Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Religious toleration in a religious state
Religious toleration in a religious state
Mar 16, 2025 8:32 PM

The concepts of toleration espoused by theologians in the officially religious states of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries deserve closer examination. So argue Tobias Dienst and Christoph Strohm in their introduction to Martinus Becanus’s 1607 treatise, On the Duty to Keep Faith with Heretics. Becanus (1563–1624), a Dutch Jesuit theologian who became court confessor to the Holy Roman Emperor, lived in and supported an officially Roman Catholic state, but this did not prevent him from developing a concept of religious toleration that viewed the toleration of Protestants and other religious adherents as advancing the greater good of society.

This work is not principally a work on religious toleration. Becanus’s main concern is to defend the thesis “that it is morally obligatory to fulfill all contracts and promises unless they are against divine law or in another way invalid.” Specifically, Becanus shows that one must keep one’s promises and honor one’s contracts regardless of the religious views of the other party. Yet, as Dienst and Strohm point out, this principle “also applies to agreements granting religious tolerance to heretics.” The matter of religious toleration is thus a part of the moral question of whether, and in what circumstances, one must keep one’s promises. Like most writers in the tumultuous religious and political context of the early modern era, Becanus did not endorse religious freedom and freedom of conscience as goods to be pursued in themselves. This is clear from his stark denunciations of unqualified religious liberty. Yet, Becanus would change his views on toleration from the more restrictive stance he takes in this treatise. Dienst and Strohm sketch his movement from regarding toleration as permissible for preventing a greater evil in society (such as religious wars) to regarding toleration as permissible for achieving a greater good (such as the possible, future conversion of religious dissenters). The authors observe that this change in Becanus’s view “is a first step toward the idea of tolerance as possibly beneficial to society and not merely as an unpreventable nuisance.”

Theologians from this era typically supported the religious states that upheld their respective confessional persuasions, and these writers often defended the use of force against religious dissenters in those states. More liberal advocates of toleration and freedom of conscience, such as Sebastian Castellio (1515–1563), often had loose confessional affiliation or were in conflict with the Catholic or Protestant authorities. Dienst and Strohm note that in the study of the history of toleration writers like Castellio have received the bulk of attention as proto-moderns, leading many scholars to “skip the time between Castellio and the early Enlightenment altogether.” That’s a gap of roughly 200 years that included hundreds of authors who wrote about toleration, liberty of conscience, and religious freedom. Becanus is one of these overlooked authors—a Catholic writer who developed the concept of religious toleration within a Catholic state. On the Duty to Keep Faith with Heretics, therefore, helps to fill a gap in mon story of the rise of religious toleration in the West.

On the Duty to Keep Faith with Heretics, edited by Wim Decock and translated by Isabelle Buhre, is the first English translation of Becanus’s treatise De fide haereticis servanda and the latest volume in CLP Academic’s Sources in Early Modern Economics, Ethics, and Law series.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Economic Liberalism and its Discontents
How do we restore confidence in free markets? Formulate a robust explanation of their moral value. Read Economic Liberalism and its Discontents on Public Discourse. In his recent book The Creation and Destruction of Value, Princeton University’s Harold James observes that the 2008 financial crisis resulted in more than the devastation of economic value. It also facilitated a collapse of values in the sense of people’s faith in particular ideas, institutions, and practices. Among these, few would question that economic...
The Financial Crisis: What We (Still) Haven’t Learned
It’s over a year now since the 2008 financial crisis spread havoc throughout the global economy. Dozens of books and articles have appeared to explain what went wrong. They identify culprits ranging from Wall Street financiers overleveraging assets, to ACORN lobbying policy-makers to lower mortgage standards, to politicians closely connected to government-sponsored enterprises such as Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae failing to exercise oversight of those agencies. As time passes, armies of doctoral students will explore every nook and cranny...
Secularism and Poverty
A colleague recently mentioned that a wag had observed the church had failed to solve poverty, so why not let the federal government have a try? I think it is interesting that anyone, such as the wag in question, could think that the federal government can effectively solve the problem of poverty. I don’t think it can because it resolutely refuses to confront the sources. Really, truly, don’t we know the cause of a great deal of the poverty in...
Studying Stewardship in Scripture
This weekend’s Grand Rapids Press featured a story about the release of the NIV Stewardship Study Bible. Ann Byle writes, Three Grand Rapids-based organizations and numerous local residents joined forces recently to create a study Bible that focuses on stewardship. The Acton Institute, the Stewardship Council and Zondervan brought the NIV Stewardship Study Bible into print after more than five years of work that began with Brett Elder, the council’s executive director. Elder traveled the world speaking on generosity. He...
Acton Commentary: After the Berlin Wall — the Enduring Power of Socialism
The Economist marked the 20th anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall by observing that there was “so much gained, so much to lose.” As the world celebrates the collapse munism, who would have imagined that in less than one generation we would witness a resurgence of socialism throughout Latin America and even hear the word socialist being used to describe policies of the United States? We relegated socialism to the “dustbin of history,” but socialism never actually died...
Veterans Day Review: As You Were
Washington Post reporter and author Christian Davenport has told a deeply raw and emotional story in his new book As You Were: To War and Back with the Black Hawk Battalion of the Virginia National Guard. This book does not focus on battlefield heroics but rather it captures the essence and value of the citizen- soldier. Most importantly this account unveils through narrative, the pride, the pain, and the harrowing trials of the life of America’s guardsmen and reservists. Davenport...
Reflecting on Berlin
I was in the 8th grade in November of 1989, and I don’t think that the fall of the Berlin Wall had any immediate impact on my thinking at the time. I don’t remember if I watched the coverage on TV, or if there were any big discussions of the event in school during the following days. I was a history buff back then, to be sure – I still am – but I don’t think that I was engaged...
Messianic Marxism
From “The Origin of Russian Communism” by Russian philosopher Nicholas Berdyaev (published by Geoffrey Bles, 1937): Marxism is not only a doctrine of historical and economic materialism, concerned with plete dependence of man on economics, it is also a doctrine of deliverance, of the messianic vocation of the proletariat, of the future perfect society in which man will not be dependent on economics, of the power and victory of man over the irrational forces of nature and society. There is...
Communism as Religion
From the opening page of Lester DeKoster’s Communism and Christian Faith (1962): For the mysterious dynamic of history resides in man’s choice of gods. In the service of his god — or gods (they may be legion) — a man expends his mits his sacrifices, devotes his life. And history is made. Understand Communism, then, as a religion; or miss the secret of its power! Grasp the nature of this new faith, and discern in contrast to it the God...
Acton Commentary: Government Health Care — Back to the Plantation
Black leaders constantly remind Americans of our racism. Should not these same leaders protest the expansion of government control contained in the health-care reform bill currently working its way through Congress? Here’s why. Notwithstanding their rhetoric of freedom and empowerment, many prominent black leaders appear content to send blacks back to the government plantation—where a small number of Washington elites make decisions for blacks who aren’t in the room. Why do minority leaders not favor alternatives that demonstrate faith in...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved