Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY
/
The Church as the bride of Caesar
The Church as the bride of Caesar
Dec 26, 2025 7:14 AM

It is telling that the Washington Post report on the religious Left's Circle of Protection campaign for big government describes the effort as one that would "send chills through any politician who looks to churches and religious groups as a source of large voting blocs," because, in fact, this is not an honest faith-inspired campaign to protect the "least of these" from Draconian government cuts, as claimed. It is a hyper-political movement that offers up the moral authority of churches and aid organizations to advance the ends of the Obama administration and its allies in Congress.

The Circle of Protection, led by Jim Wallis and his George Soros-funded Sojourners group, is advancing a false narrative based on vague threats to the "most vulnerable" if we finally take the first tentative steps to fix our grave budget and debt problems. For example, Wallis frequently cites cuts to federal food programs as portending dire consequences to "hungry and poor people."

Which programs? He must have missed the General Accountability Office study on government waste released this spring, which looked at, among others, 18 federal food programs. These programs accounted for $62.5 billion in spending in 2008 for food and nutrition assistance. But only seven of the programs have actually been evaluated for effectiveness. Apparently it is enough to simply launch a government program, and the bureaucracy to sustain it, to get the Circle of Protection activists to sanctify it without end. Never mind that it might not be a good use of taxpayer dollars.

It is also telling that the group's advertised "Evangelical, Roman Catholic, mainline Protestant, African-American, and Latino Christian leaders" who are so concerned about the poor and vulnerable in the current budget negotiations have so little to say about private charity, which approached $300 billion last year. To listen to them talk, it is as if a prudent interest in reining in deficits and limiting government waste, fraud, and bloat would leave America's poor on the brink of starvation. It is as if bureaucratic solutions, despite the overwhelming evidence of the welfare state's pernicious effects on the family, are the only ones available to munities. This is even stranger for a group of people who are called to "love the neighbor" first and last with a mitment.

Although the Circle of Protection has been endorsed by a few Catholic bishops, the predictably left-leaning social justice groups, and Catholic Relief Services, the Catholic Church in America has long moved beyond the heady (and increasingly distant) days of the 1980s when knee-jerk opposition to any reduction in government spending was the norm. That still holds, even if some of the staff and a few of the bishops at the Bishops' Conference still imbibe such nostalgia.

The actions of Wallis and the co-signers of the Circle of Protection are only understandable in light of political, not primarily religious, aims. Wallis, after all, has been serving as self-appointed chaplain to the Democratic National Committee and recently met with administration officials to help them craft faith-friendly talking points for the 2012 election. And when Wallis emerged from that White House meeting, he crowed that "almost every pulpit in America is linked to the Circle of Protection … so it would be a powerful thing if our pulpits could be linked to the bully pulpit here."

Think about that for a moment. Imagine if a pastor had emerged from a meeting with President George W. Bush and made the same statement. I can just imagine the howls of "Theocracy!" and "Christian dominionism!" that would echo from the mobs of Birkenstock-shod, tie-dyed, and graying church activists who would immediately assemble at the White House fence to protest such a blurring of Church and State.

But in the moral calculus of Jim Wallis and his Circle of Protection supporters, there's no problem with prostrating yourself, your Church, and your aid organization before Caesar. As long as he's on your side of the partisan divide.

This article first appeared at National Review Online.

Rev. Robert A. Sirico is president of the Acton Institute for the Study of Religion and Liberty, in Grand Rapids, Michigan.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY
A Prayer for Generosity Toward Those in Need During Christmas
  A Prayer for Generosity Toward Those in Need During Christmas   By: Christine F. Perry   Bible Reading   “Each of you should give what you have decided in yourheartto give, not reluctantly or under compulsion, for God loves a cheerful giver.” -2 Corinthians 9:7NIV   I was holding downthe sub shopaloneone December day.Mind you, this was not the standard of operation. However, we...
Wherever You Are, There the Lord Will Also Be
  Wherever You Are, There the Lord Will Also Be   By Keri Eichberger   Bible Reading   And surely I am with you always, to the very end of the age. – Matthew 28:20   I’ve always been a beach girl. Claiming this praiseworthy place is where I feel closest to God. “You can have the mountains,” I would say. “Take me to the...
The Conundrum of Woke Capitalism
  Commerce is supposed to be apolitical. Free-market exchanges promote economic efficiency and consumer welfare because consensual transactions between buyers and sellers are indifferent to anything but the price—Adam Smith’s “invisible hand.” Money is fungible and business is impersonal. All that matters is voluntary cooperation by uncoerced actors. As Nobel laureate Milton Friedman explained in Free to Choose, “The price system...
Vision for Eternity
  Weekly Overview:   We serve a God of boundaries. In his limitless capacity, endless creativity, and boundless existence he still chose to create boundaries. He still had vision for what was good, right, pleasing, and perfect. And as children made in his image, we are to live, think, and create as he does. In a world marked by busyness from seemingly...
Churchills Recovery of Aristocratic Virtue
  Churchill introduces My Early Life, his autobiography covering 1874 to 1904, with this observation: “I find I have drawn a picture of a vanished age.” The book is his odyssey. It describes his early wanderings and fortunes as a young officer, journalist, and member of parliament. It depicts not only the actions but also the opinions and convictions of his...
Cultivating Market Societies
  Analogies have the power to reveal new relationships and to reframe how we think. Good analogies help us understand the world. They use relationships and phenomena we experience to help us understand more complex or abstract phenomena. On the other hand, bad analogies can cause grave errors.   When people with a generally grim view of modernity raise concerns about pollution...
Reagan Resurgent?
  For a president dubbed the “Great Communicator,” it is remarkable how little consensus exists concerning Ronald Reagan’s record. Two new entries into the Reagan imaginary, Max Boot’s weighty biography of the 40th president and the new Ronald Reagan biopic starring Dennis Quaid, have reminded readers and filmgoers of the enduring Reagan enigma that continues to occupy a place of debate...
Why Its Crucial to Be on the Same Page with Debt
  Why It's Important to Be on the Same Page with Debt   By: Carrie Lowrance   Just as the rich rule the poor, so the borrower is a servant to the lender.(Proverbs 22:7, NLT)   Money problems are one of the biggest issues in marriage. It is definitely a topic that needs to be addressed before tying the knot so both parties know...
Struggling with Doubt
  Weekend, December 7, 2024   Struggling with Doubt   Zechariah said to the angel, ‘How can I be sure this will happen? I’m an old man now, and my wife is also well along in years.’ (Luke 1:18 NLT)   Have you ever prayed for something, but it took a long time for God to answer it? Then again, have you ever prayed...
Reevaluating Coming Apart
  As an adjunct philosophy professor in the early 2010s, I taught excerpts from Charles Murray’s Coming Apart. The course, “Introduction to Ethics,” was required for all students, and the only class I taught in my seven years at the University of St. Thomas. Needless to say, Coming Apart is not traditionally listed as a great work of moral philosophy. It...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved