Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Religious Shareholders: Spiritual or Political?
Religious Shareholders: Spiritual or Political?
Dec 17, 2025 3:08 PM

I have a friend who owns a vacation home that he rents out by the week and on weekends. It’s a cozy place surrounded by forest with access to one of the Great Lakes. It’s a perfect place to get away from it all, replenish the spirit and relax. The rent also helps my friend financially. Lately, however, he feels less inclined to offer his house to vacationers. It seems some of his renters take it upon themselves to move the furniture in his house in a fashion more to their liking. In one instance, a renter totally reconfigured all the cooking utensils, pots and pans in the kitchen cabinets and drawers.

Why would anyone spend precious vacation time and money only to rearrange someone else’s furniture and cookware? By the same token, why would anyone invest in pany only to introduce proxy resolutions that would negatively impact pany’s bottom line and decrease shareholder value? Wouldn’t that trip things up?

That, in effect, is what shareholder activists increasingly are doing – introducing resolutions for pet progressive campaigns targeted at such leftist bête noires as campaign finance and lobbying; climate change (including fossil-fuel divestment and hydraulic fracturing); executive pay; genetically modified organisms; and even depictions of cigarette smoking in movies.

Front and center in these exercises of corporate feng shui are “religious” investors, including As You Sow and the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility. Both have been exercising their presumed moral authority for decades against the best interests panies, themselves and other investors to further leftist agendas.

ICCR’s mission, according to the Summer 2015 issue of its publication, The Corporate Examiner:

ICCR seeks a munity built on justice and sustainability through transformation of the corporate world by integrating social values into corporate and investor actions.

It’s quite interesting that a group convinced the worst thing to happen recently in U.S. politics is the infusion of corporate money post-Citizens United. These groups would anthropomorphize corporations to the extent it depicts businesses as potential vessels of “justice and sustainability” possessing “social values.”

Just what does ICCR mean when it talks about “justice and sustainability” and “social values” in the first place? If you’re a nun, priest, clergy or other religious, it’s presumed by some that those words are freighted with moral significance derived from Scripture and church doctrine. In reality, however, ICCR (and AYS) are little to nothing more than progressive-liberal activists seeking to impose a leftist agenda on corporate America. This agenda is politically radical rather than spiritual, habits and clerical collars aside.

For the purposes of this piece, let’s take one example from ICCR’s playbook – corporate lobbying expenditures, which is also in the latest Corporate Examiner:

Corporations lobby both directly and indirectly via third party groups to promote a legislative and regulatory environment that is more favorable to their businesses. Because there is often no transparency regarding how lobbying dollars are invested, investors seek greater disclosure to ensure that these funds are managed responsibly and not deployed to promote agendas that may run counter to a corporation’s publicly stated positions. As a result, broad-based investor support for lobbying disclosure resolutions has been growing steadily across many sectors. The average vote received by lobbying resolutions this year was 27.5%, a very strong show of support when one considers the majority of shares are held by management. A first-year CenterPoint resolution received just over 41%, as did an Ameren lobbying disclosure resolutions.

Ahhh, the old David Investors v. Goliath Corporate Management scenario. The 27.5 percent stone thrown by ICCR investors may be a significant minority, but it’s still large enough to warrant valuable time that could be better spent discussing actual corporate concerns. But who’s going to tell sweet little nuns to butt out of corporate lobbying? Readers may be able to suss out the ICCR strategy, which simply put is this: Employ clergy, nuns and other clergy as a Trojan Horse that grants unearned moral credence to progressive rather than religious-based causes; watch corporate management bend over backwards to avoid a certain public-relations disaster if management treats religious investors brusquely.

Perhaps it’s time the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission tightens its proxy resolution rules to restrict further AYS and ICCR members from moving around corporate furniture and kitchen staples simply to advance leftist causes at the very real monetary expense panies and their more rational investors.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Poverty Imagery and the ‘Christmas Song’
In last week’s mentary, “The Worst Christmas Song Ever,” Jordan Ballor touched on the well-intentioned yet harmful message shared by “Do They Know It’s Christmas?” the 1984 song produced by the music group, Band Aid, in response to the famine that struck Ethiopia. Ballor describes the context and some of the song’s lyrics: The song describes Africa largely as a barren wasteland, ‘Where the only water flowing is the bitter sting of tears.’ It continues in this vein. Africa, the...
Reflections on How We Approach God
We know how God approached mankind: the surprising incarnation as a baby at Christmas.But how ought we to approach Him? Here is a wide range of 14 ways we often try, along with abenefit for each: Love the right things and you will find your way home to GodThink the right things and you will know the sovereign GodBelieve the right thingsand you will live at peaceObey, obey, obey and you will not go to hellWithdraw from the world and...
Nothing New ‘Underneath that Burning Sun’
Friedrich Hayek once called intellectuals “professional secondhand dealers in ideas.” And the Preacher proclaimed, “There is nothing new under the sun.” So perhaps it shouldn’t be surprising when ideas, memes, and other cultural phenomena pop up again and again. There is, however, a notable correspondence between an Acton Commentary that I wrote earlier this month, “The Worst Christmas Song Ever,” and a piece that appeared weeks earlier at The Federalist. In “‘Do They Know It’s Christmas’ Is The Worst Christmas...
10 Things Political Scientists Know That We Don’t
“If economics is the dismal science,” says Hans Noel, an associate professor at Georgetown University, “then political science is the dismissed science.” Most Americans—from pundits to voters—don’t think that political science has much to say about political life. But there are some things, notes Noel, that “political scientists know that it seems many practitioners, pundits, journalists, and otherwise informed citizens do not.” Here are excerpts from Noel’s list of ten things political scientists know that you don’t: #1. It’s The...
The Politics of ‘It’s a Wonderful Life’
Frank Capra’s ‘It’s Wonderful Life’ is one of the greatest movies of all time. It’s a Christmas classic and also—as I’ve always thought—a conservative classic, a film whose themes align closely with traditional conservatism. But not everyone agrees on the politics of Bedford Falls. Keith Miller and Chris Schaefer debate whether themes of the movie lean more liberal or more conservative. Naturally, I agree with Miller’s small government assessment: The movie exults in the way the Bailey Building & Loan...
A Dangerous Moment with Promise
In this mentary, Acton president and co-founder Rev. Robert A. Sirico reflects on Christmas, but also on the things weighing heavily on many hearts. Despite this being a joyful time, we are caught in perilous moment in history due to the meeting of various things: intellectual, financial, militarily, and theologically. President Ronald Reagan gave a similar address in 1981: Rev. Sirico says: How to get to the heart of the matter? That, as Shakespeare might say, is the rub. Yet,...
Lessons in humility from the Christ Child
In the latest video blog from For the Life of the World, Evan Koons offers Christmas greetings and a few timely reminders with his usual dose of humor. “He made himself nothing to be with us.” Indeed, by entering the Earth in human form, nay, in infant human form, born to the house of a carpenter, Jesus provides a striking example of the order of Christian service — of the truth and the life, yes, but also of the way....
All I Want For Christmas Is You
Parents spend a lot of time and money trying to get their children what they want for Christmas. The list written for Santa is poured over, gifts are wrapped, stockings are stuffed. But are you giving your child what she really wants? IKEA Spain wants us to think about our children’s wish lists a bit differently. ...
The Blue-Cold Child
From Flannery O’Connor’s The Violent Bear It Away: God told the world he was going to send it a king and the world waited. The world thought, a golden fleece will do for His bed. Silver and gold and peacock tails, a thousand suns in a peacock’s tail will do for his crib. His mother will ride on a four-horned white beast and use the sunset for a cape. She’ll trail it behind her over the ground and let the...
Food Stamp Sticker Shock
Grocery shopping is not a chore I enjoy. It’s a mundane task, and everything you buy you will have to soon replace. Then, when you finally get to the end of the chore, you look at the register and think, “HOW much??” It gets worse. You and I (American taxpayers) managed to “misspend” $2.4 billion this year on food stamps, now known as the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP.) How did we manage this? According to the USDA’s audit for...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved