Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Religious Left’s GMO Antagonism
Religious Left’s GMO Antagonism
Nov 14, 2024 4:11 AM

In Wednesday’s Wall Street Journal, Matthew Dalton reported that the European Union likely will approve a genetically modified organism for only the second time in the past 15 years. The EU is poised to grant E. I. du Pont de Nemours and Company permission to grow 1507, a DuPont-developed GMO corn.

DuPont first sought approval in 2001 for 1507 … After positive safety reviews and several decisions by the European Court of Justice criticizing the European Commission for delaying its decision, mission is now close to approving the crop…

The crop ‘meets all EU regulatory requirements and should be approved for cultivation without further delay,’ DuPont said.

1507 corn is resistant to the corn-borer worm, which has been known to devastate crops. Dalton writes that opposition to 1507 and, indeed, all GMOs runs strong throughout the EU. This resistance is echoed in the United States as well. The Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility, for example, has issued repeated shareholder resolutions to DuPont, Abbott Laboratories and other panies that would require panies to label GMOs. The ICCR’s “2014 Proxy Resolutions and Voting Guide” states:

Since 2000, members of ICCR have argued on behalf of consumers’ right to know what’s in the foods they eat, including whether or not those foods are genetically modified. Urging the precautionary principle, they caution against allowing potentially hazardous material into the food supply and support voluntary labeling of GMO ingredients. Because there has yet been no national mandate that GM foods be labeled in the U.S., most Americans have been unknowningly eating them for years.

The above paragraph conflates two separate issues. The first is labeling food derived from GMOs, and the second misleads readers to conclude GMOs are “potentially hazardous material” requiring the exercise of the precautionary principle. As noted by this writer in a previous post, panies to further label foods presents additional costs, which negatively impacts costs to consumers and shareholders. Additionally, GMO labeling frightens uninformed consumers who may forego the purchase of any products so labeled – thereby forcing them to buy more expensive nutrition for their families or, worse, do without the sustenance altogether.

Nowhere in the ICCR’s guide is scientific evidence to support GMO fear mongering, which makes the following assertion a real head scratcher:

ICCR members filed a resolution with Abbott Laboratories asking pany to identify and label genetically engineered crops and organisms in all its products unless long-term safety testing shows that they are not harmful to humans, animals, and the environments.

That’s a mighty tall – if not impossible – order. In the meantime, the religious members of ICCR burnish their credentials as antagonists of corporate America as well as the world’s hungriest people least able to afford non-GMO foodstuffs.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Finding civil society as Minneapolis burns
On May 25, George Floyd was murdered on the streets of Minneapolis, killed by “asphyxiation from sustained pressure” after his neck was pressed for over eight minutes under the knee of a police officer—a supposed public servant who was sworn to “serve and protect.” It’s a tragic example of the moral and institutional rot that pervades society, particularly as it relates to the enduring threats of racism, white supremacy, and over-criminalization among minorities and the poor. As if this injustice...
Riots and the broken window fallacy
The cost of the nine days of rioting following George Floyd’s death has already exceeded $100 million. Yet some economists believe that damage actually benefits our country. In the epicenter of the riots, Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey has appealed to the federal and state governments to foot the bill for the destruction, which stands at a preliminary estimate of $55 million. Much of that property damage followed Frey’s stand down order for police to largely turn a blind eye to...
Acton Line podcast: Anthony Bradley on George Floyd, police reform, and riots
The tragic and disturbing footage of George Floyd’s unjust death at the hands of Minneapolis police officers has been circulating for over a week.Floyd’s death on May 25 has sparked protests across the country and even the world, but it’s also sparked many violent riots in which people have been brutally killed munities decimated. How can we helpfully approach policing reform and how should we respond to the current widespread rioting? Anthony Bradley, professor of religion, theology and ethics at...
Understanding Pinochet
Writing a biography of someone like General Augusto Pinochet is fraught with potential pitfalls. Does it e an exercise in whitewashing someone whose regime oversaw a brutal repression which included the “disappearing” of approximately 2,228 people? Or does a biographer unquestionably accept the left’s narrative about Pinochet, one which downplays the abyss to which the much-romanticized Marxist, Salvador Allende, led Chile during his short presidency? In a new well-researched biography, Augusto Pinochet (2020), the French journalist Michel Faure navigates these...
Acton Line podcast: An introduction to François Fénelon, the forgotten philosopher
In 18th century France, the most-read book after the Bible was a work on political philosophy written by the Roman Catholic archbishop François Fénelon. Unfortunately, Fénelon’s writings on economics, politics, and theology have largely been forgotten, as only a fraction of his work has been translated into English. Fénelon was an important voice in France; during the Enlightenment, he fought for the reform of France’s political and economic institutions. His works are a critical resource for those interested in economics,...
‘Little England’ comes to Hong Kong’s rescue
As U.S. cities seek to rebuild from chaos, Hong Kong continues to resist the imposition of order—a draconian order emanating from Beijing that will crush freedom of thought and expression. British Prime Minister Boris Johnson has intervened with an historic proposal: He would allow nearly half the citizens of Hong Kong to immigrate to the UK. The es after the National People’s Congress approved a security law that would allow thePeople’s Republic of China to establish security teams in Hong...
The antidote to riots: Responsibility
George Floyd was laid to rest in a private burial ceremony earlier this week in Houston, following a massive funeral at the Fountain of Praise Church. The soul-searching that followed his tragic death has made the nation restless. Many police departments throughout the United States have already begun instituting reforms in an effort to prevent further tragic deaths and restore public trust, which is essential for police to munities in keeping the peace. The widespread failure of our institutions to...
Kuyper, Pope Leo XIII and the social question today
I was a guest on the Working Man podcast this week, discussing the connections between the Dutch theologian and statesman Abraham Kuyper and Pope Leo XIII. In 1891 both Leo and Kuyper published important documents providing Christian reflection on the “social question.” On the 125th anniversary of those publications, the Acton Institute produced an edition of these landmark contributions to the foundations of modern Christian social thought. The Working Man podcast is a production of Harmel Academy of the Trades,...
What destroyed Detroit is now destroying America
When I first moved to Grand Rapids, Michigan, in 1986, the city was an alien place to me. I had grown up on the eastern side of the state, in the I-75 manufacturing corridor that runs from Toledo to Bay City. Soon, I came to realize that in Grand Rapids, I wasn’t just living in a different region of Michigan: I was living in a different state, a different culture. It was shocking to hear people in West Michigan crow...
Black looting victim: Our business ‘is our ministry’
The nation has reached a baffling moment in our history: looting and torching minority-owned businesses for racial equality. The weeklong pandemic of mob violence following the death of George Floyd has destroyed minority business owners’ dreams, denied young minorities jobs, and left neighborhoods depleted, depressed, and alone. While ideologues like 1619 Project leader Nikole Hannah-Jones dismiss concerns over “destroying property,” the looters’ victims make clear the damage goes well beyond bricks and mortar. “We’re here for God. This is our...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved