Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Saltiness and social justice
Saltiness and social justice
Dec 24, 2024 12:52 PM

Does the theological conservatism of a church help or hinder its chances for growth? And what, if any, impact might that have on its social and political witness?

In a new research study, sociologist David Haskell and historian Kevin Flatt explore the first of these questions. Using survey data from 22 mainline Protestant churches across southern Ontario, the study concludes that “the theological conservatism of both attendees and clergy emerged as important factors in predicting church growth.”

“Our data demonstrate that within our sample, theological differences do matter for church growth,” they write. “…These associations hold even when church age, clergy age, congregant age, and the presence of conflict in the congregation are controlled for and other variables related to growth (such as worship style, youth emphasis, and clarity of purpose) are held constant.”

Though Haskell and Flattplan to develop 5 academic papers from theirdata, the current study doesn’t seek to uncover an underlying explanation as towhy the trend exists, nor does it aim to explore the other ripple effects to social witness. But for those who believe the church bears a distinct social responsibility, there’s a second overlapping and intersecting question that’s well worth asking: How might a church’s mitments and priorities impact its public voice and influence?

In his epilogue to The Church’s Social Responsibility:Reflections on Evangelicalism and Social Justice, Flatt offers a separate set of reflections on this point. Unlike thestudy on church growth, the essay doesn’t rely on survey data, but it does point us to a strong historical case study from mainline Protestantism. Titled “A Cautionary Tale,” the essay sets its focus on the United Church of Canada, a denomination that has suffered a decline in recent years, not only in church attendance and participation, but also in social influence and political witness.

In the mid-19thcentury, Flatt explains, Canada’s Methodist and Presbyterian bodies “formed the backbone of Canadian evangelicalism, mitted to biblical authority and deathly serious about the proclamation of a gospel of eternal salvation at home and abroad.” Yet after a series of theological squabbles, due in part to the rise of modernity peting ideologies of progress, many saw the “social gospel” of the early 20th century as a convenient path to unity:

Social activism of various kinds had a long history in evangelicalism, but by making the central purpose of the church the “salvation of society”—the amelioration of social conditions through activism—the social gospel bypassed awkward doctrinal discussions. Preachers could stick to the Sermon on the Mount and selections of the Minor Prophets and avoid theological showdowns with their congregations. Ministers whose theological education had shorn them of belief in original sin or the deity of Christ could still find their purpose in urban planning reform or women’s suffrage. Above all, the social gospel allowed the churches to focus on something practical and avoid what was often labeled fruitless controversy.

Thus, the United Church of Canada was created in 1925, formed largely to “pursue social reform on a national scale,” Flatt explains. This would be “a church defined by mitment to social justice.”

Over time, however, the church’s overt emphasis on social activism allowed for the creep of theological liberalism into its pews. By the 1960s, leaders were boldly questioning the virgin birth, the existence of hell, and whether Jesus was the Son of God or the only way to God and heaven. The result was a unified political ideology of little distinction with the secular Left, paired withtheological disorder in the guise of “diversity” and a decline in church attendance and participation. “A United Church that will take a firm stance to boycott goods produced by Israeli settlements in the West Bank, but won’t rebuke a moderator who denies Christ’s deity and resurrection, simply doesn’t attract much support as a church,” Flatt writes. “…If current trends continue, the United Church, formed to be the social conscience of a nation, will not have any members left to celebrate its 125th birthday.”

Yet the United Church’s over-elevation of social activism needn’t be taken a warning against social activism in general, just as we shouldn’t fall prey to the assumption that such risks e into play with left-leaning or progressive political and social ideologies. Instead, we should embrace the social role and voice of the church even as we stay wary of what Flatt describes as “the danger of well-intentioned activism being taken captive by cultural currents foreign to the gospel.”

“It is easy for churches to have their activism hijacked by alien ideologies, whether of the Left or of the Right or of some other configuration,” he writes. Churches must remain aware of those risks and avoid similar pitfalls, working to “cultivate a robust spiritual life and a thoroughly biblical social witness through what might be called a chain of faithfulness.” This chain, he continues, consists of the following ponents (quoted directly from Flatt):

Vibrant, orthodox local churches, willing to reject any gods other than the God of the Bible, shaped by the Word and the sacraments, saturated in prayer, and in general formed by liturgies and practices strong enough to counteract those of the surrounding culture.Trained elders (clergy), including seminary professors and administrators, absolutely faithful to God and their trust, serious about and skilled in the obedient interpretation and exposition of Scripture munion with the historic and global church, and held accountable by the church.Lay experts, immersed in the life of the church and the teaching of the elders, who can develop, from biblical foundations and the tradition of the church, Christian proposals regarding the pressing social and political issues of the day.Faithful social and political action by the church (institutional and organic…), guided by the voices of these experts.

The order of priorities here is important, as is the bigger picture of the integrated whole, which requires a mix of healthy relationships, sound teaching, robust institutions, and organic, spirit-led initiative, whether among individuals munities.

Getting each link right won’t be easy – it surely hasn’t been easy – but at minimum, we’d do well to reorient ourhearts, minds, and imaginations aroundthe basic premise.

“Activism that disregards Scripture or church tradition, or that is not rooted in worship and Word and sacrament, or that does not arise from careful thinking by well-trained Christians knowledgeable in their fields, may be quick and easy,” Flatt concludes, “but in the end it will ape culturally dominant patterns of secular activism, and the salt will lose its savor.”

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Resource Page on Pope Benedict XVI’s Resignation
Today Pope Benedict XVI issued a statement that he was renouncing his ministry as the Bishop of Rome, effectively abdicating as of February 28, 2013. The Acton Institute has created a resource page that will provide news and analysis of this historic event, and the election of a new pope. You can find the current resources and follow future updates here. ...
Rev. Sirico on ‘The Blaze’: Catholic Bishops Reject New HHS Concessions
Rev. Robert Sirico appeared on the February 8 edition of “The Blaze” to discuss the revisions to the HHS mandate announced by the White House on January 20. The following video features a brief part of Rev. Sirico’s contribution to the show. You may see the entire piece by going to The Blaze TV website and signing up for a free 14-day trial. ...
Video: Samuel Gregg’s talk at Heritage Foundation on ‘Becoming Europe’
“We’re ing like Europe” captures many Americans’ sense that something has changed in American economic life since the Great Recession’s onset in 2008. An economy once characterized mitments to economic liberty, rule of law, limited government, and personal responsibility appears to be drifting in a distinctly “European” direction. Across the Atlantic, Americans see European economies faltering under enormous debt; overburdened welfare states; high taxation; heavily regulated labor markets; aging populations; large numbers of public-sector workers; and governments controlling close to...
Historian David McCullough on Work and the Pursuit of Happiness
Pulitzer Prize-winning historian David McCullough is author of popular biographies such as Truman and John Adams, and at 79 years old, he’s still going strong. When asked by Harvard Business Review whether he is ready to retire, McCullough offered some interesting perspective on how he views his work through the American founders’ understanding of the “pursuit of happiness” (HT): I can’t wait to get out of bed every morning. To me, it’s the only way to live. When the founders...
After Pope Benedict Resigns, Fight Against ‘Dictatorship of Relativism’ Goes On
Today, Acton’s Rome office and the world were stunned by what the Dean of the College of Cardinals said was a “bolt out of the blue”: just after midday Benedict XVI informed the public that he would be stepping down as the Catholic Church’s pontiff and one of the world’s preeminent moral and spiritual leaders, effective on February 28. He will be the first pope to abdicate voluntarily the Seat of St. Peter in nearly 600 years. The last one...
Pope Benedict Resigns
Shock waves went through Rome at about noon today and the rest of the Catholic, make that the entire, world, as news came that Pope Benedict XVI will resign as Pope on February 28. We’ll have much more from Rome about this tremendous, unprecedented event (Pope Gregory XII resigned in 1415 in very different circumstances). Here’s what Pope Benedict had to say about a Pope resigning in the 2010 interview Light of the World: Q:The great majority of [the sexual...
Rev. Sirico on Pope Benedict XVI’s Resignation
The Rev. Robert Sirico offers his thoughts on the announcement this morning from Pope Benedict XVI that he is resigning from the papal office as of February 28. It is a sobering thought to think that the last time a Pope resigned (Pope Gregory XII in 1415), America had not yet been discovered. Yes, the possibility of a Pope’s resignation is anticipated in Canon Law (Canon 332), as long as it is disclosed “properly” and of his own free will....
‘He feels like he has been left behind in some way’
Kishore Jayabalan, Director of Istituto Acton in Rome, gave an interview today with Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty regarding the resignation of Pope Benedict XVI. While the pope cited his health as the reason he was stepping down, Jayabalan was asked if there were other contributing factors. He does also talk about the pace of global media and politics and events today. So it’s also the circumstances that are surrounding his age and ill-health. I believe what he says, that the...
Pope Benedict: The Capitalist System is Virtuous
Reflecting on the pontificate of Pope Benedict XVI, Philip Booth, professor at Cass Business School in London, says the pope was clear on his economic ideas. As he said in Caritas in Veritate: “Economy and finance, as instruments, can be used badly when those at the helm are motivated by purely selfish ends. But it is man’s darkened reason that produces these consequences, not the instrument per se”. In other words, credit derivative swaps are not evil, but those who...
Samuel Gregg: ‘Benedict XVI: Reason’s Revolutionary’
Over on National Review Online, Acton Research Director Samuel Gregg considers what will be Pope Benedict’s last legacy: In ing weeks, there will be mentaries on what this Pope has achieved in a relatively short time. This ranges from his efforts to root out what Ratzinger once called the “filth” of sexual deviancy that has inflicted such damage on the priesthood, his successful outreach to Catholicism’s Eastern Orthodox brothers, his generally excellent bishop appointments, to his reforms of the liturgy....
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved