Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The Scottish play comes alive in imaginative new Joel Coen film
The Scottish play comes alive in imaginative new Joel Coen film
Nov 22, 2026 3:42 PM

If you think you’ve seen it all before, perhaps many times before, think again. Expressive direction and Denzel Washington make this a Macbeth for a new era.

Read More…

Who needs another version of Macbeth on film? You may find yourself asking this question with the release of director Joel Coen’s The Tragedy of Macbeth, which stars Denzel Washington in the title role and, in the part of Lady Macbeth, Coen’s seemingly ubiquitous wife, three-time Academy Award winner Frances McDormand.

The story has been put on film with astonishing frequency. So you may wonder about this even if you’ve heard that the latest one is superlative. A movie of Macbeth is only a slightly more novel idea than a film about a cop in conflict with his uptight, by-the-book superiors.

Even in the silent film era, there were multiple screen versions. One featured Herbert Beerbohm Tree—by most accounts the greatest stage actor of the Edwardian Age. Among the more famous talking-picture-era takes are the 1948 version that starred and was directed by Orson Welles, at least two British renditions with Maurice Evans and Judith Anderson, a 1971 Roman Polanski account starring Jon Finch, and Trevor Nunn’s famed 1979 Royal Shakespeare Company (RSC) presentation with Ian McKellen and Judi Dench. On YouTube you can find Sean Connery’s 1961 Canadian Broadcasting Company rendering (pre-Dr. No) as well as his son Jason’s 1997 feature. There are also readily available versions with such acknowledged Shakespeareans as Anthony Sher, Eric Porter, Jeremy Brett, Nicol Williamson, and Patrick Stewart. Just five years ago a handsome account with X-Men actor Michael Fassbender and La Vie En Rose star Marion Cotillard was released into theaters, and this is to say nothing of the countless adaptations that have dispensed with Shakespeare’s verse. That includes movies like Scotland, PA and two versions in the Malayalam language, the tongue of the Indian state of Kerala. Perhaps most famously of all, there is Akira Kurosawa’s Japanese interpretation, Throne of Blood, starring the great Toshiro Mifune. There is even an old episode of The Rockford Filesloosely patterned upon it.

Spurring this surfeit is the titular role. The pletely and subtly a dramatic character is written, the harder, generally speaking, it is to perform. Thus, any hack performer can effectively take on a part in a work by Sam Shepard, but few actors can do justice to Lear or Brutus. Hamlet and Richard III paratively easier because they are less contradictory: less life-like and more expressly figures of and for the stage.

The hardest of all the parts in the standard theater repertory may indeed be the Scottish usurper. Consider that it requires an actor who is as natural as a hero as he is as a villain. That’s because there is no tragedy without the seeming magnanimity projected by a genuine leading man, yet he must also be capable of menace, otherwise, the actor cannot be persuasive as the tyrant Macbeth es. Alongside this, he must have a palpable intelligence, one that will put across a figure who has exceptional depths. Yet, even so, the actor must be able to suggest someone who is notably lacking in self-awareness. On top of this, he must have the physical presence and bearing of a great athlete. As a famous tragedian who has struggled with the role once put it, the performer has to have the manner of a likeable but dim hockey star who just happens on occasion to be a soulful philosophical genius with more than a touch of the poet.

This is immensely tempting, of course. It’s a supreme test, and the layers and paradoxes in Shakespeare’s characterization make the part irresistible for actors eager to prove themselves. That the play is the shortest of all Shakespeare’s tragedies makes it almost equally appealing for film directors. This attraction is bolstered by its abundance of action scenes and wealth of mayhem and gore.

But all the requirements of the part mean that most actors who take it on fail miserably. It’s hard to say which is worse in the Welles’s version: his acting or the dime store costumes that look like rejects from Abbott and Costello Go to Mars. Likewise, as memorable as Trevor Nunn’s RSC version is, McKellen is wrong for the part. At no time do you believe he is a great warrior or might under other circumstances have been an honorable man. To the same extent Jeremy Brett seemed about as much like a noble swordsman as Richard Simmons, and Nicol Williamson essayed the part with as much poetry as you might expect of Rob Gronkowski.

Nor do most directors have a proper understanding of the play. Polanski’s Macbeth is precisely what you would expect from the director of Rosemary’s Baby, and while Sean Connery was exceptional in the role—arguably more convincing than any other actor to play it on film—the telecast in which he starred is about as subtly directed as an episode of Married with Children, if with cheaper sets and worse lighting.

So the pairing of Washington and McDormand and the inclusion of Coen as director is e. Those who have seen Washington onstage know how gifted he is, and he happens to be endowed with more than a few of the traits the role calls for. A sometime college basketball player, he has the stature and the confidence required, along with a certain mix of leading man charm and obvious fallibility. McDormand is every bit as good as you might expect, and Coen’s direction is inspired.

Joel Coen’s decision to cast a black actor should not give viewers any fiture. At this point “nontraditional” casting has e traditional. You rarely see a stage or screen version of Shakespeare that doesn’t have mixed-race casting, and, as Shakespeare’s language is so contrary to the way we actually speak, no one should object to seeing Asian or African American performers in his plays. He was aiming, after all, for psychological truth and storytelling, not naturalism or realism. Moreover, the director has purposefully made use of costumes and sets that suggest an earlier period but that are not specifically of any place or era. So The Tragedy of Macbeth doesn’t awaken the jarring sense of incongruity that nontraditional casting produced in such recent movies as Armando Iannucci’s 2019 remake of David Copperfield, which starred the Indian actor Dev Patel.

I suspect, in fact, that audiences will have more trouble with Washington’s age than his skin color. This production of Macbeth works against mon view of the play: that it’s the story of a rising man who is putty in the hands of his sexy young wife. In this version, the hero and his beloved are making a last bid for power with their best days already behind them. Yet the performances and the presentation are pelling that these choices seem not pelling but plausible.

I confess that I disliked some of the earlier Coen brothers movies because they seemed to me too busily shot and staged: too fussy. (Think especially of Raising Arizona and The Hudsucker Proxy.) But Coen is 67 now, and what he has said in interviews is consistent with what appears on screen. The Tragedy of Macbeth was deliberately shot to use the play’s theatricality and not to turn it into a widescreen David Lean–style spectacle or crowd it up with clever camera angles. By wisely shooting the film in a moody black and white, Coen makes you listen to the text and the actors, not upstaging Shakespeare. At the same time, his direction is anything but unduly reverential.

This is not a Merchant-Ivory picture.

Recognizing that the story has many elements of horror and of the supernatural, Coen decided on a visual approach that incorporates elements of German expressionism. The result is a look that is stark, bold, and striking—at times almost avant-garde. (It’s hard to believe that he wasn’t partly influenced by the offbeat and disturbing 1971 Peter Brook film of King Lear that starred Paul Scofield.) The movie’s pictorial language and style are matched poser Carter Burwell’s unsettling score. While hinting at traditional Scottish fiddle playing, it’s also in the spirit of the more unnerving film work of Bernard Hermann: melodic one moment, eerie and purposefully repetitive the next.

The secondary players are mostly excellent, too. Brendan Gleeson is a virile pelling Duncan, and Bertie Carvel is an unforgettable Banquo. Even the small players manage to stand out with particularly excellent performances turning up from Jefferson Mays as Lady Macbeth’s physician and Moses Ingram as Lady Macduff.

Those looking for an exact rendering of the text should be forewarned, however. Small changes abound. In this version, the role of Ross has been built up, and an assortment of cuts have been made. When Malcolm and Macduff meet in England, there is no longer any effort by Malcolm to test Macduff’s loyalty, and Ross es the savior of Banquo’s son Fleance. The trimming contributes to a remarkable brevity as the movie clocks in at a tidy one hour forty-five minutes.

I have seen at least half a dozen different stage productions of Macbeth and many more film versions. This is by far the best. In my career as a playwright, I have twice had actresses literally break their legs before opening night. This has made me question many of the superstitions of the theater. But there’s no doubt that it’s hard to do the “Scottish play”—as it’s often referred to—well. Coen, Washington, and McDormand deserve great credit for their achievement.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Radio Free Acton: Egypt in Transition
As Egypt moves through the process of establishing a new, stable government after not just one but two revolutions, the security of the Coptic Orthodox munity in Egyptian society has at times been in doubt. Dr. Magdy El-Sanady, an Egyptian Coptic Christian, has worked for over 30 years in health planning, management munity development, and in non-governmental organization institutional strengthening in Egypt. Dr. El-Sanady holds postgraduate degrees in pediatrics and public health from Egypt and an M.B.A. and Ph.D. from...
Video: Kishore Jayabalan on the Changing Face of the Roman Catholic Church
Pope Francis recently installed 19 new cardinals in a ceremony at the Vatican, the first that he has chosen in his pontificate. Most of the new Cardinals hail from outside Europe and North America, and the group includes the first Cardinal from the long-impoverished nation of Haiti. Kishore Jayabalan, Director of Istituto Acton in Rome, spoke with the BBC about what this new group of Cardinals means for the Roman Catholic Church, and how they reflect the changing face of...
Acton Institute Names Lawyer and Economist Oskari Juurikkala the 2014 Novak Award Winner
Today the Acton Institute announced the 2014 Novak Award winner. Full release follows: A rigorous researcher and sound contributor to various academic disciplines and initiatives, Finnish native Oskari Juurikkala has been selected as the recipient of the 2014 Novak Award by the Acton Institute in recognition of his early promise as a scholar. Educated in both law (London School of Economics) and economics (Helsinki School of Economics), he earned a joint Ph.D. in law and economics from the University of...
What is Innovation?
“Most CEOs now spray the word ‘innovation’ as if it were an air freshener,” says Dennis Berman in the Wall Street Journal, “A little spritz can’t hurt.” A prime example, notes Berman, is what Kellogg’s CEO John Bryant described as one of pany’s most important “innovations”: a peanut butter Pop-Tart. Most of us would probably agree that a new flavor of breakfast pastry isn’t as innovative as, say, the iPhone. But how do we know? What exactly is innovation? As...
P.J. O’Rourke Defends ‘Truthiness’ Before the Supreme Court
The Supreme Courts is hearing a case that involves a First Amendment challenge to an Ohio law that makes it a crime to “disseminate a false statement concerning a candidate, either knowing the same to be false or with reckless disregard of whether it was false.” During the 2010 elections, the Susan B. Anthony List, a pro-life advocacy group, published ads in Ohio claiming that then-Rep. Steven Driehaus supported taxpayer-funded abortions (because he had voted for the Affordable Care Act)....
Apple’s Tim Cook: Profits Aren’t The Only Thing
From The Independent: He leads pany that some would consider the epitome of ruthless global capitalism. But Apple chief executive Tim Cook has shocked some in the US with an impassioned attack on the single-minded pursuit of profit – and a direct appeal to climate-change deniers not to buy shares in his firm. Eyewitnesses said Cook, who succeeded Steve Jobs as boss of the technology giant in 2011, was visibly angry as he took on a group of right-wing investors...
The Bigger The Government, The Smaller The Citizen
Dennis Prager at Prager University reminds us that big government makes everything else (goodness, charity, self-reliance) smaller. Big government also creates a sense of entitlement amongst citizens, creating ingratitude and resentment – hardly what one wants in society. ...
How IKEA and Innovation Help Refugees in Iraq
When looking for solutions to humanity’s problems, conservatives and libertarians tend to prefer turning first to free markets rather than government. The reason for such a preference is often misunderstood, and can be difficult to explain since it appears paradoxical: free markets are often better at serving human needs than governments because free markets make it easier to fail. As Arnold Kling explains, the best way to deal with failure depends on the institution. An individual needs to fail with...
McConaughey Oscar Acceptance Begs a Question
By now even many people who didn’t watch the Oscars have seen or heard Matthew McConaughey’s acceptance speech for Best Actor. The Texas actor thanked God for all the opportunities in his life, thanked God some more (cut to Academy members squirming in their seats), and then he told a story about when he was a teenager and was asked who his hero was. The answer he gave at the time: his hero was Matthew McConaughey in ten years. Then...
Religious Liberty and Business as Culture-Making
Offering yetanother contribution to a series of recentdiscussions about the religious liberties of bakers, florists, and photographers, Jonathan Merritt has a piece atThe Atlantic warning that the type of protections Christians were fighting for in Arizona e back to hurt the faithful.” “These prophets of doom only acknowledge one side of the slope,” Merritt writes. “They fail to consider how these laws could be used against members of their munities. If you are able to discriminate against others on the...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved