Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The dangers of Catholic anti-liberalism
The dangers of Catholic anti-liberalism
Mar 16, 2025 9:30 PM

Korey D. Maas, associate professor of history at Hillsdale College, has written a timely warning to American Catholics at Public Discourse titled, ‘The Coming Anti-Catholicism.’

Maas begins his essay with a recounting of the early history of American anti-Catholicism, its mitigation in the 1960s, and its troubling resurgence in recent years:

bined effects of Camelot and the Council were to make political anti-Catholicism gauche almost overnight. Nobody, therefore, is surprised today when conservative Catholics and liberal non-Catholics alike respond to any hint of it by insisting that “religion is not the issue. Fidelity to the rule of law is what matters,” or that one should only “criticize jurisprudence and ideas, not religious faith or practice.” Given this apparent consensus,suggestionsthat one’s “dogma” is a “concern” inevitably sound like an unfortunate throwback to an uglier era of American politics.

This reemerging anti-Catholicism is not merely the product of a resurgent and aggressive secularism but a new resurgence of Catholic anti-liberalism:

As in the nineteenth century, liberal anti-Catholicism and Catholic anti-liberalism are mutually exacerbating. But if the former typically remains, for the time being, in the realm of implication and insinuation, the latter is ing much more explicit. Though by no means a majority opinion among contemporary Catholics, the conviction thatliberalism has failedis emboldening an increasingly vocal minority to argue that it deserves to fail because it has been, from its very origins, patible with the Catholic faith.

Maas fears, and rightly so, that this resurgent Catholic anti-liberalism could lead to and embolden secularists in their anti-Catholicism,

Insofar as prominent and influential Catholics insist that Catholicism is fundamentally patible with the liberal tradition, liberals will feel increasingly justified in reaching the same conclusion. Attempts to convince fellow Catholics that the “teaching of the Catholic Church, always and everywhere,” idealizes the confessional state and sanctions religious coercion will inevitably convince many non-Catholics, liberal and otherwise, that this is indeed the case.

The entire essay is well worth reading.

There are however abundant resources within both the Catholic and broader Christian tradition which provide a framework to build a free and virtuous society sustained by religious principles. Liberalism itself is the product of a tradition running back as early as the teachings of Jesus Christ who admonished us to, “Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s.” (Mark 12:17)

Lord Acton places this teaching at the center of the tradition of moral and theological reflection which gave rise to the institutions, ethics, and law of Christian Europe (See Alejandro Chafuen’s Faith and Liberty: The Economic Thought of the Late Scholastics or any of the volumes in thefirstorsecond series of Sources in Early Modern Economics, Ethics, and Law). Korey Maas has recently contributed to the project of this tradition’s retrieval with his excellent contribution to the introduction to Neils Hemmingsen’s ‘On the Law of Nature: A Demonstrative Method’.

There have certainly been tensions between faith, freedom, and modernity (See Jan Klos’s book of that title) but tensions need not lead to inevitable conflict. In order to ward off conflict and build a life together both secularists, Christians, and those of other religious traditions must respect each other’s intrinsic human dignity and especially their freedom of conscience. In other words, what our contemporary challenges call for most is a return to a Christian liberalism.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
How Protestant Missionaries Spread Democracy
Over the past 500 years, some countries have proven to be more receptive to democracy than others. What accounts for the disparity? What causes some countries to be more likely to embrace democratic forms of governance? As empirical evidence shows, one strong predictor is the presence of Protestant missionaries. “Protestant missionaries played an integral role in spreading democracy throughout the world,” says Greg Scandlen. “We could preserve our own if we learn from their ways.” Today we may think of...
The Denver City Council’s Despicable Disregard for the First Amendment
If you want to sell chicken sandwiches as the Denver Airport you need to check your First Amendment rights at the gate. That seems to be the message sent by the Denver City Council to Chick-fil-A, a fast-food chain that is seeking to open a store at the Denver International Airport. The Council is considering turning away the popular franchisebecause pany promotes a Christian ethic in their business dealings. This offends the Council who is worried about how it will...
What is the Moral Difference Between Taxation and Charity?
What is the difference between paying a tax and donating to a charity? Is it moral to force others to give to the cause of your choice? Is it moral for the government to force others to give to the cause of your choice? Rob Gressis, a professor of philosophy, went on campus at California State University – Northridge, to ask students those questions. You can see an extended version of the video here. ...
Americans Don’t Know Pope’s Environmental Views (And What That Means For Us)
There has been no document by a world leader that has received more attention this year than Laudato Si. Three months have passed since Pope Francis released his encyclical on the environment, and yet the media coverage and mentary on it has hardly waned. Here on the Acton PowerBlog, Bruce Edward Walker has piling a daily list of links related to news mentary on the encyclical. To date he has 62 posts with hundreds of links. As the Associated Press...
Video: Creation And The Heart Of Man
Pope Francis has started an important global discussion on the environment with the release of his encyclicalLaudeto Si’, which the Acton Institute has been engaging in with vigor since it’s release, and has been ably covered as well here on the PowerBlog by the likes of Bruce Edward Walker and Joe Carter. But this isn’t the first time that Acton has waded into the debate over protecting the environment; Acton Founder Rev. Robert A. Sirico was debating Matthew Fox, proponent...
How Amazon is Like a Sweatshop (And What That Reveals About Flourishing and Justice)
Liberal and conservative, right and left, red state and blue state—there are dozens, if not hundreds of ways to divide political and economic lines. But one of the most helpful ways of understanding such differences is recognizing the divide between advocates of proximate justice and absolute justice. Several years ago Steven Garber wrote an essay in which he explained the concept of “proximate justice”: Proximate justice realizes that something is better than nothing. It allows us to make peace withsomejustice,somemercy,...
Overcoming ‘Anti-Foreign Bias’ in Trade and Immigration
Many conservatives exhibit a peculiar tendency to be pro-liberty when es to business, trade, and wages, but protectionist when es to the economic effectsof immigration. It’s an odd disconnect, and yet, as we’ve begun to see with figures like Donald Trump and Rick Santorum, one side is bound to eventually give way. They’ll gush aboutthe glories petition, but the second immigration gets brought up, they seem to defer tolabor-union talking points fromages past. When pressed on this in a recent...
Rev. Robert Sirico Takes On Trump’s Comments On Pope Francis
p Last week, the Washington Postfeatured an interview with Donald Trum, entrepreneur-turned-presidential candidate. Trump is clearly no fan of the ments on capitalism and free markets, and his approach to dealing with the pope on this topic is rather unique: Trump wants to scare Pope Francis. mon for someto criticize Pope Francis’s wariness about capitalism, but Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump just took that to a new level, saying he’d try to “scare” the pope by telling him: “ISIS wants...
Children Press-Ganged into EcoService
Whether they’re old enough to believe in the EcoGospel, or Gaia, or man-made climate change or not, children are the latest weapon pressed into service by the eco-warriors. First, it was co-opting Pope Francis and Laudato Si, and now it’s kids. Will they stop at nothing? The Wisconsin Daily Independent reported this past Monday that a group calling itself Citizens Preserving the Penokee Hills Heritage Park is promoting its environmental agenda with a painting of a young Native American girl...
Could Wealth Redistribution End Global Poverty?
Americans make up around four percent of the world population and yet they control over 25 percent of the world’s wealth. What if we were to simply redistribute our wealth to the most needy people on the planet—wouldn’t that end global poverty almost overnight? “The answer unfortunately is no,” says philosopher Matt Zwolinski. “Sharing one’s wealth with those who have less is admirable and it often helps to relieve immediate suffering. But just sharing existing wealth we’ll never be enough...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved