Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The sharing economy: How do we maintain a culture of ownership?
The sharing economy: How do we maintain a culture of ownership?
Apr 4, 2025 5:12 PM

As we survey the modern economy, individual ownership appears to be on the demise. We see an increasing preference for access over ownership and collaborative consumption,from the streaming- and cloud-centric features of the latest technology to the increasingly “share-happy” habits of American consumers amid a burgeoning “gig economy.”

On the surface, such a shift would seem to bring endless benefits: more options, more flexibility, better quality, cheaper prices, fewer risks, and (presumably) more freedom. Yet despite such benefits, a void in private ownership also means an absence of certain moral, social, and economic lessons, many of which form and transform the habits, disciplines, and imaginations of everyday creators and contributors across the economic order.

According to economist Tyler Cowen, we’re right to celebrate the benefits and freedoms of collaborative consumption, but do so without forgetting or neglecting the necessity of individual ownership as a cultural value:

I worry that Americans are, slowly but surely, losing their connection to the idea of private ownership. The nation was based on the notion that property ownership gives individuals a stake in the system. It set Americans apart from feudal peasants, taught us how property rights and incentives operate, and was a kind of training for future entrepreneurship. Do we not, as parents, often give our children pets or other valuable possessions to teach them basic lessons of life and stewardship?

We’re hardly at a point where American property has been abolished, but I am still nervous that we are finding ownership to be so inconvenient. The notion of “possessive individualism” is sometimes mocked, but in fact it is a significant source of autonomy and initiative. Perhaps we are ing munal and caring in positive ways, but it also seems to be more conformist and to generatefewer empire buildersand entrepreneurs.

A society with low ownership poses problems that are largely psychological—infantilizing us and diminishing our ability and capacity to own and cultivate and steward. But it also introduces significant risks to personal freedom and autonomy, consolidating power and control in products or solutions that are increasingly central to our daily lives while never actually belonging to us. From Netflix to Spotify to Amazon’s ebooks to Apple’s iOS, many of our core modern “solutions” are not ours to steward or preserve or protect, outside of a transactional decision to subscribe. “Yes, you will still own the title to your physical house,” Cowen explains, “but most of the value in that home you will in essence rent from panies or, in the case of municipal utilities, the government.”

Once again, the positives of our newfound interconnectedness and interdependence are real, extending beyond the mere material perks and flexibility. As economist Arnold Kling explains, “The more we consume the goods and services provided by others, the more we have to trust the institutions through which we obtain those goods and services.” From the standpoint of human relationship and creative partnership, this has the potential for many positive fruits, from more dynamic innovation to greater peace and social stability to increased economic growth. But only if we hold those gifts in tension with our basic calling to own and steward and transform creation. “Perhaps we are ing munal and caring in positive ways,” Cowen writes, “but it also seems to be more conformist and to generatefewer empire buildersand entrepreneurs.” It can, but needn’t be so.

As Christians, our view of “ownership” is distinct and peculiar. Whatever property we own, manage, and multiply ultimately belongs to God, and our activities ought to be oriented as such. “God makes man the master of his temporal household,” write Lester DeKoster and Gerard Berghoef inFaithful in All God’s House. “Like all stewards, man is not the owner. He is the overseer…The quality of stewardship depends on obedience to the Master’s will.”

To be clear, this doesn’t dismiss or diminish what we would consider “ownership” or economic responsibility in the current economic sphere. It amplifies it. “Our stewardship is the test,” DeKoster and Berghoef conclude. “Do we mean to serve God or mammon, the Lord or the Devil?”

Given the recent trends, Christians can wield ownership and steward our resources wisely while also seeing and seizing new opportunities to serve and share and innovate with those around us, whether through traditional material means or intangible, technological tools of exchange.

Collaborative consumption offers a path to both, should we be wise enough to pave the way accordingly.

Image: MagicH, Shared Bike (CC0)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Scandal and school, education and freedom
It’s not news that a college education costs a boatload today. But as we’ve all learned over the past week, the cost of a college education is much more – about $500,000 more over tuition, room, and board if you’re a TV celebrity like Lori Loughlin. Add $1 million bail and the possibility of prison time to boot. Some people will do anything for their kids, up to and including bribing school officials to admit their less than stellar students...
Acton Line: Neighborly help for the poor; Americans flunk political science
On this week’s Acton Line podcast we hear about a church-based ministry that engages with the homeless and poor “relationally, responsibly, passionately.” James Whitford, executive director of Watered Gardens Gospel Rescue Mission in Joplin, Missouri, joins Acton’s Andrew Vanderput in a thought provoking conversation on private charity and the intensely personal nature of the organization’s outreach. In the second segment, Aquinas College economist David Hebert and Acton’s Tyler Groenendal dig into the public’s deep dissatisfaction with America’s political institutions –...
Explainer: President Trump’s executive order on campus speech, student loans
What just happened? Earlier this month, at the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC), President Trump announced he would sign an executive order to promote free speech on college campuses.The president is set to sign to sign that executive order today, which he has vowed will require colleges to “support free speech” or face “very costly” penalties. What does this executive order do? The title of the executive order is “Improving Free Inquiry, Transparency, and Accountability at Colleges And Universities” with...
Game of Theories: Real business cycle
Note: This is post #115 in a weekly video series on basic economics. The “real” part of the real business cycle (RBC) refers to real shocks to an economy, specifically to supply shocks. As Tyler Cowen of Marginal Revolution University says, RBC is useful for plex supply shock, such as a sudden rise in oil prices. But it can also explain many of the economic downturns throughout human history. For instance, in ancient times when economies relied primarily on agriculture,...
Nihilism and mass murder: Christianity in reverse
Brazil was rocked last week by a deadly shootout in a high school in Suzano, a suburb of Sao Paolo. Two former students armed with a gun, crossbows and axes killed nine people and mitted suicide. Immediately, the media began another campaign against Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro, leading people to believe that the massacre had something to do with his pro-gun policies. There is, of course, an elementary problem of logic in this argument: Bolsonaro assumed the presidency 63 days...
Interview: Margarita Mooney on communism, freedom, and the ‘irreducible person’
The Acton Institute alumni network is now over 8,000 people strong. This group spans many disciplines and contains many of the most influential leaders from those disciplines. Margarita Mooney is one of those influential people. pleted her undergraduate studies at Yale University and her doctorate at Princeton University. She is currently an Associate Professor of Practical Theological at Princeton Theological Seminary, and is an education entrepreneur. As the founder of Scala Foundation, she has built programming designed to strengthen classical...
Tenderness: a spiritual ‘currency’?
Pope Francis intelligently realizes that Christ, our model for winning the hearts and good will of others, was a tender listener who carefully and constantly invested his gentle concern and advice in others. The return on such investment paid off as the poor and suffering sinners who listened to him – and still do through his vicars on earth – were converted by the tender Lamb of God. Read More… On March 18, in a meeting with representatives from the...
The ‘true politics’ of the gospel: An imprisoned Chinese pastor’s sermon on peace and freedom
In response to the explosive growth of Christianity in China, the munist authorities have ramped up efforts to curb the trend—imprisoning Christians, shutting down churches and schools, and moving to release their own state-sanitized revision of the Bible. Last December, Early Rain Covenant Church in Chengdu became a target of such efforts, forced to shut its doors as an estimated 100 members were hauled away by state police. This included the pastor, Wang Yi, and his wife, Jiang Rong, both...
Why do pastors receive a tax exemption for housing?
A federal court of appeals recently upheld the constitutionality of the ministerial housing allowance. The Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals in Chicago ruled unanimously that the sixty-five year old tax provision does not violate the First Amendment clause that prohibits government establishment of religion. The decision reversed a federal judge’s 2017 opinion that invalidated the allowance as a violation of the establishment clause. The court ruled the housing allowance is constitutional under two of the U.S. Supreme Court’s church-state precedents....
Captain Marvel’s grit
The latest Marvel film has done well at the box office, and for good reason. It is a solid entry in the MCU, and an introduction to a new character that promises to be central to the ongoing narrative arc following Avengers: Infinity War (some spoilers follow). There are quite a few notable themes in Captain Marvel, and I’ll highlight a couple here. First, we learn a fair amount more about the Kree, the civilization introduced in Guardians of the...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved