Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Study: How minimum wage increases hurt consumers and the poor
Study: How minimum wage increases hurt consumers and the poor
Oct 9, 2024 12:26 PM

In surveying the damage caused by arbitrary increases to the minimum wage, our attention is typically drawn to stunted job growth among low-skilled workers or tragic tales of shuttered businesses.

But are there other deleterious effects beyond those felt in business and the labor market? What about the impact on the actual price of goods?We are constantly told that businesses will simply “pass along the costs” to the consumer, but does the data actually prove that out? If so, which consumers are hurt the most?

In a newworking paperfrom the University of Zurich, researchers Tobias Renkinb, Claire Montialouxc, and Michael Siegenthaler seek to uncover the answers, focusing specifically on the impact of minimum wage increases on grocery store prices.

Analyzing scanner data in relation to “166 minimum wage increases and 62 legislative events in the US,” the es to the conclusion that consumers bear the bulk of the cost from such increases. “Moreover,” they explain, “poor households are most negatively affected by the price response.”

The researchers summarize their findings as follows:

First, the minimum wage elasticity of prices is about 0.02. We estimate the minimum wage elasticity of cost as well, and find that this elasticity is roughly the same size. Our results are consistent with a full pass-through of cost increases to consumers.

Second, we find that the response to minimum wage increases happens around the time of passage of legislation, rather than at the time of implementation of hikes. This result suggests that grocery stores set their prices in a forward-looking manner and confirms a key prediction of macroeconomic models with nominal frictions.

Third, we show that the price response of grocery stores affect the poorest households the most. In particular, price increases offset about 10% of the average nominal gains from minimum wage increases for households in this bracket. Overall, the price response lowers the benefits of minimum wage increases, and makes them less redistributive in real than in nominal terms.

As it relates specifically to the impact on the poor, it’s worth noting that, as David Trilling explains, “In real terms — after factoring in inflation — the amount offset, or canceled, is even larger. After factoring in price responses elsewhere in the economy, more of the gain from the minimum-wage increase is erased.”

This doesn’t negate the problems posed to labor and businesses, of course, but it may indicate a more limited scope of impact. Regardless of which area bears the greater pain, the findings affirm and highlight the same lesson:prices are not play things.

Despite whatever qualms we may have with the “fairness” of this or that employer’s wages (or, in this case, a grocery store’s prices), studies like this further demonstrate that our attempts to subvert and manipulate these signals “on behalf of the poor” most typically lead to more convoluted illusions, behind which the suffering continues.

“Minimum wage increases are frequently proposed as a measure to address growing wage inequality,” the paper concludes. “Our results suggest that one needs to consider the effects of minimum wages on prices to fully judge their effectiveness as a redistributive policy. In particular, we show that price effects especially reduce the effectiveness of minimum wages as an anti-poverty tool.”

Image: LukeErickson, CC0

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Water is thicker than blood
In the current edition of The Weekly Messenger (no longer active), John H. Armstrong examines the role of pastor in the Protestant church. In “Getting the Role of Pastor Right Again,” he writes, For a long time I have had serious doubts about many of the models of pastoral ministry used and promoted in the West. These models range from academic and biblical teacher models to chief counselor and care-giver. In my estimation they all fail the biblical test at...
Sweet editorial irony and eco-nostalgia
Oh, your lion eyes…Check out the two articles from this week’s journal Nature as reported on . (There must be an editor at work here with a sarcastic sense of humor.) In the first article, mentary by Josh Donlan, a plan is proposed for fighting the loss of endangered species: repopulate the American Plains with (among other things) elephants, wild horses, cheetahs, and yes, lions. The “rewilding” of parts of North America’s heartland could restore some balance to an ecosystem...
If at first you don’t succeed…
…You might be a Member of Congress: Members of Congress want to establish a new government-backed venture capital program… OK, but what’s the catch? …to replace one that’s being phased out because of sizable losses. I wonder if they’ve considered whether the Government should even be involved in the venture capital business in the first place? Hat Tip: Don Luskin ...
Ecumenical leader murdered
Brother Roger, founder of the ecumenical munity, Taize, was murdered yesterday while praying. Details here. Brother Roger founded Taize in 1940. ...
Dismembering frankenstein
A piece in the American Prospect Online by Chris Mooney examines the recurring “Frankenstein myth,” and its relation to contemporary Hollywood projects and the state of modern science. In “The Monster That Wouldn’t Die,” Mooney decries the endless preachy retreads of the Frankenstein myth, first laid out in Mary Shelley’s 19th-century classic and recycled by Hollywood constantly in films from Godsend to Jurassic Park. I’m sick of gross caricatures of mad-scientist megalomaniacs out to accrue for themselves powers reserved only...
Where does G.I. Joe shop?
In a FoxNews article, Jack Spencer of the Heritage Foundation reveals some interesting finds from their year-long study of the military industry: US Defense relies heavily on a global free market for its equipment. This may seem to fly in the face of the idea that if anyone ought to buy American, it is the American government. But as Spencer points out Congress has tried repeatedly over the years to steer defense contracts in directions that would supposedly shore up...
Benedict and World Youth Day: Becoming adults in Christ
Pope Benedict’s highly publicized trip to Germany for this week’s World Youth Day stands as an opportunity for the event to, in the words of Kishore Jayabalan, engage “serious theological and intellectual work.” The pope’s ing means, “If there is a place to show how the Christian faith shaped Europe and formed heroic persons even in its darkest hours, this is it.” Read the full text of mentary. ...
Bandaging the victims
Zimbabwe churches form body to help demolition victims Harare (ENI). Church groups in Zimbabwe have formed a coalition to help victims of a clean-up drive that left hundreds of thousands homeless and drew condemnation from the United Nations and international aid organizations. “Churches have formed a broad-based ecumenical body in the aftermath of the clean-up operation,” the Rev. Charles Muchechetere of the Evangelical Fellowship of Zimbabwe told Ecumenical News International. The prises EFZ the Zimbabwe Council of Churches and the...
The violence virus
News from Los Angeles: Two homeless men were attacked with baseball bats and one of them critically injured, allegedly by teens inspired by videos of homeless people brawling that have sold hundreds of thousands of copies over the Internet. The alleged attackers told officers they had recently seen the DVD “Bumfights” and wanted to do some “bum bashing” of their own, police Officer Jason Lee said. I examine the intersection between the market, technology, and violence in this mentary. In...
Save the date: Toward effective compassion training day
Acton Institute’s Center for Effective Compassion is offering an intensive one-day event in Ft. Myers, Fla., on Oct 28, where nonprofits munity leaders will get practical, how-to skills to help them increase the “return on investment” for charity programs. Foundation grantees, munity and faith-based service providers, students and volunteers won’t want to miss this event. Read more about the event here. ...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved