Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Shareholder Resolutions and the ‘God Card’
Shareholder Resolutions and the ‘God Card’
Nov 25, 2025 6:13 AM

The progressive politicization of certain religious orders hurries apace, especially as we enter the season of shareholder activism, proxy ballot initiatives and “corporate social responsibility” lectures from religious groups and churches. This year may generate even more activity as a result of the left’s renewed efforts to undermine Citizens United vs Federal Election Commission.

Because many religious organizations are also shareholders in public corporations, their investments grant them a proxy voice in corporate policies. Unfortunately, this voice too often is used to promote policies that are often indistinguishable from secular-left political causes and may have little connection to the tenets of their respective faiths.

One oft-stated goal of these activists is “transparency.” They claim to rectify the perception the Supreme Court ruled erroneously in Citizens United when it declared unconstitutional the placing of limits on corporate and union political spending. But these attempts to pass transparency rules and regulations extend far beyond mere campaign funding by requiring that all corporations publicly divulge the recipients of their charitable giving.

The real aim of these efforts is to shame pany in question to reduce or eliminate altogether charitable funding of groups out of favor with the corporate social responsibility, or CSR, crowd – groups that lobby, research, publish and campaign on issues that conform to the progressive or “social justice” agenda.

These initiatives are in tandem with two federal announcements last month. On Jan. 9, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission said it would submit by April a “Notice of Proposed Rulemaking,” which would panies to disclose their political spending. Another attempt to perform an end run around Citizens United is New York State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli’s revelation that his office is seeking greater transparency of panies that make political contributions.

The SEC and DiNapoli announcements coincide with the proxy shareholder season of corporate governance. During this period, any shareholder owning more than $2,000 in corporate stock or 1 percent of pany may introduce policy changes they deem important.

The rising tide of shareholder activists from religious orders has even prompted coinage of the phrase “the God card” by Sister Patricia Daly to connote a sense of moral authority for clergy and other religious who promote secular progressive causes in corporate boardrooms.

As noted by Acton’s Joe Carter, there is nothing intrinsically wrong when clergy, nuns and other religious bring their individual social and political views into the corporate boardroom. It es worrisome, however, when clerical collars and habits e a Trojan horse for promulgating progressive policies that don’t necessarily reflect the teachings of the religious institutions to which the professed religious belong.

In fact, there exists a close alignment between the causes championed by Sr. Daly and the Sisters of St. Dominic’s and the very same issues listed as policy priorities by such progressive organizations as the George Soros-funded Media Matters for America. This group launched the Conservative Transparency website in 2009 specifically to monitor corporate donations to conservative organizations.

The Sisters of Charity’s professed aim to “actively promote changes in corporate practices to achieve social and economic justice, a sustainable Earth and mon good” prompted Carter to state: “The Sisters aren’t interested so much in advancing a Catholic position as they are principles that could be accepted by any secular liberal.”

The Sisters of Charity, the Sisters of St. Dominic and other religious activists in the boardrooms and annual meetings do not speak for all the faithful within their respective traditions. Although, from ments and activism, you might assume they are doing just that. Instead, they seek to further an agenda either antithetically opposed or – as with the blatant attempts to circumvent Citizens United with calls for corporate donation transparency – totally unrelated to their respective vocations.

Corporations may acquiesce to transparency demands from shareholders or decide to pursue it as policy, which is their prerogative. They have their shareholders to answer to, after all. What’s more, religious activists on the left may choose to divest shares in favor of investing panies more aligned with their principles. But if they did that how could they hector executives and directors about “social responsibility” panies they’ve targeted for social reform?

Should the SEC or other government entities step in to require such disclosures the negative impact on free speech would be immeasurable. Subsequent reprisals from progressive activists may ricochet throughout the pany, the workforce it employs, the shareholders it enriches, and the customers it serves.

If you have your own examples and cases of how progressives are employing shareholder activism, CSR principles and the “God card” to further an agenda that may have nothing to do with corporate best interests, feel free to add them to ment box below.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
‘Genesis Code’ Opens in Grand Rapids
The second annual Grand Rapids Film Festival starts today and The Genesis Code, a film making its debut tonight, has a strong Acton connection. One of the executives driving this production is Jerry Zandstra, who also plays the Rev. Jerry Wells in the movie. You’ll see him in the opening shots of the trailer here in the pulpit, which is what is known in Hollywood as typecasting. That’s because Zandstra is an ordained pastor in the Christian Reformed Church in...
Forms of ‘Financial Oppression’
From Marketwatch today, “Morgan Stanley warns on sovereign defaults”: “Outright sovereign default in large advanced economies remains an extremely unlikely e,” they said. But bondholders could suffer losses from forms of “financial oppression,” such as repaying debt with devalued currency, the analysts warned. From last week’s Acton Commentary by Sam Gregg, “Deficits, Debt, and Self-Deception”: Then there is the increased possibility that governments will resort to other, less-conventional means of deficit-reduction. As Adam Smith observed long ago in The Wealth...
Technology to God’s Glory
David Murray is Professor of Old Testament and Practical Theology at Puritan Reformed Theological Seminary, and chairman of HeadHeartHand Media, announces the release of a new video product, God’s Technology, a product about “training our children to use technology to God’s glory.” I had the pleasure of meeting Dr. Murray over lunch one day, and I look forward to seeing his presentation of “a Christian response to the digital revolution.” Dr. Murray blogs here. You can see the trailer for...
Political Activism on Prison Rape
As a follow-up to last week’s popular discussion (thanks to Glenn Reynolds) on prison rape, Justice Fellowship has just released a statement, “Left-Right Coalition Demands Stop to Prison Rape.” The news alert begins, “A broad coalition from the political left and right has called on U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder to cease any further delay in eliminating prison rape. Calling the high incidence of prison rape ‘a moral outrage,’ Prison Fellowship and supporters from both liberal and conservative organizations unveiled...
Paul Ramsey on the Church and the Magistrate
One of the inspirations for my little book, Ecumenical Babel: Confusing Economic Ideology and the Church’s Social Witness, was the incisive and insightful critique of the ecumenical movement from the Princeton theological ethicist Paul Ramsey. Ramsey’s book, Who Speaks for the Church? A Critique of the 1966 Geneva Conference on Church and Society, has a wealth of both theoretical and concrete reflections on the nature of ecumenical social witness and the relationship between church and society. He concludes the book...
Youth: Problem or Solution for New Jobs?
The front page of a recent issue of the Vatican daily L’Osservatore Romano read like an Italian “Help Wanted” listing: “Lavori per Giovani Cercasi” (cf. Aug. 13 2010). Unfortunately, this eye-catching headline was not a classified ad targeting young professionals for job openings at the Holy See’s many curial and administrative offices – the prized “stable” positions that would have Roman youth queuing in lines much longer those to enter Sunday Mass at St. Peter’s Basilica! Rather, the Vatican newspaper...
Teachers Unions and Civil Rights Groups Block School Choice for Black Students
Today’s Acton Commentary: Teachers Unions and Civil Rights Groups Block School Choice for Black Students by Anthony B. Bradley Teachers unions, like the National Education Association (NEA), and many civil-rights organizations inadvertently sabotage the potential of black males by perpetuating failed educational visions. Black males will never achieve academic success until black parents are financially empowered to opt out of failed public school systems. The American public education system is failing many groups, but none more miserably than black males....
Health Care Subsidiarity: Continued
The escalating legal battle over the recent health care legislation has spilled out of the federal judiciary into state governments. An August 14 story from the New York Times reports: Faced with the need to review insurance rates and enforce a panoply of new rights granted to consumers, states are scrambling to make sure they have the necessary legal authority to carry out the responsibilities being placed on them byPresident Obama’s health care law. missioners in about half the states...
Soros Funding of Sojourners is Only The Tip of the Iceberg
I blogged about the Jim Wallis funding controversy here and here. Now Jay Richards, a former Acton fellow, has more at NRO, beginning with a look at Wallis’s “clarification” of his earlier denials: Note that Wallis does not apologize for falsely accusing Marvin Olasky of “lying for a living.” Instead, he blames his own misrepresentation of the truth on the “spirit of the accusation.” The “clarification” of his earlier statement is equally unsatisfying. First, Wallis is still trying to claim...
Glocalization and Locavore Legalism
I’ve been meaning to write something on the “locavore” phenomenon, but nothing has quite coalesced yet. But in the meantime, in last Fridays’s NYT, Stephen Budiansky does a good job exploding the do-gooderism of the locavore legalists. Here’s a key paragraph: The best way to make the most of these truly precious resources of land, favorable climates and human labor is to grow lettuce, oranges, wheat, peppers, bananas, whatever, in the places where they grow best and with the most...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved