Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY
/
The Right to Keep and Bear Property
The Right to Keep and Bear Property
Mar 18, 2025 6:33 PM

  Bump-stock devices, which are firearm accessories that allow semi-automatic rifles to fire more quickly, are a niche possession. They were used in the mass murder in Las Vegas in 2017 at the Route 91 Harvest Festival, and in the wake of that horror, their legality is up for debate. It is easy enough to understand why people with little interest in guns would take a dim view of firearm accessories that have helped to facilitate mass murder. Yet, those who favor banning bump-stock devices are not merely supporting restrictions on the right to keep and bear arms, but restrictions on the right to keep and bear property.

  On Arms

  In December 2018, Donald Trump’s Justice Department through the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms, and Explosives (ATF) banned bump-stock devices. While rubber bands, belt loops, and shoe strings can all facilitate bump firing, such methods have been around for as long as there have been semi-automatic firearms, the first patented bump-stock device was the Akins Accelerator in 1998. This device is beneficial because it allows the shooter to fire a semi-automatic quickly and accurately, but also safely, since the device, when properly attached, is part of the gun rather than jury-rigged methods like belt loops. Since bump-stock devices are simulacra of fully-automatic weapons, they do not fire at a constant rate like machine guns.

  The ATF determined in 2002 that a firearm with a bump stock does not qualify as a machine gun, and it made further clarifications between 2008 and 2017 regarding bump-stock devices. Most importantly, as of 2010, they were considered by the ATF as an unregulated firearm part, since the device does not mechanically alter the firearms function to fire fully automatic. Yet, under the direction of the Trump Administration, the ATF created a regulation that made what was previously legal illegal by classifying firearms with bump-stock devices as machine guns and hence, illegal by the National Firearms Act of 1986. Last fall, the Supreme Court agreed to hear a case regarding the legality of this ban.

  The bump-stock device ban is a regulation created by a federal agency under the direction of the executive that renders previously common and lawful private property illegal.

  A note on terminology before we proceed. Rather than using the phrases “gun owners,”“gun rights,” and the like that are commonly used even by those who support the natural right for self-defense absolutely, here the more accurate phrases such as “arms owners,” “arms rights,” and “arms laws” will be used. The Second Amendment correctly refers to “the right to keep and bear arms,” which includes guns, ammunition, and their accouterments rather than merely the right to keep and bear guns. This broader terminology correctly emphasizes that the natural right of self-defense includes not only guns, but that which they need to work, e.g. ammunition, and that which will allow them to work in a certain way, e.g. bump-stock devices. Recall that the American Revolutionary War began when the British army stole gunpowder from civilian colonists: the last straw of British misrule was the confiscation of non-gun arms.

  On property

  The regulation that made bump-stock devices illegal was not enacted by the US Congress, but rather created under a very expansive view of executive authority. Then-President Trump decreed that what was once legal and protected by the Second Amendment is now illegal. Both Trump and President Joe Biden (the Biden administration is supporting Trump’s position before the Supreme Court), believe that the Chief Executive has the right to create a regulation that should only be passed as a law (even if the law would be unconstitutional). The justification for such bans as the one regarding bump-stock devices is not based on the Constitution nor natural right, but rather on a purported right to safety.

  The bump-stock ban directly and unequivocally limits the right to keep and bear arms that are already commonly owned and in use. In other words, those who own bump-stock devices are required either to turn in their private property to the government or else to destroy them without any recompense. This is a gross and indefensible use of executive power. To reiterate: the bump-stock device ban is a regulation created by a federal agency under the direction of the executive that renders previously common and lawful private property illegal and makes it a felony (up to 10 years imprisonment and a $250,000 fine) to continue to own it even after the same agency stated it was legal two decades before.

  John Locke understood that owning private property gives the individual freedom by natural law, which is why Jean-Jacques Rousseau, the intellectual progenitor of the Committee on Public Safety, believed rather in natural compassion. Rousseau’s natural compassion is based on a subjective utopian ideal, hence there is no private property. It is natural compassion that led Trump, after the mass murder in Las Vegas, to ban bump stocks. It is this same natural compassion that led so many in the government, including Trump, to allow violations of liberty during Covid. Natural compassion is by its nature anti-liberty, and those who act according to it have, in Thomas Sowell’s terminology, the Unconstrained Vision of the Anointed.

  However, there is a particular type of individual property that is met with the most loathing by those with the Unconstrained Vision. Arms frustrate totalitarian designs in government, which is why many consider the right to bear arms to be a second-class right. Arms are not only property, but the actuality of belief in the natural law rather than natural compassion. Thus, arms and those who keep and bear them are the particular enemy of the Compassionate Anointed. Arms are private property; arms owners mock the claim of the government’s monopoly over public safety by the mere action of owning arms; arms owners assert the right of the individual to protect himself, his family, and other property without dependence on the government; and civilian-owned arms remind the government to tread carefully when it comes to violating the rights of the individual.

  While bump-stock devices can be used in conjunction with semi-automatic rifles for nefarious purposes by malevolent men, this does not justify the violation of natural rights in the name of natural compassion that occurs when the government bans these devices or other arms, particularly by executive-cum-administrative fiat.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY
Molières Medicine for Wayward Youth
  Before the Internet and social media, there was Johann Gutenberg’s seventeenth-century movable-type printing innovation. (The Chinese invented something similar centuries before, but without impact). It revolutionized the spread of literacy and contributed to the Protestant movement’s break from the Catholic Church.Between the printing press and the Internet, there were other things: the telegraph, radio, and TV. None diffused written texts...
Sparkling Gems from the Greek
  Are You Tired of WaitingFor Your Fruit-Producing Season?   Rooted and built up in him, and stablished in the faith, as ye have been taught, abounding therein with thanksgiving. - Colossians 2:7   Have you ever been so frustrated at waiting for a fruitful time in your life that you said to the Lord, When is the fruit-producing season ever going to...
Your Life Needs Your Unique God
  Your Life Needs Your Unique God-Made Pace   By Keri Eichberger   For we are God’s handiwork, created in Christ Jesus to do good works, which God prepared in advance for us to do. - Ephesians 2:10   As my heart rate reached 175 beats per minute, lightheadedness shifted to disorientation. Hints of nausea grew to deep gut punches. My breath shallowed and...
J. K. Rowling and the Hate Monster
  Let me tell you about an intense time in British politics: one where Scotland’s hate speech legislation came into force, the final Cass Review into paediatric gender medicine was published, a UK general election was called, and Nigel Farage made a triumphant political return.   Throughout, J. K. Rowling tweeted.   On June 3, Farage left his quondam job as telly broadcaster...
An Unveiled Lifestyle
  An Unveiled Lifestyle   Weekly Overview:   Living an unveiled lifestyle is the way in which we experience the fullness of what’s available to us in our restored relationship with God. It’s a powerful lifestyle of faith, direct encounters with our heavenly Father, and life transformation. It’s when we live our lives in light of the perfect sacrifice of Jesus that we...
SCOTUS Did Not Dodge the Abortion Pill Case
  A unanimous ruling by the Supreme Court of the United States, preserving a federal agency’s relaxed regulations of an abortion-causing drug, is not what contemporary Court-related coverage and commentary would lead one to expect. Although, in fact, consensus is the order of the day at the Court, breathless reports of split decisions, bitter dissents, and partisan divides—especially in June—tend to...
Arab Israeli Christians Stay and Serve as Gaza War Riles Galilee
  One Friday evening, a young woman sat her toddler on her lap at Christ the King Evangelical Episcopal Church in Maalot-Tarshiha, a mixed Arab-Jewish town in northern Israel five miles from the border with Lebanon. Like mothers everywhere, she clapped her hands and beckoned a response.   What does the cow say? Moo, the child replied.   What does the dog say?...
When We Get Too Weary (Galatians 6:9)
  When We Get Too Weary (Galatians 6:9)   By Anne Peterson   And let us not grow weary of doing good, for in due season we will reap, if we do not give up.- Galatians 6:9   Let’s face it, we all get weary. Wiping the sleep out of our eyes, we know that we’re doing what we’re supposed to be doing. A...
After Roe’s Reversal, Most Churches Still Aren’t Involved with a Local Pregnancy Center
  Two years ago, the Supreme Court overruled Roe v. Wade and the right to an abortion. In the aftermath, many churchgoers say theyve seen their congregations involved in supporting local pregnancy resource centers.   On June 24, 2022, in Dobbs v. Jackson Womens Health Organization, the Supreme Court opened the door for states to pass laws restricting abortion. In the aftermath,...
Confident Praying
  Weekend, June 22, 2024   Confident Praying   Never stop praying. (1 Thessalonians 5:17 NLT)   Herod Agrippa was the consummate career politician. The main thing for him was staying in power. So, he had James arrested, and then he executed him. He saw that curried favor with his constituents, so he planned to execute Peter as well.   Now, this wasn’t the same...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved