Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The danger of looking past economics and raising the minimum wage
The danger of looking past economics and raising the minimum wage
Apr 7, 2026 6:30 AM

This past week, one of the rising political figures in the Democratic Party, Mayor Peter Buttigieg of South Bend, Indiana penned an op-ed for the South Bend Tribune arguing that raising the minimum wage is “the right thing to do.”

Mayor Buttigieg, cites three reasons why he believes raising the minimum-wage is the right thing to do: It’s good for business, good for the economy, and good for family. All these “goods” assume that raising the minimum-wage does not reduce employment.

So what do basic economic principles say about raising the minimum wage? Take a look at this graph.

What you see is a graphical representation of what a labor market looks like with a minimum-wage. The curve marked with an “S” represents the supply of labor at the given price and quantity and the curve marked with a “D” represents the demand for labor at the given price and quantity. Where those two curves intersect is what economists refer to as market equilibrium, it is what the market wage would be without any external interference. The dashed line above the equilibrium represents a price floor and in a labor market it is also known as the minimum-wage. The minimum-wage means that labor cannot be bought or sold on the market below that level. The distance between the demand curve and the supply curve at the minimum-wage line represents a surplus and in a labor market this is called unemployment. As you can see, the amount of labor being supplied is greater than the amount of labor being demanded. According to this economic theory, when an artificial price floor is put in place, unemployment is created. And when the price floor is increased, so is unemployment. None of this theory matters, according to Buttigieg. Later in the editorial, he makes the claim that we don’t need to rely on economic theory because historical data shows us that “increases in the minimum wage have had little or no negative effect on the employment of minimum-wage workers.”

What Buttigieg is claiming, doesn’t make any sense. First he says that we don’t need to rely on economic theory, which shows us the negative effects of a minimum wage, because we have historical data. Then he says that this historical data of increases in the minimum-wage show little or no negative effect. So why does Mayor Buttigieg suggest that we continue down this path, that according to economic theory and historical data, produce negative effects?

The most bizarre aspect of the fight to increase minimum-wage is that its proponents are advocating for policies that put the very people they claim to care about at the most risk of losing their jobs. This study conducted by the Mercatus Center at George Mason University, offers empirical evidence of how increasing the minimum wage creates higher unemployment among the least-skilled, least-experienced, and least educated workers. Not only is this fight counterintuitive, but it is also the continuation of a historically racist movement.

Economist Thomas Sowell has written about this in the New York Post:

In South Africa during the era of apartheid, white labor unions urged that a minimum-wage law be applied to all races, to keep black workers from taking jobs away from white unionized workers by working for less than the union pay scale.

Some supporters of the first federal minimum-wage law in the United States — the Davis-Bacon Act of 1931 — used exactly the same rationale, citing the fact that Southern panies, using non-union black workers, were able e north and underbid panies using unionized white labor.

It’s amazing that supporters of a minimum-wage once understood that it could be used to price certain people out of the market, and today the supporters of increasing the minimum-wage claim to care the most about those same people.

Increasing the minimum-wage is not the right thing to do. It would only have further negative effects on employment which would result in a domino effect on the economy, business, and families. Ignoring economic theory is not how we should care for the “least of these” in society, and instead of creating more economic barriers we should be taking steps to remove what is already holding back the most vulnerable from reaching their full potential.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Rev. Robert Sirico: The Tea Party Movement and Catholic Social Teaching
Rev. Robert Sirico talked about the Tea Party movement and Catholic Social Teaching yesterday with Al Kresta on Ave Maria Radio. Click on the link below to listen: [audio: From Kresta in the Afternoon: The Tea Party Movement: How Does it Gel With Catholic Social Teaching? Since their not-so-quiet arrival on the U.S. political scene, the tea party has garnered a great deal of attention and found growing support among disgruntled Americans, many of whom are Catholics. A missioned earlier...
More on American Exceptionalism: The Podcast
Acton podcast host Marc Vander Maas was joined by John Pinheiro, Jordan Ballor, and myself to discuss the issue of American Exceptionalism. Click on the link below to listen: [audio: There has been quite the uptick regarding the topic because of fears that America has lost its greatness. “America’s Destiny Must Be Freedom,” is mentary I penned in June related to that fear, as well as an overview of America’s freedom narrative. I also hosted an Acton on Tap on...
ENI: WCC Head Addresses Lausanne Congress
World churches’ leader’s speech reaches to evangelical Christians By Munyaradzi Makoni Cape Town, 18 October (ENI)–The head of the World Council of Churches has reached out to a global gathering of Evangelicals saying Christians of different traditions need to learn from each other to participate together in God’s mission. “We are called to be one, to be reconciled, so that the world may believe that God reconciles the world to himself in Christ,” the WCC general secretary, the Rev. Olav...
A Report from Acton’s 20th Annual Dinner
David Bahnsen, writing on The Bahnsen Viewpoint, has a great report on last night’s Acton dinner: “Good news – the President has announced a reduction of the government work force by one million people (20%). Bad news – the cuts were ordered by President Raul Castro in Cuba.” So began the 20th anniversary dinner of The Acton Institute tonight in Grand Rapids, MI. Acton co-founder, Kris Alan Mauren loosened up the crowd with the aforementioned joke which served the dual...
Rev. Robert Sirico: Tea Party Must Define Ideas
A new Detroit News column by Acton Institute President and co-founder Rev. Robert A. Sirico: Tea party must define ideas By Father Robert Sirico If the recent analysis by the New York Times on the success of the tea party movement is correct, the influence of this movement favoring limited government and low levels of taxation may have a decided impact in the ing elections, particularly in holding the Republican leadership’s feet to the fire on a variety of related...
Reflections on Acton’s Twentieth Anniversary
I remember my first Acton event in 2002, a “Toward a Free and Virtuous Society” conference that I attended as a graduate student. There are a number of things I remember quite clearly, but perhaps most striking was an occasion when someone said something to the effect that those with wealth are able to do more for the Kingdom of God than the poor. This is basically the same view that was once articulated in John Stossel’s special TV program...
Cape Town 2010, China, and Cybersecurity
The Third Lausanne Congress on World Evangelization, also known as Cape Town 2010, was reportedly the target of an cyber attack. The official statement from the congress says, “The puter network developed for sharing Congress content with the world promised for the first two days of the Congress.” “We have tracked malicious attacks by millions of external ing from several locations,” said Joseph Vijayam, IT Chair of The Lausanne Movement, sponsor of the gathering. “Added to this was a virus...
Acton Institute Wins Templeton Freedom Award for Ethics and Values
News from the Acton Institute: Grand Rapids, Mich. (October 22, 2010) – The Acton Institute won first place in the Ethics and Values category in the 2010 Templeton Freedom Awards for Excellence in Promoting petition. The award, managed by the Atlas Economic Research Foundation, recognized Acton for its production of film documentaries that municate the principles and values of individual liberty and a free society.” Atlas cited Acton for “first-rate documentaries designed municate the importance of virtue, limited government, and...
How Do You Say ‘Crony Capitalism’ in Hebrew?
It turns out there’s a phrase for the reality of ‘crony capitalism’ in Hebrew: hon v’shilton, which is “literally translated as capital and government, an expression Israelis use to describe the rich’s influence on government.” Check out Bloomberg Businessweek for an overview of current controversy on Israel’s “business elite.” Of course business need not corrupt government. But the temptation for those with a concentration of economic power to turn that into political advantage in order to retain economic dominance is...
The Subversion of Charity and Christian Identity
There were a few stories from the Grand Rapids Press over the weekend that form data points pointing toward some depressing trends: a decline in charitable giving (especially to churches), supplanting of private charity by government welfare, and the attempt to suppress explicit Christian identity. Here’s a list with some brief annotations: “Study reveals church giving at lowest point since Great Depression” (10/23/10): This is really a damning first sentence: “…congregations have waning influence among charitable causes because their focus...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved