Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Rhode Island makes it difficult to suspend students
Rhode Island makes it difficult to suspend students
Mar 16, 2026 7:26 PM

The current problems with the school-to-prison pipeline often start with poor school discipline policies. Various school discipline policies and tactics have e under criticism for being overly harsh—often causing students to drop out of school. The frequent use of suspension and expulsion for minor offenses has monplace in many schools across the country.

Over the summer Gina Raimondo, the Democratic governor of Rhode Island, signed a bill into law making it harder for schools to suspend students for minor infractions. The law creates stricter guidelines for when students can be sent home from school in order to lower the number of suspensions. High suspension rates are just one of the contributing factors to the school-to-prison pipeline. A Febuary 2015 study by The Center for Civil Rights Remedies looked at some of the contributing factors to the problem and how the policies affect different parts of the population.

Data cited in the report found that most suspensions occur in secondary school and are rarely used in younger grades. Students who had a disability were suspended twice as much as non-disabled students in the 2009-10 school year. One out of 3 students with an emotional disturbance were suspended.

The data on the types of students most often suspended shows part of the problem in discipline, that is, suspension often replaces needed intervention for at-risk students. If suspension is used as a primary form of punishment it does not encourage growth but instead increases chances of dropout and delinquency. For example, being suspended once in 9th grade doubles a student’s chance of dropping out. Minority students were most often the recipients of suspensions and therefore recipients of the increased chances of delinquent behavior outside of school.

The study says that myths fuel the pipeline, especially mon perception that suspension is reserved for major offenses. Most suspensions are actually for minor offenses. In California, the report found that most suspensions occurred for disruption and defiance, while major offenses monly punished through expulsion. Instead of deterring behavior, suspension was found to reward misbehaving students. They found that school involvement was the best way to discourage delinquency. In other words, keeping students in school helped keep them out of trouble outside of school. The rising number of suspensions actually increased delinquency and contributed to problems in school safety.

The crisis in suspension is one of the leading contributors to the school-to-prison pipeline where the main victims are minority, disabled, and emotionally disturbed students. Without changes to how we discipline students, and more involvement from parents in the discipline process, the school-to-prison pipeline will continue to hurt the most disadvantaged in munities. Some might argue that public schools are simply ing extensions of America’s growing police state tendencies.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
A victory for socialism? The Israeli Kibbutz
While eating lunch at an Israeli Kibbutz last winter, I learned firsthand about what used to be a self-contained, munity. I was struck by the local guide’s positive view of socialism, believing it to produce munal life and economic prosperity. The guide’s praise only echoes A.I. Rabin and Benjamin Beit-Hallahmi from Michigan State University who wrote that “[t]he most successful attempt at building a mune has been the Israeli Kibbutz.” The optimism expressed by these observations is not without cause...
Alejandro Chafuen in Forbes: Opus Dei and Jesuit priests against socialism
For most of the 20th century, Marxism set its sights on state authority and openly political and economic goals. In more recent decades, though, many proponents of Marxism and other socialist stripes have sought to sow change on a societal and cultural level – a trend which some have termed “cultural Marxism.” Two authors who not only condemned Marxism but also saw its cultural transition early on are Monsignor Fernando Ocáriz Braña, current prelate of Opus Dei, and Rev. Enrique...
One nation under debt
The federal debt is a risk to our future. The nation’s growing debt will weaken our economy and threaten our safety and security. Unfortunately, politicians either avoid the issue or suggest reforms that sound good but can’t solve the problem. However, there is a way forward if we act soon, note John Cogan, Daniel Heil, and John Raisian. ...
Uruguay’s dignifying prison: Entrepreneurship as rehabilitation
The United States faces significant challenges when es to prisoner rehabilitation. According to a recent study, more than 700,000 prisoners are released annually from federal and state prisons. Unfortunately, “within three years, 40 percent will be reincarcerated.” To curb that trend, we’ve seen a range of efforts to improve correctional education and find better ways of supporting prisoners in their journeys toward social reconnection. Yet one of the most effective and inspiring examples is found in a country not typically...
Bernie Sanders’s workers wanted $15 an hour—so he cut their hours
On Friday I mentioned the ongoing labor dispute between the workers and management of Bernie Sanders’s presidential campaign. The longtime advocate of raising the federal minimum to $15 an hour is finding that it’s easy plain about greedy employers until you e the one having to make payroll. Presidential campaigns are labor intensive and require an army of low-skilled workers who are willing to work long hours performing rote and mundane task. But as Sanders has discovered, paying for such...
How ideologues devalue and dismiss economics
Economics is often dismissed as ideological, reductionist, and mendacious. In the United States we see these criticisms increasingly from both the political left and right. This e as no surprise as the lessons of economicshave implications for the prudential decisions that make up much of our political life. Ideologues of all parties chafe at constraints. Carl Menger, one of the driving forces behind the marginal revolution in economics, was no stranger to these sorts of criticism. His essay, ‘The Social...
Video: Bruce Riley Ashford on religious liberty in a secular age
The Acton Lecture Series resumed on July 18 with a lecture by Bruce Riley Ashford, provost and professor of theology and culture at Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary, speaking on the subject of how to maintain respect for religious liberty in a rapidly secularizing culture. The West has been going through a process whereby all references to God must be stripped from the public square, and religion itself is increasingly seen as implausible or obsolete. Ashford tackles the tough question of...
Culture and creativity: Thoughts on our environment
Between a summer heatwave in the United States and Europe and a recent speech by President Trump, the topic of climate and environmental policy and conditions has been even more prominent than usual lately. Having spent most of the past year as a Fulbright postgraduate scholar in Australia, including a very hot summer during which the Green New Deal proposal was announced, I’ve been recently reminded of a conversation I had with another scholar on the topic of climate and...
Bernie Sanders: The apologist for inequality
Since Bernie Sanders announced his candidacy for president in the 2020 election, he has brought a seemingly disastrous and looming problem to the attention of the American people, much like he did in his 2016 run: e inequality panied by the tyrannical rule of the elite 1%. Why did someone who seems to be so radical have such a big influence on the Democratic primary in 2016, and have such support in this new race? It’s because he took something...
Explainer: Who is Boris Johnson?
Boris Johnson, a champion of free trade and lower taxes, will serve as the next prime minister of the UK beginning on Wednesday, July 24. Officials announced on Tuesday that Johnson won 66.4 percent of the Conservative Party’s popular vote, besting rival Jeremy Hunt 92,153 votes to 46,656. In his victory speech, Johnson thanked his opponent, Jeremy Hunt, for being “a font of good idaeas, all of which I propose to steal,.” He also praised outgoing Prime Minister Theresa May...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved