Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Subsidies or tax breaks, both are cronyism
Subsidies or tax breaks, both are cronyism
Jan 16, 2025 3:53 AM

Last week, President-elect Donald Trump along with Vice President-elect Mike Pence, who is the current governor of Indiana, struck a deal with United Technologies, the pany of Carrier, in order to save over 1,000 jobs from being sent from Indiana to Mexico. This deal will supposedly give Carrier over $7 million in tax break incentives and it has everyone across the political spectrum reacting in different ways.

People on the far-left such as the self-described democratic-socialist senator from Vermont, Bernie Sanders say “It is not good enough to savesome of these jobs.” According to Sanders, the President-elect should be doing more to intervene with the private market in order to save more jobs.

Republican Speaker of the House, Paul Ryan overlooked the fact that the government is meddling in private business in order to defend Trump’s actions by saying “I think it’s pretty darn good that people are keeping their jobs in Indiana instead of going to Mexico.”

On one hand you have a democratic socialist advocating for more intervention on the private market and on the other hand you have prominent leaders within the Republican Party (the party that many perceive as championing the principle of free enterprise) defending actions that resemble crony capitalism. Even the VP-elect, someone who many thought of as a smart fiscal conservative, is giving up on the ideas of free enterprise. He said this in a statement shortly after the Carrier deal “The free market has been sorting it out and America’s been losing.”

The most surprising response to the Carrier deal came from pany itself. In a statement released shortly after the deal was finalized pany said this: “This agreement in no way diminishes our belief in the benefits of free trade.” How ironic.

At libertarian think-tank, Mises Institute, which promotes the ideas of Austrian economist Ludwig von Mises and others from the same tradition, writer Tho Bishop defended Trump’s actions with Carrier. In an article Bishop recently posted to the Mises website titled In Defense of Trump’s Deal with Carrier Bishop said this “While some have described Trump’s approach as crony capitalism, if the terms of the deal really are limited to tax relief, such claims are baseless.”

Had the terms of the deal been centered on the government giving subsidies to Carrier as an incentive to keep jobs in the United States, I don’t think Bishop, Sanders, Pence, or Ryan would still be defending it. But because it is a special tax break given to Carrier that somehow makes it a good thing in their eyes.

This highlights mon misunderstanding of basic economics, which is the idea that targeted tax breaks for panies are effectively different than subsidies therefore making the former a permissible action. U.S. Representative Justin Amash understands this well. Right after conservatives and libertarians began defending the Carrier deal, Amash tweeted this:

govt taxes each person $10 and gives just you $1

=

govt taxes each person $10 except taxes just you $9

They are economically identical.

— Justin Amash (@justinamash) December 1, 2016

Amash explains in 140 characters how a targeted tax break is economically equivalent to a subsidy. It puts one firm at an advantage to peting firms with the help of the government. This is clearly crony capitalism.

This is not to say that people like Rep. Amash and other advocates of free markets are in favor of the current corporate tax system. If the government wants to prevent jobs from being sent overseas, corporate tax rates should be simplified and lowered but when this happens in the form of special favors to specific firms the American people do not benefit.

If conservatives and libertarians want to be a part of the movement that stands for free enterprise and equal opportunity, they need to stop praising such deals and start identifying crony capitalism with accuracy and criticism.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Good, true, and beautiful: C.S. Lewis
Silence took the place of applause as the room struggled to manifest a question to the finality of Peter Kreeft’s lecture; unfazed, the professor filled with excitement at the chance to quip the crowd quoting Aristotle: “human beings are curious by nature.” A smirk crept across his face as he both laid forth a potential congratulation for our ascension beyond curiosity as gods or the insult of being beasts below curiosity. With that, the air filled with questioning hands. A...
Classic Chuck Colson: Stand Up For Religious Freedom
Chuck Colson, founder of Prison Fellowship and BreakPoint, spoke in a 2009 Breakpoint broadcast about religious liberty. His words apply even more today. Allow me to make a very direct statement. I believe it is time for the Church in this country to stand up for religious freedom. Especially over the course of the last few years, we have seen repeated efforts — in the courts, in state legislatures, in Congress and on Pennsylvania Avenue — to erode what has...
Supreme Court Puts Check on EPA Overreach
With the Supreme Court handing down significant rulings on such issues as housing, Obamacare, and same-sex marriage, it’s not surprising other decisions handed down last month received less attention. A prime example is the defeat the Court handed to President Obama administration’s agencies. In the 5-4 ruling, the Supreme Court recently struck down ing EPA regulations concerning emissions of mercury and other toxins at power plants. the Court pointed out that the EPA did not properly consider the costs of...
‘Logic Is An Enemy And Truth Is A Menace’
In a land long ago and faraway, before shows like “The Bachelor” and “How I Met Your Mother,” there was “The Twilight Zone.” Remember the shiver you got when that music came on? And “The Twilight Zone” was never a “horror” show – no maniacs running around chopping teens to bits after sexually assaulting them, all on screen of course. No, “The Twilight Zone” wanted to get you to think … and maybe a little scared. Take this episode: The...
Post-Obergefell, Kansas Governor Signs Executive Order on Religious Liberty
In response to the Supreme Court’s ruling on the case of Obergefell v. Hodges, Governor Sam Brownback issued a new executive orderto ensure religious freedom protections for Kansas clergy and religious organizations. In the majority opinion of Obergefell, Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote that, despite this newly invented “right” for same-sex couples to marry, religions and their adherents “may continue to advocate with utmost, sincere conviction that, by divine precepts, same-sex marriage should not be condoned,” and further, that “the First...
Economist Richard Fuller To Pope: Don’t Blame Capitalism For Environmental Woes
At The Federalist, a round-table discussion brought up several issues regarding the encyclical, Laudato Si’. A quick reading of the discussion sees several themes emerge: the pope shouldn’t be writing about science, this es down too heavily against free markets, and that modernity has much to offer in the way of solving humanity’s many problems. Now, if free markets and capitalism are really to blame for pollution, it would stand to reason that those would be the countries with the...
Poverty in the Developing World
Michael Matheson Miller, research fellow at the Acton Institute, presented a course at Acton University a few weeks ago titled, “Poverty in the Developing World.” The purpose of the lecture was to demonstrate the root cause of global poverty and to analyze the impact of attempts to alleviate poverty through economic aid. Miller was able to draw from the insights he gained during his extensive travels across the globe, and his conclusion was that aid often harms local economies because...
How Prostitution is Like Predatory Lending
“Because the Bible tells me so.” Most of us think of thatphrase as part of one of a belovedchildren’s hymns (“Jesus loves me this I know, for the Bible tells me so.”). But it’s also one of the most sophisticated premises for a moral argument. Because Scripture is a channel through which God’s self-revelation can be known, arguments based on moral appeals to the Bible (i.e., interpreted through proper contextualization and hermeneutical principles) should be pelling and authoritative. Unfortunately, this...
Charleston, Guns, and Natural Law
In the aftermath of the Charleston church shooting in which nine people were killed during Bible study, debates and pushes for more gun control revived. Shooter Dylan Roof’s weapon of choice was a .45 caliber handgun with five extra magazines of ammunition. Rightly so, this heinous crime shocked the nation, especially munities. Calls for prayer and support for the victim’s families immediately followed the tragedy. Inevitably, these prayers were followed by new demands for gun controls. Understandably, after such a...
Acton University: What can you do today to make a difference for tomorrow?
I have an overwhelming desire to connect my passions with positive change. But there are so many things in this world to be passionate about. Passion to make the world a better place. Passion to expand education, uplift the impoverished, and abolish injustice. I find myself stuck; Wanting to do more, but not being capable of such grand plans… Last week my friend asked: “What can you do today to make a difference for tomorrow?” Her challenge blew me away....
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved