Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
The Chicago Black Sox and baseball’s rule of law
The Chicago Black Sox and baseball’s rule of law
Nov 25, 2024 6:25 PM

Sports have already been an Acton topic in the past week, so another sports story can’t hurt: 100 years ago this month was the 1919 World Series between the Chicago White Sox and Cincinnati Reds, infamous ever since for the “Black Sox” scandal, in which eight members of the heavily favored Chicago team accepted money from gamblers to throw the series to Cincinnati. The series ended on October 9, 1919, though the reckoning for players involved in the scheme was not e until late 1920. On September 28 of that year, the eight accused players were indicted and immediately suspended by White Sox owner Charles Comiskey.

The scandal didn’t have the political fallout that last week’s NBA kerfuffle had, but it was a big deal at the time, of course, and the changes it ushered in are still with us today. More to an Acton point, it’s a parable of sorts on the rule of law and its implementation.

John Thorn, Major League Baseball’s official historian, points out in this article that “the scandal was a cataclysmic event in the game’s history not because it was the first time anyone had cheated, but because it was the first time the public knew about it.” According to Thorn, attempts to fix the Series had already been made in 1903, 1905, 1914, 1917 and 1918 – fully a third of all the World Series played before the Black Sox debacle – in addition to countless such efforts in less important games. Gambling and baseball were anything but strangers to one another. The Chicago fix, though, brought the sport’s darker side out into the open and convinced team owners that they needed to do something to restore their credibility with the public. Ultimately their solution was a new office of Commissioner of Baseball, someone who had no financial interest in the game and would provide real enforcement of the rules. In the words of National League president John Heydler, “We want a man as chairman who will rule with an iron hand….Baseball has lacked a hand like that for years. It needs it now worse than ever.” The “iron hand” they found was that of an Illinois federal judge named Kenesaw Mountain Landis.

Kenesaw Mountain Landis had been named a US district court judge by Teddy Roosevelt in 1905 and quickly gained a reputation for zealous enforcement, and for his theatrical sense. His courtroom in Chicago was adorned with two murals – one of King John agreeing to the Magna Carta and one of Moses about to smash the tablets of the Law. He was a longtime baseball fan too, patronizing both Chicago teams, and had even been offered a contract to play professionally before deciding to pursue law instead. Upon his appointment missioner in November 1920, he wasted no time in bating infractions that had long been winked at – during his tenure Landis would issue lifetime bans on 18 players. In 1921 he also locked horns with Babe Ruth, whose popularity had until then largely allowed him to do what he wanted. Ruth went ahead with an off-season barnstorming tour despite Landis’s refusal to approve it; Landis succeeded in asserting his authority and the tour fell flat. missioner suspended Ruth for over a month and even gave him an in-person two-hour lecture on respect for authority. “He sure can talk,” the Babe said afterwards.

Landis’s first concern on taking office, though, and what he remains most known for, was his response to the Black Sox scandal. The eight suspended White Sox players’ trial began in July of 1921 in the Cook County Circuit Court in Chicago. On August 2, jurors acquitted all eight. But that wasn’t good enough for Landis: “Regardless of the verdict of juries, no player who throws a ball game, no player who undertakes or promises to throw a ball game, no player who sits in confidence with a bunch of crooked ballplayers and gamblers, where the ways and means of throwing a game are discussed and does not promptly tell his club about it, will ever play professional baseball again.” He placed all eight on the lifetime ineligible list, a ban that – to the dismay of Shoeless Joe Jackson fans – remains in force today.

Some of the actions Landis took may seem a bit harsh in hindsight. He argued – correctly, I would say – that they needed to be to bring some order into the Wild West of Major League norms. It’s also undeniable that baseball owners who were looking for a rule of law (and a burnishing of their tainted credibility) got what they wanted. Landis restored baseball’s integrity in the public eye, and it wasn’t just a façade – players got the message that schemes and shenanigans, or even passive knowledge of them, would no longer be tolerated. The integrity of the rule of law is a quality that goes beyond just a game.

(Homepage photo: 1919 Chicago White Sox. Public domain.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Alexis de Tocqueville, socialism, and the American Way
Tocqueville determined that the one defining factor in the United States was equality of condition, says John Wilsey in this week’s Acton Commentary. Tocqueville noticed that Americans apparently had the singular ability to prevent equality of conditions from yielding democratic despotism. Through voluntary associations, vigorous local government, a pursuit of self-interest rightly understood, and laws that were based on an accepted moral structure taught in disestablished church bodies, Americans were able to strike that critical balance between private interests and...
Russell Kirk’s 100th Birthday
I’d like to join in the chorus of Russell Kirk memorials that have graced the PowerBlog these past few days memorate Kirk’s 100th birthday. Over at The Federalist today, I can only hint at the significant contributions Kirk wrote on behalf of conservatism, sound economics and Christian humanism. Herewith a brief excerpt: [H]e was so much more than a Cassandra ceaselessly caviling against Communism. More to our great fortune, Kirk scoured the world’s great literature, philosophy, and political theory. From...
The Spanish tradition of freedom in the 16th and 17th centuries
The following article is written by Angel Fernández Álvarez and translated by Joshua Gregor. Juan de Mariana This October 31, I will give a conference entitled The Spanish School of the XVI and XVII Centuries at Harvard University, in order to explain in detail the “institutional framework” and the principles of growth upheld by the late Spanish scholastics. In the conference, organized by the Harvard Real Colegio Complutense, I will explain the importance of Christian humanism, which spread especially from...
Who is John Rawls and why should you care?
This is a guest post for the Acton PowerBlog By Kevin Brown Imagine asking a diverse group of rich, poor, attractive, unattractive, intelligent, unintelligent, white, non-white, educated, and non-educated — what makes a society just. Do you think you would get the same answer? Neither do I. Diverse individuals have diverse experiences, values, and contexts — and our varied backgrounds will inevitably color our perception of what is just, fair, and equitable. Given this, how can we as a society...
The spiritual core of political hate
A new study confirms that creeping tribalism has Americans bitterly divided, acrimonious, and dismissive of others based on political differences. Behind this animosity lies a spiritual principle that Rev. Timothy Keller touched on during his address at this year’s Acton Institute annual dinner. Keller, pastor of Redeemer Presbyterian Church in Manhattan, offered his insights in a lecture he titled “Identity, Business, and the Christian Gospel” – but its lessons go to the heart of every human being. Who am I?...
The reason young people embrace socialism revealed
Why do young people throughout the West have an increasingly positive view of socialism? The answer has been ferreted out between the lines of a survey recently conducted for the Charles Koch Institute. Young people’s infatuation with socialism remains one of the most lamented (or celebrated) facts of the cultural landscape – but both sides agree, it is an undeniable fact. Americans under the age of 30 hold a more favorable view of socialism than capitalism, according to a Gallup...
What determines the value of your money?
The value of money is determined by how much (or how little) of it is in circulation. But who makes that decision, and how does their choice affect the economy at large? Doug Levinson looks at the role of the U.S. Federal Reserve efforts to affect inflation and deflation affects the value of our money. ...
The nation-state and security of freedom
In a recent article for Law and Liberty, Samuel Gregg, Acton’s Director of Research, reviews French political scientist Gil Delannoi’s new book Le nation contre le nationalisme. “Since 2016,” Gregg writes, “it has e evident that millions of people are not content to be herded, sheep-like, by intellectuals, techno-utopians, and supranational bureaucrats down the path of global governance. Their discontent is being expressed through a renewed emphasis upon the nation and an associated stress on nation-state sovereignty.” This emphasis on...
The best ways (empirically speaking) to alleviate global poverty
Virtually all poverty es from economic growth and migration—not redistribution or philanthropy. That’s how economist Bryan Caplan summarizes a fascinating new working paper by Lant Pritchett of the Harvard Kennedy School and Center for Global Development. To make it easier to get the gist of the argument (without having to read all 32 pages), I’ve taken the liberty of “interviewing” the paper. All questions are my own and all answers (with the exception of the parts in brackets) are exact...
Why we have a moral obligation to promote innovation
Note:This article is part of the ‘Principles Project,’ a list of principles, axioms, and beliefs that undergirda Christian view of economics, liberty, and virtue. Clickhereto read the introduction and other posts in this series. The Principle:25A — We have a moral obligation to promote innovation. The Definitions: Innovation –Something (i.e., an idea, method, process, product, service, tool, etc.) that isnew, original, or improved which creates value and is uniquely useful. (Source) Human flourishing – A holistic concern for the spiritual,...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved