Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Rev. Robert Sirico: Dialogue With Pope Must Include Free Markets
Rev. Robert Sirico: Dialogue With Pope Must Include Free Markets
Mar 18, 2025 10:24 PM

In today’s Roll Call, Acton Institute president Rev. Robert ments on Pope Francis’ September visit to the U.S. and what may be part of the dialogue when the pope is here. While the media tabulates the pontiff’s popularity on certain topics, Sirico says there are more important things to note.

Popularity ratings may be important for politicians but not for a pope believed to be the successor to St. Peter and the Vicar of Christ on earth.

His job is to preserve the truths of the Faith, not put them up for a vote.

The Church is not a democracy, whereby some polling data could alter the content of the Church’s doctrine the way McDonald’s might alter the ingredients in a Big Mac.

The polling data is sandwiched between the pope’s trip to Cuba and the U.S., and the June 2015 release of his papal encyclical on the environment, Laudato Si’. The encyclical is critical of the role of markets, in their effects on both the environment and the poor. This is where Sirico raises some important questions.

How can a faithful Catholic, who also believes that freer markets make for less poverty, put together a disconnect between what the pope wants for the poor and the proven means of getting them out of poverty? No doubt these kinds of controversies have their role to play in how favorably Americans view the pope, but it does not explain the loss in his favorable ratings on the part of progressives who would cheer on his broadsides against an ‘economy that kills.’ Perhaps they have worked out that Pope Francis is, after all, a Catholic.

Of course the pope is going to speak out about the protection of the environment and the need for proper stewardship. His predecessors have done the same. And any follower of Christ must be adamant in defending the poor and voiceless. But when people begin to get the impression that matters they take seriously are ignored or superficially dismissed — or when a variety of legitimate views are not invited into the conversation about the economy and poverty — it is hard to have any meaningful dialogue.

Sirico ends mentary with the hope that the pope’s apparent “bias against free markets” will not denounce free markets outright, but that Francis can shape his message in a way that allows for an understanding that gives:

greater meaning to life than profits forts; that technology can be employed to ease the plight of the poor and help to clean the environment; that the solution to poverty is creativity in and freeing of the market rather than suggesting that ‘[t]he alliance between the economy and technology ends up sidelining anything unrelated to its immediate interests.’

Isn’t it precisely bination of a free economy, rooted in a moral culture that takes truth seriously, the rule of law, and technology that is in good part responsible for a much cleaner environment, safer births, and longer life spans?

In order to do this, Sirico points out, there must be on-going dialogue, and he es that. Let’s hope the pope does as well.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Right to Work: The UAW and Planned Parenthood Make Common Cause
Video: UAW President Bob King thanks Planned Parenthood, environmentalists, clergy, et al., at anti Right-To-Work Protest looks at the — at first blush as least — strange alliance between the United Auto Workers union and Planned Parenthood on the Michigan Right to Work issue. Elise Hilton of the Acton Institute, interviewed by LifeSiteNews reporter Kirsten Andersen, says that the UAW, Planned Parenthood and other like minded groups are afraid that right-to-work laws will help defund the progressive agenda. “I don’t...
Ikaria and the Inseparability of Individual and Communal Flourishing
The New York Times has a fascinating profile on Ikaria, a Greek island located about 30 miles off the western coast of Turkey. With roughly 8,000 inhabitants, the island is known for its slow and relaxed lifestyle, munities, and healthy citizenry. As Ikarian physician Dr. Ilias Leriadis says in the article: “Have you noticed that no one wears a watch here? …We simply don’t care about the clock here.” Brendan Case offers a good summary of the article at Call...
‘Goodbye, Taiwan’: No Babies Means No Economic Base
It’s no secret that certain parts of the world have been losing population for some time. The tightly-controlled Chinese birthrate is the first thing es to most minds regarding this topic. However, large parts of Asia, Europe and now even the United States are beginning to see clear danger signs when es to economies and low birth rates. Taiwan’s birthrate is “dropping like a stone…” says an editorial in the Taipei Times. The majority of people realize there is a...
‘Markets Don’t Make Capitalism’
Earlier this week Dylan Pahman reflected on the question, “Which capitalism?” He helpfully explores the nature of capitalism and the importance of definitions. This conversation reminded me of a point made by Michael Novak during his conversation with Rev. Sirico earlier this year at Acton University. In the Q&A session, he argues that it is essential to understand the nature of what distinguishes capitalism from other economic systems: Novak says that “markets don’t make capitalism,” but rather that “enterprise, invention,...
Two Christian Views on Right to Work
MLive asked Rev. Robert Sirico and Peter Vander Meulen, a coordinator of the Christian Reformed Church in North America’s Office of Social Justice, ment on Michigan’s new Right to Work law. Meulen says that the change won’t have much impact on the state’s economy but will adversely affect relations between Republicans and Democrats on “just budget priorities” such as Medicaid and energy: In one fell swoop, with a policy that doesn’t have much effect, we have just trashed an entire...
The Poverty Trap in France
In France, more than half ofthe population benefits directly or indirectly from welfare payments. Not surprisingly, the result has been that that the poverty rate for the past twenty years has remained unchanged. “Despite its good intentions,” saysSylvain Charat, “welfareship has created a ‘poverty trap.’” Let’s take an unemployed mother living alone with two children between six and 10 years old. In 2010, there were 284,445 French families in this situation that were on welfare. This mother will be given...
Wealth and Political Rhetoric in Ancient Christian Perspective
Last Thursday, NPR ran an interesting piece by Alan Greenblat that featured the perspective of several of the nation’s rich (read: annual household e over $250,000) in relation to President Obama’s determination that the Bush era tax increases end for the nation’s rich as part of any deal related to the looming “fiscal cliff.” The article features a variety of perspectives, but I would like to reflect upon one particular section of that article here. Greenblat writes, [Mark] Anderson recognizes...
Be Fruitful, Multiply, and Grow the Economy
In one of the most memorable mid-1990s episodes of The Simpsons, the curmudgeonly misanthrope Charles Montgomery Burns achieves a lifelong dream: Since the beginning of time, man has yearned to destroy the sun. I shall do the next best thing: block it out. While Mr. Burns had no use for our nearest star, the other residents Springfield were dismayed by the citywide sun-block. They understood, as Steve Martin once said, that “A day without sunshine is like, you know, night.”...
Two Catholic Views on Right to Work
On Friday I linked to MLive’s presentation of two Christian views on right to work. In that article, Rev. Sirico argued in favor of the legislation since it advances the freedom of workers. On the opposing side was Peter Vander Meulen of the Christian Reformed Church. Meulen didn’t argue against the morality of the law, but plained that it led to further political polarization and harmed the potential for bipartisan support on issues that “make life better for the large...
Today’s AU Online Lecture with Victor Claar Postponed
If you haven’t joined us for this lecture series yet, there’s still time! The final live session for the Globalization, Poverty, and Development AU Online series, Fair Trade vs. Free Trade, has been postponed. This means that you now have a few extra days to catch up on the lectures that we’ve already held before joining us next week for Victor Claar’s lecture on Tuesday, December 18, 2012. Also, if you’re interested in learning more about topics related to development,...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved