Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Samuel Gregg on banking and the common good
Samuel Gregg on banking and the common good
Dec 10, 2025 12:03 AM

Can we live the good life in the world of finance and banking? Acton’s research director, Samuel Gregg, explores that question in his latest book For God and Profit: How Banking and Finance Can Serve the Common Good. He was recently interviewed by the Social Trends Institute in order to discuss the motivation behind writing the book as well as expanding on the theme of his book.

Some of the highlights:

What’s the biggest challenge facing Christians and other people of good will seeking to shape the world of finance and banking?

Perhaps the most important is that we need to learn how modern banking and finance functions before they make suggestions or critiques. There’s no point criticizing something like short-selling unless you understand, first, what short-selling is, and second, the ways in which it actually serves as an early warning system for significant problems in a business or even an economy. In fact, short-sellers are invariably light-years ahead of the regulators when es to such matters.

Another example is speculation. The word has very negative connotations but speculation plays a crucial role in stabilizing prices over the long-term and smoothing the supply and demand modities (such as food, oil, and minerals) and currencies. This in turn enables individuals and business engage in better planning for their economic future. Are there forms of speculation that amount to sophisticated gambling? Yes, but those cases are actually very rare.

A second major challenge is to see finance as not something that’s merely useful from time to time but as something through which the ponent of mon good can be further realized. Because finance helps to put the goods of the world to use for billions of people over extended periods of time. When I invest in the stock market, for instance, my investment is put to work in other people’s businesses and enterprises, thus helping others—who, in all likelihood, I’ll never know—realize their dreams and ambitions now and in the future. In that sense, finance provides a bridge between me and others, and my present and future, and other peoples’ present and future. It builds trust, prices risks, and enables opportunity. Without these factors at work, we would all be living in the subsistence economies that characterized the pre-medieval world.

Can virtue be found in the financial sector?

Absolutely. Money can certainly e an idol and greed is never good. But we can be virtuous in the use of money and capital in ways that go beyond philanthropy and charity.

Reading Aquinas on this matter is eye-opening. He defines magnificence as the virtue of “that which is great in the use of money.” It is not so much, he specifies, about making gifts or charity. Nor, Aquinas adds, does the person who embraces this virtue “intend principally to be lavish towards himself.” Rather, he says, magnificence concerns “some great work which has to be produced” with a view to the good that goes beyond the immediate gain, and which cannot be done “without expenditure or outlay” of great sums of money. Moreover, magnificence for Aquinas also concerns “expenditure in reference to hope, by attaining to the difficulty, not simply, as magnanimity does, but in a determinate matter, namely expenditure.”

Here we find a hitherto underappreciated basis for a Christian understanding of finance as a vocation. Magnificentia isn’t so much about who owns the wealth. Aquinas points out that the poor man can also choose to do great things. Rather it’s about the one who deploys great sums to help realize a “great work.” It’s also important to know that Aquinas links the act of magnificence to one of the three great theological virtues: the act of hope. This is especially relevant to finance, for without hope—the expectation of, and firm confidence in, positive es, even in conditions of uncertainty—the entire world of finance would crumble from within.

Read the full interview at STI.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Charity misdirected: New study explores Christian attitudes about orphanages
While many orphanages are doing good and necessary work, others have contributed to cycles of child abandonment, family disintegration, and poverty. Unbeknownst to many American Christians, the majority of children living in orphanages have living parents, and such families would likely be better served by a different kind of support altogether. Read More… Orphan care has long been a central focus of Christian missions, prompting many churches to offer significant support for orphanages around the world, whether through financial donations,...
Parenting after the pandemic: More freedom, less ‘safetyism’
Whatever one thinks of the prudence of the lockdowns as a means for containing the virus, they inadvertently doubled as an extreme experiment in what happens to children when they are over-sheltered and over-protected from the outward journeys of daily life. Yet, to a lesser degree, that experiment was already well underway before the pandemic ever began. Read More… Should parents prioritize extreme safety or thoughtfully push their kids toward independence and self-reliance? It’s a question that moms and dads...
The necessity of boring politics
The government is working well when no one pelled ment on it. As poet Henry David Thoreau said: “That government is best which governs least.” Read More… Movie audiences experience high emotional engagement when they identify personally with the characters. The same is true in modern American politics, which increasingly have e treated as a source of social identity and entertainment. But should politics be a source of entertainment? Or should politics be boring? The founding fathers explicitly ordained six...
America is crossing economic Rubicon of government management
If anyone had any lingering doubts about where American economic policy is heading over the next fouryears, those should have been removed by President Joe Biden’s proposed $6 trillion budget for 2022. Whatever Congress does with this proposal, there’s no doubt that government is now viewed by leading policymakers and, judging from recent surveys, by millions of Americans as the primary engine that should be driving the economy. Whether it is the disinterest in the implications of America’s public debt...
Crypto and Blockchain: A flash in the pan or something more?
To preserve economic liberty, Central Bank Digital Currencies need to operate within a clearly articulated rule of law while allowing tertiary cryptocurrencies to freely operate within a decentralized institutional framework which protects individual privacy while retaining economic stability. Read More… Ever since the first Bitcoin was mined in January of 2009, we’ve seen an ever-growing interest in cryptocurrencies and blockchain — the technology upon which Bitcoin is based. What are we to make of it all? Will Bitcoin or another...
The ‘man of public spirit’: Politics as art, not science
Politicians have given us many occasions to be critical of their actions. Politics, like all sausage making, is rarely palatable. Nevertheless, Aristotle observed that man is by nature a political animal, drawn into association with others in order to satisfy inherently social needs. Politics need not take the form of what Ambrose Bierce calls it in The Devil’s Dictionary: “a strife of interests masquerading as a contest of principles.” Of course, thinking about politics clearly and constructively is often made...
Why capitalism is worth conserving
Capitalism is worth conserving not because free markets are a “necessary tool” for economic growth, but because economic freedom honors the dignity and creative capacity of the human person. Read More… Amid the waves of populism and protectionism sweeping across the American Right, capitalism has e a favorite target of many prominent conservatives, blamed for the decline of religion, the demise of the family, and the erosion of civil society. Whether the e from politicians like Josh Hawley or pundits...
Finding meaning in work: Christian vocation means working with ‘holy intent’
For those who are lost and looking for meaning in a fragmented world – constantly torn between idols of work and leisure, with little left in between – “the power of holy intent” orients our hearts and hands beyond ourselves. It focuses our worship on the Worker and Creator who made us in his image and likeness. It reminds us that, whether we recognize it or not, he is the one we are truly working for. Read More… America’s new...
The ‘chicken and egg’ interplay of religious liberty and economic freedom
Does e before the other – or are religious liberty and economic freedom mutually reinforcing and indivisible? Read More… The contributions of religious life to economic prosperity are increasingly evident, prompting many to study the relationship between the two. A recent study from Canada found that religion adds billions to the economy. In the United States, research has shown much of the same, pointing to growth that outsizes that of the world’s panies. What’s less explored are connections between the...
Beyond nationalism and globalism: Jesus points to another kingdom
In our era of hyper-partisanship, often we think of political divides in simple terms of Republicans versus Democrats, or progressives versus conservatives. Nevertheless, even today there are some divides that cut across party lines. One such divide is that between nationalists and “globalists” or “imperialists” (both pejorative terms given by nationalists to those who support greater international cooperation). On the right, former President Donald Trump opposed many international trade relationships and generally called for an “America first” approach to foreign...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved