Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Religious toleration in a religious state
Religious toleration in a religious state
Mar 16, 2025 10:32 PM

The concepts of toleration espoused by theologians in the officially religious states of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries deserve closer examination. So argue Tobias Dienst and Christoph Strohm in their introduction to Martinus Becanus’s 1607 treatise, On the Duty to Keep Faith with Heretics. Becanus (1563–1624), a Dutch Jesuit theologian who became court confessor to the Holy Roman Emperor, lived in and supported an officially Roman Catholic state, but this did not prevent him from developing a concept of religious toleration that viewed the toleration of Protestants and other religious adherents as advancing the greater good of society.

This work is not principally a work on religious toleration. Becanus’s main concern is to defend the thesis “that it is morally obligatory to fulfill all contracts and promises unless they are against divine law or in another way invalid.” Specifically, Becanus shows that one must keep one’s promises and honor one’s contracts regardless of the religious views of the other party. Yet, as Dienst and Strohm point out, this principle “also applies to agreements granting religious tolerance to heretics.” The matter of religious toleration is thus a part of the moral question of whether, and in what circumstances, one must keep one’s promises. Like most writers in the tumultuous religious and political context of the early modern era, Becanus did not endorse religious freedom and freedom of conscience as goods to be pursued in themselves. This is clear from his stark denunciations of unqualified religious liberty. Yet, Becanus would change his views on toleration from the more restrictive stance he takes in this treatise. Dienst and Strohm sketch his movement from regarding toleration as permissible for preventing a greater evil in society (such as religious wars) to regarding toleration as permissible for achieving a greater good (such as the possible, future conversion of religious dissenters). The authors observe that this change in Becanus’s view “is a first step toward the idea of tolerance as possibly beneficial to society and not merely as an unpreventable nuisance.”

Theologians from this era typically supported the religious states that upheld their respective confessional persuasions, and these writers often defended the use of force against religious dissenters in those states. More liberal advocates of toleration and freedom of conscience, such as Sebastian Castellio (1515–1563), often had loose confessional affiliation or were in conflict with the Catholic or Protestant authorities. Dienst and Strohm note that in the study of the history of toleration writers like Castellio have received the bulk of attention as proto-moderns, leading many scholars to “skip the time between Castellio and the early Enlightenment altogether.” That’s a gap of roughly 200 years that included hundreds of authors who wrote about toleration, liberty of conscience, and religious freedom. Becanus is one of these overlooked authors—a Catholic writer who developed the concept of religious toleration within a Catholic state. On the Duty to Keep Faith with Heretics, therefore, helps to fill a gap in mon story of the rise of religious toleration in the West.

On the Duty to Keep Faith with Heretics, edited by Wim Decock and translated by Isabelle Buhre, is the first English translation of Becanus’s treatise De fide haereticis servanda and the latest volume in CLP Academic’s Sources in Early Modern Economics, Ethics, and Law series.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
DOJ: Banning the Homeless from Sleeping Outside Violates the Eighth Amendment’s ‘Cruel and Unusual Punishments’ Clause
While being homeless is not a crime, cities across America are increasingly making activities associated with a lack of shelter against the law. A survey of 187 cities found that 34 percent impose city-wide bans on camping in public and 18 percent impose city-wide bans on sleeping in public. In 2009, a group of homeless plaintiffs challenged the city of Boise, Idaho over its ordinance banning sleeping and camping in public places. This week the Department of Justice issued a...
Politics and Prophetic Distance: Russell Moore on the Power of a Gospel Community
Last week, I was pleased to attend the ERLC’s 2015 National Conference on Gospel and Politics, of whichthe Acton Institute was a proud co-sponsor. The speaker line-up was strikingly rich and diverse, ranging from pastors to writers to politicos to professors, but among them all, Russell Moore’s morning address was the clear stand-out. Moore beganby asking, “How do we as Christians engage in issues that sometimes are political without ing co-opted by politics and losing the gospel and the mission...
Seattle’s Minimum Wage Experiment is Already Failing
Last year when Seattle announced it was raising the minimum wage to $15 per hour, I made four predictions about how the policy would affect the city over the next three years. One of the predictions was that, Unemployment will increase for low-wage workers— It’s true that economists disagree about the effects of the minimum wage on employment and the living standards of minimum wage earners. But almost all of the disagreement is about relatively small increases—less than 20 percent....
Samuel Gregg on the ‘Seamless’ Ethic of Life
Cardinal Joseph Bernardin (1928-1996)At The Catholic World Report, Acton Research Director Samuel Gregg examines the use of the expression “a consistent ethic of life” — a phrase which has been used by Roman Catholic bishops as far back as a 1971 speech delivered by then-Archbishop Humberto Medeiros of Boston. More recently, Chicago Archbishop Blaise Cupich used the phrase in a Chicago Tribune article about the scandal of Planned Parenthood selling body-parts from aborted children. Elaborating, Cupich said “we should be...
5 Facts About Islamic State’s Theology of Rape
A year ago this month, Islamic State (also known as IS, ISIS, or ISIL) began a systematic program of capturing women and girls for the purposes of rape, forced marriage, and sexual slavery. Yesterday, the New York Times brought renewed attention to the war crimes in an article examining how IS enshrines a theology of rape. Here are five facts you should know about how IS views and justifies the practice of sexual slavery: 1.IS considers rape of sex slaves...
Why Do Intellectuals Hate Capitalism?
In an interview with Reason TV,Whole Foods co-founderJohn Mackey answers a rangeof questions about why so many intellectuals areopposed to the freemarket, whetherthroughouthistory and to this today. “Is it a misunderstanding of what business does?” asks Nick Gillespie. “Is it envy? Is it a lack of capacity to understand that what entrepreneurs do or what innovators do?” Here’s a sample: Intellectuals have always merce. That is something that tradesmen did; people that were in a lower class. And so you...
The Realism of S. L. Frank
S. L. Frank Today at The Imaginative Conservative, I offer a brief look into the social though of the Russian philosopher S. L. Frank: In his 1930 book, The Spiritual Foundations of Society, Frank offers a refreshing vision of a conservatism that cannot survive apart from creativity. The book is a remarkable tour de force of intelligent, nuanced, and in some ways even prescient Christian social thought. One can find references—some explicit, some in Frank’s own words—to personalism, natural law,...
Now Available: ‘Psalms II’ by Frans van Deursen
Christian’s Library Press has now released Psalms II, the fifth primer in its Opening the Scriptures series, and the second in a two-part release on the book of Psalms. The book is currently available for orderon Amazon. Written by Dutch Reformed minister Frans van Deursen, and newly translated by Nelson D. Kloosterman, the volume provides an introduction to Psalms, a book which serves as “the oldest songbook that God’s people possess,” as well as the “oldest breviary or prayer book,”...
The Inherent Hypocrisy of Fossil-Fuel Divestment
Fr. Michael Crosby You can’t really take fossil fuel divestment seriously unless you ignore a lot of inconvenient truths. These would include such things as Al Gore’s carbon footprint or the fuel bill for the dozens of private jets flown to any UN climate summit. On a more mundane level, we might point to benefits of abundant and affordable resources of coal, natural gas and crude oil that power modern industrialized economies and will continue to dominate as future energy...
‘Creation and the Heart of Man’ on Logos
Creation and the Heart of Man, the first volume of Acton’s Orthodox Christian Social Thought monograph series, is now available for pre-order on Logos Bible Software. Those who pre-order can get the book at a discounted price. In addition, the Logos edition is able to offer some unique features: In the Logos edition, this volume is enhanced by amazing functionality. Important terms link to dictionaries, encyclopedias, and a wealth of other resources in your digital library. Perform powerful searches to...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved