Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The immortality of bureaucracies
The immortality of bureaucracies
Dec 22, 2025 11:38 AM

Both The Hill and The Washington Post reported this week that the Trump Administration has decided to dismantle the Office of Personnel Management. Unless you work for the Federal Government, you are unlikely to have heard of this particular bureaucracy. But until now, its prime responsibility has been to manage the Federal Government’s civilian workforce.

But what is interesting about this move is the way it is being reported. The Hill, for instance, stated that “the OPM would be the first federal department eliminated since World War II.”

These words highlight the fact that some people are shocked at the very idea of terminating a federal government bureaucracy—one which was created forty years ago out of the United States Civil Service Commission which was itself created in 1883.

Missing from this reporting is the notion that it is entirely possible for a government organization (be it a department, agency, or bureau) to lose its reason for being, or to e redundant, or to have fulfilled its original purpose, or even e part of the problem that it was supposed to resolve.

The contrast with private sector organizations is worth stressing. Private businesses, charities, and schools open and close with a regularity that I suspect many people who work for governments around the world would find astonishing. Typically, private entities disappear because they can no pete, or they lose customers and clients, or because they lack sufficient revenue, or because their particular purpose has e redundant or surpassed by technology.

Government bureaucracies seem, however, to be immune from these challenges. They simply go on and on and on. The amount of funding which they receive from taxpayers may vary. But the notion of actually eliminating a government agency carries the air of heresy on places like Washington D.C. and other cities whose very lifeblood is the government. From the standpoint of organizational theory, the truly successful bureaucracy is one that successfully perpetrates its existence across time.

Even OPM isn’t really disappearing. Its functions are, the Post reports, being shifted to three other departments. This underscores that once a government agency is created, it mysteriously acquires the quality of immortality. That itself is a good reason for legislators to think very carefully before setting up any new state bureaucracy. For you can be sure that once it is created, it will never die.

Image source: Marines.mil

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Saving our(s)elves
Coming to a stadium near you (HT) A series of concerts “bigger than Live Aid” is being planned for July, in a bid to put the subject of climate change before an audience of a global audience of 2bn. The event, scheduled for July 7, will feature co-ordinated film, music and television events in seven cities including London, Washington DC, Shanghai, Rio de Janeiro, Cape Town and Kyoto, with major broadcasters and media owners aiming to extend the reach of...
Black virtue: Success beyond the Super Bowl
This year’s Super Bowl was widely hailed as an advance for black Americans because, for the first time, two black coaches faced off in the game. But, as Anthony Bradley observes, coaches Tony Dungy and Lovie Smith pointed to an even greater achievement: They did it “the Lord’s way.” Read mentary here. ...
The role of limited government
Our religious and political rights are uniquely bound up together. Most young Americans, and far too many older native born American citizens, have little or no idea how important this truth really is. The central idea behind this unique relationship in American political understanding is limited government. This is really what classical liberalism understood and fervently practiced. Modern liberalism has little or nothing to do with this understanding, preferring to stress ideologies that are neither truly liberal nor limited. The...
The legitimacy of ‘secular’ work
In this month’s issue of Christianity Today, John D. Beckett, chairman of the privately held R. W. Beckett Corporation, speaks about his new book, Mastering Monday: A Guide to Integrating Faith and Work. When asked, “Do you think churches still don’t understand business as a calling?” Beckett responds, I do. Relatively few churches and pastors are reinforcing the legitimacy of a call into so-called “secular work.” I have colleagues with tremendous business influence who are starving spiritually in their local...
Questioning “Brain Drain”
I mentioned a long time ago that this book, with its provocative and interesting thesis, was in the works. Stepping Out of the Brain Drain: Applying Catholic Social Teaching in a New Era of Migration, by Michele Pistone and John Hoeffner, is now available from Lexington Books. The blurb: Catholic social teaching’s traditional opposition to “brain drain” migration from developing to developed countries is due for a reassessment. Stepping Out of the Brain Drain provides exactly this, as it demonstrates...
Commerce and war: Poles apart
Make trade, not war? In an excerpt from his new book “The Commercial Society,” Sam Gregg examines the long held view that nations engaged in trade are less likely to wage war. He notes that nations which are busy mercial pursuits, instead of war making, may also be more vigilant about “protecting the fabric of freedoms upon mercial societies depend.” Read mentary here. ...
Show me the money
I’m a bit behind on this story, but as was reported by numerous media outlets over the past few months, a new trend has begun at some American churches. ATM machines, dubbed “Automatic Tithing Machines,” are appearing at some Protestant churches in the South. The machines are administered by the for-profit business SecureGive, run by Pastor Marty Baker and his wife, who integrated the machines at their Stevens Creek Community Church in 2005. Proponents point to the transition to a...
Faith in higher ed
Most of our talk at Acton about educational choice addresses K-12 programs, i.e., the public schools. There already exists a great deal of choice at the levels of higher ed, and so they are not of the most immediate concern. But the issues I raised earlier this month about the integration of faith and learning are just as relevant in the realm of higher ed as they are in secondary education. Here’s what David Claerbaut, author of Faith and Learning...
‘I was a stranger and you invited me in.’
The story of a Confessing Church pastor and his family who ed in two prisoners who escaped from the Buchenwald concentration camp is told in, “Seeing the Other Side-60 Years after Buchenwald” (RealMedia). The short film, about 14 minutes, is based on Mona Sue Weissmark’s Justice Matters: Legacies of the Holocaust and World War II. Why did Pastor Seebaß and his family help the prisoners and in the process endanger themselves? “It was all about loving your fellow man.” ...
Government pay and performance
Travis Sinquefield at Disorganizational Behavior examines this Washington Post article on new parts of an annual survey given to government workers. Among the new statements the employees were asked to evaluate was this: “Pay raises depend on how well employees perform their jobs.” Only 22 percent of the respondents agreed with this statement, while 45 percent disagreed (25 percent were neutral). John Gage, president of the American Federation of Government Employees, said that a performance-based system of rewards would not...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved