Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Religious Shareholders: Spiritual or Political?
Religious Shareholders: Spiritual or Political?
Apr 10, 2025 8:55 AM

I have a friend who owns a vacation home that he rents out by the week and on weekends. It’s a cozy place surrounded by forest with access to one of the Great Lakes. It’s a perfect place to get away from it all, replenish the spirit and relax. The rent also helps my friend financially. Lately, however, he feels less inclined to offer his house to vacationers. It seems some of his renters take it upon themselves to move the furniture in his house in a fashion more to their liking. In one instance, a renter totally reconfigured all the cooking utensils, pots and pans in the kitchen cabinets and drawers.

Why would anyone spend precious vacation time and money only to rearrange someone else’s furniture and cookware? By the same token, why would anyone invest in pany only to introduce proxy resolutions that would negatively impact pany’s bottom line and decrease shareholder value? Wouldn’t that trip things up?

That, in effect, is what shareholder activists increasingly are doing – introducing resolutions for pet progressive campaigns targeted at such leftist bête noires as campaign finance and lobbying; climate change (including fossil-fuel divestment and hydraulic fracturing); executive pay; genetically modified organisms; and even depictions of cigarette smoking in movies.

Front and center in these exercises of corporate feng shui are “religious” investors, including As You Sow and the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility. Both have been exercising their presumed moral authority for decades against the best interests panies, themselves and other investors to further leftist agendas.

ICCR’s mission, according to the Summer 2015 issue of its publication, The Corporate Examiner:

ICCR seeks a munity built on justice and sustainability through transformation of the corporate world by integrating social values into corporate and investor actions.

It’s quite interesting that a group convinced the worst thing to happen recently in U.S. politics is the infusion of corporate money post-Citizens United. These groups would anthropomorphize corporations to the extent it depicts businesses as potential vessels of “justice and sustainability” possessing “social values.”

Just what does ICCR mean when it talks about “justice and sustainability” and “social values” in the first place? If you’re a nun, priest, clergy or other religious, it’s presumed by some that those words are freighted with moral significance derived from Scripture and church doctrine. In reality, however, ICCR (and AYS) are little to nothing more than progressive-liberal activists seeking to impose a leftist agenda on corporate America. This agenda is politically radical rather than spiritual, habits and clerical collars aside.

For the purposes of this piece, let’s take one example from ICCR’s playbook – corporate lobbying expenditures, which is also in the latest Corporate Examiner:

Corporations lobby both directly and indirectly via third party groups to promote a legislative and regulatory environment that is more favorable to their businesses. Because there is often no transparency regarding how lobbying dollars are invested, investors seek greater disclosure to ensure that these funds are managed responsibly and not deployed to promote agendas that may run counter to a corporation’s publicly stated positions. As a result, broad-based investor support for lobbying disclosure resolutions has been growing steadily across many sectors. The average vote received by lobbying resolutions this year was 27.5%, a very strong show of support when one considers the majority of shares are held by management. A first-year CenterPoint resolution received just over 41%, as did an Ameren lobbying disclosure resolutions.

Ahhh, the old David Investors v. Goliath Corporate Management scenario. The 27.5 percent stone thrown by ICCR investors may be a significant minority, but it’s still large enough to warrant valuable time that could be better spent discussing actual corporate concerns. But who’s going to tell sweet little nuns to butt out of corporate lobbying? Readers may be able to suss out the ICCR strategy, which simply put is this: Employ clergy, nuns and other clergy as a Trojan Horse that grants unearned moral credence to progressive rather than religious-based causes; watch corporate management bend over backwards to avoid a certain public-relations disaster if management treats religious investors brusquely.

Perhaps it’s time the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission tightens its proxy resolution rules to restrict further AYS and ICCR members from moving around corporate furniture and kitchen staples simply to advance leftist causes at the very real monetary expense panies and their more rational investors.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Christian shareholder activism: Good or bad?
Over the years, mentators have had reason to criticize religious groups that try to influence corporate policy through shareholder resolutions and similar activities. The criticism has revolved around two points. One, Christian shareholder activism has often focused on issues that are matters of prudential application of moral teaching (e.g., environmental practices) rather than non-negotiable moral evils (e.g., abortion). Two, such activism often seems to imply, if not explicitly proclaim, that the normal operation of business is not adequately “good,” and...
Incrementalism and public policy
There’s a long-running debate among public mentators concerning the prudence of pursuing an all-or-nothing agenda or moving incrementally toward a particular goal. How much modation is wise if that modation does make movement, however small, towards an ideal state of affairs, and yet also reinforces a system that is structurally opposed to the ultimate realization of that same ideal? When is it politically prudent to let the perfect potentially be the enemy of the good? These questions in the context...
Farm bill takes aim at taxpayers
The new farm bill may be one of the most shameless displays of government largesse ever, even more so when you consider who will most benefit from the pork. Citizens Against Government Waste called it “The most farcical farm bill in history.” The Economist dubbed it “Harvest of Disgrace.” The Wall Street Journal opines, “If farm prices stay high, consumers face higher grocery bills and farmers get rich. If farm prices fall, taxpayers kick in the difference and farmers still...
Did Maxine Waters just suggest that she might try to nationalize the US oil industry?
Why yes, yes she did: Link: Via Hot Air. ...
Memorial Day: John Gillespie Magee Jr. & ‘High Flight’
John Gillespie Magee, Jr. is remembered fondly by American aviators who defended and sacrificed for this nation in World War II to the present day. He is remembered for his touching poem High Flight, which he penned in 1941. Magee was born to an American father and British mother in Shanghai, China in 1922. His parents were Christian missionaries in the country. Well educated in China, England, and the United States, Magee received a scholarship to Yale University, where his...
Saviano’s Gomorra and the plague of crime and corruption in Italy
When thinking of southern Italy, Americans probably imagine the Amalfi Coast, Mount Vesuvius, and lemon groves, but to the average Italian the picture is of rotting garbage in the streets of Naples and the Mafia. These realities have been strikingly portrayed in Roberto Saviano’s book Gomorra (ET), which is also the basis of a newly-released motion picture in Italy. Saviano is a young journalist who clearly describes the dark side of his country. It is probably the most courageous “j’accuse”...
35th Anniversary of ‘The Passing of the Night’
“I want to show that the smartest and the bravest rely on their faith in God and our way of life,” was Robinson Risner’s answer to why he wrote The Passing of the Night: My Seven Years as a Prisoner of the North Vietnamese. 2008 marks the 35th anniversary of the release of American prisoners of war from North Vietnam and the publication of Risner’s often horrific but ultimately triumphant account. Many books written by and about American military prisoners...
Climate change warrior to head the SBC?
Rumorhas it that the Rev. Johnny Hunt is on the short list (if you consider six guys "short") to preside over the Southern Baptist Convention this summer. Big Daddy Weave notes that Reverend Hunt signed the Southern Baptist Environment and Climate Initiative. Could his signature on this initiative cause him trouble during the nomination process? Were he to be elected, would it signal a shift in the prevailing Southern Baptist Convention reluctance to engage issues like climate and energy? We...
‘Liberty, fraternity, equality, adultery!’
There is a fascinating article from City Journal‘s Myron Magnet titled, “Mr. Sammler’s City,” which gives some insight and background to Saul Bellow’s Mr. Sammler’s Planet. This is one of Bellow’s novels I read for my research on Henderson the Rain King, and Magnet’s piece serves as an excellent primer. Here’s a sample: Sammler, for his part, can’t help recalling that almost all modern revolutions, from the Jacobins to the Nazis and the Communists, have ended with the streets running...
Dealing with rising gas prices
As the Drudge Report today hails ing of the fuel-efficient Smart car, it might be worth pointing out other ways in which people are adapting to deal with higher fuel prices. I don’t mean to minimize any of the pain associated with skyrocketing energy costs, whether personal (I feel it, too) or economy-wide, but it is interesting to observe the myriad and often unexpected effects of price changes. It’s the market working. Or, to put it another way, it’s the...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved