Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
PowerBlogging the State of the Union
PowerBlogging the State of the Union
Jan 21, 2026 4:38 AM

I’ll be watching President Bush’s final State of the Union speech tonight and PowerBlog readers are invited to react and respond in ments section below.

I’ll be updating this post throughout the night (below the break) for those of you interested in the mentary. For now, let me just add this spoiler: the State of our Union is strong!

And for those of you who subscribe to SIRIUS Satellite Radio, I’m scheduled to discuss the speech at 10:40 PM Eastern on The Catholic Channel, channel 159. The conversation will focus especially on the proposed tax rebates, the federal budget, and tax cuts. Update: The audio of the interview is streaming here (download MP3 here).

Here’s a brief primer on what to expect tonight.

I think I’ll be watching NBC’s coverage, off the strength of their American Gladiators prelude.

NBC’s presidential historian reminds us that the President’s approval ratings are historically low. A bit later, Tim Russert notes that the President’s are at 31%, while Congress’ are at 18%.

Prediction: The perception of George W. Bush’s legacy will improve with age. People on both sides of the aisle will point to his leadership in a time of national trial.

9:12 PM: The President says we must “trust people with their own money.” That sounds about right. This is clearly a reference to the importance of passing the stimulus package quickly. Only in Washington does “immediate” action mean something finally happens four or five months later.

9:14 PM: The President starts strong on taxes, following up on his stress on the economic stimulus package. He says he will veto any bill that crosses his desk that raises taxes.

9:15 PM: The President promises a balanced budget by 2012, just about the time the next President’s first term will be ending. He’s right that the government needs to be accountable for how it spends the citizens’ money. Tax cuts without a balanced budget seem prima facie irresponsible.

9:17 PM: He will veto any bill that doesn’t cut earmarks in half. How about just eliminating them? Check out Citizens Against Government Waste.

9:21 PM: On education, Bush reiterates the legacy of No Child Left Behind, calling it a “bipartisan” achievement that needs to be strengthened. Barack Obama and Ted Kennedy are sitting next to each other.

9:22 PM: “Pell Grants for Kids” sounds like a public school voucher system.

9:26 PM: On energy, the President wants to fund carbon-capturing technologies for coal plants. It’s simply a fact that attempts to make the US energy independent will have to take advantage of coal, at least in the short- to mid-term, since it is so readily available domestically.

9:28 PM: Time and again the President is equating increased government funding with “dynamic” innovation in technology and science. I’m with Arnold Kling on this question, preferring privately funded innovation prizes over “trying to work the political system.”

9:32 PM: Speaking of the President’s legacy, one of the things he has done that will have lasting effects is bring entitlement reform onto the table. He never got anything passed, but he did a lot of the heavy lifting necessary for true reform by bringing these “pressing” issues into the public consciousness.

9:34 PM: He’s also taken a lot of heat over his attempts to find a moderating position on immigration. He’s right that we need a “humane” solution.

9:35 PM: “People when given the chance will choose a future of freedom and peace.”

9:50 PM: The last fifteen minutes or so have focused on the war on terror, particularly on Iraq: “We will not rest until this enemy has been defeated.”

9:54 PM: Transitioning from a discussion of a two-state solution in Israel and Palestine (two “democratic” states) and the threat of Iran, the President starts to discuss domestic security. I am thankful and frankly amazed that we have not suffered another terrorist attack on American soil since 9/11.

9:57 PM: The President is outlining prehensive plan to advance both American foreign interests and meet the demands of our conscience by creating a more passionate” foreign policy focused on increased foreign development aid.

10:01 PM: The President concludes with a bit of history, noting the change in language from the Articles of Confederation, “We the undersigned delegates…”, to the Constitution, “We the people…”, which was ratified on September 17, 1787.

10:04 PM: Tim Russert called the speech the “minimalist agenda of a lame duck President.”

As appropriate in a time of war, the bulk of the speech focused on the war on terror in its various fronts. Given the “lame duck” status of a relatively unpopular President, it is an open question how much influence, beyond the “veto” threat that was raised more than once in this speech, President Bush will have over the next year on domestic policy.

10:06 PM: David Gregory points to the President’s “bitterness” over his inability to pass either entitlement or immigration reform. Again, these two issues, especially the former, is likely to be one of the important legacies of his domestic work. History will vindicate his argument that Social Security needs radical reform.

I think it’s an interesting question as to what sort of tone this speech has set for any potential Presidential successor of either party. Was this used at all as an opportunity to try and set up the agenda of the next President?

10:16 PM: Kansas governor Kathleen Sebelius delivers the Democratic response.

10:18 PM: Sorry, that’s the “American” response, focusing on the economy. “A temporary fix is only the first step,” referring to the stimulus package.

10:21 PM: On a number of domestic issues, from raising the minimum wage to “going green,” the governor asks the President, “Will you join us?”

Here’s a link to the full text of the 2008 State of the Union address.

It looks like action on the economic stimulus package might not be so immediate. The WaPo is reporting that the Senate version to be taken up tomorrow has some rather significant divergences from the plan agreed to by the President and the House leadership.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Warming wailing waning
Sometime Acton publications contributor and adjunct scholar Thomas Sieger Derr posts on the First Things blog under the title, “The End of the Global Warming Scare?” Derr identifies a trend that has not been ignored on this blog: increasingly vocal and widespread skepticism toward at least the most dire predictions emanating from the climate change disaster crowd. I would add to Derr’s observations that consternation over oil prices is likely to encourage reluctance to implement any costly programs that have...
Assumptions about the ‘Libertarian’ Jesus
Here’s the key assumption in Michael Gerson’s piece from last week, “The Libertarian Jesus”: passion cannot replace Medicaid or provide AIDS drugs to millions of people in Africa for the rest of their lives. In these cases, a role for government is necessary passionate — the expression of mitments to the general welfare and the value of every human life. passion certainly could do this, and much more. Private giving generally dwarfs government programs in both real dollars and effectiveness....
Did Maxine Waters just suggest that she might try to nationalize the US oil industry?
Why yes, yes she did: Link: Via Hot Air. ...
Looking for happiness, finding faith
Dr. Arthur C. Brooks spoke about “happiness” at an Acton Lecture Series event last week. Dr. Brooks, a professor of Business and Government Policy at Syracuse University and a visiting scholar with the American Enterprise Institute, presented evidence which suggests that religion is the greatest factor in general human happiness in the United States. Religion, argues Dr. Brooks, is essential to human flourishing in the United States and public secularism should be strongly guarded against by everyone – religious or...
Farm bill takes aim at taxpayers
The new farm bill may be one of the most shameless displays of government largesse ever, even more so when you consider who will most benefit from the pork. Citizens Against Government Waste called it “The most farcical farm bill in history.” The Economist dubbed it “Harvest of Disgrace.” The Wall Street Journal opines, “If farm prices stay high, consumers face higher grocery bills and farmers get rich. If farm prices fall, taxpayers kick in the difference and farmers still...
Book Review: Carl Anderson’s ‘A Civilization of Love’
On March 29, Carl Anderson’s A Civilization of Love (HarperOne, 2008) first appeared on the New York Times Best Seller list as one of hottest-selling books in America among the “Hard Cover Advice” category. Since then the author has been on an energetic European and American tour to promote his book. In just 200 pages, Anderson writes convincingly to elaborate a treatise to dispel dominant secular ideologies whose ethical frameworks falsely aim at human fulfillment and forming good and just...
Dealing with rising gas prices
As the Drudge Report today hails ing of the fuel-efficient Smart car, it might be worth pointing out other ways in which people are adapting to deal with higher fuel prices. I don’t mean to minimize any of the pain associated with skyrocketing energy costs, whether personal (I feel it, too) or economy-wide, but it is interesting to observe the myriad and often unexpected effects of price changes. It’s the market working. Or, to put it another way, it’s the...
European foreign aid caught between dishonesty and incompetence
International aid groups have criticized the EU and many of its member states for falling behind their promises to step up foreign aid to 0.5 per cent of GDP by 2010 and 0.7 per cent by 2015. On the one hand, these groups are right to expose the accounting tricks governments use in order to promote themselves as saviors of Africa. On the other hand, the aid groups should consider very carefully whether their focus on state aid is really...
Memorial Day: John Gillespie Magee Jr. & ‘High Flight’
John Gillespie Magee, Jr. is remembered fondly by American aviators who defended and sacrificed for this nation in World War II to the present day. He is remembered for his touching poem High Flight, which he penned in 1941. Magee was born to an American father and British mother in Shanghai, China in 1922. His parents were Christian missionaries in the country. Well educated in China, England, and the United States, Magee received a scholarship to Yale University, where his...
Intellectual foundations of evangelicalism
In an interview promoting his recent book Faith in the Halls of Power: How Evangelicals Joined the American Elite, D. Michael Lindsay, describes what he sees to be the intellectual sources of evangelicalism: And the interesting thing is that the Presbyterian tradition, the Reformed tradition, has provided some of the intellectual gravitas for evangelical ascendancy. And it’s being promulgated in lots of creative ways so that you have the idea of Kuyper or a mission of cultural engagement is being...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved