Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Subsidiarity in action
Subsidiarity in action
Dec 10, 2025 6:14 AM

In January, I wrote about the Central Plains wildfires as a very personal crisis in my Oklahoma hometown.

I underscored the importance of subsidiarity, which is the idea that a central authority should perform only those tasks which cannot be handled effectively at a more immediate or local level. I’ve now had opportunity to practice subsidiarity in Oklahoma. And I can tell you, it’s harder to do than to talk or write about in the abstract.

The preceding months of drought had created a tinderbox that fueled fires that burned out thousands of Oklahoma and Texas families, including hundreds in my home town and surrounding counties. As the wildfires burned, an upscale West Michigan children’s clothing resale shop was seeking a donation location for 2,000 pieces of clothing. The need was obvious. The Effective Compassion staff at Acton now had opportunity to support local helpers in the wildfire areas, to literally equip an exercise in subsidiarity.

In politics and in society, the principle of subsidiarity represents one of the bulwarks of limited government and personal freedom. My humble, small-town Oklahoma mother can understand that. But in the wake of unprecedented national disasters, such mon sense can be overrun with the lure of government relief money. The bureaucratic morass of FEMA hurricane response should warn us off such temptations.

The “let the government do it” attitude springs eternal with this culture, despite obvious and continued failure. However, the “let the locals do it” approach requires more of the locals — and in this case of clothing to needy Oklahoma neighbors, that meant me.

The picture of Mari Kuhn, Acton’s Effective Compassion program manager, and me lugging huge garbage bags of clothing from the resale shop and stuffing them into a big SUV ical at best. The significance of these two older moms exercising their “clothes police” authority (too short, too low, too little material) as the clothing was moved from bags to shipping boxes did not go unnoticed by teenage helpers. Multiple emails, phone calls, and dead-end solicitations were required before finally securing those boxes and gratis trucking services to move 36 shipping boxes from Grand Rapids to Seminole, Okla. pany moved the boxes to Arkansas, and their supportive staff recruited yet another pany to move the boxes to Oklahoma. (Note to self: provide information so that the nonprofit organization receiving these clothes sends the appropriate IRS in-kind receipt to both panies. And make sure that the pastor knows when he has to be available for the delivery — and shows up.)

Loaded boxes were put on a palette, shrink wrapped, and then awaited the trucking schedule that would work. Multiple calls to munity recipient organizations required connecting sound economics and passion. No, the clothing would not be given to a group that simply opens its doors and provides free clothing to anyone in need — with the needy self-selecting. Subsidiarity requires discernment; undercutting the local clothing sales businesses would be bad economics.

Once we connected to a local church in Oklahoma with appropriate storage facilities and a larger mitted to distribute the clothing to a broad area of needy families, our subsidiarity exercise appeared to hold some promise. But to be the best use to divergent groups — burned out families with children, a local domestic violence shelter and a prisoner re-entry family support program — all 36 boxes had to be sorted.

I live in Michigan. If I was going to make this particular subsidiarity exercise work in my home town, I had to go to Oklahoma. And I needed to recruit help for a significant six hour job to make the effort even more local. I did both.

Perhaps we don’t say “subsidiarity” much because we don’t practice subsidiarity enough. We remain delusional about government resources and capacities. Subsidiarity requires mitment to neighbors mitment that should be more visible in our civil society. The talk about subsidiarity isn’t so important. The doing is.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Acton Institute’s New Building Has Room To Grow
The Acton Institute is anticipating a move to our new building in the heart of Grand Rapids, MI. With the generous funding of donors, the 24,000 square feet of space will allow us to serve an even munity. Acton’s Executive Director, Kris Mauren, says the $6 million renovation allows the Institute to remain in its Grand Rapids home, while raising its international profile. “This is a great place to be and it doesn’t stop us from being the international organization...
Review: A Free People’s Suicide
Below is my review of A Free People’s Suicide: Sustainable Freedom and the American Future by Os Guinness. A final version of this book review will appear in the Fall 2012 Journal of Markets & Morality (15.2). You can subscribe here. «««◊»»» A Free People’s Suicide: Sustainable Freedom and the American Future. By Os Guinness (Downers Grove, Illinois: InterVarsity Press, 2012). 205 pages Review: A Free People’s Suicide That our republic suffers from disorder and decay is no secret. The...
Do We Belong to the Government or Does that Government Belong to Us?
During the recent Democratic National Convention, the party played a video which stated, “The government is the only thing we all belong to.” Daniel Kelly explains what’s wrong with such claims: That pact statement raises a question I thought we had settled quite some time ago: Are we a people who has a government, or a government that has a people? Pretty much the whole of Western political history is the story of ing the former and fleeing the latter....
Rand or Röpke?
On his personal blog, author and publishing industry executive Joel J. Miller asks, “What if we dumped Rand for Röpke?” Good question. Miller says that it’s simply unnecessary for Christians to invoke Rand in their defense of the free market. Why not base that defense on the work of a Christian economist instead? “Unlike Rand,” he writes, “Röpke grounded his critique of socialism and his defense of free markets in a thoroughly Christian understanding of man and his world.” He...
Nuns vs. Managers in the Proxy Wars
For many nuns in the U.S. April is a busy month. Not only do they have the liturgical season of Easter but they have the proxy season of corporate governance. The proxy season is the time when panies hold their annual shareholder meetings. During these meeting any shareholders who own more than $2,000 in stock or 1% of pany can mend pany take a specific course of action or institute a policy change for the betterment of pany. As the...
Leaves and Fruit: The Spiritual Value of Manual Labor
In his Acton Commentary today, Jordan Ballor writes, All work has a spiritual dimension because the human person who works in whatever capacity does so as an image-bearer of God. “While the classic Greek mind tended to scorn work with the hands,” write Berghoef and DeKoster, “the Bible suggests that something about it structures the soul.” If we derogate work with the hands, manual and skilled labor, in this way, we separate what God has put together and create a...
‘There’s an open season on business people’
From the video vault, a classic presentation by Rev. Robert A. Sirico, president and co-founder of the Acton Institute, based on his monograph The Entrepreneurial Vocation. ...
Of Ministers and Muck Farmers
In today’s Acton Commentary, “Mike Rowe and Manual Labor,” I examine the real contribution from a star of the small screen to today’s political conversation. Mike Rowe, featured on shows like The Deadliest Catch and Dirty Jobs, has written letters to both President Obama and Mitt Romney focusing attention on the skills gap and our nation’s dysfunctional attitudes towards work, particularly hard labor, like skilled trades and services. In his letter to Romney, Rowe writes that “Pig farmers, electricians, plumbers,...
Appreciating the Role of Subsidiarity
Subsidiarity, the idea that those closest to a problem should be the ones to solve it, plays a particular role in development. However, it can be an idea that is a bit “slippery”: who does what and when? What is the role of faith-based organizations? What is the role of government? Susan Stabile, Professor of Law at St. John’s University School of Law, has written “Subsidiarity and the Use of Faith-Based Organizations in the Fight Against Poverty” at Mirror of...
Leading Up
Most of the time we spend on this planet we are looking down. Down at our desks . . . down at our feet . . . down at the dishes. Life is full of little details that require us to look down, put our backs into the work and get things done. But the problem with mon posture, as C.S. Lewis puts it, is that “…as long as you’re looking down, you can’t see something that’s above you.” Of...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved