Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Solving Africa’s state-society gap
Solving Africa’s state-society gap
Apr 5, 2025 11:14 PM

The advent of 2019 has many wondering what kind of world will emerge in the next many years. Predictions of disruptive, technological change, and the transfer of geopolitical power abound. A recent report by the Hoover Institute specifically analyzes what kind of political, economic, and technological trends will form on the continent of Africa, given the shifting sands of our times.

One portion of the report pays particular attention to African governance. Given that governance is a key ingredient to economic development, the answer to this questions has enormous implications for not only Africa, but for the world.

Although it has abated, conflict and poverty-driven migration in recent years caused political and economic shock waves throughout Europe and beyond. Given that the average age across Africa today is 18 and the continent’s population is predicted to essentially double from 1.2 billion people today to 2.4 billion people by 2050, it would be easy to imagine another migration crisis brought on by an influx of young, opportunity-starved Africans seeking better fortunes beyond their native shores.

Will the governance styles employed in the immediate future by African states be supportive of economic development or act to retard it? Will they help establish opportunity for their burgeoning and youthful populations or spark another migration crisis? The answer to these questions will be found, in part, to whether many African countries can solve their “state-society gap.”

Identified in the Hoover Report, the “state-society” gap is a negative characteristic of many African country’s governance styles. This phenomenon can best be defined as the habit of governments to orient themselves externally, concentrating primarily on the wants and demands of foreign interests in order to secure financial support and investment. This results in governments ruling with minimal input from their people or the institutions that make up civil society within their nations.

This state-society gap, the Hoover Report states, “lies at the heart of the problems faced by many [African] states. Governments that rely on foreign counterparts and foreign investment … for a major portion of their budgets – rather than on domestic taxation – are likely to have weaker connections to citizens and domestic social groups.”

In other words, because foreign interests have provided so much financial support to African governments, the incentive is to appease and focus on those same foreign interests, instead of establishing the relationships with civil society that results in a flourishing society. These governments are essentially discouraged from building the institutional foundations necessary for a prosperous country because all of the funds needed to function are provided by foreign entities, not domestic taxation.

How did this disconnect develop? Unfortunately, the West’s meddling on the continent, both past and present, created this destructive chasm. This characteristic was almost certainly baked into the very formation of many modern African states as they were largely the creation of colonial officials and cartographers, not native political will.

The Cold War between the West and the Soviet Union certainly exacerbated many African nations’ state-society gap. In order to bring countries into their respective orbits, the two Cold War powers provided various forms of aid to many African nations. As the Hoover Report notes, “This situation supported an external orientation in African politics in which Cold War reference points and former colonial relationships assured that African governments often developed only a limited sense of connection to their own societies.”

Most recently, the West (and China) helps perpetuate this state-society gap through the provision of international aid, or Official Development Assistance. How does aid, which is meant to help a country, unintentionally undermine its economic development? Michael Fairbanks, an international development expert who worked for years with Rwanda’s government, gives a few reasons:

The development consultants that pany aid money themselves have an external orientation, which leads them to focus on the wants and desires of the foreign entities from which they came. The counsel they provide to African governments therefore, ends up influencing these governments to focus on those priorities instead on those of the people. Hence, aid “severs the link between a ruler of a country and his people.”

For Africa to rise, the state-society gap that plagues many of its countries will have to be bridged. Africa will truly prosper only when countries focus more attention on building the native institutions necessary for their own development. For its part, the West has the opportunity to stop exacerbating that gap by rethinking its approach to aid, which has done so much to make African governments more reactive to foreign interests than to its own people. It’s not only Africa’s prospects for flourishing that rest on the closure of this gap. In this increasingly interconnected and globalized world, ours does as well.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Sirico: The Drama and Reality of Choosing a New Pope
In today’s The Detroit News, the Rev. Robert Sirico seeks to set aside some of the rumors, skewered Hollywood depictions, and media predictions that swirl around any papal conclave. Of course, this time is decidedly different, as the cardinals ing together not after the death of a pope, but one’s retirement. There is much talk throughout all the Church as to whom the next pope will be, and as Fr. Sirico points out, “[n]o one, not even the most well-informed...
Orthodoxy and Natural Law: A Reappraisal
At Ethika Politika today, I examine the recent critique by David Bentley Hart in the most recent issue ofFirst Things of the use of natural law in public discourse in my article, “Natural Law, Public Policy, and the Uncanny Voice of Conscience.” Ultimately, I offer a measured critique—somewhat agreeing with, but mostly critical of Hart’s position—pointing out Hart’s oversight of the vital role of conscience in classic natural law theory. What I find so bizarre, and have for some time...
Creating a Culture That Lasts: Matthew Lee Anderson on ‘Radical Christianity’
I recently expressed my reservations about David Platt’s approach to “radical Christianity,” noting that, outside of embracing certain Biblical constraints (e.g. tithing), we should be wary of cramming God’s will into our own cookie-cutter molds for how wealth should be carved up and divvied out. In this month’s cover story inChristianity Today, my good friend Matthew Lee Anderson of Mere Orthodoxy does a nice job of summarizing some additional issues surrounding the broader array of “radical Christianity” books and movements....
Audio: Discussing ‘Becoming Europe’ on African-American Conservatives
Samuel Gregg recently spoke with Marie Stroughter from African-American Conservatives. They discuss Gregg’s new book, ing Europe: Economic Decline, Culture, and How America Can Avoid a European Future. Stroughter asked Gregg about the dichotomy between “cuddle capitalism” (the European social model) and a dynamic market economy. Gregg says that Americans are more and more choosing a ‘Europeanized’ economy favoring security over economic liberty. Listen to the full audio here: [Audio: You can purchase the hardcover or eBook version of ing...
As You Sow’s Grim Reaping
Religious groups seeking to serve myriad liberal agendas during the 2013 shareholder proxy resolution season look no further than As You Sow, a group dedicated to “large-scale systemic change by establishing sustainable and equitable corporate practices.” AYS will unveil its Proxy Preview on March 7. Trumpeted as the “Bible for socially progressive foundations, religious groups, pension funds, and tax-exempt organizations” by the Chicago Tribune, this year’s preview predictably includes such “issues” as hydraulic fracturing; e-waste recycling; waste disposal; and pushing...
Rand Paul Knows What We Know: Power Corrupts
After nearly 13 hours of speaking in an attempt to stall the confirmation of CIA Director nominee John Brennan, Sen. Rand Paul ended his filibuster. The filibuster is a grandiose method of legislative stalling, requiring the speaker to hold the floor, talking the entire time and not sitting down. In essence, one tries to talk a bill to death. The most famous fictitious depiction of the filibuster is probably is Frank Capra’s Mr. Smith Goes To Washington. Paul Rand, as...
Jayabalan: Possibility of a Non European Pope
Update: Video Interview with Kishore from Rome. Cardinal Malcolm Ranjith As the world awaits the beginning of the conclave, many are looking at non European Cardinals as potentials for the next pope. Channel News Asia points out that “68 per cent of the world’s Catholics currently from Latin America, Africa and Asia, there are increased calls for the next pope to be a non-European.” They asked Kishore Jayabalan, director of Acton’s Rome Office, to offer his thoughts on non Europeans...
Architecture, Human Flourishing, and Health Care
In a recent issue of Metropolis Magazine, Thomas de Monchaux tells the story of an amazing lesson about innovation that Americans can learn from Rwandans. This is no surprise, but readers will learn that burdensome government regulations stifle innovation and undermine human flourishing. De Monchaux recounts the story of Michael Murphy, executive director and co-founder of the Boston-based MASS Design Group, and Alan Ricks, MASS cofounder and COO, attempting to take what they learned from building health care facilitates and...
The Gospel and the Church: Turning Criminals into Co-Creators
I’m just back from the republic of Texas and Acton’s Toward a Free and Virtuous Society conference. One of my fellow lecturers was Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary professor Ben Phillips. In between sessions, he showed me a recent Houston television news piece on SWBTS’s Darrington prison extension, where Phillips and other Southwestern profs are bringing prisoners to Christ, with a plan to send graduates of the program to other Texas prisons. Many of these men may grow old and die...
Audio Roundup: Acton Vatican Experts on the Conclave
Acton president and co-founder, Rev. Robert Sirico, and Director of Research, Samuel Gregg, are currently in Rome for the ing papal conclave. Here’s a roundup of their observations, including thoughts on the legacy of Pope emeritus Benedict XVI. Rev. Sirico was recently on the Laura Ingraham show discussing Benedict XVI’s resignation and legacy with guest host, Raymond Arroyo. Rev. Sirico pointed out that in some ways this is an “era of firsts,” once a new pope is elected, there will...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved