Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Supreme Court: Yes, Of Course the Fifth Amendment Applies to All Property
Supreme Court: Yes, Of Course the Fifth Amendment Applies to All Property
Oct 25, 2024 12:24 AM

“The Fifth Amendment applies to personal property as well as real property,” wrote Justice Roberts in a Supreme Court rulinghanded down earlier this week. “The Government has a categorical duty to pay pensation when it takes your car, just as when it takes your home.”

You might be thinking, “Was that ever in doubt?” The answer is apparently yes—at least it was by the federal government since the time of FDR’s New Deal.

During theNew Deal era, Congress gave the USDA the authority to take raisins, along with many other crops, from farmers pensation and keep them in a government-controlled “reserve” to prevent them frombeing sold in U.S. markets. But while many of the other reserves faded away, the governmenthas continued to take raisins from farmers—and claims it’s allowed to do so for because the taking benefits the farmer.

The raisins are given to the Raisin Administrative Committee, a California-based organization made up of industry representatives, whichis allowed to sell off some of those reserve raisins to pay its own expenses and to promote raisins overseas. Many raisin farmers were fine with this price-fixing cartel. But one farmer refused to go along.

Marvin Horne refused to surrender his raisins to the government. Because of his refusal to allow his crops to be taken pensation Hornepotentially “owed” hundreds of thousands of dollars in fines and over 1 million pounds of his crops to the federal government.

Horne challenged the law (Horne v. US Department of Agriculture), arguing the taking of his property pensation is a violation ofthe Fifth Amendment, while the Obama administrationclaimed they can take personal property pensating the owner. More broadly, the government argued they have the ability to take a broad range of personal property—from raisins to iPhones from Americans pensation. A lower court had agreed, ruling that while the Fifth Amendment protectsrealproperty (i.e., land) it does not apply topersonalproperty (e.g., your car).

Fortunately, all nine Supreme Courtjustices disagreed (though they expressed differing views pensation). As Roberts notes in his opinion, “This principle [of pensation], dating back as far as Magna Carta, was codified in the Takings Clause in part because of property appropriations by both sides during the Revolutionary War. This Court has noted that an owner of personal property may expect that new regulation of the use of property could “render his property economically worthless.”

Roberts cites some of the instances of government taking property prior to the American Revolution and notes, “Nothing in this history suggests that personal property was any less protected against physical appropriation than real property.”

In legal terms, real property is land or anything attached to land. Personal property is property that can be moved, i.e., anything that can be subject to ownership that is not land. So if it was not clear before, the Court made it clear now: All your property is covered by theFifth Amendment.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Frank Schaeffer’s Fundamentalist Fakery
Frank Schaeffer: Bachmann, Palin, Perry Use Religion Like Snake Oil Salesmen (2011) Remaining Orthodox in a Secular World : A Sermon by Frank Schaeffer (2002) Mark Tooley, president of the Institute on Religion and Democracy (IRD), has a story on about Frank Schaeffer’s call for the Occupy Wall Street protesters to go after evangelical Christians. Schaeffer is the son of evangelical theologian Francis Schaeffer (1912-1984). Tooley: A blogger for The Huffington Post, young Schaeffer is now faulting religious conservatives for...
Commentary: Rome and Moscow Make Common Cause
With Europe’s traditional moral framework – Christianity – under increasing attack, the Roman Catholic and Russian Orthodox churches are drawing closer in order bat the forces of secularism and “Christophobia.” Rev. Johannes L. Jacobse looks at efforts to set aside long held theological disputes and forge a unity of action on social questions. Subscribe to the free weekly ANC and other Acton publications here. +++++++++ With the Rise of Militant Secularism, Rome and Moscow Make Common Cause By Rev. Johannes...
Vatican Economic Analysis Incomplete, Says Gregg
Acton’s director of research Samuel Gregg has provided his reasoned take on the new document from the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace — it’s up at The Corner. While its diagnosis of the world economy is fairly accurate, the council’s treatment plan is lacking in prudential analysis. Gregg’s disappointment is expressed at the end: “For a church with a long tradition of thinking seriously about finance centuries before anyone had ever heard of John Maynard Keynes or Friedrich Hayek,...
EU Regulation Makes its Way to the US
The aggrandizement of the European Union’s powers, particularly of its regulation, has had a steadygrowth within Europe, and is now looking to move outside European borders. Namely in one American industry, the airline industry, passengers may soon be paying higher air fares, not because of factors within the American financial market, but because of a carbon emissions tax that the EU will be imposing on American airlines which service flights to EU member countries. For example, if an American carrier...
Taxes Yesterday, Today, and Tomorrow
Amid the hustle and bustle of preparing for tonight’s Acton Institute annual dinner, I’m trying to carve out some time to make final preparations for my participation in the 9th Annual Christian Scholars’ Symposium hosted by the Christian Legal Society. Tomorrow afternoon I’ll be debating with Gideon Strauss of the Center for Public Justice on the question, “Justice, Poverty, Politics & the State: Is There a Christian Perspective?” One of the pressing issues related to the size and scope of...
Vatican Releases Note on Global Financial Reform
This morning the Pontifical Council for Justice and Peace issued a bold statement advising how to bring order to the global financial crisis. I was in attendance at the much anticipated press conference that was organized to debrief reporters on the statement’s content. The statement came in the form of a “Nota” (“Note” in Vatican terms): Towards Reforming the International Financial and Monetary Systems in the Context of Global Public Authority. The President and Secretary of the Council, together with...
Samuel Gregg: Two Useful Moments in Last Night’s Debate
Acton’s director of research Samuel Gregg’s reaction to last night’s GOP presidential debate is up at NRO’s The Corner. Like most people who saw the debate, he didn’t like the childish bickering, of which he says “the trivializing effects upon serious discussion are hard to deny.” “There were, however, two useful moments,” he says: One was several candidates’ efforts to put the contemporary disease of identity politics in its appropriate place (i.e., the grave). The second was a number of...
Vatican’s Call for Central World Bank: What the Left Misses
Samuel Gregg is quoted in today’s New York Times story about the Vatican note calling for a central world bank — he gives the final word on the document. The “politically liberal Catholics” quoted before him reveal that they have missed a crucial distinction in the document produced by the Pontifical Council for Peace and Justice. Gregg, of course has picked up on that distinction; he wrote yesterday: Putting aside doctrinal questions, this text also makes claims of a more...
‘Central World Bank’ Would Hurt Cardinal Turkson’s Native Ghana
Last summer, Acton’s PovertyCure team traveled to Ghana to meet with its economists and entrepreneurs — the men and women who are helping the country develop. It just so happens that they also met briefly with Peter Cardinal Turkson, president of the Vatican’s Pontifical Council for Peace and Justice and co-author of the note released yesterday that has stirred up a global controversy. Cardinal Turkson, a native of Ghana, calls for the establishment of a central world bank in his...
Jim Wallis Speaks to Grand Rapids’ Aged
Jim Wallis, the author, public theologian, speaker, and mentator behind the Christian Left’s Circle of Protection, was in Grand Rapids last night, and I went to hear him speak. Wallis was presented as the latest in a long line of progressive luminaries to speak (or play their guitars) at the Fountain Street Chruch: Eleanor Roosevelt, Clarence Darrow, Margaret Sanger, Malcolm X, Gloria Steinem, U2, and the Ramones have all appeared on the same dais. He was introduced to speak about...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved