Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The Giver: Adding Color to a Monochromatic World
The Giver: Adding Color to a Monochromatic World
Apr 12, 2026 5:06 PM

The Giver, a cinematic adaptation of Lois Lowry’s contemporary young adult classic, is great summer action-adventure entertainment. The film also serves as a terrific example for future moviemakers seeking to transfer themes of spiritual faith to celluloid without succumbing to preachiness and overwrought didacticism.

Yes, The Giver is yet another dystopian sci-fi adventure story featuring handsome young protagonists rebelling against established A-list Hollywood stars portraying adult autocrats. But, unlike the silly, over-the-top political media and often disturbing ultraviolence of The Hunger Games, The Giver delivers the action without unnecessary onscreen carnage. True – for the most part – the adults are still autocratic poops, but the purpose behind their actions derives not from ic-book arch-villain text book. Instead, the world depicted in the movie is closer to attempts at social engineering witnessed on a daily basis; from all-pervasive surveillance cameras to language policing and nanny-state enforcement.

Taking a cue from the original Star Trek television series, the setting of The Giver has, like Spock’s home planet, Vulcan, eliminated human emotion and biological passions in response to some catastrophe (presumably war). One individual is entrusted to all pre-catastrophe memories, the title character (Jeff Bridges). The Giver resides in an outpost on the edge of civilization, a bunker filled with books and a grand piano. He is charged with transferring his memories to Jonas (Brenton Thwaites), the state-designated Receiver of Memories. Like Spock, the Giver performs his own version of the Vulcan mind-meld for the transference of memories.

Why does the state go to all the trouble of eliminating historical memories while preserving them in only select few? As Bridge explains, the elders believe they must “know the past in order to guard the future.” An echo of George Santayana’s famous saying, of course. The remainder of the population is injected daily with a concoction that deadens biological urges, reminiscent of the soma in Aldous Huxley’s Brave New World. All memories of warfare and poverty suppressed, but also of the simple joys of life. “Use precise language” is a mantra whenever abstract words as “love” are uttered. Biologically, babies are genetically engineered in laboratories before given to “families” for nurturing to adulthood. Those not making the state-designated weight and length requirements are discarded, as are the elderly. Those making the cut are sent to state schools whereupon their strengths and weaknesses are monitored constantly for eventual placement in a career determined the best fit by the Elders.

Missing in the narrow confines of this “ideal” society – made obvious by Phillip Noyce’s direction – is the color that fleshes out humanity, warts and all. Noyce relies on a monochromatic palette for the first portion of the film before Jonas’ awakened memories. While this can brings to mind Gary Ross’ execrable 1998 film Pleasantville wherein libertinism alone brings color to the black-and-white1950s town, The Giver emphasizes the necessity of the entire panoply of an imperfect humanity.

Those conversant in natural law will recognize the film (and novel as well) champions free will as opposed to totalitarian micromanagement. More subtly, the film and novel also champion faith. In The Giver’s climax, Jonas is required to take a literal leap of faith, resulting in a most satisfying denouement wherein the Christmas song “Silent Night” figures prominently.

The Giver is a primer on how to make a film for both faith-based and secular audiences. Many films designed to capture spiritual audiences are monochromatic throughout – if you’re a Christian and the film is marketed to your demographic, you can bet your last kernel of popcorn all the film’s antagonists are evil through-and-through. Meanwhile all the protagonists stumble through a minefield of obvious foreshadowing before reaching the finish line whereupon grace is guaranteed. The Giver, on the other hand, slyly holds the faith card up its sleeve before sliding it across the viewers’ consciousness.

Freedom-loving film aficionados would do well to mend The Giver. It’s a terrific adventure film that portrays the dangers of a too-near futuristic society resorting to social and biological engineering at the expense of individuality, privacy, religious faith and God’s greatest gift: free will.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Toxic Mortgages and Personal Responsibility
Mortgage foreclosure rates soared 53 percent in pared with a year earlier, and many people who were eager to buy a house with low “teaser” interest rates and creative financing are in trouble. Acton Senior Fellow in Economics Jennifer Roback Morse expects new calls for goverment oversight of the mortgage industry, which is already highly regulated. A better idea, she suggests, would be for buyers to examine their motives for acquiring real estate with gimmicky loans and take some responsibility...
God’s Politics Blog at Beliefnet
In case you haven’t seen it yet, Beliefnet, in conjunction with Sojourners, is hosting a blog based on Jim Wallis’ book, God’s Politics: Why the Right Gets It Wrong and the Left Doesn’t Get It. One of the key features in the blog’s short tenure to date is a discussion between Jim Wallis and Ralph Reed, former leader of the Christian Coalition. Jim says that Ralph is his “first dialogue partner on God’s Politics,” so perhaps we can expect more...
China, Christianity, and the Rule of Law
Earlier this month Forum 18 published an article that examined whether the establishment of a law regarding religion at a national level would be a positive step toward ending the sometimes arbitrary and uneven treatment of religious freedom issues throughout the country. In “Would a religion law help promote religious freedom?” Magda Hornemann writes, “For many years, some religious believers and experts both inside and outside China have advocated the creation of prehensive religion law through the National People’s Congress,...
Proportionalism Critique
The debate has not been confined to Catholic circles, but it has been concentrated there. Many (most?) American Catholic moral theologians of the post-Vatican II era have been enamored with one form or another of “proportionalism,” a theory of morality that eschews the traditional Catholic focus on the “intrinsic” goodness or badness of human acts. (Bad acts must be avoided always.) Proportionalism’s critics have accused its adherents of being simply consequentialists by another name. Consequentialism, which permits using evil means...
Conference on Christianity and the Environment
Courtesy of today’s Zondervan>To The es this announcement, replete with extensive related links: The MacLaurin Institute is sponsoring a conference at the University of Minnesota through tomorrow exploring what it means for people to demonstrate a Christian perspective as they live their lives at the interfaces of three “worlds” — natural, engineered, and human. It will also study how Christian virtues ought to influence public and private policies regarding the interaction of these worlds. Here are a couple of the...
Religion & Liberty: Being Good and Doing Well
The Summer 2006 issue of Religion & Liberty is now available. This issue focuses on the relationship between virtue and success. Looking at this question from several different perspectives – from an economic to a Biblical point of view – we convey that a virtuous society will best satisfy the requirements for liberty and free, and effective, markets. Inside This Issue: The Economy of Trust: R&L interviewed Kenneth Arrow, a Nobel Prize and National Medal for Science winner, on the...
Tithe and Tithe Again
In a way, the Center for Social Innovation at Stanford recognizes a fact that Ron Sider has written on and I have thought about for a long time. In “A New Take on Tithing,” Claude Rosenberg & Tim Stone write: Too often, individuals make decisions about how much money to donate to charitable causes on an ad hoc basis. As a result, many people give less money than they can actually afford. If the affluent contributed as much to nonprofits...
The Fleecing of America
NBC Nightly News has long had a special feature titled, “The Fleecing of America,” which investigates various instances wasteful spending by government officials. To get a visual clue about the massive size and diversity of the federal budget, check out “Death and Taxes”, the 2007 edition, “a representational graph of the federal discretionary budget. The amount of money that is spent at the discretion of your elected representatives in Congress. Basically, your federal e taxes.” The website also notes, “Don’t...
The Green Old Party
A਋it of green conservative politics for your Friday – You’ll see why in a minute. First, read this blog post by the Sierra Club on Linc Chafee (Republican, RI), and then this: Meet Wayne Gilchrest, Republican member of the House of Representatives, First Congressional District of Maryland, former house painter, teacher, Vietnam veteran — and past, present and future canoeist who has yet to find himself up that well-known proverbial creek without a paddle, though he must think at times...
Annan on the UN: The Way, the Truth, and the Life
Allow me to summarize the message of outgoing UN General Secratary Kofi Annan’s speech to the General Assembly yesterday (HT: International Civic Engagement): “The United Nations is the way, the truth and the life. No es to utopia but through it.” You pare the text of Annan’s speech to see if I’ve gotten it right, and then contrast my summary with another source. ...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved