Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Populism vs. capitalism: The myth of the market as a ‘tool’
Populism vs. capitalism: The myth of the market as a ‘tool’
Nov 14, 2024 1:12 AM

Tucker Carlson’s recent rant on the corrosive grip of cultural elites and pro-market conservatism has led to a bounty of intra-movement debate and introspection, ranging from loud “amens!” to loud “nay, nevers!” to critiques of resentful populism to more nuanced efforts to weigh and reconcile the legitimate tensions at play.

But as we explore the plicated arguments about how and whether we can or should use the levers of government to insulate families munities from “market forces,” it may be helpful to pause and consider what we actually mean (or ought to mean) when we discuss “market capitalism,” not to mention what’s actually at stake beyond the material stuff.

In an effort to do so, Jonah Goldberg puts his finger on a piece of passing rhetoric in Carlson’s monologue, which has unfortunately mon in the cultural vocabulary: the free market is simply a “tool,” a human system that requires top-down hacks, upgrades, and well-engineered human intervention.

“Market capitalism is a tool, like a staple gun or a toaster,” Carlson says in his monologue. “You’d have to be a fool to worship it. Our system was created by human beings for the benefit of human beings. We do not exist to serve markets. Just the opposite. Any economic system that weakens and destroys families is not worth having. A system like that is the enemy of a healthy society.”

For those of us who believe that “market capitalism” represents more of a manifestation than a “system,” such a notion is highly plete—not because we bow at its altar, but because we appreciate its contribution to all else, including to the strength of the munity life, and civil society.

Yet such contributions are not measured only according to a populist’s value sheet of post-war factory jobs and economic predictability. As Goldberg goes on to explain, the mitment here is not to materialistic machinery, stock-market wizardry, or any series of economic forts, or conveniences. mitment is to economic liberty and its inherent value to flourishing individuals, families, munities.

“Economic liberty is a right, too,” Goldberg writes. “Just because the free market looks like a ‘tool’ from the vantage point of some policymakers and other elites gazing at society from olympian heights doesn’t mean my right to buy and sell what I want isn’t a right too.”

But the “tool” analogy also falls short in its distraction from the intangible and social aspects of free and open exchange. Again, far from being some cold, banker-controlled machine—a “toaster”—the market is, at its simplest, an ever-evolving and ever-adapting web of human relationships bent toward creative service to our neighbors. We can say these relationships are simply a “means to an end,” but this, too, overly narrows and distorts our cultural imaginations when es to what we’re actually engaged in, leading to the very es that Carlson is trying to avoid.

How we behave and engage in those relationships is critical, to be sure, and it ought to be oriented toward something (and Someone) well beyond the material outputs. But restoring that sort of cultural mindset e from reform-con incentive structures or tech-school subsidies, however helpful or productive such solutions may be. It e, first, from a rejection of the blindly utilitarian and materialistic world that a growing number of “conservative populists” prefer to imagine.If we succumb to the myth of the market as merely a “tool,” we are bound to adopt the fruits of those materialistic assumptions.

Working within a context of true economic freedom, we don’t just create, innovate, collaborate, and serve our neighbors because doing so gets us a profit or desired metric of GDP. We do so because it’s part of our social and spiritual natures as human persons. We do it becauseit unites us to the grand family of humankind.

Once we recognize and embrace this truth about “market capitalism”—that its core value is not material prosperity but economic liberty, and that economic exchange is profoundly social munal in nature—we begin to see that our responses to a changing world ought to flow every which way, from market to family, family munity, and back and forth and back again.

That doesn’t mean that the tensions aren’t real or that riding them will be easy. As Yuval Levin explains in his own response to Carlson’s monologue, the challenges are profound:

Markets and a traditional moral order characterized mitments to family, munity, and country can also be in very great tension with one another.

The market values risk-taking and creative destruction that can be very bad for family munity, and it rewards the mon cultural denominator in ways that can undermine traditional morality. It seeks the largest possible consumer base in ways often hostile to national boundaries and loyalties. Modern markets can also encourage consolidation in ways that are very far from friendly to civil society.

Traditional values, meanwhile, discourage the spirit petition and self-interested ambition essential for free markets to work, and their adherents sometimes seek to enforce codes of conduct that constrain individual freedom and refuse to conceive of men and women first and foremost as consumers.

These are serious challenges and tensions, but they will not be e by making enemies of that which can be reconciled. They will not be resolved by taming pro-market dogma or forcefully tipping the political-economic teeter-totter from a fanciful scenario of free-range banker-elites to a fanciful utopia of over-regulated pencil-pushers and government-protected industries.

Adaptations, integrations, and reconciliations will need to take place, but at the points where economic, social, and spiritual flourishing overlap and intersect. We will need to set our sights toward a holistic vision of human flourishing, one that recognizes the necessity of economic liberty, family stability, and a virtuous, service-oriented society—all woven closely together.

Our aims and efforts around the restoration of the American family and broader civil society are noble and necessary. They simply need to be fused together with a broader vision of what the free market actually is—not a tool for us to hack, but a liberty for us to inhabit, aligning those efforts with the restoration of all else.

Image: Tucker Carlson, Gage Skidmore(CC BY-SA 2.0)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
A Suggestion for Rounding Out ‘A Call for Intergenerational Justice’
I’d like to thank Gideon Strauss of the Center for Public Justice and Jordan Ballor of the Acton Institute for their gracious and thoughtful contributions to the discussion of “A Call for Intergenerational Justice” at last night’s Open Mic Night in Grand Rapids. It was an excellent example of the kind of spirited and good natured dialogue we need in confronting the problems of poverty and the national debt. Earlier this week I pointed out that there was indeed a...
Open Source Software and Market Competition
The traditional Drupal logo Last week I attended Drupalcon Chicago 2011. Acton Institute’s website runs the Content Management System called Drupal. It is a highly customizable website publishing tool that powers around 1.7% of the Internet. Drupal scales: you can use it for a personal website, but very large outfits use Drupal including the White House and Grammy. As you may know, open source software is free. Anyone can download the package and begin using it or view the internal...
Five Things
It’s been awhile since I’ve done a summary post of this kind, but there’s been a fair number of things of interest over the last week or so that are worthy of a quick highlight. So here’s an edition of the aptly named “Five Things” (HT): Carl Trueman reflects on his visit to the Acton Institute. Concerned about how his Republocrat credentials e across, Trueman says, “Despite my fears that I might be heavily outgunned at Acton, the seminar actually...
Green Patriarch: No Nukes
With the terrible human toll from Japan’s earthquake and tsunami catastrophe only now prehended, and the grave follow on crisis at the country’s nuclear power plants unfolding by the hour, the anti-nuclear power crowd has already begun issuing statements such as the one Greenpeace put out saying that “nuclear power cannot ever be safe.” Predictably, reports Geoffrey Lean in the Telegraph, “battle lines” are being drawn: On Saturday, some 50,000 anti-nuclear protesters formed a 27-mile human chain from Germany’s Neckarwestheim...
Social Justice and the ‘Third California’
In his New Geographer column on Forbes, Joel Kotkin looks at the “profound gap between the cities where people are moving to and the cities that hold all the political power” in California. Those living in the growing “Third California” — the state’s interior region — are increasingly shut out by political elites in San Francisco and other coastal cities. Kotkin observes that the “progressives” of the coast are “fundamentally anti-growth, less concerned with promoting broad-based economic growth — despite...
A Discussion of ‘A Call for Intergenerational Justice’
Last night Gideon Strauss of the Center for Public Justice was generous enough to join us for a public discussion of the recently-released document, “A Call for Intergenerational Justice: A Christian Proposal for the American Debt Crisis.” This document has occasioned a good deal of reflection here at the PowerBlog, and Gideon took the time to engage this reflection, introducing the context of the Call and answering questions about it. Gideon got to chide me for not signing the document...
Can the U.S. learn from Europe’s green mistakes?
Kenneth P. Green, of the American Enterprise Institute (AEI), recently examined green energy in Europe in an essay titled, “The Myth of Green Energy Jobs: The European Experience.” Green thoroughly analyzes the green industry in Europe while seeking to discover the reasons behind its current downward spiral. As readers discover, this is largely due to the green industry being unsustainable while heavily relying on government intervention and subsidies. Green uses the failing green industry in Europe to forewarn the United...
Religion & Liberty: An Interview with Thomas C. Oden
Religion & Liberty’s winter issue featuring an interview with patristics scholar Thomas C. Oden is now available online. Oden, who is a Methodist, recalls for us the great quote by Methodist founder John Wesley on the Church Fathers: “The Fathers are the most mentators on Scripture, for they were nearest the fountain and were eminently endued with that Spirit by whom all Scripture was given.” Oden reminds us of the relevancy of patristics today, he says “You can hardly find...
Samuel Gregg: Business vs. the Market
In a new essay for Public Discourse, Acton Research Director Samuel Gregg explains why we shouldn’t only focus on public sector unions as examples of organizations that seek government power and taxpayer dollars to advance their ends. “A considerable portion of the munity is equally culpable,” Gregg writes. Excerpt: The attractions of business-government collusion are enhanced when the state’s involvement in the economy grows. This is partly a question of incentives. The larger the scope of government economic intervention, the...
Japan Quake, Military Aid, and Shane Claiborne
Waking up to the devastation today in Japan was heartbreaking. Malcolm Foster, reporting for the AP, notes: A ferocious tsunami unleashed by Japan’s biggest recorded earthquake slammed into its eastern coast Friday, killing hundreds of people as it carried away ships, cars and homes, and triggered widespread fires that burned out of control. Reporting for Reuters, Patricia Zengerle and David Morgan’s headline reads: “U.S. readies relief for quake-hit ally Japan.” From their article: The Defense Department was preparing American forces...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved