Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The paradox of flourishing: Where authority and vulnerability meet
The paradox of flourishing: Where authority and vulnerability meet
Apr 7, 2026 5:07 AM

In our discussions about politics, society, and culture, the vocabulary of “human flourishing” has e increasingly popular, moving dangerously close to the status of blurry buzzword.

Yet at its best, the termcapturestheconnective tissue between the material and the transcendent, the immediate and the eternal, pointing toward a holistic prosperity that accounts for the plexity of the human person.

In his latestbook, Strong and Weak: Embracing a Life of Love, Risk and True Flourishing, Andy Crouch examines the broader ideal. ‘“Flourishing’ is a way of answering the first great question,” he writes. “What are we meant to be? We are meant to flourish—not just to survive, but to thrive; not just to exist, but to explore and expand.”

Inorder to actually embody that answer, Crouch believes we have to grasp the underlying“paradox of flourishing.” es from being both strong and weak,” he writes, requiring us to “embrace both authority and vulnerability, both capacity and frailty – even, at least in this broken world, both life and death.”

In truth, most of us tend toelevate one to the detriment of the other, relishing in abuse of power or pursuit of poverty. Yet as humans created in the image of God, and as citizens of an upside-down Kingdom, we are called to embrace bine each together. Suchis the path to real life and abundance, both in the now and not yet.

To understand such a paradox, Crouch argues, we have to reexamine our definitions of authority and vulnerability. Using a 2×2 chart to demonstrate his point (see above right), Crouch explains that,when rightly ordered and properly understood, its a mixture that paves the way to anabundant life.

When we think about authority, for example, we can often fall into traps of exploitation or withdrawal. Rightly understood, Godly authority is something quite different: “the capacity for meaningful action.”

When you have authority, what you do, or do not do, makes a meaningful difference in the world around you…This authority, uniquely ours as the image bearers of God, is a gift in every way. It does e from our own autonomous selves—it is given by Another. And it is good. The sorrow of the whole human story is not that we have authority, it is the way we have misused and neglected authority. Our drive for authority – our sense of frustration when we are denied it, or our sense of grief when we lose it es from its fundamental goodness.

So authority is meant to characterize every image bearer – even the most vulnerable. As infants, long before we could provide for ourselves in any way, we learned that we were capable of meaningful action. We emerged from the womb and instinctively sought to recognize a human face. We learned that others would give meaning to our cries.

When we think about vulnerability, on the other hand, we often fall into traps of glorified suffering or (again) withdrawal. A pursuit of vulnerability is not one that idolizes weakness as a good in itself, but one that values “exposure to meaningful risk.”

The vulnerability that leads to flourishing requires risk, which is the possibility of loss – the chance that when we act, we will lose something we value. Risk, like life, is always about probabilities, never about certainties. To risk is to open ourselves up to the chance that something will go wrong, that something will be taken from us – without knowing for sure whether that loss e to pass or not.

To be vulnerable is to be exposed to the possibility of loss – and not just loss of things or possessions, but loss of our own sense of self. Vulnerable at root means woundable – and any wound deeper than the most superficial scratch injures and limits not just our bodies but our very sense of self. Wounded, we are forced to e careful, tender, tentative in the way we move in the world, if we can still move on our own at all. To be vulnerable is to open oneself up to the possibility – though not the certainty – that the result of our action in the world will be a wound, something lost, potentially never to be gained again.

When bine each of these together,we’re reminded of theupside-down economics of the Gospel, and it yieldsplenty of implications for our personal walk and witness. But in telling us something about the needs and dreams of the human person, such a framework offers plenty ofhints for how we ought to structure and imagine our society:

The same psalmist who celebrated human dominion over the creatures also was capable of looking up into the heavens and grasping what they meant for the significance, or insignificance, of our small and transitory lives…I e to believe that the image of God is not just evident in our authority over creation – it is also evident in our vulnerability in the midst of creation. The psalm speaks of authority and vulnerability in the same breath – because this is what it means to bear the image of God…

When authority and vulnerability bined, you find true flourishing. Not just the flourishing of the gifted or affluent, but the needy and limited as well…In the end, this is what love longs to be: capable of meaningful action in the life of the beloved, mitted to the beloved that everything meaningful is at risk.

So howdo we structure a society that cultivates the conditions for such flourishing, keeping the underlying paradox in mind? How do we foster institutions of culture and government that recognize human capacity and create room for “meaningful action”? How do we embrace “exposure to risk” as a value, also using our power, authority, and dominion to protect and nurture and disciple the most vulnerable?

“If we want flourishing, this is what we will have to learn,” Crouch concludes. “What we will have to unlearn, and be saved from, are our failures of authority, vulnerability or both.”

For more, see Strong and Weak: Embracing a Life of Love, Risk and True Flourishing.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Setting the World Ablaze, Thales-Style
Parents are desperate for alternatives to public schools and even conventional college educations. The classical education movement is seeking to meet this need. And Thales Academies are among the best examples of what the movement has to offer. Read More… Business and educational entrepreneur Robert L. Luddy is a conservative Catholic who embraces dynamism and adaptability in bringing visions to life. Thales Academy is one such vision. In his new book, The Thales Way, Luddy provides the blueprint for and...
‘The Soul of Civility’ and Our Only Hope
A new book by Alexandra Hudson offers hope in our contentious times, a better way to confront differences. Now it’s up to us to take the advice seriously. Read More… Our world is suffering a deep unrest. The term “civil war” has been thrown around more than once in reference to the deep divide that seems too broad to risk crossing. And it’s not just the protests that devolve into riots or the January 6storming of the U.S. Capitol—it’s the...
How States Strike Back at Federal Religious-Freedom Protections
Some states are working to circumvent recent SCOTUS rulings meant to protect conscience rights. Which states is what’s proving interesting, and disturbing. Read More… In the wake of the Supreme Court’s decision in Obergefell v. Hodges (2015), in which the majority of the court ruled that the Constitution supports a right to marry for same-sex couples, many Americans in the “wedding business” faced a dilemma. Bakers like Jack Phillips and web designers like Lorie Smith found themselves unable to deliver...
Halcyon: A Resurrection Without Salvation
The new novel offers an alternative future where the dead are raised and the past is forgotten, leaving us to answer the question, “What does life mean when time is our plaything?” Read More… Set in the opening decade of the current millennium, Elliot Ackerman’s Halcyon is a tale based on many alternative historical events—most notably, that Al Gore won the 2000 election, oversaw the capture of Osama bin Laden shortly after the 9/11 attacks, declined to launch into the...
John Newton: From Slave Trader to Abolitionist Pastor
The story of John Newton’s conversion is legendary. His hymns, like “Amazing Grace,” perennial favorites. His pastor’s heart, exemplary. His fight for an abolition of the slave trade, monumental. But none of this came quickly or easily. Read More… John Newton (1725–1807) is a pivotal figure in the English evangelical revival or awakening. His is an early example of a settled evangelical ministry in the second half of the 18th century, involving pastoral work, hymn-writing, and even mentoring the likes...
Is Neoliberalism Dead?
The Chilean Miracle of the 1990s is usually pointed to as a win for the Chicago School of economics, which advocated laissez faire capitalism, limited regulation, and cuts in government spending. But that was then, and this is the era of Bidenomics and a “post-liberal” New Right. Are free markets as dead as General Pinochet? Read More… Louis Menand wrote a curious article for the New Yorker called “The Rise and Fall of Neoliberalism.” The article is curious on two...
Overlooking Rural America
An attempt to understand “overlooked” Americans reveals more about the observer than the observed. Read More… With magnifying glass in hand, a budding naturalist can learn a great deal about ants scuttling around the driveway. Were the ants to glance upward, however, they might learn even more about the eager eyes—blown up from the ant’s perspective to enormous proportions—looking down at them. In The Overlooked Americans: The Resilience of Our Rural Towns and What It Means for Our Country, social...
Scorsese’s Moral Vision Shines Through Killers of the Flower Moon
This true story of the systematic murder of Osage Indians for their oil is both foreign and familiar territory for the director of Goodfellas, The Wolf of Wall Street, and Silence. Read More… What do we think about when we think about Martin Scorsese? Many of us think about gangster stories, especially ultra-violent, grisly, and operatic ones. He helped bring the genre into the modern age with his masterpieces Mean Streets, Goodfellas, Casino, and The Departed. Even when he strayed...
Getting Beyond Right-Wing and Left-Wing
The stark polarization that marks our politics may be more a misclassification of certain positions. A little history lesson is in order. Read More… Back in the 1970s, Sixty Minutes had a regular feature called Point/Counterpoint, which came at the end of every show. Each week there would be a different topic. Journalist Shana Alexander would present a standard-issue “liberal” version of the argument while James J. Kilpatrick assumed the “conservative” side. Although the sparring partners sniped at one another,...
How Did George Orwell Know?
For those trapped behind the Iron Curtain, Orwell’s Nineteen Eighty-Four seemed more a documentary than a work of dystopian fiction. How did a man who had never traveled munist Russia get so much so right? Read More… The collocation in the title captures the thoroughgoing exploration of the topic in a phrase: George Orwell and Russia. Masha Karp is not the first to ponder George Orwell’s relationship to Stalinist Russia—and the relationship of both Stalinist and munist Russia to Orwell—but...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved