Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Sen. Elizabeth Warren brings government muscle to corporate ‘accountability’
Sen. Elizabeth Warren brings government muscle to corporate ‘accountability’
Sep 22, 2024 1:36 AM

It was in Godfather III where Al Pacino as Michael Corleone said it first and said it best: “Just when I thought I was out, they pull me back in!” Before we were able to put away our party hats after celebrating the Supreme Court’s Janus decision in June, Missouri rejected a right-to-work measure at the state’s primary ballot box last week.

And now Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) wants to do a federally legislated end run around Janus with a proposed bill she calls The Accountable Capitalism Act. She announced her proposed bill in an Aug. 15 Wall Street Journal essay. Despite what seems obvious in the title “Companies Shouldn’t Be Accountable Only to Shareholders,” Warren fails to mention “serving customers and clients” at all, but – in true social-justice, shareholder activism mode – instead panies need to pay their employees more.

According to Warren, the Act would require that large corporations submit to a federal charter that increases the likelihood of legal actions taken against panies:

Corporations with more than $1 billion in annual revenue would be required to get a federal corporate charter. The new charter requires corporate directors to consider the interests of all major corporate stakeholders—not only pany decisions. Shareholders could sue if they believed directors weren’t fulfilling those obligations.

Stakeholders seems like nothing more than a weasel word for anyone who wants to cause mischief at any pany whereas shareholders have real, green skin in the game.

In other words, Warren wishes to deploy government muscle to bring corporations to heel in their dealings with employees. To quote Vito Corleone as portrayed by Marlon Brando in the original Godfather: “She’s gonna make corporate America an offer it can’t refuse.” All this because relationships apparently between employers and employees in the country’s panies heretofore have been unable to resolve these differences on their own. It’ll certainly take government tossing a horse’s head into the collective bed of America’s CEOs – at the expense, no less, of shareholders of whom some if not many are also employees of panies dinged by antagonistic stakeholders.

Warren contrasts two statements made by the Business Roundtable. The first, in 1981, she characterizes as mon good that businesses “have a responsibility, first of all, to make available to the public quality goods and services at fair prices, thereby earning a profit that attracts investment to continue and enhance the enterprise, provide jobs, and build the economy.” In 1997, Warren writes, “the Business Roundtable declared that the ‘principal objective of a business enterprise is to generate economic returns to its owners.’” Somehow, readers are to infer this is a terrible, horrible, not-good thing. Shareholders making a return on their investments? Heaven forfend!

All this assumes shareholders are, to a person, all fat cat, Daddy Warbucks types and not simply working stiffs with a mortgage, kids in college, a five-year note on the car in the driveway – oh, and a 401K account. Sure, wealthy people also benefit from owning – say – mutual funds and retirement accounts, and why shouldn’t they? After all, CNN Money noted that Warren and her husband were worth between $3.7 million and $10 million in 2015:

The vast bulk of Warren’s wealth is held in mutual funds and retirement accounts with TIAA-CREF, a financial pany that provides retirement services to universities. The couple’s largest holdings are the ultra-safe TIAA-CREF Traditional fund, in which they each have at least $1 million. The fund offers three guarantees: you’ll never lose your principal, you’ll always get a minimum interest rate and you’ll receive a lifetime e stream.

That’s a whole lotta wampum. But the heart of Warren’s argument is that U.S. wages have stagnated to 1979 levels. It’s a serious problem, if true as a recent Pew Research Center concludes. But, it’s not exactly an parison. As pointed out above, many middle-class workers today are squirreling e away in tax-free retirement funds – many of them matched by employers, no less – a reality that didn’t exist 40 years ago. And then there’s the benefits provided by employers to their workers, the costs of which vastly exceed what was spent as a percentage of corporate profits in 1979.

Isolating wages from benefits doesn’t seem like an honest argument. But have wages really stagnated as much as the Pew research suggests? According to the Manhattan Institute’s Scott Winship, the Bureau of Labor Statistics numbers used by Pew aren’t reliable mainly because they tend to exaggerate inflation. Using Winship’s research, Ramesh Ponnuru writes in Bloomberg Opinion:

Pew appears to be using a measure of inflation called CPI-U, which is produced by the Bureau of Labor Statistics and used by many other researchers. But as Scott Winship, then an analyst at the Manhattan Institute, detailed a few years ago, that measure overestimates inflation — and vastly overestimates its cumulative impact over time….

The government produces a statistic that does not have these flaws and goes back to 1929: the PCE deflator. Use that better measure of inflation, and the flat trend line in wages since 1978 that Pew found es a 22 percent increase. pensation, including benefits, must have grown even more. (For those readers wondering whether that apparent progress just reflects growth at the top of the e distribution, Winship has calculated that workers in the middle of the distribution saw a 31 percent increase pensation from 1967 to 2015.)

It seems Warren hasn’t ever encountered a problem real or imagined that doesn’t necessitate some massive government program to remedy it. In this instance, it’s not difficult to predict dozens, hundreds or even thousands of nuisance lawsuits brought on by social justice warriors and so-called religious shareholder activists aligned under the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility umbrella and other religious groups who consider business an inherent evil and are panies are denying employees their “fair share” of corporate profits. Here’s hoping Warren’s Accountable Capitalism Act winds up sleeping with the fishes.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
The Jacobins’ manifesto: ‘The Socialist Manifesto’ by Bhaskar Sunkara
“If you are a socialist, and you are toying with the idea of writing a book – now is the time to do so,” writes Kristian Niemietz. “There seems to be an infinite demand for this message right now,” he states in a new book review posted atReligion & Liberty Transatlanticat the author’s request. Niemietz, the head of political economy at the London-based Institute of Economic Affairs (IEA), reviews The Socialist Manifesto: The Case for Radical Politics in an Era...
China replaces Ten Commandments with socialist propaganda: Report
Congregations in China’s officially recognized Protestant church have been forced to replace mandments to Moses with a quotation about the triumph of socialism, according to a religious liberty watchdog. The action literally substitutes socialism as an idol, in violation of the First Commandment.The Chinese government’s attempt to change the teachings of the60,000-church Three-Self Patriotic Movement unmasks how socialism crushesreligious liberty and reduces Christians to subservience – or elevates them to martyrdom. The magazineBitter Harvestreports: The Ten Commandments are the basis...
George Washington’s farewell address
On this date in 1796, near the end of his second term as president, George Washington published The Address of Gen. Washington to the People of America on His Declining the Presidency of the United States. Better known subsequently as his “farewell address,” it is his announcement of retirement from the presidency and from public life. He says, moreover, that he had wanted to retire after his first term but that considerations of duty had dissuaded him: “The strength of...
New ‘Religion & Liberty’ focuses on the student loan crisis
The newest issue ofReligion & Libertyhas been uploaded. You can view it here. This issue ofReligion & Libertyfocuses on higher education in all its fulness. Two statistics throw the college tuition crisis into stark relief: Since 1978 – the year the federal government offered subsidized loans to all students – the cost of college tuition has risen by 1,375 percent. And another 1,400 students default on those loans every day. The cover story by Anne Rathbone Bradley unravels the crisis...
The problem with intellectuals
I am in the curious position of being a blogger who distrusts opinions. The late yoga master B.K.S. Iyengar put it best when he wrote, “An opinion is yesterday’s right or wrong knowledge warmed up and re-served for today’s situation.” Too often opinion is divorced from both personal experience and rigorous thought. F.A. Hayek’s essay “The Intellectuals and Socialism” is an attempt at defining the nature and function of professional opinion-havers. His description of them as, “second hand dealers in...
Rev. Ben Johnson at Natl Catholic Register: Praying to the true ‘King of Israel’
The week after Donald Trump tweeted a message proclaiming himself the ing of God,” I decided to say a prayer to the “King of Israel” (although quietly, since my bishop encouraged me to pray so softly that no parishioner would hear me). I am assured that literally thousands of priests in this country have joined me in standing before our altars and whispering an identical prayer, using the same moniker. This is not a confession of idolatry nor an insider’s...
Fact check: Did the wealth tax increase the number of millionaires?
“If you want less of something, tax it,” the old adage goes. If that is the case, why is a prominent European newspaper reporting that the number of millionaires increased after one nation introduced a wealth tax? “Number of super-rich in Spain grows 74% since reintroduction of wealth tax,” a headline in Spain’sEl Paisreportedrecently. Here are the facts: Background Spain introduced a wealth tax (Patrimonio) in 1977 as a “temporary” measure. In 1991, lawmakers admitted the 14-year-old tax would be...
Alejandro Chafuen in Forbes: The uncertainties of the Brexit debate
Acton’s own Alejandro Chafuen recently returned from a visit to England, and today in Forbes he offers a few of his impressions and analyses of the contentious Brexit process. The political machinations of the current situation are seemingly endless, but its ramifications are more than just political. As Chafuen points out, for instance, the ongoing saga brings uncertainty for anyone who does business in the UK. “We have many issues that go to a referendum in Switzerland. But after the...
Acton Line podcast: Why the ‘1619 Project’ is a lie; Yes, we’ve tried ‘real socialism’
In August, the New York Times launched the ‘1619 Project,’ an initiative that includes school curriculum, videos, and a podcast, which aims to “reframe” the history of America’s founding around slavery. The Times claims that since the year 1619, “[n]o aspect of the country that would be formed here has been untouched by the years of slavery that followed.” So what is the Times trying to plish with the ‘1619 Project’? Ismael Hernandez, founder and director of the Freedom &...
Samuel Gregg on ‘The specter of scientism’
In this week’s Acton Commentary, Acton Research Director Samuel Gregg looks at how “scientism” treats the scientific method as the only way of knowing anything and everything. Without dismissing the real achievements of modern science, he notes that “one side-effect of these triumphs was that some began treating the empirical sciences as the only form of true reason and the primary way to discern true knowledge … ” Notwithstanding these serious flaws with scientism, its acceptance has two effects on...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved