Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Sirico: ‘Christianity safeguards balance of anthropology between social, individual’
Sirico: ‘Christianity safeguards balance of anthropology between social, individual’
Feb 5, 2025 8:07 PM

Rev. Robert A. Sirico, second from left, takes time to chat with participants at the April 20 Rome conference “Freedom with Justice: Rerum Novarum and the New Things of Our Time”

French journalist Solène Tadiépublished an exclusive interview today with Rev. Robert A. Sirico: “Entretien avec le père Robert Sirico pour le 125e anniversaire de l’encyclique Rerum Novarum“. Rev. Sirico was in Rome as thefinal speaker at Acton’s April 20 Rome conference “Freedom with Justice: Rerum Novarum and the New things of Our Time” when he made many ments that spurred journalists to follow up with him afterward.

Toward the middle of her interview, Tadiéasked what he thought about European socialists claiming thattheyhad created the term “liberalism”.

Sirico responded with pastoral and intellectual depth about the social and individual dimensions of the human person. In the end, hesays Christianity provides the best “anthropological balance”, between classical liberal individualism and liberal socialists over-emphasizing the social dimension of man. His answer, published for Institut Coppet, is transcribed below (listen in audio file from 7:52-10:58). It is well worth reading in full:

This is a very French question, and it’s a very good question…. because it goes [back] to the question of the Renaissance and the Iluminismo — the Enlightenment– and a number of these issues that cluster around…And even in the contrast between the French Revolution and the American Revolution.

Without going into a long historical discourse, here is what I what I would say: I think that Christianity, over the centuries, came to a higher and higher view of the dignity of the human person. Certainly, it was a very radical notion right at the beginning, because it is said that people were redeemed not by basis of their ethnicity, but by basis of their personal relationship with Christ.For example in the baptismal rite, I can’t baptize a number of people at once. I have to baptize them one at a time. And so this speaks to the dignity of the human person.

That notion began to be developed over centuries. es to fruition artistically in the Renaissance…and philosophically in parts of the Enlightenment. But I think the Enlightenment es a distortion and rather than seeing man as being the apex of the creation, he es the center of the universe.

And if in that sense liberalism is born in that period, and if socialism takes from that an understanding of the human person, I think it does so in a way that distorts the balance that’s in Christianity. In Christianity, there is always this tension between the material and the transcendent. In the Incarnation, Jesus is God and man.

I think that what happens to the extent that socialism is derived from liberalism it is because it over-emphasizes the social dimension of the human person. And that’s true that the individual is simultaneously individual and social. From the moment of our conception, we exist within our mother’s womb. We are physiologically [and] genetically distinct from our mother. It is not correct to say that a fetus is part of a woman’s body. It is not biologically part, but it does exist within a woman. And so simultaneously were individual and in relationship, and the whole rest of our lives is that.

What I think Christianity safeguards is this ‘balance of anthropology’ between the social and the individual. And what socialism does is separate out from that idea the social dimension. And, by the way, what erroneous liberalism does is separate out the individual from the social dimension.

And that’s why I think that neither is sufficient. We need to have both of these acknowledgments, that human beings are social and are individual…and then build a society based on that — which is why a society built on solidarity and subsidiarity is so important.

For the full article in French, go here. Follow the conversation from the Rome conference on social media via the hash tag #125onFreedom.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
From the Bureau of Goldfish Zoning and Canine Regulation
Reuters reports Rome</city />’s latest laws: Fish can’t be put in fish bowls and dogs must follow a mandatory exercise schedule. “It’s good to do whatever we can for our animals who in exchange for a little love fill our existence with their attention,” said Monica Cirinna, the councilor behind the by-law. “The civilization of a city can also be measured by this,” she told Rome</city /> daily Il Messaggero. (see article) The civilization of a city can be measured...
A plea for circumspection
Gregory of Nazianzus, in his first theological oration, “An Introductory Sermon against the Eunomians,” makes a plea for appropriateness in the airing of theological disagreements. He writes, “If we cannot resolve our disputes outright, let us at least make this mutual concession, to utter spiritual truths with the restraint due to them, to discuss holy things in a holy manner, and not to broadcast to profane hearing what is not to be divulged” (ੵ). His concern is that public disagreements...
Gracious competition
So often we are bombarded with news of businesses accusing others of unfair trade practices, petition smashing, monopolization, etc. Every once in a while, its good to hear about the good business that goes on, the appreciation that pany has for another, and a customer oriented view of production. In that spirit, I offer up panies: Adobe (the creators of the PDF and Photoshop) and Apple. Apple’s recent foray into the image-editing world with the release of Aperture has many...
Add DDT to the Malaria-fighting arsenal
Acton Senior Fellow Marvin Olasky in a column today on looks at the “important new coalition” called Kill Malarial Mosquitoes Now that is working to bring the banned pesticide DDT back into battle against malaria. The disease, he writes, kills an estimated 1 million people annually — 90 percent of them Africans. The United States has been contributing about $200 million per year to Africa’s war on malaria. Four months ago, President Bush promised an additional $1.2 billion over five...
Does pork get your goat?
John Stossel, the icon of indignation, has a piece today decrying the spending habits and attitudes of our Republican-led Congress. I will let you read his article for the details, but for what it’s worth, here are some reasons why I think the disgust Stossel projects is an entirely proper and fitting response to pork barrel spending. When a servant of the people makes his servitude a catch-all reason for indiscriminate exertions of spending power, we call this pork. And...
For Associate Justice – Samuel A. Alito, Jr.
In a move seemingly destined to cause a massive political fight on Capitol Hill, President Bush has nominated Judge Samuel Alito, Jr. to succeed retiring Justice Sandra Day O’Connor on the United States Supreme Court. In his years on the federal bench, Alito has earned a reputation as a reliable conservative voice, even earning the nickname “Scalito” for his philosophical resemblances to current Justice Antonin Scalia. Your thoughts on the nomination are e in ments section. (If you have an...
2005 Annual Dinner highlights
piled a short list of quotations taken from the remarks made by Rev. Robert Sirico and former president of El Salvador, Francisco Flores. Both speeches are available online Francisco Flores – Speech highlights: “Responsibility and freedom are two sides of the same coin.”“A free man is a responsible man.”“Opportunity is choice, and choice is freedom.” Robert Sirico – Speech Highlights: “If you’re not a socialist when you’re young, you have no heart. But if you remain a socialist when you’re...
Taxing the wages of sin
A lively discussion is going on over at the evangelical outpost on the idea of the “sin tax,” spurred on by Rev. Sirico’s paper on that subject. A key point to remember: once the state gets to decide which activities are immoral (but not illegal) and has a vested financial interest in them, you’ll find more and more activities ing “sins.” Exhibit A: eating fast food. For more on this subject, see “The Sin Tax Craze: Who’s Next?” by Rev....
Miers withdraws
And so the search for a replacement for Sandra Day O’Connor will continue: Harriet Miers withdrew her nomination to be a U.S. Supreme Court justice Thursday in the face of strong criticism from President Bush’s most conservative supporters, who say she doesn’t have the qualifications or experience necessary to serve on the nation’s highest court. ...
‘The Donald’ on success and responsibility
Real estate mogul and reality show guru Donald Trump made a guest appearance on the NBC soap opera “Days of Our Lives” last week and, in a real stretch, he played himself. The brief cameo was in the context of Mr. Trump’s visit to the Horton Foundation, a charity based in the fictional town of Salem. The dialogue between Trump and Mickey Horton gives us some insight into Donald Trump’s view of economic success and the resulting responsibility: Donald Trump...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved