempting to muzzle opposing voices such as ALEC, the Chamber of Commerce and The Heartland Institute who dare express climate-change skepticism? What group will they target next should their disclosure efforts succeed? BCAM and ICCR might want to up their game when es to discussing unsettled science rather than adopting the disingenuous albeit easier route of stifling debate.

It appears Ms. Compere, BCAM and ICCR won’t be happy until all corporations are subject to Commons-era rules that reflect activist shareholders’ disdain for nearly everything private. Should they succeed, it truly would be a tragedy.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Microfinance Challenged
PowerBlog has in the past endorsed the concept of micro-loans as a market-friendly and thereby effective way of aiding the poor, especially in developing countries. Now Arneel Karnani has attacked microfinance in a prestigious publication, largely on the basis of macroeconomic data. Over at Business as Mission Network, microfinancier Peter Greer supplies a thorough and fascinating response to the charges. Certainly any movement needs it critics and Karnani scores some genuine points, but it seems to me that Greer’s rebuttals...
Acton Launches New Website
The Acton Institute has just refreshed its online look. Go to www.acton.org to see pletely redesigned Website. All of your favorite content is still available but it should now be easier to find and keep track of. Here is a short list of improvements that you may note: Updated navigation: We now use a horizontal drop-menu system along the top of the website to make finding the content you want a little bit easier.Now@Acton: Find the most current content right...
UK Approves Creation of Chimeras
The Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority (HFEA) in the UK has given generic approval allowing “human-animal embryos to be created and used for research.” According to a Christian Science Monitor report, Evan Harris, “a lawmaker on a mittee that has oversight in this field,” says that “No scientist I have found has provided scientific reasons as opposed to religiously based ethical reasons for not proceeding,” he adds, even though mittee “looked high and low for such scientists.” Typically the case...
Samaritan Award Winner
The Acton Institute’s 2007 Samaritan Award winner for outstanding private, voluntary charitable service has been awarded to the Arkansas Sheriffs’ Youth Ranches, Inc. Their mission statement reads, “To address, remedy, and prevent child abuse and neglect by creating safe, healthy, and permanent homes for children.” One of the outstanding aspects of the program is their belief in not abandoning those who participate in their program just because they reach a certain age. Participants are allowed to stay involved and seek...
D. James Kennedy Dies (1930-2007)
From WPBF: FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. — A pioneering megachurch pastor and prominent Christian broadcaster has died in Fort Lauderdale. The Rev. D. James Kennedy died early Wednesday morning at his home due plications from cardiac arrest in December. The 76-year-old Kennedy had not been seen publicly since then; his retirement was announced on Aug. 26. Kennedy took the Coral Ridge Presbyterian Church in Fort Lauderdale from a congregation of 45 in 1959 to a megachurch of nearly 10,000 members today....
Islam, Democracy and Turkey
Bilal Sambur, Ph.D., is assistant professor on the faculty of divinity at Suleyman Demirel University in Isparta, Turkey. He is a guest scholar this summer at the Acton Institute. Islam, Democracy and Turkey By Bilal Sambur The inauguration of Abdullah Gul as Turkey’s new president has provoked a great deal of discussion — and anxiety — about the rise to power of a man who is an observant Muslim with a background in Islamic politics. Instead of anxiety, the world...
Globalization By Itself is Not Enough
A recent NBER paper, “Distributional Effects of Globalization in Developing Countries,” by Pinelopi Koujianou Goldberg and Nina Pavcnik examines some effects of trade liberalization on low-skill workers. Les Picker summarizes the findings, “Not surprisingly, the entry of many developing countries into the world market in the last three decades coincides with changes in various measures of inequality in these countries. What is more surprising is that the distributional changes went in the opposite direction from what the conventional wisdom suggests:...
Faith and Football
This mentary by Anthony Bradley, “Obviously, Sports Do Not Build Character,” (along with our poll question) made me think of the series of articles appearing in the current issue of Christianity Today, which included a cover story on the NFL and an editorial addressing faith and the NBA. And that made me think of this parody (HT: the evangelical outpost): Update: See also the new “Centre for the Study of Sport and Spirituality.” ...
Faith and Freedom Vs. The Super – State
Darkness and light have been used to symbolize powerful metaphors in literature, art, film, and all sorts of creative venues. In Scripture, darkness and light are often used to evoke good and evil. In the 9th chapter of John’s Gospel, Jesus heals a man born blind, who furthermore is brought into the fullness of light through faith in Christ. Jesus, however, implicates the Pharisees, by saying, “If you were blind, you would not be guilty of sin; but now that...
English, Speak You Do It?
They say that those who can’t do, teach. But what if you can’t teach? From the AZ Republic: “Hundreds of students in Arizona are trying to learn English from teachers who don’t know the language, state officials say.” I’ve never been too attracted to the whole “English-only movement,” but I would think the language should at least be the sine qua non of our educational system. That is, we should be teaching English and other languages. Some of the examples...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved