Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The immortality of bureaucracies
The immortality of bureaucracies
Jan 17, 2026 6:24 PM

Both The Hill and The Washington Post reported this week that the Trump Administration has decided to dismantle the Office of Personnel Management. Unless you work for the Federal Government, you are unlikely to have heard of this particular bureaucracy. But until now, its prime responsibility has been to manage the Federal Government’s civilian workforce.

But what is interesting about this move is the way it is being reported. The Hill, for instance, stated that “the OPM would be the first federal department eliminated since World War II.”

These words highlight the fact that some people are shocked at the very idea of terminating a federal government bureaucracy—one which was created forty years ago out of the United States Civil Service Commission which was itself created in 1883.

Missing from this reporting is the notion that it is entirely possible for a government organization (be it a department, agency, or bureau) to lose its reason for being, or to e redundant, or to have fulfilled its original purpose, or even e part of the problem that it was supposed to resolve.

The contrast with private sector organizations is worth stressing. Private businesses, charities, and schools open and close with a regularity that I suspect many people who work for governments around the world would find astonishing. Typically, private entities disappear because they can no pete, or they lose customers and clients, or because they lack sufficient revenue, or because their particular purpose has e redundant or surpassed by technology.

Government bureaucracies seem, however, to be immune from these challenges. They simply go on and on and on. The amount of funding which they receive from taxpayers may vary. But the notion of actually eliminating a government agency carries the air of heresy on places like Washington D.C. and other cities whose very lifeblood is the government. From the standpoint of organizational theory, the truly successful bureaucracy is one that successfully perpetrates its existence across time.

Even OPM isn’t really disappearing. Its functions are, the Post reports, being shifted to three other departments. This underscores that once a government agency is created, it mysteriously acquires the quality of immortality. That itself is a good reason for legislators to think very carefully before setting up any new state bureaucracy. For you can be sure that once it is created, it will never die.

Image source: Marines.mil

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
It’s wealth not poverty that’s on the rise
The Census Bureau today released a report citing that 37 million Americans lived under the poverty line, a jump of 1.1 million from 2003. “I was surprised,” said Sheldon Danziger, co-director of the National Poverty Center at the University of Michigan. “I thought things would have turned around by now.” What’s missing are the poverty threshold numbers that reveal that a family of four is considered “poor” if family e is below $19,000. What’s actually on the rise is not...
Principled giving
The devastation that we have seen this week in the Gulf Coast region and especially New Orleans is almost beyond our capacity to understand. Our instinct is to do something – anything – to help those in need, but when the crisis is this huge, what does one do? Writing for National Review Online, Karen Woods, the Director of Acton’s Center for Effective Compassion, lays out some ways that we can most effectively use our resources to help the many...
For our freedom and yours: Remembering solidarity
Today marks the 25th anniversary of the formation of Poland’s Solidarity movement. Samuel Gregg says that Solidary gives us a view of a labor union whose “stand for the truth about the human person and against the lie of Marxism contributed immeasurably to the collapse of one of the two great totalitarian evils that disfigured the twentieth-century.” Read the full text here. ...
Has Europe gone completely insane?
Outsiders looking from the outside into Europe will probably answer that question in the affirmative, and with good reason. The churches are emptying, the economies are tanking, and the politicians continue to fiddle along. Very few have a clue of how to fix things. Very few, but not all. The President of the Czech Republic, Vผlav Klaus, spoke at a Mont Pelerin Society meeting in Iceland last week. Citing Friedrich von Hayek and Raymond Aron, Klaus has a clear eye...
Robertson’s fatwa
Rev. Robert Sirico responds to Pat Robertson’s highly-publicized call for the assassination of Venezuelan president Hugo Chavez. “What is needed here, I believe, is a time of reflection. Christianity is not a national religion. It is does not regard every enemy of the nation-state as worthy of execution. It prefers peace to war. It chooses diplomacy over threat. It respects the right to life of everyone, even those who have objectionable political views,” he writes. Read the full text here....
Lootin’ in Louisiana
Following the devastation in New Orleans from Hurricane Katrina, bands of looters are running rampant throughout the city. Things have gotten so bad that New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin “ordered virtually the entire police force to abandon search-and-rescue efforts and stop thieves who were ing increasingly hostile.” According to reports, “Looters used garbage cans and inflatable mattresses to float away with food, clothes, TV sets — even guns. Outside one pharmacy, mandeered a forklift and used it to push up...
Dunn deal: A challenge for the NFL
Pro running back Warrick Dunn, a native of Louisiana, is challenging every NFL player (other than New Orleans Saints) to donate at least $5,000 to hurricane relief efforts. “If we get players to do that, that would amount to $260,000 per team. I have heard from so many players both on my team and around the league who just want to do something. Well, this is the best thing that we can do and it’s something we should do,” he...
Fair trade goes bananas
You may have heard of “fair trade,” one of the more recent economically-myopic efforts to act as “guarantees that farmers and farmworkers receive a fair price for their labor.” I’ve written before about the fair trade coffee movement (especially in the Church), which has perhaps gained the most public attention. But fair traders haven’t overlooked any consumables, and the broader movement is likely to receive more attention in the future, as fair trade is a plank in platform of the...
The voice of a secular prophet
The Americans brought this on themselves. That’s one ing from around the world as it surveys the devastation following Hurricane Katrina. In what can only be described as callously political maneuvering, Germany’s environmental minister Jürgen Trittin said today, “The increasing frequency of these natural events can only be explained through global warming which is caused by people.” Instead of offering condolences, well-wishes, or prayers, minister Tritten delivered the judgment of secular environmentalists. The Americans’ crime? “A U.S. citizen causes about...
‘No Higher Calling’
Courtesy of Rev. Eric Andrae, Lutheran pastor Bo Giertz offers us a great exposition of the “great cloud of witnesses” (Hebrews 12:1) and sums up the importance of the pastoral ministry. “‘It is a great thing to receive a heritage…. It is wonderful to stand in the same pulpit, to learn of [those who have gone before us,] and to carry forward the work they began. Sir…, can anything be greater than to be a pastor in God’s church?'” (Bo...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved