Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The spiritual core of liberty
The spiritual core of liberty
Apr 3, 2025 8:37 PM

Last week FEE published an essay by economist Dierdre McCloskey titled “The Core of Liberty is Economic Liberty.” McCloskey writes,

[E]conomic liberty is the liberty about which most ordinary people care. True, liberty of speech, the press, assembly, petitioning the government, and voting for a new government are in the long run essential protections for all liberty, including the economic right to buy and sell. But the lofty liberties are cherished mainly by an educated minority. Most people—in the long run foolishly, true—don’t give a fig about liberty of speech, so long as they can open a shop when they want and drive to a job paying decent wages.

In my recent book, Foundations of a Free & Virtuous Society, I argue much the same thing. However — and I don’t think McCloskey would disagree — I point out that, from the economic point of view, all social liberties can be understood as expressions of economic liberty:

[W]ithout free markets, rightly understood [as open markets], we wouldn’t have freedom in society at all. What is freedom of speech if not a free market of speech? What is freedom of the press if not a free market of publication? What is freedom of religion if not a free market of religion? What is democracy if not a free market of politics?

Of course, many in the liberal tradition would be quick to point out that such freedom is not absolute:

The British lord and Roman Catholic John Acton once remarked that “the Catholic notion” of liberty is “not the power of doing what we like, but the right of being able to do what we ought.” Similarly, Benjamin Franklin said that “only a virtuous people are capable of freedom.”

That qualification noted, I think it is worthwhile to furthermore ask not simply “What is the core of liberty?” but “Where can the core of liberty be found?”

At first, it might appear that these are just two ways of putting the same question. They are not. Historically and developmentally — though not without exceptions — economic liberty is usually one of the last that a civilization embraces (the other ers being press freedom and full democracy).

The typical er is religious liberty. As I wrote a few years ago for Public Discourse, “A country that values and protects religious liberty offers fertile soil for economic liberty to flourish.”

I continued to note,

Religious bodies and organizations cannot be considered free from government restriction without private property rights, freedom of exchange, and equal treatment before the law. Granting such rights certainly does not equate to liberalizing an entire economy, but it can be an important first step.

Indeed, we could add freedom of speech and press to that list as well. Societies that respect religious liberty create a sphere in which all other social liberties are present as well.

While the logical core of liberty in society may be best understood through an economic lens, the history of liberty suggests that the spiritual core of liberty flows from the nature and rights of conscience. As Acton once defined it, “Liberty is the reign of conscience.”

The Roman Catholic saint Pope John Paul II understood this well, writing in 1991,

[I]t is necessary for peoples in the process of reforming their systems to give democracy an authentic and solid foundation through the explicit recognition of [human] rights. Among the most important of these rights, mention must be made of the right to life, an integral part of which is the right of the child to develop in the mother’s womb from the moment of conception; the right to live in a united family and in a moral environment conducive to the growth of the child’s personality; the right to develop one’s intelligence and freedom in seeking and knowing the truth; the right to share in the work which makes wise use of the earth’s material resources, and to derive from that work the means to support oneself and one’s dependents; and the right freely to establish a family, to have and to rear children through the responsible exercise of one’s sexuality. In a certain sense, the source and synthesis of these rights is religious freedom, understood as the right to live in the truth of one’s faith and in conformity with one’s transcendent dignity as a person. (Emphasis added.)

This has always struck me as somewhat paradoxical since I first read it. After all, without life, one cannot have any other rights or liberties. In that sense, the right to life is the most fundamental. But because the pope had a broad understanding of what that right entailed, es to the conclusion that “religious freedom” is “the source and synthesis of these rights.”

It was from religiously liberal (for its time) British America that the first modern democracy plete with freedom of press, speech, and assembly — was born. Yet it still struggled to respect the right to life in many areas, slavery being the worst failing in this regard.

The right to life, being passing, is perhaps more the goal or telos of liberty than its seed or core. It was the basis by which Acton thought historians had a duty to judge figures of the past and call out every instance of the corrupting tendency of power.

Acton believed this because, being a Whig and a Christian, he expected the history of liberty to progress in a positive direction. No doubt he would have been disheartened by the twentieth century, but he was a good historian and knew that history is messy, to put it lightly.

Yet, at least on McCloskey’s account, that conviction has proven faithful, despite the horrors of recent memory:

The liberal plan of equality, liberty, and justice made masses of people bold…. Make everyone free, it turned out (the experiment had never been tried before on such a scale), and you get masses and masses of people inspired and enabled to have a go. “I contain multitudes,” sang the poet of the new liberty. And he did. He and his friends had a go at steam engines and research universities and railways and public schools and electric lights and corporations and open source engineering and containerization and the internet. We became rich by giving ordinary people their economic liberty.

For the sake not merely of material enrichment, but spiritual, we ought to continue the expansion of economic liberty today. For the sake of economic liberty, and moreover for the right to life, we ought to support the “reign of conscience” as well.

Image: “Portrait of Lord Acton.” Source: Wikimedia Commons. Public Domain.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
New bookshoppe items
There are two new items that should be noted in the Acton Bookshoppe. The first is The Call of the Entrepreneur DVD which is now available for pre-order. The DVD is not expected to ship until the fall but you can start lining up for one of the first copies right now. The second item is The Call of the Entrepreneur Study Guide by Rev. Robert Sirico. The study guide touches on many of the same themes as the DVD,...
Cutting budgets and taxes
Both of our major political parties have missed what seems so obvious. One says that we need more tax cuts to strengthen the economy. This is correct. The problem is that they are not willing to also make serious budget cuts. That party has spent more than any previous administration. The other political party wants to expand federal government by spending more of our money by raising taxes. The first plan helps the economy in the short run but not...
The (civil) religion test
Commentators call it “The Religion Test.” What does it mean when the Constitution says there should be no religious test for holding office in the United States? Historically it has plainly meant that no candidate, be they a Quaker, a Baptist, a Pentecostal or a Mormon can be barred from office because of their religion. The question is once again on the table with the serious candidacy of Mitt Romney for the presidency. And many who are concerned about Romney’s...
Do unto music as is done unto movies
There once was a time when it was, in practice at least, more difficult and costly to copy videocassette tapes than it was music pact discs, puter programs. That, in part, is the justification for how the US Copyright code treats music puter software differently than, say, movies. It’s also why you see panies, like Blockbuster and Netflix, that specialize in delivering rental videos for limited home usage. panies, like Gamefly, specialize in the rental of video games for consoles...
Austrians at Acton University 2006
A contingent from Austria that attended last year’s Acton University produced a video on their experiences: Want to learn more? Register for next month’s Acton University 2007 (June 12-15, 2007) today. Applications are also open next month for the Toward a Free and Virtuous Society conference to be held in Sonntagberg, Austria, Sept. 20-23, 2007. Applications will be accepted June 1-July 1, 2007. ...
Sponsor a child’s education
There are details about how you can sponsor a child to receive an education at the new Christian Primary School in Kabala, Sierra Leone at the project’s blog. The school is an effort pursued by Fraser Valley Christian High School in Surrey, British Columbia, in conjunction with Christian Extension Services in Sierra Leone. I have mentioned the new school in a previous Acton Commentary. The cost of sponsoring a child is $200. Some more details about the education offered by...
Government divides, families unite – Pope Leo XIII saw it coming
Jennifer Roback Morse takes a look at The War Between the State and the Family, a book that examines some of the family unfriendly social policies of the United Kingdom. The state, she finds, is in the process of atomizing the family into a loose association of persons with easily separated relationships. posing society into nothing but a collection of unattached individuals has been destructive of individuals and society alike,” Morse writes. Read the mentary here. ...
Business ed in Catholic Universities Conference
The John Ryan Institute at the University of St. Thomas announces its 2008 symposium in the series Catholic Social Thought and Management, to be on the topic of “Business Education at Catholic Universities.” These biennial conferences are large affairs passing a refreshingly diverse array of viewpoints. The conferences page is here, though the link to the 2008 event seems not to be operational yet. ...
Changing the shape of magazine delivery
New postal rates went into effect yesterday, but the biggest impact of the new rates and policies hasn’t yet been felt. A new set of policies governing the delivery of magazines through the mail has been postponed until July. That’s a bit of needed good news for small magazines that will face rather hefty price increases. The increases have even got The Nation’s Katrina vanden plaining that “the Postal Service is a monopoly.” Maybe it’s time for magazines that can’t...
Christians in the marketplace
This week’s ACT 3 weekly essay, “Why Christians Ought to Make a Difference in the Marketplace,” by David L. Bahnsen: I have heard it said in my life on more than one occasion that God sent his Son to save souls. Indeed, for evangelicals, that is certainly true. However, for the professing believer who talks of a deep concern for individual souls my question and answer will either be a gigantic disappointment or it may be a true experience of...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved