Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Review: Blue Collar Intellectuals
Review: Blue Collar Intellectuals
Jan 27, 2026 3:38 PM

“Stupid is the new smart,” and “Pop culture is a wasteland” are just a few lines from Daniel J. Flynn’s introduction to Blue Collar Intellectuals: When the Enlightened and the Everyman Elevated America. Certainly, one does not need to read Flynn’s account to surmise that there are grave problems with our culture. But many would miss some great stories and a return to a people and time that crafted a great uplifting for mass audiences.

Flynn has profiled six intellectuals or thinkers who sprung out of the immigrant backgrounds and / or a working “blue collar” origins. They opened up and popularized the great works, theories, and conversations of Western Civilization for the everyman. It seems it is of little coincidence that in profiling Mortimer Adler, Eric Hoffer, Ray Bradbury, Will and Ariel Durant, and Milton Friedman, Flynn touches on diverse streams of thought such as history, literature, economics, philosophy, and popular story teller. Flynn laments that we do not see these type of public intellectuals today and we are surrounded by passive and meaningless entertainment that not only debases but detaches us from the great ideas and mon heritage.

Will and Ariel Durant popularized history with their widely popular 11-volume The Story of Civilization. Flynn lauds them as writers who “extracted history from the academic ghetto whither it had retreated, opening the conversation about the past to ers.”

Mortimer Adler, piled The Great Books of the Western World set, once quipped, “The only education I got at Columbia was in one course.” That course studied the classic works of Western Civilization and Adler sought to package them for mass consumption. A brilliant mind, Adler received a Ph.D from Columbia without ever receiving a high school diploma, bachelor’s, or master’s degree. Adler held a disinterest and disdain for the academic bubble, and in turn academics turned their noses up at his work for packaging and popularizing the great works. “The Great Books Movement, for better or worse, offered education minus the middleman. It is no wonder the middleman objected so vociferously,” says Flynn.

The idea that somebody who took on entrepreneurial endeavors and worked a myriad of jobs in the economy might make a better or more notable economist makes sense. But it’s not always the case, when one looks at say the lifelong academic John Maynard Keynes. Flynn notes what many free marketers already know about Milton Friedman and that is he “waited tables, peddled socks door-to-door, and manned roadside fireworks stands. He attended the public schools and lived in rent controlled apartments.” Friedman harnessed his experiences, professorship, books, a “Newsweek” column, and a PBS series to popularize libertarian free-market economic principles. He transformed public policy and much of the economic lingo and ideas we borrow today es from the free-market economist.

Eric Hoffer, the longshoremen philosopher, was the favorite author of President Dwight D. Eisenhower. His book The True Believer covers the psychology of mass movements. “Hoffer’s patriotism stemmed from the belief that America was the workingman’s country. That the everyman became president hardly proved America’s mediocrity; it proved the excellence of the American everyman,” says Flynn.

Ray Bradbury, still writing, and most noted for Fahrenheit 451, could not afford college. He has proudly said that he is an alumnus of the Los Angeles Public Library. Bradbury glamorized small town Midwestern life and the significance of books, while slamming the detached superficial culture that suffers from a lack of education and critical thinking.

Flynn has weaved together some wonderful stories to remind us that great culture and deeper ideas are accessible to the masses. I have often wondered how some history professors could turn a lively and passionate subject boring. History, and other academic subjects, have too often been turned into gender-bending, “evil colonialist” type studies, eschewing much of the established work of Western Civilization. They deliberately use their own inner language and codes. “The ivory tower has e a tower of babble,” Flynn says.

He makes the easy case that a vapid society is objectionable and bankrupt of purpose, meaning, and ideas. He also highlights the less known significance on society of six influential thinkers, who because of their background, were able to help uplift the masses to the great ideas and release those ideas from an academic ghetto. Outside of Friedman, I did not know much about these figures and the stories he tells are lively and I did not realize how some of these thinkers already had had an influence on me. Growing up, my family had the set of The Great Books of the Western World, so it was fascinating to hear the story behind it.

As somebody with a divinity degree, and as an observer of ministry and churches, I thought about this problem in our faith culture. Today, there is a serious issue with the need to see Church as a form of entertainment first. Too often churches reflect the very same problems that plague our culture. There is little use for serious deeper reflection in some churches, and little use for the study of doctrine and traditions. The consequences are that confusion abounds today about what Christianity teaches and its transformative power. A revival and renewal is not just needed in culture, but in many of our churches too. There is a great need for teachers and preachers to deliver that word in days such as these as well.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Just a Minute: Tracy Letts’ new drama defies logic and plausibility
When a Pulitzer- and Tony Award–winning playwright can’t get his historical facts straight, there must be a reason. It can’t be as simple as all Native Americans are interchangeable, can it? Read More… In the past 90 years, there have been three periods during which the American intelligentsia has been dominated by the most radical leftists. The first was in the Great Depression. This was when it monplace to say that capitalism had failed and the great hope of the...
Norm Macdonald is gone and there’s nothing funny about that
edian’s last Netflix special was recorded in his home by himself during COVID lockdown, out of concern he would not live long enough to tape it before an audience. What he has to say in these 86 minutes is more than ics manage in their entire careers. Read More… Norm Macdonald was the edian in his time among those who stayed out of political controversies. His specialty was pointing out how fortable we are facing the reality of our human...
Your job is not your vocation
What we do to sustain life and what we’re called to do for the good of the gospel and our neighbor are two different things. But the first can be put in the service of the second. Read More… It is sometimes claimed—wrongly—that until the Reformation, the only vocations known to Christian teaching were monastic and/or clerical. One might be called to a monastery or called to the priesthood, but ordinary work, family life, secular singleness—these are the things of...
The Catholic Church is the West’s best ally in the Pacific
The tiny region of North Bougainville in Papua New Guinea may not be on many people’s radars, but it could hold the key to the West staving off further Chinese aggression in the Pacific. But the West will need help. Enter the Catholic Church. Read More… It was the Cold War, and Portugal’s empire was collapsing. The dictatorial regime established by António de Oliveira Salazar was enduring a revolution, and thus the once great colonial enterprise that ruled some of...
Twitter will be no worse with owner Elon Musk, and probably no better
Who buys the 17th-most-popular social media platform in the world is a cause of great concern to relatively few people, who unfortunately have the loudest voices. That’s the real problem, and one Musk almost certainly cannot fix. Read More… Elon Musk has already created the first truly successful electric car. He wants pany SpaceX to put men on Mars. Musk himself has occasionally joked that he wants to die on Mars, just not on impact. Successfully landing and establishing an...
Fix America’s broken schools before it’s too late
A new book is very good at pinpointing what’s gone wrong with our public school system. However, when es to concrete solutions, it’s missing in action. Conservatives especially need to do better if their voices are going to be heard. Read More… There’s a currently a revolution erupting in public school districts across the country. For quite some time, students haven’t been learning, teachers haven’t been teaching, and educational leaders have only been making things worse. In response, parents have...
Income inequality is not a problem for government to fix
Taxing the rich to make others richer is a recipe for e stagnation, petition. Read More… Implicit in concerns about rising e inequality is a critique of the underlying system that generated that inequality: a free market regulated petition. In a free market, people are rewarded with earnings that correspond to the value they create for others. For this to happen, however, everyone ideally has an equal opportunity to earn an ever expanding e. The perceived problem is that such...
The Right look at American conservatism deserves your attention
In his new book, Matthew Continetti details the 100-year history of the battles between the “Right” and conservatives, between populism and neoconservatism. In short, there were more than a few Donald Trumps before 2016, and Conservatism Inc. isn’t dead yet. Read More… In January of 1992, the libertarian theorist Murray Rothbard published an untimely reflection in the traditionalist journal Chronicles. The conservative and Republican elite had effectively scuttled former Klansman David Duke’s bid to e governor of Louisiana. In the...
Chinese oppression of the Uyghurs goes global
Even when this ethnic and religious minority finds safe haven outside China, the Chinese Communist Party still manages to harass and threaten them. The United States, as well as other nations of goodwill, should not tolerate the exporting of repression by a foreign power. Read More… Under Xi Jinping, the People’s Republic of China (PRC) has returned to its Maoist past. Both Xi and Mao Zedong promoted party and especially personal rule. Both sought to extinguish even the hint of...
Jurassic World: Dominion is transhumanism as entertainment
If only men weren’t necessary for reproduction is the theme of the latest installment in the Jurassic World trilogy. Fun for the whole family, so long as, you know, there are no dads. (And yes, spoiler alert.) Read More… There’s a new Jurassic World movie out in theaters, to round up the post-Spielberg trilogy that began in 2015 and continued in 2018, a long time for a trilogy these days—the Star Wars sequel trilogy came out in four years, as...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved