Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The Minimum Wage: A Denial of Freedom and Duty
The Minimum Wage: A Denial of Freedom and Duty
Jan 21, 2026 12:43 PM

In this week’s Acton Commentary, “The Minimum Wage: A Denial of Freedom and Duty,” I look at the concept of minimum wage legislation from the perspective of the employer/employee relationship.

In his second epistle to the Thessalonians, the apostle Paul sets down a moral principle: “If a man will not work, he shall not eat.” But Paul’s words seem also to imply the opposite positive principle, something like, “If you will work, you should eat.”

Even so, I argue, it does not follow that the government should be the guarantor of this reality. Drawing in part on the thought of Abraham Kuyper, I find that “the civil government has a role in justly and fairly enforcing the contractual relationship between employer and employee. It does not, however, have the absolute right to determine the specific nature of this relationship in any and all circumstances.”

Throughout mentary, I address some of the concerns raised in an interview conducted by Faithful America, a weblog associated with the National Council of Churches. Faithful America talked with man named Dan, who gave his experiences of working for and living on the minimum wage. A transcript copy of the interview is pasted in below the jump (the audio is available here).

Dan: The only thing I can say is that if we wasn’t in a rural area around here, we would not be able to make it. We would all be on welfare, and we would all be…it’s hard to tell. I mean, I work for myself and I know that it’s hard just to make it just working for myself. But yeah, minimum wage, I know I’ve worked a lot of minimum wage jobs and once you pay your bills you pretty much, a lot of times you don’t get to pay your bills.

It’s sad, but if we didn’t live in this area where we could have a garden, where you could go hunting or fishing, and a lot of people do that, and have something like that to put meat on their table and food on their table, I tell you what there’d be a lot of starving people. And there are a lot in West Virginia that lives from hand to mouth. And a lot of people that lives in town, they don’t have that money even if they do work they’re still getting assistance from the government or the state just to live.

Q: What do you when the e in?

Dan: A lot times you just stick them back, you’re usually in debt. You usually don’t ever get them paid. It depends on what it is. It used to they couldn’t cut your electricity off or your gas or whatever you had. But now they e and shut it off. They’ll just shut your water or shut your electricity. But yeah when the e in you just got to knuckle down and make the best of it.

Q: Do you have children, Dan?

Dan: Yeah, I got a little boy.

Q: What do you tell him?

Dan: Well, you make it a game or whatever and say, “Well, the electricity’s off,” or he shouldn’t even be concerned with it, so you just sort of make it a game, like we’re camping or something and you just make up something fun out of it. The way I feel about my e first, I’m going to make sure I take care of them, take care of my boy. We’re a proud bunch of people. I mean I go out and I give it my all. I’ll tell you there ain’t no slacking down. If there’s a job to do I do it. My dad always told me, you go up to demand a job you do the job. Even if you’ve worked there ten or twenty years a lot of times and you’re just a labor man you’re not going to go very far anyway. You’d be lucky if you worked twenty years to go from minimum wage up to seven dollars around here.

Q: What do you hope for your son?

Dan: A better life than I got. I’d like to be able to leave him a piece of land and a house where he can have a good job and go to college and be something. But the way it is here, like I told him yesterday, there was no way I could go to college because we didn’t have any money to go to college. And I told him I said if there was any way possible I’m going to get you into college and get you to make something of yourself anyway and go up and be better off than I am.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Should We Tax Volunteer Work for Charities?
During the debate about how to resolve the fiscal cliff crisis, lawmakers on both sides have considered reducing the charitable tax deduction. That strikes many people as the wrong approach (especially those of us who work for non-profits!) even though we may not be able to explain why it’s such a bad idea. Fortunately, John Carney has provided a superb explanation for why reducing or removing this deduction is counterproductive. For instance, changing the charitable deduction as Carney notes, has...
Economics is Too Important to be Left to Economists
I rather like Serene Jones’ piece in Huffington Post, “Economists and Innkeepers.” Jones got some things right. She knows that Christian Scripture teaches many economic lessons, like subsidiarity and stewardship (although she doesn’t use those terms.) She says, “Economic theory is replete with theological and moral assumptions about human nature and society” and that is correct. As Istituto Acton’s Kishore Jayabalan reminds us, Things like the rule of law, a tradition of equality for the law, which should cut down...
Social Engineering Makes For Poor Economic Policy
Writing over at The Atlantic, American Enterprise Institute scholar Christina Hoff Sommers shares the unsettling story of what a growing number of Swedish activist groups and political factions are attempting to do to “traditional” gender roles. Is it discriminatory and degrading for toy catalogs to show girls playing with tea sets and boys with Nerf guns? A Swedish regulatory group says yes. The Reklamombudsmannen (RO) has reprimanded Top-Toy, a licensee of Toys”R”Us and one of the largest panies in Northern...
Something Vastly More Powerful Than Evil
In his latest Forbes column, Rev. Robert A. Sirico explains why despite the tragedy in Newton we can speak of joy during this Christmas season: When we ask our bewilderedwhy? –we are not looking for data points.Even less should we offer glib responses in the face of this shattering loss – this modern-day slaughter of the innocents. We are, instead, seeking themeaningin the face of thismysterium iniquitatis.The meaning we seek is not so much the significance of evil as the...
Conservation and Entrepreneurial Environmentalism
I found this profile of Mark Tercek, the former Goldman Sachs managing director who was tapped to head the Nature Conservancy, raises some profound issues concerning the relationship between economics and the environment: Tercek, 55, e to the Conservancy to fight financial brush fires. With the help of his board and the input of the Conservancy’s 600 scientists, he wants to remake the face of the American and global environmental movements. He has no quarrel with the current model—largely built...
When I Grow Up
“What do you want to be when you grow up?” That’s mon question asked of children the world over. ChildFund International has put out their global survey of children for 2012, and that’s one of the questions they asked, with some intriguing results. When asked, “If you could grow up to be anything you wanted, what would you be?” there were some rather remarkable disparities between the answers of children in the developed and the developing world. Kids in the...
Court: Justice Dept. Can’t Just Say ‘Trust Us, Changes Are Coming’
“There is no, ‘Trust us, changes ing’ clause in the Constitution,” wrote Judge Brian Cogan in his ruling issued two weeks ago against a Justice Department motion to dismiss the Archdiocese of New York’s lawsuit against the HHS mandate. “To the contrary, the Bill of Rights itself, and the First Amendment in particular, reflect a degree of skepticism towards governmental self-restraint and self-correction.” More federal judges ing to the same conclusion. Earlier this week a federal appeals court in Washington,...
Why Christians in Business Should Read Poetry
Writing for the Harvard Business Review, my friend (and coauthor) John Coleman argues that business professionals can benefit from reading poetry. While his article is not directed at people of faith, I think his claims are particularly relevant to Christians in the business world: Poetry can also help users develop a more acute sense of empathy. In the poem “Celestial Music,” for example, Louise Glück explores her feelings on heaven and mortality by seeing the issue through the eyes of...
Work as Service and Servant
I recently pondered what e of the global economy if we were to to put God at the forefront of our motives and decision-making. The question came as a reaction to Tim Keller, whose recent book calls on Christians to challenge their views about work. By re-orienting our work to be a “servant” instead of a “lord,” Keller argues, we will actually find more fulfillment in the work that we do. Keller’s main point in the video I discussed was...
Free Kindle Ebook: ‘A Field Guide to the Hero’s Journey’
Acton is offering a free Christmas gift: a free Kindle download of the new book, A Field Guide to the Hero’s Journey. The book, co-authored by Jeff Sandefer and Rev. Robert Sirico, has been called a “the modern ‘how-to’ for entrepreneurs working on plishing big things” by Andreas Widmer, and is a terrific book not only for adults but for young people. You can also listen to the authors discussing their collaboration on this book on this Radio Free Acton...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved