Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Religious Shareholders Stump for Union Super PACs
Religious Shareholders Stump for Union Super PACs
Dec 11, 2025 2:46 PM

Hoo boy … this campaign season is exhausting enough already without reporting the efforts of religious shareholder activist groups uniting to undo the U.S. Supreme Court’s Citizens United decision. But, to quote Michael Corleone in the third Godfather film: “Just when I thought I was out, they pull me back in!”

Joining the anti-Citizens United religious shareholders are public-sector unions, riding high after the eight-justice Supreme Court split evenly this week on Friedrichs v. California Teachers Association. The split decision ensures that public-sector unions may continue to pulsory union dues. Any honest guesses as to how this money will be spent must include political activity.

For its part, religious shareholder activists As You Sow continue to hold up their end of the bargain, openly working with unions to squelch opposition voices. Although AYS proxy resolutions on corporate political activity have fallen from a record high of 139 in 2014 to 98 resolutions thus far this season, readers may rest assured, as AYS warns in its 2016 ProxyPreview:

More will likely emerge as the year progresses, from the broad coalition of investors and allied public interest groups that wants panies to disclose more on how they spend on elections and lobbying, with oversight from boards of directors.…

Investor concern about corporate political activity predates the landmark 2010 Citizens United U.S. Supreme Court decision that opened up new avenues for corporate spending; the campaign was started more than a decade ago by the Center for Political Accountability (CPA), which developed the model shareholder proposal still in use for disclosure of election spending. Members of the umbrella Corporate Reform Coalition, which includes many shareholder proponents but a range of other reformers as well, will be active in the ing proxy season. The coalition continues to press for mandated election spending disclosure by way of a proposed SEC [Securities and Exchange Commission] mandate but to date has been stymied; this year it is seeking to influence votes at mutual panies on the subject and has targeted Vanguard, which in the past has voted often with management.

That sound readers hear is your writer’s eyes pirouetting in their sockets. AYS has targeted panies this proxy season – Alphabet, American Airlines Group, AT&T, CenterPoint Energy, Emerson Electric, Raytheon, Spectra Energy, Travelers and Verizon Communications – with multiple resolutions pertaining to political spending and lobbying. The ProxyPreview continues:

The lobbying transparency campaign begun in 2012 is coordinated by Walden Asset Management and the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME). For the last three years, political spending reformers and climate change activists also have been asking panies about their support for public policies that could mitigate global warming, tying together the two main themes of recent proxy seasons, but these resolutions for the most part are filed ‘to make a point’ but withdrawn before they go to votes.

Seriously? How is this responsible investor behavior? Readers will note also that a ProxyPreview sidebar, authored by John Keenan, corporate governance analyst, AFSCME Capital Strategies (page 29 for those interested), reports:

[A] coalition of 66 investors have filed at least 50 proposals for 2016 which panies to disclose their lobbying, including federal and state lobbying, payments to trade associations and third parties used for indirect lobbying, and any payments to tax exempt organizations that write and endorse model legislation. Since 2011, more than 80 investors have filed over 200 shareholder proposals seeking lobbying disclosure. During that time, the proposals have averaged more than 25 percent support while also leading to over 40 withdrawal agreements for improved disclosure.

Followed by these disingenuous howlers:

Investors believe lobbying disclosure safeguards corporate reputation and protects shareholder value. One concern is reputational risk associated with controversial political spending or third party involvement. Companies with a high reputational rank perform better financially, and executives find it much harder to recover from reputation failure than to maintain reputation. The 2016 proposals continue to focus on risks of membership in the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC), a tax-exempt organization that convenes state lawmakers and corporations to adopt model laws that include Voter ID and climate change denial. Highlighting a need to manage reputational risks of third party involvement, more than panies have publicly announced leaving ALEC.

It’s hard to imagine Keenan writing this with a straight face. Because, you know, corporations looking out for the best interests panies, employees, shareholders and all that, for Keenan, seemingly inconsequential stuff. But here’s the rub: Keenan represents a public-sector union, which means his group produces nothing as opposed to private-sector unions employed by panies whose political activity keeps Keenan awake at night.

Why, after all, would Keenan care? Following Occam’s Razor, the simplest answer is usually the best: AFSCME operates as a political Super PAC, and shutting down opposing views, policies and candidates is their goal. As noted by Mitch Hall in The Federalist this week:

Indeed, some seem to think Citizens United is just another unfair loophole for the nation’s panies to use to their advantage. But the Supreme Court’s ruling gave regular individuals and, more importantly, labor unions the exact same right to give as much as they want to political mittees.

In fact, as the Seattle Times reports, nearly half of the top 20 organizational contributors to super PACs so far in 2016 have been unions or their affiliates, not big businesses.

Of course, AFSCME isn’t the only public-sector union affiliated with the nominally faith-based AYS. Others include the California State Teachers Retirement System, NYC pension funds and the City of Philadelphia Public Employees Retirement System. AYS is doing the hump work for the super PAC unions.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Christian Scholarship and the Crisis of the University
This past weekend, I had the privilege to attend and present a paper at the 2013 Kuyper Center for Public Theology conference at Princeton Seminary. The conference was on the subject of “Church and Academy” and focused not only on the relationship between the institutions of the Church and the university, but also on questions such as whether theology still has a place in the academy and what place that might be. The discussion raised a number of important questions...
Obamacare and the Hubris of the Technocrats
Sen. Max Baucus (D-Mont.) was one of the key architects of Obamacare and one of the legislation’s greatest champions. But now he fears a “train wreck” as the Obama administration implements its signature healthcare law. In a recent hearing he asked Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius for details about how the Health Department will explain the law and raise awareness of its provisions, which are supposed to take effect in just a matter of months: “I’m very concerned that not...
Will New Internet Sales Tax Laws Create Market Fairness?
It’s called the “Marketplace Fairness Act,” but how fair is it and who does it really benefit? The legislation, which is expected to pass the Senate, is heralded by supporters as instituting market equity to the brick and mortar retailers. Supporters also proclaim it will help to alleviate state budget shortfalls. The Marketplace Fairness Act gives new authority to states to directly collect sales taxes from online retailers. Jia Lynn Lang at The Washington Post explains: Since before the dawn...
Fighting Poverty with Toy Blocks and Economic Growth
AEI’s Values and Capitalism just released a new book titled, Economic Growth: Unleashing the Potential for Human Flourishing. In support of the book, they’ve produced a video highlighting the great work of Tegu Toys, a wooden block manufacturer based in Honduras. In a country where 64% of people live below the poverty line, Tegu is creating economic growth and, in the process, is seeing the lives of its employees transformed. Chris Haughey, Tegu co-founder, started pany in Honduras with a...
How to See Like a State
What does it mean to see like a State? “In short, to see like the state is to be myopic,” says Brian Dijkema. “This myopia views geography, people, their customs and traditions in a way that “severely brackets all variables except those bearing directly” on the state’s interests of revenue, security, and order.” An example from the institutional point of view of schools illustrates the point well. Education, and the shape of the schools that provide it, is one of...
ICCR Shareholders vs. World Hunger
Finding solutions for feeding the world’s poorest is about as non-controversial a mission as you could imagine for someone pursuing a religious vocation. Yet, the investors belonging to the Interfaith Center for Corporate Responsibility put politicized science ahead of that mission in their opposition to genetically modified organisms (GMOs). The ICCR’s approach to GMOs leans more toward anti-business political activism than any concern for producing plentiful crops that are resilient against pests, diseases and extreme weather events such as drought...
Sec. Kerry Urges Turkey to Re-Open Orthodox Seminary
The Halki seminary near Istanbul was the main school of theology of the Eastern Orthodox Church’s Ecumenical Patriarchate of Constantinople from 1884 until the Turkish parliament enacted a law banning private higher education institutions in 1971. For more than 40 years, the law has kept Orthodox clergy schools closed. But in an encouraging development for religious liberties, Secretary of State John Kerry is urging the Turkish government to reopen the seminaries: “It is our hope that the Halki seminary will...
Orthodox Bishops Kidnapped By Terrorists
Two Syrian Orthodox bishops have been abducted by terrorists in a suburb of Aleppo in Syria as they were returning from Antioch (Antakya, Turkey). While both clergymen are believed to be alive, their driver was killed during the attack: Syriac Orthodox bishop Yohanna Ibrahim and Greek Orthodox Archbishops of Aleppo Paul, who also happens to be the brother of Patriarch John of Antioch and All The East were abducted en route to Aleppo from a town on the Turkish border...
Where Opportunity and Obligation Meet
Over at Fare Forward, Cole Carnesecca provides some great insights into how we should think about calling, offering some similar sentiments to those expressed in my recent post on family and vocation. “Whatever else you may think you are called to,” Carnesecca writes, “if you have a spouse and children, you are called to your family.” Focusing on the troubled marriages of Methodism founder John Wesley and Chinese evangelist John Sung, Carnesecca explains how a misaligned and over-spiritualized concept of...
Neither Worshipping Nor Demonizing Capitalism
Questions about poverty and social teaching are on the forefront of Pope Francis’ mind, as he’s made convincingly clear in his young papacy. This calls for cogent thinking on the topic, according to Fr. John Flynn, LC in “Francis and Catholic Social Teaching: Debates About Economy, Equality and Poverty Sure to Continue.” Flynn cites Jerry Z. Muller, professor of History at the Catholic University of America, who gives credit to the astonishing “leap in human progress” that capitalism has brought...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved