Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Russell Moore on socialism: How should Christians think about it?
Russell Moore on socialism: How should Christians think about it?
Apr 5, 2025 6:03 PM

A plurality of American Christians now believes that capitalism is at odds with “Christian values,” a trend that’s been panied by a range of political leaders and Religious-Left thinkers who promote the patibility of Christianity with expansive state control. Paired with our culture’s growing interest in “democratic socialism,” such arguments are especially worthy of reflection.

In a new video, Russell Moore examines this debate, mon plaints against capitalism and asking, “Is socialism consistent with a Christian view of reality?”

While noting the more practical and historical failures of socialism, Moore focuses most of his attention on the theological and moral implications. This begins with a reckoning of the various moral challenges presented by modern-day capitalism.

Moore recognizes and affirms a range of these challenges—an inequality of es, continuous disruption and displacement by innovation and automation, the enabling of immoral products and industries, and so on. Yet in each of these areas, Moore argues, socialism fails to provide the proper recourse or response, serving instead to simply reassign human depravity to more impenetrable places and more passing levels of power and control.

Indeed, when we look at the Bible and the bigger-picture Christian vision for human destiny, we find some principles that can help guide us in structuring just political institutions and cultivating a framework for human flourishing.

“The Bible does not mandate a particular economic system and the Bible does not give us an economic blueprint,” Moore explains. “But the Bible does reveal some principles.

I have excerpted key sections of Moore’s explanation below, organizing them into several key ideas (my own paraphrasing/interpretation of his argument):

1. The Bible promotes the notion of private property.

There is such a thing as private property. Even in the Ten Commandments—“you shall not steal”—in order to steal, there has to be a connection between what you have and what you don’t have, what belongs to you or what belongs to your family and someone else. You can see that even in the injustice that is done with Ahab taking the land of Naboth in 1 Kings 21. This is Naboth’s property; it’s his inheritance that’s being taken away. And that’s consistent with the rest of the Bible. Adam is created with a connection between his labor and his life. “You will bring forth bread from the ground.” Jesus indicates that that’s pointing to something even more primal. “I see what my Father is doing, and I share in that.”

2. The Bible promotes generosity munity—which are different from state control.

When e to the New Testament, some people will say, “Look, you have the early church. They are sharing their resources.” Yes, but this is not state action. This is voluntary—the work of the spirit within people who are forming a counterculture. So you see, for instance, Ananias and Sapphira, who are struck dead because they lied about having some property and some money that they didn’t bring into that counterculture. The issue is not that they were being coerced into some sort munistic system. Simon Peter says that’s not the case. “You would not have had to do this, but you lied to the Holy Spirit.” The issue is they are giving an appearance that isn’t actually the case.

3. The Bible reveals certain limitations on the state.

The Bible reveals limits on the state. It doesn’t detail those limits, but you have a clear limitation both in Romans 13, with what the state is given to do, and in terms of demonstrations of when the state oversteps those bounds, in Revelation 13.

4. Human depravity isn’t limited to “private” human action or enterprises.

If we understand human depravity, that means that, yes, we are going to have a suspicion about what we can do in businesses. Nobody who has a clear-eyed view of human nature would say that the market is morally neutral or that everything the market does will be morally right. But if we have a clear-eyed view of human nature, we would also say the state also is not exempt from that. What happens in socialism is that the state tends to e nearly passing in dealing with the economic aspect of life in a way that just doesn’t work. Why? Because it’s driven by an ideology that attempts to see the world through a purely economic lens…It’s an ideology rather than a prudential understanding of how the world works.

As is evident in each of these points, for the Christian, the proper alternative to socialism is not simply “more capitalism,” but rather, “more capitalism, better embodied and inhabited.” As Moore explains, we will still face a number of challenges within a free market, whether it be the pain, struggle, and suffering in tough jobs petitive industries or the temptation to look inward rather than outward.

Throughout history, socialism has failed and capitalism has succeeded, in many cases despite whatever virtues or vices existed in the culture at large. But while capitalism may prove better at “managing” our depravity, it also offers us the freedom to pursue much more. Within a context of economic freedom, Christians will encounter new temptations, to be sure, but we will also have more opportunity respond accordingly—embracing a call to creativity, stewardship, and value creation that breathes with the extravagant generosity of the Gospel.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Peter Jackson’s World War I film is superb
In 1909, the British scholar and later Nobel Peace Prize winner, Sir Norman Angell, published a short pamphlet entitled Europe’s Optical Illusion. Subsequently republished a year later as The Great Illusion, Angell argued that the economic cost of a mass war in the industrial capitalist world would be so great, that, if it happened at all, it would be momentary. Angell also thought that the integration of capitalist economies across national boundaries which prevailed at the time made the likelihood...
The libertine road to serfdom
The Sexual State: How Elite Ideologies Are Destroying Lives and Why The Church Was Right All Along. Jennifer Roback Morse, Ph.D. TAN Books, 2018. 406 pages. Reviewed by Rev. Ben Johnson Keen-eyed analysts have probed every ideological trend threatening liberty – from socialism and fascism to the Alt-Right – with one glaring exception: the revolt against personal responsibility. Jennifer Roback Morse, the founder of the Ruth Institute,capably fills this void in The Sexual State. Building on her previous book Love...
A world of economic miracles: The power of human cooperation
Surrounded by economic abundance, it can be easy to be distracted by what we see—products, tools, technology, resources—and assume our newfound prosperity stems from material causes. In turn, given the stability of many institutions and the increasing pace of innovation, continuous economic progress now seems somewhat inevitable. Economists like Deirdre McCloskey have challenged such notions, pointing instead to the power of rhetoric, virtues, and ideas to shape all else. It takes a special something to cultivate a society wherein basic...
Socialism, by any other name
At the end of January I had the pleasure to speak with my friend of many years Ricardo Ball about the ongoing crisis in Venezuela. The conversation was livestreamed from the Acton Institute allowing an international audience to listen in as we discussed recent developments from the streets of Caracas. The conversation is still available for viewing on our livestream page. The tragic case of Venezuela is but one in a seemingly endless series of failures of socialism from which...
Cronyism and conservatives
A major problem with America’s economy is what’s often called “crony capitalism” or simply “cronyism.” In other places, I’ve defined cronyism as the situation in which free markets are hollowed out and replaced by political markets. Businesses e less interested in meeting consumer demand and much more focused on extracting privileges, favor, grants, etc., from the state. When people speak about “the Swamp,” cronyism is often what they have in mind. Economic entrepreneurship gets displaced by political entrepreneurship. With good...
Explainer: What you should know about Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez’s Green New Deal
What exactly is the Green New Deal? Yesterday Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) released a proposed resolution titled, “Recognizing the duty of the Federal Government to create a Green New Deal.” The document is a simple resolution, a proposal that addresses matters entirely within the prerogative of the House of Representatives. It requires neither the approval of the Senate nor the signature of the President, and it does not have the force of law. Simple resolutions concern the rules of one...
Venezuelan Cardinal stands down Maduro’s Vatican mediation request
The Venezuelan bishop of Merida and current apostolic administrator of Caracas, Cardinal Baltazar Porras Cardozo, stood tall and firm while rejecting the validity of President Nicolas Maduro’s recent appeal for Vatican diplomacy. Maduro had written to the pope this week seeking his help amid an escalating violent opposition to his socialist government which has all but destroyed the country’s economy and thrust millions of people into abject poverty. Cardinal Porras publicly denounced Maduro’s letter to Pope Francis – of which...
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez’s Green New Deal is the same old socialist hooey
Official Washington is all atwitter today over the release of the “Green New Deal” by New York freshman Democrat Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Massachusetts Senator Ed Markey, also a Democrat. The proposal bundles many long-desired goals of the environmentalist movement into a neat legislative package, described by left-leaning Vox in this way: The resolution consists of a preamble, five goals, 14 projects, and 15 requirements. The preamble establishes that there are two crises, a climate crisis and an economic crisis...
How San Fransisco’s housing policy makes it harder for the homeless
I recently highlighted California’s counterproductive restrictionson private efforts to feed the homeless. But the state’s policies aren’t just inhibiting the bottom-up activities of non-profits and charities. They’re also restricting potential solutions via entrepreneurial investment. Alas, many municipalities have severely restricted new residential development, causing the housing supply to diminish and the cost of living to soar. In a city like San Francisco, such an approach has led to the highest rents in the world and a housing market wherein 81%...
A rule of thumb for the Green New Deal
I have a couple rules of thumb that I hope help me cut through some of the noise around various policy proposals and political debates. One has to do with budgetary reform (a topic I covered at some length last week): If the plan doesn’t engage with entitlements, then it isn’t really a serious proposal. The same goes for policies that have to do with environmental stewardship, and particularly those focused on lowering carbon emissions. If nuclear power isn’t a...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved