Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The Green New Deal sits on a throne of lies
The Green New Deal sits on a throne of lies
Dec 29, 2024 12:10 AM

Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez intended the Green New Deal to cement her position as the intellectual leader of the democratic socialist movement, but even passing scrutiny caused the $93 trillion proposal to fade into obscurity. In an attempt to revive her signature plan, the New York congresswoman read the entire text of the bill during a ponderous speech before the House of Representatives.

More than a year may have passed since the plan’s critics snickered at its proposals to end air travel and abolish bovine flatulence, but some things have not changed. The budget-busting act would still cost an average of $75,168 per household. And it still rests on a series of shoddy premises and misinformed economics.

AOC’s speech, “along with the actual text of her bill, are at odds with numerous facts about pollution, regulations, and the economics of energy,” writes James D. Agresti of in a probing new analysis posted on the Acton Institute’s Religion & Liberty Transatlantic website.

Agresti, who has a well-earned reputation for rigorous and trustworthy analysis of current events, explores each aspect one-by-one. He notes that regulations harm consumers while benefiting well-connected corporations:

[R]egulations and subsidies like those required to implement the Green New Deal raise energy costs. This harms consumers while increasing the revenues of corporations. Such policies have already guaranteed corporations double-digit profits on certain energy projects and supplied them with funds for executive bonuses.

He brings a transatlantic aspect to his analysis by citing the energy policy of Germany, where a rush to replace fossil fuels with renewable energy has led to widespread blackouts:

In Germany, where government is more aggressive than the U.S. in forcing the use of renewable energy, the average price of household electricity is about three times that of the United States. Yet Germany is still nowhere close to the Green New Deal’s mandate of “meeting 100 percent of the power demand in the United States through clean, renewable, and zero-emission energy sources.” … The costs of getting to AOC’s 100 percent figure would be multiplicatively greater than the three-fold premium paid by German households. This is because when wind and solar generation increase, so do the costs of backing them up for the inevitable times when the sun isn’t shining or the wind isn’t blowing.

Christians determined to prudently care for creation must be informed about the science, and the economics, that lead to human flourishing. Agresti’s article is an indispensable aid to that end.

Read his mentary here.

A.J. This photo has been cropped. CC BY 2.0.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Samuel Gregg: Benedict XVI and the Irrelevance of ‘Relevance’
In a new analysis in Crisis Magazine, Acton Research Director Samuel Gregg examines “the shifting critiques” of the pontificate of Benedict XVI including the latest appraisal that the world is losing interest in the Catholic Church particularly because of its declining geopolitical “relevance.” But how do some of these critiques understand relevance? On one reading, it parisons with Benedict’s heroic predecessor, who played an indispensible role in demolishing the Communist thug-ocracies that once brutalized much of Europe. But it’s also...
The Temptations of Poverty
Galatians 2:10 reads, “All they asked was that we should continue to remember the poor, the very thing I had been eager to do all along.” This is the conclusion to the Jerusalem Council, in which Paul and the leaders in Jerusalem are reconciled and unified, and where is decided that Paul and Barnabas “should go to the Gentiles, and they [James, Peter, and John] to the circumcised” (v. 9). The concluding point that both groups are to keep in...
Where Corporatism and Crony Contraceptives Collide
In an Acton Commentary last month, Jordan Ballor presented a helpful explanation of the differences between “capitalism” and “corporatism”, a capitalist system that has been corrupted: The main dynamic of the market system is the relationship between the producer and the consumer. Corporatism, by contrast, brings to the fore the role of the “managerial state,” in which the government takes on an increasingly larger task in telling producers what they should produce and consumers what they should consume. This can...
Do the Poor Need Capitalism?
A 2009 paper from the National Bureau of Economic Research says that the number of people in the world living on less than $1 per day fell from 403 million in 1970 to 152 million in 2006. An analysis from the American Enterprise Institute says the biggest factor was the rise of the middle class in China and India, at a time when the world’s population grew by 3 billion. Is capitalism a greater asset than liability in the fight...
Religious Liberty, Rhetoric, and Partisan Squawking
A look at religious liberty, the HHS Mandate, and political discourse. Read More… Concerning the HHS mandate, somehow getting lost in the shuffle is the primacy of religious liberty. Mollie Hemingway offers a good post at Ricochet on the media blackout. Certainly, political partisanship and lust for power is clouding the centrality of the First Amendment. I recently heard two women chatting in a public place about this issue. They had convinced themselves that Rick Santorum wanted to snatch their...
The School Zone to Serfdom
The Washington Post recentlyreported on what looked like an interesting development in education reform going on in California: The national battle over the best way to fix failing schools is ripping through this desert town like a sandstorm, tearing apart munity that is testing a radical new approach: the parent takeover. Parents here are trying to e the first in the country to use a trigger law, which allows a majority of families at a struggling school to force major...
Faith and Family Can Close the Achievement Gap
One of the most problematic aspects of the U.S. educational system is the persistence of the achievement gap. White students generally perform better on tests than black students. Rich students generally perform better than poor students. And students of similar socioeconomic background perform differently across classrooms and school systems. The effect is not only felt on the individual level—low school performance has been linked to crime, low earnings and poor health—but on our country’s economy. The consulting firm McKinsey &...
Indivisible a New York Times Bestseller
Former Acton Research fellow Jay Richards’ new co-authored book, Indivisible, has climbed onto The New York Times Bestseller list, holding onto a top ten spot for a second week. The book was published by FaithWords and, in an interesting cross-publishing arrangement, is also available in an Ignatius press edition with a foreword by Ignatius founder Fr. Joseph Fessio. Jay’s co-author, James Robison, is the co-host of the evangelical daily show LIFE Today. If you’ve had the chance to hear Jay...
Malthus and the Contraceptive Mandate
“The power of population,” wrote the Rev. Thomas Robert Malthus in 1798, “is indefinitely greater than the power in the earth to produce subsistence for man.” In other words, unless population growth is checked by moral restraint (refraining from having babies) or disaster (disease, famine, war) widespread poverty and degradation inevitably result. Or so thought Malthus and many other intellectuals of his era. Unfortunately, methods of population control range from the unpleasant (disease, famine, war) to the downright horrifying (abstinence)....
Christian Libertarianism Revisited
Last week, in reply to a post by Jacqueline Otto, I wrote an article asking What is a Christian Libertarian? Ms. Otto has written an additional reply entitled, “Four Things Christian Libertarians Believe.” To address Mr. Carter’s doubts, and to counter Mr. Teetsel’s unbelief, here is my layman’s attempt to articulate four of the fundamental beliefs held by Christian libertarians that synthesize their faith with their political ideology. For a more developed understanding, please visit Norman Horn’s website: While I...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved