Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The minimum wage is speeding the robot apocalypse?
The minimum wage is speeding the robot apocalypse?
Oct 11, 2024 10:17 AM

Intellectuals like Stephen Hawking and Elon Musk increasingly worry about an apocalyptic world awaiting in the not-too-distant future, when automation replaces all human work(and, in time, artificial intelligence displaces humanity). A new UK study finds the robots may have found an ally: a higher minimum wage.

A looming increase in the minimum wage will likely result in a robots replacing a growing number of workers, according to the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS).

The UK’s minimum wage – the National Living Wage (NLW) – will rise from £7.50 today to £8.50 ($11.50 U.S.) by 2020.

The IFS has surveyed the jobs likely to be paid minimum wage and measured the “routine task intensity” (RTI) of each one. As you may expect, RTI is higher for menial labor and lower for occupations that require judgment and decision-making.

The increase is unlikely to harm waiters, bartenders, or those involved in care professions, the report states.

“But those set to be brought within the minimum wage net in 2020 are more than twice as likely to be in the ten per cent most ‘routine’ occupations – such as retail cashiers and receptionists – as those who were directly affected by the minimum in 2015,” the IFS warns. “This kind of work tends to be easier to ‘automate.’”

It is not difficult to understand. Owners hire employees to perform tasks necessary to earn a profit. The higher their wage floor, the more tempting it is to invest in automatons who do not take breaks, go on strike, or get surly with the customers.

Thus, the unemployment rate rises as the minimum wage ticks up. The Labour Party’s proposal to raise the minimum wage to £10 (about $13.50 U.S.) “would bring even more employees in more automatable jobs into the minimum wage net,” the report states.

This is true across the transatlantic space. Theory will soon give way to reality in the United States, where California has just raised the state minimum wage to $11 an hour for businesses with more than 25 employees. When that rate reaches $15 an hour in 2023, it will cost 400,000 jobs, according to a study from the Employment Policy Institute (EPI).

EPI found that every 10 percent rise in the minimum wage reduces employment by two percent – or five percent for low-wage workers.

If the harm disproportionately hits those at the lower end of the wage scale, it also hurts those already living in pockets of economic stagnation. Canada’s Fraser Institutefound thatOntario’s $15 minimum wage would have “severe effects” on those who live in “economically weaker regions” – that is, those munities are already suffering the most, presumably the ones the increase was intended to help.

Further, workers often face a panoply of impoverishing progressive policies. The “fight for 15” is usually conjoined with demands for steeper taxes on “the rich” to fund more generous public benefits. But the welfare state’s cost is seldom confined to the affluent, Dr. Madsen Pirie of the UK’s Adam Smith Institute explained in November:

The problem for the low-paid is not so much that employers pay too little, but that the government takes too much. At a mere £8,164 [or $11,050 U.S.] per annum, the government starts charging National Insurance at 12 percent. At only £11,500 [$15,563 U.S.] per year it starts charging e tax at 20 percent. Add the amount the government takes in VAT, insurance taxes, stamp duty, airport departure tax, fuel duty, alcohol duty and tobacco tax, and it adds up to a huge slice of a low-paid persons’ earnings.

Nonetheless, well-meaning Christian and Jewish clergy continue to protest for a $15 minimum wage in the United States as a matter of “justice.”Surely, the “robot apocalypse” is not the Parousia they hoped to bring to pass.

Automation is far from an unbridled negative. In time, it will create new breakthroughs, professions, and vocations in which human beings may exercise their gifts. But in the meantime, poorer workers in less attractive areas lose out.

This is another example of interventionist economic policies inspired by the best of intentions hurting the most vulnerable people.

domain.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
The Deep, Dark Web: Like Cockroaches, Human Traffickers Prefer The Dark
Maybe you’ve heard of the “Dark Web,” but aren’t sure exactly what it is. Maybe you don’t know anything about the Dark Web. Let’s begin by saying it’s aptly named. And as dark as it is, we need to know about it. The term “Dark Web” (or Dark Internet) refers to areas of the Internet that are no longer accessible, or that have “gone dark” – i.e. dead ends. This happens when Internet routers stop referencing parts of the Internet,...
When the Church Was the Center
This summer I made a visit to Colonial Williamsburg in Virginia, and on a tour of churches, I heard a fascinating explanation of how society functioned when the church was the place where the poor had their material needs met, not the government. The Bruton Parish Church in Williamsburg is one example. According to church records, Burton Parish formed in 1674 following the merger of several colonial parishes originating as far back as 1633. As a Church of England congregation,...
The City Mouse and the Country Mouse
Over at the Federalist, Gracy Olmstead wonders “what happens when people bring the country to the city?” She goes on to argue that “urban farming could have conservative implications and outworkings—and we should encourage these endeavors as much as possible, in our efforts to bring traditional principles back to urban environments.” Is there a way to bring the city mouse and the country mousetogether? I’ve argued for the need for urban farming initiatives in the context of renewal movements in...
When is a Self-Described Libertarian Not a Libertarian?
A new report by the Pew Research Center finds that about one-in-ten Americans describe themselves as libertarian — and yet hold views that do not differ much from those of the overall public. As Pew’s Jocelyn Kiley says, “Self-described libertarians tend to be modestly more supportive of some libertarian positions, but few of them hold consistent libertarian opinions on the role of government, foreign policy and social issues.” Overall, 11 percent of Americans describe themselves as libertarian and have a...
Watch ‘The Economy of Creative Service’ for Free
For the Life of the World: Letters to the Exilesisa 7-part series from the Acton Institute that seeks to examine the bigger picture of Christianity’s role in culture, society, and the world. Today you can watchepisode 3,The Economy of Creative Servicefor free all day today at premiere.flannel.org. Below is the trailer for episode 3. ...
Some Thoughts on Economic Patriotism
Sic semper tyrannis, eh? The Burger King acquisition of Tim Hortons and the resulting plans to move the corporate headquarters under the taxing authority of the Canadian government is being derided by some as unpatriotic. This is the latest in a long string of similar phenomena over the last decade or so, as we see patriotic loyalty (or the lack thereof) ing a political issue in the context of offshoring, globalization, outsourcing, and so on. A response to the charge...
Oikonomia: New Blog at Patheos’ Faith and Work Channel
The Acton Institute has just launched Oikonomia, a new blog at Patheos’ Faith and Work Channel, which will provide resources specific to the intersection of faith, work, and economics. Other partners at the channel include The High Calling, Steve Garber’s Visions of Vocation, and Theology of Work Project, among others. The blog will include a variety of content from across the Acton ecosystem, including mentaries, video clips, and book excerpts, providing a centralized source of information on whole-life discipleship, stewardship,...
Pray and Labor?
“The Church fathers, East and West, have a long tradition that affirms the value of human labor,” writes Acton’s Dylan Pahman at Humane Pursuits. “And their reflections on the subject contain depths of insight still relevant for those of us who live in “the world” today, such as how to find meaning in whatever work one may do.” On the one hand, plenty of people may not see even a little lasting good in their job. The average factory worker,...
Great Britain is Poorer Than Every US State
At the height of power, circa 1922, the British Empire was the largest empire in history, covering one-fifth of the world’s population and almost a quarter of the earth’s total land area. Yet almost one hundred years later, Great Britain is not so great, having lost much of its previous economic and political dominance. In fact, if Great Britain were to join the United States, it’d be poorer than any of the other 50 states — including our poorest state,...
Which Inequality? Trends Toward Equality in Lifespans and Education
Earlier this month, I wrote a two part article for the Library of Law & Liberty, critiquing the uncritical condemnation of e inequality by world religious leaders. In part 1, I pointed out that “while the Pope, the Patriarch, the Dalai Lama, and others are right about the increase in [global e] inequality, they are wrong to conclude that this causes global poverty—the latter is demonstrably on the decline. And that, I would add, is a good thing.” F. A....
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved